Back to the discussion

in Thèmes › Voyager à pied (randonnée)

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan? (page 1 of 3)

Discussion started by Galadriella on 2019-11-21

59 replies

This thread has been translated into English.


Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Galadriella · 2019-11-21 · Message 1 of 60

Hi everyone! Just back from the Manaslu Circuit in Nepal, and I think for my next trip, I'd love a wilder environment. I'm considering a trek (two to three weeks) in Central Asia. Several agencies organize this kind of trip, and I was initially leaning toward Tajikistan, but after looking at travel photos, the landscapes seem very similar to the Alps, while Kyrgyzstan’s scenery looks more "exotic"—maybe closer to Mongolia? But these are just photos, and I’m struggling to get a real sense of it. I’d love to hear from people who’ve been to these destinations... Thanks so much! :-)

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Willemspie · 2019-11-21 · Message 2 of 60

It depends on where in each country, but in my opinion, Kyrgyzstan has landscapes more similar to the Alps, like in the valleys above Karakol, though it also has steppe-like scenery. Tajikistan is more remote and less touristy than Kyrgyzstan.

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Voyageur1606 · 2019-11-21 · Message 3 of 60

Back from the Manaslu Circuit in Nepal, I think for my next trip I’d like a wilder environment.


Nepal still has plenty of wild regions—there’s no shortage of them. 😉

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Galadriella · 2019-11-21 · Message 4 of 60

Hi there! Maybe, but it seems like agencies don’t offer many options (I only found one trip, in western Nepal, toward Lake Rara, but the route didn’t look very challenging, so I ruled it out). Since I’ll be traveling solo, I’d like to join a group, so I need to go through an agency.

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Voyageur1606 · 2019-11-21 · Message 5 of 60

There’s the Upper Dolpo, Upper Mustang, or Kanchenjunga, but it’s not cheap.

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Galadriella · 2019-11-21 · Message 6 of 60

Yeah, I’ve considered the Upper Dolpo—it really appeals to me, but wow, it’s so expensive...!

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Meg2 · 2019-11-21 · Message 7 of 60

There are landscapes similar to the Alps in both Kyrgyzstan (Pamir Alay and Tian Shan) and Tajikistan (Fan Mountains), as well as in southeastern Kazakhstan (Tian Shan, Ala Tau). And there are stunning and/or more off-the-beaten-path landscapes in all three countries. If you're looking for more remote spots, generally speaking, Tajikistan has the least tourist infrastructure, while Kyrgyzstan has a higher density of tourists. But still, we're far from mass tourism once you step away from the main routes.

The trade-off is that you need to be more self-sufficient: in the Pamir, there are only a few isolated base camps, the population density is low, and except in the main valley bottoms, locals don’t have much in stock.

There are also interesting treks on the Chinese or Pakistani sides, but I haven’t tried them—the logistics are more complicated, especially in China’s Xinjiang, where it’s nearly impossible to travel independently.

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

OneChai · 2019-11-22 · Message 8 of 60

In Tajikistan, as mentioned earlier, the landscapes that resemble the Alps are in the Fan Mountains (which I haven’t visited, by the way). On the other hand, in the Pamir, it’s a whole different story. It’s extremely mineral—very similar to the landscapes in Ladakh, India, or northern Pakistan. I find it incredibly impressive, especially along the Wakhan Valley, with its lush green fields in the valley when cultivated, and then these massive, completely barren mountains. Personally, this kind of landscape is my preference, which is why I have a huge soft spot for Tajikistan. But of course, that’s just a matter of taste. For a better idea of what these landscapes look like, there are two photo galleries and quite a few articles with pictures on my blog in the Tajikistan section.

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Perju · 2019-11-22 · Message 9 of 60

For a better idea of what these landscapes look like, there are 2 photo galleries and quite a few articles with photos on my blog in the section Tajikistan


And here too ....😉 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ipkIpiZBAxs&t=0s

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Galadriella · 2019-11-22 · Message 10 of 60

... Thanks for the link. If I may ask for your opinion, out of the trips below offered by Terres d'Aventure (for example), which one do you find more interesting and scenic? https://www.terdav.com/ps-tadjikistan#suggestions Thanks a lot!

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Willemspie · 2019-11-22 · Message 11 of 60

Not applicable in your case, since you want to go hiking in the Pamirs and not in the Fann Mountains (more alpine), and you're also not mentioning going to Uzbekistan.

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Perju · 2019-11-22 · Message 12 of 60

...If I may ask for your opinion, which of the trips below offered by Terres d'Aventure (for example) seems the most interesting and scenic to you...?


Couldn’t have said it better than Willemspie—the itineraries they’re considering are mixed, with Uzbek cities and mountain circuits. If you don’t want to go to Uzbekistan, there’s no option with this agency. On the other hand, if Uzbekistan appeals to you and you don’t want to see landscapes like the Alps, the one including Song Kol Lake is the only one with a more "Mongolian" vibe, but only in that area... and Issyk-Kul, in my opinion, isn’t great.

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Galadriella · 2019-11-22 · Message 13 of 60

Ah, so the Fann Mountains won't be as much of a change of scenery, then...? I don’t mind heading to Uzbekistan after the trek to see some of the wonders of the famous Silk Road, even if trekking is my priority. I don’t know why, but the Pamir seems to be less offered by agencies and it’s also more expensive...?

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Michael7759 · 2019-11-22 · Message 14 of 60

Hi there!

I’ve been to Kyrgyzstan but not Tajikistan.

As mentioned earlier, the hikes around Karakol are quite similar to the Alps... if you're looking for something "wild," you can find it, but you’ll need to "break away" from the classic Karakol treks to encounter fewer hikers. Either way, it doesn’t resemble the "Mongolian steppes"—these are alpine-style mountains. https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/randonnees-dans-les-montagnes-de-karakol/

I’ve also explored the area around Song Kol Lake, and wow, it’s a whole different vibe! Steppe-like landscapes, yurts, horses—we loved it. Some parts around Song Kol Lake are a bit "touristy" (though it’s all relative). But if you’re up for a little adventure, it’s easy to get off the beaten path. https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/trek-vers-le-lac-son-koul/

Happy travels!

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Galadriella · 2019-11-22 · Message 15 of 60

Ah, it's a tough call... I’d love to feel a bit off the beaten path, but I’ve heard Kyrgyzstan is more touristy than Tajikistan, which makes me a little nervous. Also, I’d rather sleep in a tent than a yurt because, from what I’ve read, yurts can get pretty crowded—hello snoring, I know how it goes from staying in mountain huts! So maybe Tajikistan fits my criteria better (stunning landscapes, challenging treks, camping, and wild nature...)?

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Michael7759 · 2019-11-22 · Message 16 of 60

Yeah, Kyrgyzstan is definitely more touristy than Tajikistan... I don’t know Tajikistan at all, though, so it might be what suits you best. That said, keep in mind that tourism in Kyrgyzstan is still pretty low-key, and it’s easy to find yourself alone in the mountains camping wild with your own tent...

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

OneChai · 2019-11-22 · Message 17 of 60

Agencies tend to recommend the Fan Mountains because they're much more quickly accessible from Dushanbe. The Pamir is remote and takes a long time to get to, not to mention it's tricky to combine with anything else.

Anyway, no guarantees on this analysis—it's just my take, worth what it's worth.

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Willemspie · 2019-11-22 · Message 18 of 60

The Fann Mountains offer some really beautiful hiking, but you yourself mentioned at the start that you wanted something different, and you’ll find that in the Pamirs. I—and others who’ve replied here—have traveled and hiked in the Pamirs without going through any agency.

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Galadriella · 2019-11-23 · Message 19 of 60

Yeah, it's tempting to go without using any agency, but traveling alone doesn't appeal to me, and I don't know who to go with. So apart from an agency, I don't have any ideas.

Trekking in Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan?

Meg2 · 2019-11-23 · Message 20 of 60

A local guide based in the Pamir might be a good solution, given what attracts you. I know there’s at least one independent guide in the Bartang Valley: Ibex Pamir Tourism: www.pamirtourism.com

There are also several possible contacts through the Khorog tourism office, "Pamir Eco-Cultural Tourism Association": pecta.tj > members

Note: There aren’t many trekkers in the Pamir, so it won’t always be possible to join a group if you have date constraints. Plus, trekking there is generally more expensive than in the north of the country because it’s harder to access, and local agriculture produces little—so they bring in supplies by truck from Dushanbe or Osh. That said, life in Tajikistan is still relatively cheap for us.

Otherwise, the Fan Mountains are less exotic than the Alps in terms of landscapes, that’s for sure, but they’re beautiful, and life with Tajik villagers is still quite immersive... I haven’t been back since the Samarkand–Panjakent road reopened. The upside of this reopening: you can easily combine the Fan Mountains with visits to cities like Samarkand. Possible downside: a few more tourists, but there were really very few before 2017!

VoyageForum — the largest community of French-speaking travellers.