Back to the discussion

in Thèmes › Voyager en camping-car

Converting a heavy-duty bus/coach/truck into a motorhome (page 131 of 161)

Discussion started by Patrick26 on 2004-06-14

3213 replies

This thread has been translated into English.


Converting a heavy-duty motorhome from a bus/coach/truck

Fr159 · 2007-03-15 · Message 2601 of 3214

I just checked the 56-201 and you're right I'm so embarrassed I was wrong, but it's absurd!!

Thanks Mrkonn for asking the question—I'll ground the chassis this weekend.

Converting a heavy-duty camper into a bus/coach/truck

Fr159 · 2007-03-15 · Message 2602 of 3214

Sorry, but I'm a bit lost now—we're talking about earth, so the 3rd wire in 220V. In 220V, there’s a live wire, a neutral, and an earth. There’s absolutely no question of connecting the neutral to the chassis. 😠 So the circuits will only get mixed up in case of faults, when the current flows back through the earth. Anyway, it’s risky for the appliances, and I won’t even get started on the amazing lightning rod your bus will become! 🏴‍☠️!

Converting a heavy-duty camper into a bus/coach/truck

Patrick26 · 2007-03-15 · Message 2603 of 3214

We all agree, it's absurd!

In case of an electrical problem with a device, the leakage current escapes through the chassis!

The chassis is the 24V ground!

I'm still skeptical! And if I have to, I'll make the connection, but there's no guarantee I won't undo it after the Veritas inspection!

Don't want to fry my 24V setup if there's a problem with the 220V!

My bus isn't a mobile home!

PATRICK26

Converting a heavy-duty camper van from a bus/coach/truck

Franois · 2007-03-15 · Message 2604 of 3214

No, because if you have a leak, your residual current circuit breaker (30 mA or 15 mA) detects it instantly by comparing the current that "goes out" to the appliance and the one that "comes back." So even if you're outside with a hairdryer and there's a "leak" through your body, the circuit breaker trips even if you're not touching the chassis of your bus. Anyway, that's how I did it, and it works really well. But all roads lead to Rome—I took the safest one.

Good luck to everyone, and see you around!

Converting a heavy-duty camper van from a bus/coach/truck

Mrkonn · 2007-03-15 · Message 2605 of 3214

😉Thanks again for all these replies,

Can we run a braid that touches the ground (earth) under the bus to get a ground connection?

Setting up a heavy motorhome in a bus/coach/truck

Christian06 · 2007-03-15 · Message 2606 of 3214

Hi everyone, we're all glad to see Patrick participating more and more in the forum—looks like he's doing better and better! 🙂

For the grounding issue, it's important to remember that normally you have 3 low-voltage circuits: the 24-volt circuit original to the bus the additional 24-volt circuit for the living area the 12-volt circuit obtained from the 24-volt (some specific appliances only work on 12 volts).



Apart from the first circuit (original to the vehicle), the other two circuits include appliances or lighting that you power at low voltage using two-conductor cables, namely one negative and one positive. Since this negative is not connected to the chassis, but to the secondary batteries, there's normally no possible return path, in case of a grounding fault with a 220-volt phase (consider that at a campsite or elsewhere, when you connect to 220V, you won't always have the phase on the same wire , so consider that in this case, we disregard the neutral, because there's a 50/50 chance of ending up with a phase on your supposedly neutral wire (even for just an instant, as François mentioned before) on the vehicle chassis.

So if you've properly powered your low-voltage "appliances" with two-conductor cables, they shouldn't be at any risk.

However, for the first circuit—the original bus circuit—I doubt that all the motor accessories from the manufacturer and from equipment suppliers are all powered with two-conductor cables 🤪😕 and that they mostly use the chassis ground as the negative pole connector for the starter batteries. 😐

So I'm more concerned, in case of 220V returning through the chassis (even just for a brief moment) for the original bus and motor equipment, if the ground is connected to the chassis.

The other problem indeed comes from connecting to a generator or a campsite outlet with faulty grounding. In that case there's no protection for people on board if a phase accidentally contacts the chassis. That's a bit like what happened to the late Claude François.

So you need to (and I haven't seen anyone do this in a motorhome, me neither 🤪), in case of using a generator, connect your ground wire to a small stake driven into the ground (it's always something that will keep you from taking the full discharge) until the 15 or 30 mA circuit breaker trips.

So if you're traveling with your wife, tell her to wear her hair in braids; in case of an electrical shock, you'll see her braids stand straight up on her head, and you'll have that visual warning to jump off the bus in time 😏

Setting up a heavy motorhome in a bus/coach/truck

Moumoute · 2007-03-15 · Message 2607 of 3214

I have a question, it's not related to the current topic but anyway.

For the axle tax on our motorhomes over 12 tons, how did you choose to pay it - quarterly or with a daily pass? I haven't been to customs yet, I just looked online (www.finances.gouv.fr/formulaires/douanes/tvr1/index-d.htm) and couldn't find the price. Can anyone help me with this? For reference, since the tax varies based on weight and suspension type, mine is 13 tons with mechanical suspension.

Converting a heavy-duty camper into a bus/coach/truck

Patrick26 · 2007-03-15 · Message 2608 of 3214

no axle tax for VASP MOTORHOMES and VASP AUTOCARAVANES!

but axle tax for NON-SPEC VASPs!

I’m not insisting! I’m just saying I already mentioned this two years ago at the very start of the forum!

Doing NSPC is stupid. Here’s another reason! I won’t bring up the tachograph, Sundays when you can’t drive, etc...

Okay, I said I wouldn’t insist...

PATRICK26

For those who made the wrong choice, grab the tissues before heading to this address to see the rates!

http://www.douane.gouv.fr/data/file/1501.pdf

Converting a heavy-duty motorhome from a bus/coach/truck

Jose6440 · 2007-03-15 · Message 2609 of 3214

hi everyone

I agree with you—you need to ground the group to an earth rod, and when you're plugged into a 220V outlet, the outlet’s ground serves as the earth. But I’d still add a residual-current circuit breaker to the panel.

For info, François, a fault-current circuit breaker in France is called A RESIDUAL-CURRENT CIRCUIT BREAKER.

See ya, JOSE

Converting a heavy-duty camper van from a bus/coach/truck

Moumoute · 2007-03-15 · Message 2610 of 3214

Sorry Patrick, I can’t remember what you wrote at the start of the forum. You know how it is—I’ve been following the thread since the beginning. At first, it was just a dream, but the day the baby’s in the yard, you’re like, *whoa*, I should’ve jotted down the details like they advised!

But I’d love to know why we’re not included in the exempt vehicles listed on the customs website.

Thanks for your quick reply, though I notice your clock’s a bit off!

Long live the VASP MOTORHOME

Converting a heavy-duty motorhome from a bus/coach/truck

Franois · 2007-03-15 · Message 2611 of 3214

All the more reason not to bridge the negative 220 and the vehicle ground. However, if campsites have outlets with crossed wires, they’re criminals, and normally the converter detects polarity errors and doesn’t activate the relay (promised, I’ll try it tomorrow and keep you "in the loop"—yeah, the Swiss do have a sense of humor sometimes!!!!)

What’s more, even with bifilar conductors, all the negatives end up connected (at least the 24V engine and living area ones).

What’s certain is that this is an interesting topic that requires some thought.

Converting a heavy-duty camper into a bus/coach/truck

GX47 · 2007-03-15 · Message 2612 of 3214

Hey Pat,

What you're saying there (I unplug the earth after the Véritas inspection) doesn’t sound like you at all.

Also, you absolutely must install a differential switch (RCD) at the start of the 220V system—otherwise, there’s no protection, and the fault remains until someone gets electrocuted.

And no, your 24V system isn’t at risk.

Gazmobile, where are you? I need help...

I don’t have much time right now, but I’ll give a quick rundown based on everything I’ve just read.

If there’s a fault (one 220V phase touching the casing of an appliance, thus the earth, then the vehicle’s chassis, then the vehicle’s negative—whether unifilar or bifilar, we don’t care, the auxiliary battery’s negative is connected to the vehicle battery’s negative), nothing happens at all! The circuit breaker trips instantly (as long as you’ve installed a 30mA RCD).

Then, you could connect your house’s phase directly to the vehicle battery’s negative, and nothing would happen (well, unless your dog comes to pee on the wheel—then it creates a loop with the ground and makes a "Hot Dog" ). Nothing happens because there’s no closed circuit (thanks to the tires insulating the vehicle from the ground). It’s a bit tricky to understand, but you won’t have a 220V potential difference (-12V or -24V) at the battery terminals because there are two different circuits and two different power sources. However, if your chassis isn’t earthed, and you don’t have a differential switch or proper setup, you’ll have 220V on the casing of your faulty appliance. If the earth is connected to the chassis but there’s no RCD, the 220V stays on the chassis (until your dog comes to pee on it ).

Also, keep in mind that these regulations were designed for a 220V installation with an external connection.

For an autonomous 220V system, there’s a big issue: we don’t know what to do with the earth from the generator. Unlike EDF, which distributes the neutral via the ground (at the power plant and transformer output), the generator is two-wire. Connecting an earth to the ground shouldn’t trip the RCD... ??? I think the best solution is to connect it to the appliance casings and the chassis, just like with EDF 220V, and install a differential circuit breaker at the generator’s output—then no more problems. Though, if there’s no loop, maybe there’s no risk at all???

For 220V installations via an inverter, it’s equivalent to a safety transformer, so no problem (unless you connect phase/neutral, because the human body acts like a 40W bulb—same issue as with EDF 220V, by the way—I’ve had the unfortunate experience 😕).

With all this, I don’t know what the regulations say about RCDs. I thought it had to comply with "household" standards, but I didn’t even question it—I just installed a 30mA RCD at the start. I took my Master’s inspection at Véritas last Thursday, and the first thing the inspector checked on the 220V system was the presence of the RCD and the 16A circuit breaker for the socket. He didn’t specify if it was mandatory, but he DIDN’T note it on the acceptance report, so...

Sorry, I’ve gone on too long again

Converting a Bus/Coach/Truck into a Heavy-Duty Motorhome

Franois · 2007-03-16 · Message 2613 of 3214

Hi everyone,

Well, I did it—I tried wiring the converter by crossing the neutral and live wire at the input; contrary to what I thought, it works! That's a good reason not to bridge the ground and neutral. Have a good day everyone and have a great weekend!

Fitting out a motorhome in a truck/bus/coach

Moumoute · 2007-03-16 · Message 2614 of 3214

Another question - my cabin fan is burnt out. The cause is its 4-speed transistor (I'm not sure if that's the exact term) which overheated. Result: only high speed works now + an incredible grinding noise 🤪. Anyway, I'm replacing the whole thing, and at Iveco it costs 280 + 80 😮. Do you know where to get used heavy-duty parts?

Setting up a camper van in a heavy-duty bus/truck/coach

GX47 · 2007-03-16 · Message 2615 of 3214

yes, you absolutely must not connect the 220V negative to the earth, otherwise it's like a short circuit and it'll trip the breaker. it's the battery negative that actually serves as the earth for the 220V, which doesn't cause any problems. the battery negative will always stay at 0 while the 220V negative is 50 times per minute at -220V relative to the earth so Flash!

on the other hand I didn't understand what you reversed, the converter input is 24V and output 220V right? or the other way around?

Converting a heavy-duty camper van from a bus/coach/truck

Franois · 2007-03-16 · Message 2616 of 3214

I reversed the power supply on the inverter to simulate a wiring error in the plug (like when you connect to a terminal or at home); the inverter then works as a charger and the 220V passes directly through, powering everything "directly," but the phase and neutral are also reversed in the bus. That’s why you shouldn’t bridge the ground and neutral—because in this scenario, the phase ends up on the neutral, and thus on the ground. And then the circuit breaker should trip. These are tests I’ve done with my Studer inverter.

François

Converting a heavy-duty camper into a bus/coach/truck

Christian06 · 2007-03-16 · Message 2617 of 3214

For those who aren't familiar with electricity:

Another very important point: Be aware that a residual-current circuit breaker (RCCB) doesn’t protect you for sure.

In an electrical circuit, if there’s no leakage, no matter what electrical devices you plug in, the current flows from one power wire to the other, and the overall intensity of this current travels along the line and returns via the other wire. Your RCCB compares the current entering one terminal with what exits the other. If there’s a difference of more than 10 mA or 30 mA (depending on the breaker type), it trips instantly. So far, so good—this is how this type of breaker is supposed to work.

But—and this *but* is important—if there’s no leakage (to the ground, which is independent of the circuit), it considers the input and output currents to be equal. So, if you’re wearing rubber boots and you touch a live wire with one finger and the neutral (or another live wire in a 380 V system) with another finger, the current passes through your body without any leakage (thanks to the rubber boots). Since the current returns to the same value at the other terminal of the RCCB, it doesn’t detect anything and lets you quietly fry.

In the case of the bus you’re concerned about, since the tires provide insulation from the ground, it’s dangerous not to install a grounding rod when using a generator. If something goes wrong—even assuming you’re not living in rubber boots—no RCCB will protect you. If your bus is grounded (via the power cable or a grounding rod), the current leaking to the ground through your feet will cause a drop in amperage that the RCCB will detect instantly.

Converting a heavy-duty camper van from a bus/coach/truck

GX47 · 2007-03-16 · Message 2618 of 3214

😉 Hi,

That’s exactly what’s worrying me—are we sure the current will properly ground with a generator, since there’s no earth loop like with the EDF grid? I can’t be certain, and I don’t have a generator to test it. If I can snag one for free, I’ll give it a try 😉

Totally agree about the circuit breaker—I’ve experienced it firsthand (phase/neutral, one wire in each hand, and I got thrown against the wall by my body’s vibrations 🏴‍☠️. Afterward, it felt like a full-body muscle strain). The setup had an EDF 300mA and 60A breaker at the meter, but nothing tripped—except me 🤪. But with DC electrocution, you’re done for—no vibrations, just cooking 😇

Converting a heavy-duty camper from a bus/coach/truck

GX47 · 2007-03-17 · Message 2619 of 3214

Just to clarify my doubt about powering via a generator—it’s like an electric fence. You connect the positive to the wire and the negative to the ground. If the negative isn’t connected to the ground but to another wire, you can touch the wire at 10,000V without feeling anything at all because there’s no circuit loop through the ground. (I’ll still point out that my electric fence is powered by the EDF grid but has an isolation transformer, and I’ve tried it myself😛)

That’s what makes me doubt a generator, which works the same way (independent of the EDF grid).

Ah, the magic of electricity.......😏

GX47

Converting a heavy-duty camper into a bus/coach/truck

Franois · 2007-03-17 · Message 2620 of 3214

I agree, but let's face it: wearing rubber boots, holding one wire in one hand and the other in the second hand is just asking to get electrocuted; you've got to keep your feet on the ground and not look for impossible scenarios. We're trying to prevent accidents caused by faults, not trapeze artists working without a safety net (or without disconnecting the power while working on the circuit!!!)

Cheers to all

VoyageForum — the largest community of French-speaking travellers.