Back to the discussion

in Entre deux voyages › Réflexions de voyageurs

Travel: A Right for All? Reflections on Global Freedoms and Inequalities (page 1 of 3)

Discussion started by Noirenvoyage on 2024-12-10

54 replies

This thread has been translated into English.


Travel: A Right for All? Reflections on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Noirenvoyage · 2024-12-10 · Message 1 of 55

Hello fellow travel enthusiasts! 🌍 As a traveler and blogger, I’ve often been struck by the huge inequalities tied to freedom of movement. While some cross borders with ease, others face major obstacles due to their nationality, background, or the restrictive policies of certain countries.

On the occasion of International Human Rights Day, I wrote an article reflecting on this issue: 📖 Travelers' Rights: A Reflection on Freedom of Movement and Global Inequalities

In this article, I cover topics like:

Inequalities between passports ("strong" vs. "weak" passports). The specific challenges faced by travelers from marginalized communities. How to take action to promote more inclusive and equitable travel.

I’d love to hear your thoughts! 😊 Have you ever experienced these inequalities while traveling? How do you think we could raise more awareness about this issue? Feel free to share your experiences or ask questions in this thread. I can’t wait to discuss this with you!

Travel is also about building bridges between cultures. So let’s make sure it becomes a reality for everyone. ✈️🌎 Thanks for reading, and I look forward to exchanging ideas with you!

Travel: A Right for Everyone? Thoughts on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Kola · 2024-12-10 · Message 2 of 55

This reflection on the challenges of moving around—depending on your passport, origin, or skin color—does it focus only on travel as a leisure activity, or does it also extend to other reasons people have for wanting to leave home?

Travel: a right for all? Thoughts on global freedoms and inequalities

Djackx67 · 2024-12-10 · Message 3 of 55

Interesting topic.... I haven't read your article yet, but just the title already gives me a lot to think about.

Freedom of movement—you only have to look back at 2020 to answer whether we’ve ever faced this kind of travel difficulty before. And back then, some countries quickly banned travelers based on their nationality.

Can we raise awareness about this issue?... In my opinion, 90% of people couldn’t care less, including those with a supposedly "humanist" mindset who showed during Covid that their humanism was just on paper. Besides, I don’t really see how we can raise awareness about nationality and passport power... Take action, apart from signing petitions or writing to embassies...

Same goes for the idea that traveling is about "building bridges between cultures"—that deserves its own topic, but here again, traveling shows that the cultural side only interests a small minority of travelers. Plus, social media and smartphones are contributing to the erasure of cultures and the creation of a global "culture" based on selfies, stories, etc....

Travel: A Right for Everyone? Thoughts on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Jojoone1 · 2024-12-10 · Message 4 of 55

I can’t remember which American politician said: "All human beings are equal in rights at birth, and that’s pretty much the last time."

Otherwise, there’s also Jean Yanne: "Men are born free and equal in rights. After that, they’re on their own."

Travel: A Right for All? Reflections on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Attila · 2024-12-10 · Message 5 of 55

Hello,

First, an obvious point:

As long as different countries don’t have the same standard of living, the same level of freedom, or the same acceptance of differences, travel won’t be easy for everyone...

At the opposite end, the least powerful passports belong to countries like Afghanistan, Syria, or the DRC, where traveling becomes a real obstacle course.

That makes sense for the first two... (I don’t know enough about the DRC’s situation to comment on it.)

Then there’s also the question of unequal rights to leave one’s own country.

I don’t think a North Korean citizen could travel freely even if every other country in the world accepted them without a visa...

A person can be blocked just as much at departure as at arrival...

Finally, while many more countries are accessible to some nationals, it doesn’t change the fact that, for example, French citizens are also subject to rules when traveling to numerous countries—and the cost of visas and how easy they are to obtain weigh heavily when choosing a destination.

Some countries also opt for reciprocity: if you demand this from my citizens, I’ll demand the same from yours.

Global powers have often built their freedom on the exploitation of other nations.

Yes. Every nation on every continent has exploited its own population as well as its neighbors.

The wheel turns, and yesterday’s exploited become tomorrow’s exploiters, only to become the exploited again the day after.

We can’t stay stuck in the past. If we do, the future will remain just as blocked...

Travel: a right for all? Reflections on global freedoms and inequalities

Jojoone1 · 2024-12-11 · Message 6 of 55

Hi there,

How do you manage to align your desire for more inclusive and equitable travel with your ecological concerns and your fight against overtourism?

Travel: a right for all? Reflections on global freedoms and inequalities

Mathews · 2024-12-11 · Message 7 of 55

Have you ever felt these inequalities during your travels? How do you think we could raise more awareness about this issue?

well yeah, there are obviously a lot of inequalities around the world. The risk with this discussion topic is stating the obvious, and we’re not going to change the world here. There are still tons of people living in slums, and social benefits like social protection or reduced working hours—many countries don’t have those. Oh, and your blog isn’t working.

Travel: A right for all? Thoughts on global freedoms and inequalities

Jojoone1 · 2024-12-11 · Message 8 of 55

You probably didn’t miss today’s article in *Le Figaro* about the impact of tourism on greenhouse gases.

If you did, here’s the end of the article: "A simple reduction in tourism volume (for example, if all countries reduced tourist demand by 5%) is 'not an ideal approach,' according to this *Nature Communications* study, as it isn’t 'fair and equitable' across countries. While efforts are being made in transport electrification and technology, aviation remains the Achilles’ heel of global tourism emissions. Limiting the growth in demand for air travel, particularly long-haul international flights, 'would yield desirable results from both a climate and social perspective,' suggests the international team behind the study.

'The inequality in carbon emissions from travel stems from the gap between those who can and those who cannot afford to travel abroad,' the authors note. 'Focusing on limiting the continued growth of international air travel rather than domestic tourism would offer a more socially equitable approach,' they argue."

As a climate skeptic, I don’t buy it for a second, of course.

Travel: a right for all? Reflections on global freedoms and inequalities

Attila · 2024-12-11 · Message 9 of 55

the impact of tourism on greenhouse gases.

Instead of targeting long-haul flights, wouldn’t it be better to curb short-term trips?

Going to Rome for 2 days, Tenerife for 4, or Cancun for 6 seems like an aberration to me.

A tax of 500 € for a same-day round trip, 300 € for a weekend, 200 € for a week, and 100 € for a fortnight would greatly reduce global tourism and, therefore, carbon emissions from air travel. This would also solve the problem of the proliferation of Airbnbs in certain cities where residents now struggle to find housing (not to mention the nuisances).

Sure, that would spell the end for Ryanair and other low-cost airlines, but personally, I wouldn’t lose any sleep over it... Short-term tourism would refocus on local travel. Restaurateurs, hoteliers, and shopkeepers wouldn’t suffer for it.

As a climate skeptic, I don’t believe in this for a second, of course.

Air travel also causes noise pollution. Overtourism does too, by the way (plus rising prices, housing shortages, waste management issues, etc.).

When it comes to the climate, I can only note the changes over the past 55 years. And especially the disruption! I don’t know the causes, but it seems hard to deny that things are evolving.

Travel: A Right for All? Reflections on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Jojoone1 · 2024-12-11 · Message 10 of 55

Your arguments are understandable, but I doubt we’re grasping the full picture. Whether it’s cars or planes, other fuels have been possible for a long time, but...

Regardless, flights departing from European airports will be powered by at least 20% sustainable fuels by 2035, with a target of 70% by 2050.

When it comes to weather, reasoning on a human lifespan scale doesn’t make sense. Besides, all the planets in the solar system are currently warming, and it’s not because of the flights we take.

And those alpine lakes in northern Italy that formed when massive glaciers melted 10,000 to 15,000 years ago—our cars didn’t cause that.

Studying history shows we’ve experienced warmer periods a thousand, two thousand, three thousand years ago. These periods are called climatic optimums because they provided excellent conditions—warmth and humidity—for agriculture. The Roman climatic optimum lasted from the 2nd century BCE to the 2nd century CE and coincided with the peak of Rome, and it also affected... China, during the Han Empire. The "Beautiful Middle Ages" corresponds to the medieval climatic optimum, from the 10th to the 14th century, which also impacted Song Dynasty China. Historically, it was the cold periods, like the Little Ice Age from the 14th to the 19th century, that were... catastrophic.

18,000 years ago, the sea level was 120 meters lower.

To better monitor rising sea levels, Al Gore (the man behind *An Inconvenient Truth*) built himself a multi-dozen-room villa by the sea. Now *that’s* standing by your convictions.

The most comprehensive measurement records are maintained by the PSMSL (Permanent Service for Mean Sea Level), founded in 1933 and based in Liverpool. This organization tracks around 2,900 observatories worldwide. The major ports of the Atlantic, North Sea, Baltic Sea, and Mediterranean show no perceptible acceleration in sea level rise.

With some uncertainty, there appear to be long cycles of warm and cold periods roughly every 12,000 or 16,000 years. The start of the last warm cycle enabled the rise of humanity. We’ve got about 3,000 to 4,000 years left. After that, as has happened many times before, the ice will return as far as the Mediterranean. By then, let’s hope our successors have a "Mars Exploration" section open on VoyageForum...

Travel: A Right for All? Reflections on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Attila · 2024-12-12 · Message 11 of 55

Whether it's for cars or planes, other fuels have been possible for a long time but...

The great global conspiracy preventing the rollout of new technologies???

No big deal—when there’s no more oil, we’ll just have to switch to something else.

Besides, all the planets in the solar system are warming up right now, and it’s not because of the planes we take.

Or is it...

The climate has naturally changed, is changing, and will continue to change.

But are humans disrupting natural cycles? That is the question...

A question some scientists will answer with a firm "yes," while others will say "no"...

When in doubt...

After all, I don’t have kids, so a flood story could be a fitting conclusion.

Travel: A Right for All? Reflections on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Jojoone1 · 2024-12-12 · Message 12 of 55

I think it’s more that the climate shapes people.

About a year ago, I saw a really interesting documentary on Arte, complete with maps, about the reasons behind the changing borders of the Roman Empire.

After its peak, there was a sharp decline, then a period when it almost fully rebuilt itself, and finally, the definitive fall.

The investigation concluded that the empire’s expansion and contraction strictly matched periods of favorable or unfavorable climate.

The same pattern held true for Pre-Columbian civilizations and many others.

Travel: A Right for Everyone? Thoughts on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Attila · 2024-12-12 · Message 13 of 55

In the past, yes. Man was nothing, or almost nothing.

But in the present? Billions of human beings now have access to technologies previously unknown.

Travel: a right for all? Reflections on global freedoms and inequalities

Mathews · 2024-12-12 · Message 14 of 55

Hey Jojoone, if the Roman Empire collapsed, it was mainly because the empire was vast—too vast to administer. And the central state, centralized in Rome, was too spendthrift. To maintain the communication routes, it was forced to levy heavy taxes.

Travel: A Right for All? Thoughts on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Jojoone1 · 2024-12-12 · Message 15 of 55

So France must be way bigger than I thought, given how much we pay in taxes there.

Travel: a right for all? Reflections on global freedoms and inequalities

Mathews · 2024-12-12 · Message 16 of 55

We often say that the French flag flies over all the oceans, but when you see what's happening in New Caledonia, the French West Indies, and the social unrest that follows... you wonder if the French Empire isn't starting to wobble. Not to mention the African countries doing everything they can to expel French nationals from their soil. All that's left is for the Bretons, Basques, and Corsicans to demand their autonomy 😛

Travel: a right for all? Reflections on global freedoms and inequalities

Attila · 2024-12-12 · Message 17 of 55

On the other hand, Mayotte has no desire to become Comorian again...

I’m not sure if becoming Russo-Chinese is a great tip for Africa.

Travel: A right for all? Reflections on global freedoms and inequalities

Mathews · 2024-12-12 · Message 18 of 55

Yes, it's certainly a question. But the Chinese bring in massive cash through investments in Africa, something the French state seems to have been unable to do. Investments help finance the local economy. However, it's not just a political issue but also a financial one, as local populations and governments risk becoming too indebted. That was the case for Sri Lanka at one point—the country struggled to honor a debt owed to China. . On a brighter note, the project to build a "barrier" against desertification in the Sahel seems to be taking shape by developing a green belt. Maybe one day we’ll be able to regreen the Sahel, so you see, it’s better to see the glass as half full rather than half empty 🙂

Travel: A Right for Everyone? Thoughts on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Attila · 2024-12-12 · Message 19 of 55

If you don’t consume (VAT), you’re not a property owner (property tax), and you use tax loopholes (income tax), your taxes end up being significantly reduced...

On top of that, if you only receive a pension of around 1,000 € per month, you avoid CSG, CRDS, and CASA while seeing your pension automatically adjusted according to the inflation rate!

Pure bliss...

Travel: A Right for Everyone? Thoughts on Global Freedoms and Inequalities

Attila · 2024-12-12 · Message 20 of 55

The Chinese are the biggest capitalists you could ever find. Plus, they don’t mess around...

When the bill comes due, it’s gonna hurt...

Not for everyone, though—the locals in charge will have helped themselves, as usual.

VoyageForum — the largest community of French-speaking travellers.