in Entre deux voyages › Livres, films et documentaires
The Hippie Trail to India in the 60s and 70s (page 5 of 8)
Discussion started by Becdanlo on 2013-09-22
141 replies
This thread has been translated into English.
The 1960s-70s India route
Bleulargo · 2020-08-01 · Message 81 of 142
You're right to clarify, GeorgesOZ—this is absolutely not a criticism of anyone! Including the author of the graphic novel in question! Others will love it, and that’s great. I’d totally understand if my feelings and opinion aren’t shared.
And all reading recommendations for this India route are welcome! 🤗
The 1960s-70s Hippie Trail to India
Kola · 2020-08-01 · Message 82 of 142
I went to the bookstore with the firm intention of buying the comic "Hippie Trail"....
It feels like snippets of stories grabbed at random from this girl’s shared life with her mother. But it lacks a real narrative with events that flow together and tell the details of that year of travel.
In short: I didn’t relate to it at all compared to all my memories of my trip, and I didn’t learn anything.
Maybe reading this discussion started a few weeks ago in another part of the forum by Sevelalib will change this first impression...
Sevelalib, is Séverine Laliberté, the author of the comic Hippie Trail, A Prenatal Autobiography, a comic that left the traveler unimpressed—the traveler who was about 25 years old (give or take ;-) in 1973, the year the author was born on the "Hippie Trail"...
Maybe in the traveler’s memory there are memories stronger than time and distance that could flesh out the author’s story and provide answers to the questions that haunt her...
@GeorgesOZ
Without having seen the comic in question, I’m not surprised by your reaction... A simplistic story made of random snippets, etc., you say? I’m wary of what a bunch of people—psychologists, writers, etc.—have written about these trips between adventure and self-discovery. You can’t easily grasp the mindset of those who undertook these journeys. There’s even a hint of deception in claiming to “have grasped,” “have understood,” or “have shared” it all in just 2 years (or more).
Your words give the impression that you’re lumping together the book mentioned by Ttleme: "The Drug Trip" with the comic "Hippie Trail, A Prenatal Autobiography."
If the first is the book of a writer and psychologist who spent two years on this route to India to understand it, the second is a graphic novel, panels and images that retrace an intimate story, deeply tied to this route to India.
The 1960s-70s India route
Bleulargo · 2020-08-01 · Message 83 of 142
Maybe reading this discussion started a few weeks ago in another part of the forum by Sevelalib will shift that first impression...
Maybe in the traveler’s memory, there are moments—stronger than time and distance—that could enrich the author’s story and answer the questions that haunt her...
Unfortunately, while my memory seems almost intact, and even if I make the effort..., the era for Sevelalib’s parents feels quite distant from what I experienced. Those few years later really make a difference. Besides, the little video she posted—I don’t relate to it either. So I can’t provide her with any answers. Too bad.
As for my impression of her book, it’s too colored by my own personal experience, which might have unconsciously wanted to find my own story in it... But that’s not possible. That doesn’t take anything away from Sevelalib’s work, her story, her experiences, or her commitment.
The 1960s-70s India route
Bleulargo · 2020-08-08 · Message 84 of 142
GeorgesOZ, since we both experienced AFGHANISTAN in the same years, did you happen to meet Father Serge de BEAURECUEIL in KABUL? I had the opportunity to meet him and visit his home during my second trip to AFGHANISTAN in 1968, in July, right after the "May 68 events". He was very interested in what had happened in France and in PARIS, where I was coming from, and we had long discussions about it. I was myself very curious to know who he was and why he was in KABUL, him being a Dominican father.
These exchanges and this "enlightening" encounter left a deep impression on me. How could this man, a Catholic from the French upper bourgeoisie, heir to a large and beautiful family fortune, well-connected in Afghan families of all backgrounds... etc., take care of so many children in their education and instruction, accepting many setbacks with grace!!
He passed away on March 2, 2005, in France, and was buried there. His funeral was held at the Russian Church of Sylvanès (in the south of Aveyron). He was later buried at the foot of the church he had built with logs he had brought from Russia, not far from the Abbey.
What a remarkable man this father was, and what a beautiful encounter in this land of Afghanistan!
The India route of the 1960s-70s
GeorgesOZ · 2020-08-09 · Message 85 of 142
GeorgesOZ, since we both experienced AFGHANISTAN in the same years, did you happen to meet Father Serge de BEAURECUEIL in KABUL? I had the opportunity to meet him and visit his home during my second trip to AFGHANISTAN in 1968, in July, right after the "May 68 events".
He was very interested in what had happened in France and in PARIS, where I was coming from, and we had long discussions about it. I was very curious to know who he was and why he was in KABUL, him being a Dominican priest.
These exchanges and this "enlightening" encounter left a deep impression on me. How could this man, a Catholic from the French upper bourgeoisie, heir to a large and beautiful family fortune, well-connected in Afghan families of all backgrounds... etc., take care of so many children in their education and instruction, facing many setbacks with grace!!
He passed away on March 2, 2005, in France, and was buried there. His funeral was held at the Russian Church of Sylvanès (in the south of Aveyron). He was later buried at the foot of the church he had built with logs brought from Russia, not far from the Abbey.
What an incredible man this priest was, and what a beautiful encounter in that land of Afghanistan!
Hello,
I didn’t have the chance to meet this Dominican priest in Afghanistan like you did. He was clearly a person of great human depth—no doubt about it! I see he was deeply interested in Sufism....
The 1960s-70s India Trail
Sevelalib · 2020-08-13 · Message 86 of 142
Hello Bleulargo,
I totally get that this graphic novel might not resonate with everyone and that it didn’t match what you expected from a "road" story—especially if you traveled it yourself, more or less around the same time. To be honest, the real subject of my story isn’t "the road" at all, but the investigation I carried out to piece together the story of my birth and that rather disastrous trip my parents took to Afghanistan, which ended with a 28-month prison sentence in the Greece of the Colonels. I’m a traveler myself, mostly for my archaeology work, which has taken me to remote places in India, Syria, Bangladesh, and the Caucasus for several years in total. And I think if I’d wanted to tell *The Journey*, I would’ve approached it from a different angle.
What particularly interested me here—beyond filling in the gaps of my personal history—was the way memory worked for the different people I interviewed. They clearly didn’t experience the same trip, even though they were all in the same car together.
And then there’s the discovery of this specific journey, which I’d somewhat mythologized (and which probably pushed me onto the road myself), only to find out it wasn’t quite as glamorous as I’d imagined. But it’s my parents’ story. It doesn’t claim to represent all hippie trails (thankfully). Besides, more than half the book covers my mother’s incarceration and what followed. But I don’t plan to leave the Hippie Trail just yet—we’ve got other projects in the works about other stories from this route, since I’ve become the keeper of some truly fascinating accounts. Maybe some of those will align more with your own journey.
Best,
Séverine
The Road to India in the 60s and 70s
Bleulargo · 2020-08-13 · Message 87 of 142
Séverine, your post really touches me, and very sincerely. I completely understand your intention, the "road" you had to travel, your questions, and your duty to remember.
As you realized, there was no "aggression" on my part, neither toward your book nor toward you (I’d feel terrible!). Just a simple feeling about my memories of my two hitchhiking trips to Afghanistan in 1966 and 1968, long before your parents. And every adventure is personal, in body, heart, and spirit.
What your parents experienced—and you by extension—goes beyond the adventure of simple travel.... And your professional life has no doubt allowed you to feel what they felt 🤔
Happy travels 🌍
The 1960s-70s India route
Dniorthe · 2020-08-16 · Message 88 of 142
Hi there,
I bought the comic book when it first came out... long before this original post existed, and yes, I "fell into the trap" of a preconceived notion about the travel theme and—boom—dived into an extraordinary personal and family story.
So, knowing a bit about the beginning of the journey (up to Iran), I didn’t try to find something familiar but rather to spot elements of comparison, changes between then and now.
I found this story fascinating... and I highly recommend it! I’ll remind my favorite comic book seller about it too!
To answer more broadly those who might have been, in a way, disappointed... the only solution to rediscover your own story is to start writing it (drawing it, telling it...).
Dominique
The 60s-70s India Road Trip
Veve75020 · 2020-08-20 · Message 89 of 142
I second that, I loved this graphic novel!
The 1960s-70s India route
Sevelalib · 2020-08-23 · Message 90 of 142
But you’re all so sweet! 😊
The 1960s-70s Hippie Trail to India
Caro96 · 2020-08-25 · Message 91 of 142
Thanks for this list. I asked in another thread about graphic novels on travel, and someone recommended *Hippie Trail* by Séverine Laliberté, which I see mentioned at the end of this discussion.
I’d love to know if any of these novels have been adapted into films? Thanks.
The 60s-70s India Trail
GeorgesOZ · 2020-08-25 · Message 92 of 142
Thanks for this list. I asked in another thread about graphic novels on travel, and someone recommended Hippie Trail by Séverine Laliberté, which I see mentioned here at the end of the discussion.
I’d love to know if any of these novels have been adapted into films? Thanks.
That’s a great question, Caroline—one I’ve wondered about too. There’ve been a few American films loosely inspired by the hippie phenomenon (*Hair*, *Easy Rider*, for example), but I don’t know of any specifically about the India trail.
I think there are actually some key differences between what was happening in North America, Europe (Lanza del Vasto, ashrams, protests at Larzac, etc.), and on the India trail. The discussion so far highlights that: there’s this big “hippie” catch-all where everything gets lumped together, pretty haphazardly.
I’d love to see how it could’ve been portrayed on film.
The 1960s-70s India trail
Caro96 · 2020-08-25 · Message 93 of 142
I just saw that Barjavel’s book was adapted into a film starring Jane Birkin, and there’s an Indian movie called Haré Raama Haré Krishna. Of course, I’ve no idea how good they are.
The 1960s-70s Hippie Trail to India
Parigino · 2020-08-25 · Message 94 of 142
Otherwise, you can go on YouTube and search for "hippie trail"—you’ll find some documentaries with vintage footage. You’ll probably relate to those more than a movie or comic, no matter how good they are! 🙂
The 60s-70s India Trail
GeorgesOZ · 2020-08-25 · Message 95 of 142
Otherwise, you can go on YouTube and search for "hippie trail": you’ll find a few documentaries with vintage footage. You’ll probably relate to that more than a movie or comic, no matter how good they are 🙂
Yeah, more raw, less "enhanced," more authentic.
The 1960s-70s India Route
Caro96 · 2020-09-05 · Message 96 of 142
Hi Bernard,
Following the conversation I had with Georges (
https://voyageforum.com/discussion/orient-dans-annees-1970-d2682781-13/), I learned that you wrote a collection of short stories about the East in the 1970s. Could you tell us more about it?
Thanks 🙂
The 1960s-70s India Overland Route
Becdanlo · 2020-09-05 · Message 97 of 142
Hi Caro96,
I haven’t posted an update—GeorgesOZ wants to talk about a collection of firsthand accounts of the 60s overland route mentioned in the first post of this thread.
🙂
The Road to India in the 60s and 70s
Bleulargo · 2020-09-05 · Message 98 of 142
Caro96, I had the same idea as you and the same urge to get it!
There were two left on FNAC.com—I ordered one! There’s still one left for you 😎
I’ll take this chance to thank Becdanlo for the info.
Happy reading.
The 1960s-70s India route
Caro96 · 2020-09-05 · Message 99 of 142
Thanks to both of you for the info—I checked out the publisher’s site myself 🙂
The 1960s-70s India route
GeorgesOZ · 2020-09-05 · Message 100 of 142
Thanks to both of you for the info—I checked out the publisher’s site myself! 🙂
Happy reading to you and Régis!