Skip to content
Who really loves India?
India › South Asia (Indian subcontinent) Fastkoala

Who really loves India?

Translated into English.
Add a reply…

Sign in to reply

Your reply to “Who really loves India?” is one step away. We’ll bring you right back to it.

Create a free account

Why become a member?

74 replies

Elconcombre· 18 years ago
... actually, the issue with this topic is basically the generalizations you can find in it...

Of course, there’s nothing wrong with saying you didn’t like it. But saying it’s "filthy"—that’s already more troubling, because that would imply ALL of India is filthy, which is far from true. But it’s clear the country has a lot to do to change mentalities when it comes to the environment—I remember, for example, the looks of sheer surprise I’d often get when I put my cigarette butts in my pocket instead of tossing them on the ground...

And it’s true that after Leh (I haven’t been there, but I have, let’s say, a vague idea...), it must make quite a contrast with Delhi! Like I said in my post, India is a country of sometimes mind-blowing contrasts... between Rameswaram, Candolim, Darjeeling, Jaisalmer, or Delhi, just to name a few examples... But saying Leh "isn’t India..."—that doesn’t seem true to me either. So, being "afraid" of returning to Delhi...

Can you find something "better" than India? I don’t think you can think of it that way, in my opinion. Different, yes. More in line with what you might expect, possibly. But not "better" or "worse"... Everyone has their own perspective...
Duppyconquer· 18 years ago
That’s normal, Noham. But if I’d been you, I would’ve watched the video, and during your nap, I’m sure you would’ve been off! lol! 😉

Good luck with your prep,

Cheers,

David.
Marcomarco· 18 years ago
Or else, go to Dailymotion and type "India syndrome." .


I found lots of videos, but not "India syndrome"

Yes, at the bottom of the page http://www.dailymotion.com/playlist/xg8a3_froggygoestobollywood_inde-du-sud

By the way, other videos (another page I created) here:

http://video.google.fr/videoplay?docid=-9220026929077480399

(Deshnok, Spirituality in South India, Amma's Ashram, etc.) - on the right: "more videos from this user"

And soon lots more (Kashmir, Indian truckers, Sadhus, etc.) 😇
Frisotine· 18 years ago
Hi Faskoala,

I’m really sorry to hear that! I went to India over 10 years ago (in the north) and now I’m heading to the south for 3 months because I was completely fascinated by this country. First, the people: it was such a joy for me to see how a small smile from me could spark so much happiness and smiles from the women I greeted (I should mention I have curly hair, which isn’t very common there). Then there was this man on his bike carrying a huge sheet of glass in the middle of chaotic, unbelievable traffic. The strength and gentleness I saw in the eyes of Indians is maybe what fascinated me the most, despite the extreme poverty. I also have this "spot" etched forever in my memory: a peasant woman in a sari in her field, sowing seeds along the furrow her husband had traced—a queenly bearing, a grace so breathtaking it took my breath away! And the children—their liveliness, resourcefulness, their joy for life despite the living conditions you know all too well. And you can bring so much joy with so little—I’m not talking about money, just your behavior, your smile. That, for me, was pure happiness!

I also remember this man (a cured leper) who came up to me with a big smile, sitting on a skateboard because he had no legs, holding out his stump to beg. I thought how in India, people with disabilities are part of society and integrated into it, whereas here, they’re often in institutions... Sure, it can be shocking, but if you respond with a smile and give him 2 or 3 rupees, you’re letting him live among people.

The country itself: isn’t it crazy—all those palaces, temples, the contrasts, all those differences from ours?

I also want to say that I never walked around showing my shoulders, always in long pants and without any jewelry, but always clean!

Come on, Faskoala, don’t dwell on these impressions—they’re understandable but maybe a little one-sided, no?

I hope you quickly regain your "pep" and wish you joyful discoveries... in India, of course!
KliFF· 18 years ago
I found the city of Madurai really unpleasant, especially noisy and oppressive. The temple is magnificent, that’s for sure, even though it’s under renovation so the towers are hidden by scaffolding. The atmosphere inside is also very special and pleasant, but apart from that, I couldn’t stand the city.


I get how you felt arriving in Madurai, especially if you were coming back from Kerala. I found the people much ruder, it’s more oppressive, stressful, and dirty. We ended up in solicitation and tough negotiation situations more often than usual. It’s one of the cities I liked the least, despite its beautiful temple. We quickly headed to Thanjavur (which I really liked) and Pondicherry—places I found much more welcoming. But everyone has their own feelings: I met plenty of people who loved Madurai.

India has so much to offer, and it’s so easy to get around. If a place doesn’t suit us, we just move a few kilometers away for a whole new adventure until we find spots with the right vibe for us!
Teamten· 18 years ago
We had the same impression as you about the city of Madurai—beautiful temples, but a lot of "solicitations," which is surprising in the south... Madurai suffers in comparison with Thanjavur (amazing temple and very friendly people).
Dixy· 18 years ago
We just got back from northern India with the family. We often stayed two days per stop. We loved India, even though the big cities are tougher. Delhi, Agra, and Jaipur seem harsh for a first visit. The dirt got to me after two days—I’d forgotten about it until my 12-year-old daughter got sick. But I was charmed by how kind everyone was, and within two days, she was back on her feet. I didn’t even think about the dirt anymore. I loved India, even if some sights were hard to stomach.

Don’t read too much before you go, or you might not end up going at all. I think I’d read too much negativity, but once we were there, there was so much positivity.

We won’t be going back next year—we’re ready for new adventures—but we’ll head to southern India instead.

India is different for everyone, and let’s not be too preachy about it.
Stalingrad· 18 years ago
Well done, FastKoala—you’ve figured out how to rack up a ton of engagement on this blog! You start a thread about loving or hating India, and hating it works even better because you’ll rile up everyone who loves the country (like me) and we just *have* to respond. 😉
Show 10 more replies
FastkoalaOP· 18 years ago
The goal isn't to make a splash or not—it's just an observation. I find that for those doing the same route, there are other countries that are more interesting to see, like Nepal, which I loved.
Stalingrad· 18 years ago
OK, but I find it funny that every time a post like yours is written, all the India aficionados (and aficionadas) react 😉😉😉. It just shows how much we all have this country in our hearts and how it never leaves anyone indifferent.
Lavinçoune· 18 years ago
Hey, I think what can be fascinating about India is that Western tourists are faced with a very ancient civilization with its own codes and habits, its still-hierarchical society.... Culture shock is definitely guaranteed!
Marcomarco· 18 years ago
Okay, but I find it funny that every time a post like yours is written, all the India aficionados (and aficionadas) react 😉😉😉


It’s normal—we come here for that too! 😉

The "best" example of this kind of reaction: click here
Elconcombre· 18 years ago
oh wow... a BIG MOMENT from the "India forum" on VF! worth reading from start to finish... eye-opening, sometimes...
Marcomarco· 18 years ago
(I just took a quick look at "Genevieve"'s blog—apparently she hasn't "done" India since... and, I imagine, it's thanks to us here 😎 ) What a loss for the Indian nation!
Lamouette· 18 years ago
hi there

I haven’t been to Thanjavur, but I did go to Madurai, which I loved for its non-stop buzz—right into the late hours—throughout the temple district. It’s honestly one of the most beautiful temples I’ve visited, along with the one in Rameswaram.

We stayed between the train station and the temple, and we had no issues in the city. In fact, that’s where my husband got a haircut for just 30 rupees! On the other hand, we didn’t really like Chennai (Madras)—it’s super polluted, overrun with traffic, noisy, and there’s not much to see. Plus, it rained for three days straight while we were there.

happy travels
Noham· 18 years ago
Thanks, and I was also wondering if I was the only one drawn to Madurai

You might also like