"The Scottish Trilogy" (book), Peter May
FR

Translated into English.

Original post
KO
Sometimes a trip, a desire to travel, a travel dream... begins between the pages of a book. These three invite you to Scotland, on the Isle of Lewis. And although they’re published by Babel Noir, Actes Sud’s collection dedicated to crime novels with a dark atmosphere, and even though each book features a crime to solve, these three stories go far beyond the genre.

The central character, Fin, a man who wasn’t gifted with lightness or whimsy at birth, used to be a cop. He isn’t anymore, having left the police after a personal tragedy... A crime with a modus operandi similar to a case he was handling brings him back to Lewis... He’ll stay there. Because the time seems right for him to retrace the steps of his own story... a story deeply rooted in this land of melancholic geography, this island battered and rebattered by the winds, frozen in the past, where beliefs and traditions endure, defying time.

This austere island where his tender years were bruised. This harsh land that closes in on the dead... and returns them to the living years later, when the time seems right for them to put their childhood to rest, by facing the figures and ghosts that once crossed it.

Past and present intertwine, the memories of one explaining and perhaps unraveling the shadows of the other... and it’s only by confronting the darkness that he’ll find a strength he didn’t know he had, one that may—likely will—help him overcome the unspeakable.

In each book, Peter May, like a historian and anthropologist rolled into one, explores a page of the past, highlighting some of Scotland’s darker chapters: the omnipresence of religion, the conflict between Protestants and Catholics, the rituals marking the passage into adulthood, the terrible fate of orphans... the shadowy corners of the human soul.

A poetic, dense, and minimalist writing style that cuts to the essence, with just the right words to describe childhood, solitude, second chances—those who offer them and those who seize them—the weight of things... and happiness sometimes so close yet not always allowed to be grasped.

Three intense stories set in the same landscape: nature ever-present, the icy dampness, the slippery machair, the dry peat that fuels the fires... and Gaelic, that language with its harsh, guttural, rugged sounds?... which isn’t pronounced exactly as it’s written.

Peter May The Scottish Trilogy, Complete edition by Éditions du Rouergue Or In paperback, Actes Sud publisher, Babel Noir collection 1/ The Blackhouse 2/ The Lewis Man 3/ The Chessmen
KA Kate Globetrotter ·
Hi there!

I don’t know this author, but I’m a fan of dark crime novels from Nordic European literature (Indriðason, Larsson). Their characters have such strong personalities, and the constant twists keep me hooked. It can get *very* dark, but it’s so good!

Thanks for these new titles! 🙂
Mes photos sur Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/153304262@N05/albums "Le Temps nous égare. Le Temps nous étreint. Le Temps nous est gare. Le Temps nous est train".
CH Cheechako Veteran ·
Closer to home... have you heard of Hervé Jaouen?
https://www.flickr.com/photos/135039272@N03/
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
Hey there...

the constant twists and turns keep me hooked.

In this long epic, Peter May sets aside the usual tropes of the genre: no suspense, no red herrings... More than mastering plot twists, he excels in meticulous detail—vivid descriptions of the island landscapes, capturing their atmosphere, harshness, and leaden skies... and of his characters, whose luminous cracks lead them to sift through melancholic fragments of the past, chasing shadows to dispel so life can move forward again.
KA Kate Globetrotter ·
Closer to home... have you heard of Hervé Jaouen?

Oh yeah, I’d forgotten about him—I bought one of his books at the Brive Book Fair about ten years ago: *Below the Calvary*. I have good memories of it...
Mes photos sur Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/153304262@N05/albums "Le Temps nous égare. Le Temps nous étreint. Le Temps nous est gare. Le Temps nous est train".
DO Dolma Globetrotter ·
And there we go! 3 books (I prefer the Babel noir collection) that’ll make my "to-read" pile grow even taller. In that pile, only one French author (still there because I savor his work in small doses), so that’ll make one more—wow! My favorite authors are gonna frown at me!

Thanks, Kola! 🙂

Dolma
un chemin et la caresse du vent, alors je pars en voyage...
EL Eleni13 Regular ·
Sometimes a trip, a desire to travel, a travel dream... begins between the pages of a book.

That’s often the case for me. So, thank you!
Non ! non, c’est bien plus beau lorsque c’est inutile ! (Edmond Rostand)
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
Hey there...

"... climb a little higher up the pile" Watch out it doesn’t topple over! 🏴‍☠️

"... only one French author" Is that the one who fell?

"... that’ll make one more, well I never!" French by choice, Peter May became just that...

See you soon, Dolma... 🙂
DO Dolma Globetrotter ·
That’s the one who fell? 🤪

But who picked himself up so happily!

French, Peter May became by choice... 😊

I respect his choice, of course—the main thing is that his writing stays... Scottish!

Dolma 😏
un chemin et la caresse du vent, alors je pars en voyage...
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
Thanks to you! 🙂

Whether you love them or hate them, once you’ve visited them, it’s impossible to forget these islands located at the far west of Scotland

A taste of travel, a travel memory... or a dreamy, contemplative armchair journey... Peter May, accompanied by a photographer, David Wilson, retraced the steps of his hero... and offers a book of memories and images that illustrate the key moments of the trilogy.

Peter May’s Scotland Éditions du Rouergue
EL Eleni13 Regular ·
Thanks to you! 🙂

Whether you love them or hate them, once you’ve visited them, it’s impossible to forget these islands located at the far west of Scotland

A taste of travel, a travel memory... or a dreamy, contemplative armchair journey... Peter May, accompanied by a photographer, David Wilson, retraced the steps of his hero... and offers a book of memories and images that illustrate the key moments of the trilogy.

Peter May’s Scotland Éditions du Rouergue

I’m jotting down all these titles! 🙂
Non ! non, c’est bien plus beau lorsque c’est inutile ! (Edmond Rostand)
CH Charlotte37 ·
A colleague lent me this trilogy a few months ago when I was planning my upcoming trip to Scotland (we leave next Monday!). We won’t be going to the Isle of Lewis, but it still got me in the mood 😉 (I hadn’t heard of the photo book before).
VO Voyajou Globetrotter ·
Choir, another impossible island. Darker even than Lewis. A chorus of laments. An imaginary atoll, tending toward a hexagon. An island whose fallen inhabitants have three hundred and twelve words for gray. Choir also goes far beyond genre, belonging to none. One of those books where the story is merely a pretext for the art. One of those reads you don’t recover from. That leaves you finished.

Choir. Eric Chevillard (published by Minuit)

@Kate: Further from home, have you heard of « The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency », mysteries set in Botswana but written by... a Scotsman? 😮
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
Lewis... such fitting words to describe childhood, solitude, second chances. Choir... Impossible Island.

Literary lands at opposite ends of the world, yet a single word echoes faintly from the past... like a fragile, luminous thread, a messenger, a bridge from one to the other: Cadere Cadere: to fall... Cadere: chance (learn more here)

Choir From those readings you never recover from. The ones you finish utterly spent. So... to have the chance to (let) fall (the book) on the right side. And thus, to rise again.
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
Closer to home... do you know Hervé Jaouen?

I didn’t know him, and I’m discovering an eclectic* and... prolific author.

The first volume of the series tracing the history of a Breton family could have put me off: rough writing, clumsy characters, marital/parental relationships described without depth or nuance—kids are born, and the next page they’re grown and in conflict with their father—and yet... Is it the presentation, the comparison to Les Rougon-Macquart...? Is it the story sprinkled with Breton words, expressions (I still prefer Gaelic), and place names I recently walked and will return to? Doesn’t matter, the charm worked.

The second book is darker, the third one I’m still reading...

*Any suggestions for discovering his Irish and crime novels?
CH Cheechako Veteran ·
Prolific indeed. Eclectic too. You’ve got to read *La cocaïne des tourbières* and *Fleur d’HLM* to realize the gap.

The first volume of the series tracing the history of a Breton family could have put me off: crude writing, clumsy characters, conjugal/parental relationships described without depth or nuance—kids are born, and the next page they’re grown and in conflict with their father.

Jaouen is known for his ability to adapt his style to his characters. I wonder if you’re not mixing up the author with his characters a bit: rough, simple, basic... Because shallow marital relationships fit the described environment well. It’s far from romance, or even J.C. Rufin, for sure... but calling it crude writing? The language is packed with Breton expressions and *bretonismes*—those Breton phrasings applied to French, which you’d only notice if you’re Breton yourself or very used to the speech of western Bretons.

No matter, the charm worked.

After such a critique, that’s surprising.

the third one I’m reading now...

Really? Do you enjoy torturing yourself? Or have you finally been won over?

PS: Thanks, because Peter May’s Scottish trilogy will be in my bag for my next trip.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/135039272@N03/
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
Characters who are frustrating, simple, crude... can be described with subtlety. No, it’s really the style—the way the story is managed over time, skimming over things, rushing through 20 years in just a few pages—that I didn’t like in this first volume. But when he weaves the fate of his unique heroes, whether triumphant or pathetic, with meticulous detail, he’s on par with the great naturalist novelists... There’s a bit of Maupassant in his ambitious characters, some Simenon in his suffocating closed-door scenes, and a touch of Zola in the sometimes very raw descriptions of life as it is... (Ruffin... never read him, so I can’t say.)

The language is indeed packed with Breton expressions, as well as Bretonisms: those Breton sentence structures applied to French, which you’d only notice if you’re Breton yourself or very familiar with the phrasing of western Bretons.

Not Breton, not a Breton speaker... but I *can* read carefully, you know? 😛

PS: You’re welcome... and when you’re done, the other Scottish stories aren’t bad either: The Blackhouse, The Fugitives of Glasgow, The Disappeared of the Lighthouse.

Happy travels, and maybe you’ll come back and tell us about it...?
CH Cheechako Veteran ·
Hello, I’m really enjoying reading your posts—you have an incredible talent for adopting the language, style, and even the emphasis of literary critics...

those of his characters with luminous cracks, who search in the melancholic fragments of the past for the shadows to dispel in order to ease the melancholy...

I was blown away!

But tell me, in which title does this story appear:

children are born, and the next page they’re grown and in conflict with their father—

Is it in *The Sisters Gwenan*? Or is the son’s childhood really summed up in just a few pages? If so, you might’ve started in the middle. The saga begins with *The Daughters of Roz Kelenn*, then *Those of Ker Askol*, followed by *The Sisters Gwenan*, and *Those of Menglazeg*.

but read carefully, I know you know how

I don’t doubt it. But when you can also *listen* while reading (the Bretonisms have all their flavor if you’ve heard the accent), and there, we were delighted!

*Any suggestions for discovering his Irish and crime novels?*

*The Farewell to Connemara*, *The McGovern Testament*, *The Peat Bog Cocaine*, *Irish Chronicles*, *Flora of the Sea Spray*. Also worth noting: *The Skies of Audierne Bay*, heavily inspired by the Outreau case.

Safe travels, and maybe you’ll come back and tell us about it...?

Why move at all when you can travel so magnificently from a chair? as J.K. Huysmans once said, I think. Could be the theme for another epic thread on the forum, right?
https://www.flickr.com/photos/135039272@N03/
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
But then you would have started in the middle.

I always start a series, a saga... a trilogy in order.

So it’s in The Daughters of Roz Kelenn, the first volume of this Breton series, that the author plays with time as he pleases, skipping years here and there. At last, I found it...

And I wouldn’t have the same reservations about the following volumes, where, between disorienting Bretonisms, he weaves sharp, fierce, lyrical, or disillusioned phrases... Portraits drawn with precision (the astonishing Ténénan in Those of Ker-Askoll), scenes where pathos clashes with the burlesque, but poetry always wins (the legendary wedding in Those of Menglazed)...

Thanks for the other suggestions.

What’s the point of moving when you can travel so magnificently in a chair? I think J.K. Huysmans said that. Could be the theme for another sprawling thread on the forum, right?

What’s the point of moving when you read all this and realize travel doesn’t teach you everything, after all? Isn’t that the theme of... discussions... forum?
CA CatherineGil Globetrotter ·
🙂, Thanks Kola for this reading recommendation! I loved the first one, "The Blackhouse," with its structure of flashbacks to childhood and adolescence that really help understand Fin Macleod’s psychology, plus the stunning descriptions of the island—the landscapes, the harshness of life, and its evolution. Right now, I’m finishing "The Lewis Man," and I have to say I’m feeling a bit burned out. Probably shouldn’t have read all three back-to-back, especially since I’d just finished the "The Chessmen" trilogy (also excellent, set on the island of Groix), which I’d bought on a whim after my favorite bookseller recommended it—I didn’t know the author at all.

Actually, this happens to me a lot when I read several books by the same author in a row. I get tired of the style, the structure, which starts to feel like a "gimmick," and I lose that sense of surprise or reunion you get when you love an author 🙂.
Catherine " La lucidité est la blessure la plus proche du soleil" René Char

http://www.catherinegil.com
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
Actually, this often happens to me if I read several titles by the same author in a row—I get tired of the style, the composition, which then feels like a "gimmick" to me, and I no longer get that sense of surprise or reunion even if I like the author 🙂

On the other hand, when I discover an author and they make me want to follow them, I love immersing myself completely in their universe... and lingering until I’ve practically read everything. I start from the beginning when I know there will be recurring characters whose relationships and feelings will evolve from one book to the next, alongside the main plot.

Little stories within the big one, which don’t end once the case is solved, and push the word "The End" far beyond the last page turned... if you don’t go all the way (holding your breath) to the end of the trilogy, you won’t know that......... 😛

(I love this peaceful haven, this section and its exchanges, sheltered from clashes and disagreements. 🙂 )
CA Caro96 Regular ·
Amazing trilogy...
Caro La beauté des mots ne saurait excuser leur aigreur ~ voyageforum.com/discussion/votre-playlist-route-d10352797
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
A few years later, Peter May adds a fourth volume to his Scottish Trilogy: Loch Noir

Should he have reread the first three books, recaptured that dark and heavy atmosphere occasionally pierced by glimmers of light to fully appreciate the nuances of this opus?... Maybe.

Fin is no longer a field detective and now lives in Glasgow with Marsaili. His job no longer excites him, and their relationship is at a crossroads. Time and daily life have gently lulled them to sleep.

A bolt from the blue will shake up their monotonous life and bring them back to Lewis, the island of their childhood and youth. Fin has 3 days to prove (or not) the innocence of their son, accused of murder...

This island is one Peter May clearly enjoys revisiting, retracing his hero’s steps like a meticulous topographer... but describing an environment by oversaturating the narrative with street names, intersections, roads, forks, or detailed itineraries—as if following a GPS—makes it hard to establish an atmosphere.

The alternation between past episodes and the present-day investigation unfolds the story without displeasure but without real brilliance. The bonds linking the characters, childhood friends now settled with varying degrees of success in their adult lives, are reactivated... and when Fin recalls a tragic episode from their adolescence, it’s clear it will be a key piece of the puzzle coming together before our eyes.

The book is also a subtle, well-researched plea for ecology. The author describes and denounces the ravages of fish farming—what look will we now cast on the salmon on our plates?—and a striking event momentarily diverts the crime story to show human powerlessness in the face of nature’s implacable laws.

Despite the endearing characters, the setting, and the harshness of the Gaelic language that the author sprinkles throughout the book, the whole feels uneven, and the magnetic charm of the trilogy has, in my eyes, slightly frayed.

Loch Noir by Peter May Rouergue Noir

Similar discussions

You might also like