Cabin baggage size (1 centimeter over)
FR

Translated into English.

Original post
VO
Hey everyone,

I booked a flight with RyanAir for next month, with the priority+ option and two cabin bags. So I can take a 10 kg bag with dimensions 55x40x20 in the cabin (plus another smaller one). The problem is that the smallest suitcase I have (which is supposed to be designed specifically for cabin size standards, according to the manual) has the following dimensions: 55x37x21, so it's just 1 cm over (wheels included) on one of the measurements.

I wasn’t too worried at first, but I’ve read dozens of stories about people’s misadventures and the hassles they’ve had with RyanAir.

Since I don’t want my suitcase to end up in the hold (that would waste time picking it up when I’m already arriving late and need to get to the city center), nor do I want to pay an extra fee (apparently 50 €) for the outbound and return flights for just 1 centimeter—especially since I paid for the "priority+" option and I’m not exactly rolling in money—I’d love some advice.

Have any of you been in the same situation? I’ve read that with this airline, they check bags in templates (testing them in different positions) and are completely uncompromising. I tried contacting customer service, who, as luck would have it, "don’t handle this kind of request," and a rep I spoke to wasn’t much help.

I know it’s a low-cost airline, and I don’t expect luxury or even kindness, but come on—just 1 cm on a short flight with the + option... I’m a bit overwhelmed by everything I’ve read...

Just to clarify, since I’m going for 8 days, I can’t just take one bag for my stuff. I’ve done that for shorter trips before, and it was a hassle—I even had to buy an extra bag for the return trip... Luckily, the inspector was nice about it!

Thanks so much! I’m a newbie when it comes to air travel :) Hope I posted this in the right section!
NA Nataly03 Globetrotter ·
hi with Ryanair, it has to fit in the "sizer" and they're strict. if you're not far from the airport, do the test.
MI MirandaMouse Globetrotter ·
Honestly, I rarely see checks at the airport with Ryanair, and I often fly with them... At worst, they check suitcases that REALLY look too big.

Personally, I often go away for exactly one week and I only take a small soft travel bag that’s never been checked or forced into the hold—precisely because it’s soft. It can hold up to 12 kilos, and I find it super practical. I can only recommend it to those who don’t know what to take... It even worked for me for a 3-week summer trip...
VO VoyageurL ·
Thanks to both of you for your replies!

I think I’ve found the solution (on Amazon): a bag and a suitcase approved by Ryanair and other airlines that fit the dimensions perfectly (here’s the link in case it helps others with cabin baggage issues).

Plus, they’re soft, so hopefully no problems—I’m relieved, and it also solves the issue with my bag (my satchel was too big). I got both for 25 €, and I’d rather pay that than risk a 50 € penalty for being 1 cm over the limit!
CL Clicsouris Veteran ·
Just to clarify, since I'm going for 8 days, I can't take just one bag for my stuff. I've done that for a shorter trip before, and it caused me some hassle—I even had to buy an extra bag for the return trip...

Are you changing clothes three times a day or bringing back 20 kg of gifts for the family? 😛

Checks are relatively rare, and the size limits aren’t measured down to the millimeter. For one centimeter, you’re not risking much...
VO VoyageurL ·
Both 😛 But seriously, since I’m heading to Andalusia, I’m planning some pretty long trips (all the way to Portugal or the very south of Spain) and a mix of activities (beach, hiking, shows...) and I think I’ll do a little (a lot of) shopping 🙂 so it’s better to have some extra space in my luggage.

Last time, I decided to take only a small backpack and very few clothes for a shorter stay in Madrid, and it really caused me some hassle. I ended up having to buy a bigger bag on top of that.

Anyway, the hard-shell suitcase bothered me for other reasons, and I much prefer these two soft bags I found. It’s true that for just one centimeter it seemed totally ridiculous, but when you read some reviews and comments, it does make you think. Let’s just say at least I’m sure it’ll work.
CY Cycy56 Regular ·
Hi, I travel regularly with so-called "cabin-sized" suitcases, but I can never be sure they really are because I’ve never had them checked. To keep costs down with low-cost airlines, you check in online and don’t even go to the check-in desk anymore. The only possible check is at boarding—but how can they refuse a suitcase at that point? Plus, they’ve got other things to do. I’d say there’s a 99.99% chance you won’t have your size checked, and you won’t have any issues bringing your suitcase into the cabin.
NA Nataly03 Globetrotter ·
"But how do you refuse a suitcase at boarding?"

Of course it’s possible! There’s even a rack right in front of the boarding gate to check if the suitcase meets the size requirements. If the suitcase doesn’t fit in the rack, the passenger will have to pay the checked baggage fee.
CY Cycy56 Regular ·
It's true that after boarding, they can still put suitcases in the hold (I was only thinking about check-in counters). However, I’ve never seen staff at the boarding gate check the size of a bag, despite the sizers. I actually noticed this during my last trip, which is why I chimed in on this topic. I can believe it might happen, but in that case, when and where do you pay? Besides, I use a hiking backpack whose dimensions don’t perfectly match the requirements of the airline I regularly fly with (cabin-sized but not strictly within the limits). So even 1 cm—even for a hard-shell suitcase—doesn’t worry me at all.
VO VoyageurL ·
Yeah, I’ve read similar stories to what Nataly03 described. But the problem’s solved now since I’ll be getting the soft, compliant bag and suitcase soon. They’ll come in handy for future trips too, so in the end, it’s better to play it safe—especially since it’d be silly to have paid extra (and a lot, at that) for a cabin-baggage option just to end up having to check one of them for 1 cm.
VO VoyageurL ·
Personally, I’d rather not tempt fate. Even if it might pass for just 1 cm, all it takes is one inspector who feels like making trouble, and boom—there you go. From what I’ve read, they’d ask people to pay on the spot, otherwise they can’t board or have to leave their luggage behind...

At a push, a soft bag might go unnoticed, but the suitcase I originally wanted to take is hard, pretty big, and stands out easily... Plus, since I plan to use public transport once I’m in Andalusia, the two bags I just bought will make things easier—one of the bigger ones can be worn as a backpack.
CY Cycy56 Regular ·
Safe travels with your backpack, then! It's easier when you're on the move once you're there. 😉
VO VoyageurL ·
Exactly! I really don’t feel like lugging around a hard-shell suitcase on every bus or train ride—or even on foot.
BL Blesl Veteran ·
Hello, .. The only check that can be done is at boarding, but how can you refuse a suitcase at that point? Plus, they’ve got other things to do.

Hi,

Don’t be so sure—there can be a check right before boarding. I’ve seen it happen on a KLM flight from Amsterdam to Paris. A KLM flight attendant walked along the boarding line and pulled out "cabin" bags she deemed non-compliant (her assessment was very subjective—she even tried, unsuccessfully, to pull ours, even though they met weight and size requirements). From what I understood (my English gives me away, or almost), she was having them sent on a later flight... in the hold.

Wilfried was right to play it safe.

Have a good day,

BL
EL Elgordo Veteran ·
Hello, .. The only check that can be done is at boarding: but how can you refuse a suitcase at boarding? Plus, they’ve got other things to do.

Hi,

Don’t be so sure—there can be a check just before boarding. I’ve seen this happen on a KLM flight from Amsterdam to Paris. A KLM flight attendant walked through the boarding line and pulled out "cabin" bags she deemed non-compliant (her assessment was very subjective—she even tried, unsuccessfully, with our bags, which were within weight and size limits). From what I understood (my English is a bit rough), they were sent on a later flight... in the hold.

Wilfried was right to play it safe.

Have a good day,

BL

Yeah, I’ve seen this in Vienna too—I even "hid" my bag so the flight attendant wouldn’t take it. Same thing in Brazil on a domestic flight. There, I was already on the plane when the flight attendant came and took my bag. Though I’ll admit, I’d gone overboard—it was *really* big 🙂

Actually, this can happen even with compliant bags if the flight is really full and they realize the hold is almost empty. In that case, they’ll check at boarding and put bags in the hold. But the upside is there’s no extra charge 😏

It’s a bit of a cat-and-mouse game because everyone tries to bring as much as possible on board and nothing in the hold. And they know it, too.
DO Dom751 Globetrotter ·
Same thing on an AF flight between Warsaw and CDG and another departing from CDG to BUD, I think. Actually, it's mathematical—there isn't enough space in the overhead bins if every passenger on a full flight decided to put one in.

Before boarding, there’s a first check where the ground hostess puts a "gate-checked" tag on bags that can fit under the seat, just to remind passengers it’s not a good idea to put that bag in the overhead bin. Then, they ask for volunteers to have their bags checked into the hold. Finally, the last passengers (less than ten) to board are forced to have their bags checked into the hold.
TA Tatra Globetrotter ·
Good evening,

I know low-cost airlines do this—Transavia, for example. However, I’ve never seen it on the Star Alliance flights I’ve taken. Sometimes on very small aircraft, like Dash planes, there’s a container at the foot of the plane.

Michel

Same on an AF flight between Warsaw and CDG and another from CDG to BUD, I think. Actually, it’s mathematical: there isn’t enough space in the overhead bins if every passenger on a full flight decided to stow one bag each.

Before boarding, there’s an initial check where the ground hostess puts a tag on bags that can fit under the seat, just to remind passengers it’s not a good idea to put that bag in the overhead bin. Then, they ask for volunteers to check their bags into the hold. Finally, the last passengers (less than ten) to board are forced to check their bags into the hold.
PR Protege Globetrotter ·
Hi there,

United does this in the US. BA starts doing it when there’s any doubt, in certain airports.
TA Tatra Globetrotter ·
Yes.... When the luggage is truly oversized, I get it, of course. But forcing a passenger to take risks with the integrity of their belongings in a bag that was perfectly within the cabin size limits—even risking their physical safety if that bag contains potentially life-saving medication—is just unacceptable to me. They have rules; they should enforce them instead of making arbitrary decisions.

Michel

Good evening United does this in the US. BA is starting to do it too when there’s doubt, at certain airports.
NA Nataly03 Globetrotter ·
uh, well, exactly! 1 cm extra is 1 cm too much, so the airlines are perfectly within their rights. Sometimes it gets through... and sometimes it doesn’t!

Similar discussions

You might also like