Back to the discussion

in Destinations › Amérique du Nord

7-day stay in New York: hotel or apartment rental?

Discussion started by Claudius69 on 2026-10-15

3 replies

This thread has been translated into English.


7-day stay in New York: hotel or apartment rental?

Claudius69 · 2026-10-15 · Message 1 of 4

Hi there, I’d love to return to New York in 2027 (June or September), where I’ve already been for a week back in 2009. The Alexander Hotel, where I stayed, is now closed, and I’m wondering if renting an apartment might be a good idea. There’ll be 6 of us (2 couples), and we’d like to stay around Manhattan, preferably the Upper West Side or Upper East Side. Does anyone have a great tip to share, or, failing that, the details of a decent hotel with a good value for money? Thanks in advance! ;)

7-day stay in New York: hotel or apartment rental?

Mitch341 · 2026-10-16 · Message 2 of 4

Good evening, I'd like to return to New York in 2027 (June or September), where I've already been for a week in 2009. The Alexander Hotel, where I stayed, is now closed, and I was wondering if it might be a good idea to rent an apartment. There would be 6 of us (2 couples), and we'd like to stay around Manhattan, preferably the Upper West Side or Upper East Side. Does anyone have a lead to share, or, failing that, the details of a decent hotel (good value for money)? Thanks in advance! 😉

Hello! It seems that apartment rentals are now banned in the Big Apple.

Worth checking, of course. Otherwise, there must be a Dark Web for rentals! 😉

7-day stay in New York: hotel or apartment rental?

Caussat · 2026-10-17 · Message 3 of 4

That’s right—short-term rentals are banned if the owner doesn’t live on the premises.

To keep costs down, look for a hotel in Long Island City with easy subway access. Pick one that includes breakfast (usually pretty basic and not great, but it fills you up to start the day) and has a fridge and microwave in the room (pretty standard in this type of hotel). I can’t recommend a specific hotel since the one I stayed at has closed.

Jersey City on the other side might have good deals, but getting to Manhattan is trickier.

7-day stay in New York: hotel or apartment rental?

Nataly03 · 2026-10-26 · Message 4 of 4

Hi! Apartment rentals are banned for short stays in New York. The owner must live in the property, and the unit can’t be independent. If you see listings that don’t meet these rules, they’re illegal and can cause big problems—Americans are really strict about this and there are a lot of reports.

VoyageForum — the largest community of French-speaking travellers.