Good evening,
Goulding’s is a timeless place where you half-expect John Wayne to stride through the door of his cabin—both Johns left their mark on this already historic spot. Well-located in a valley, it’s still outside Monument Valley! The only upside is you can find two-bedroom apartments there for 340 € on 15/11/2019.
A hotel in Mexican Hat (I’m not talking about Kayenta)—like the San Juan Inn by the river or Hat Rock Inn—will save you a few bucks, but you’ll quickly lose those savings in extra distance and, more importantly, time.
Then there’s The View, which offers THE view of the famous buttes. Sure, it’s a bit pricier, but not by huge margins. Plus, this hotel is newer. You’ll find rooms of different standards and quality—I prefer the two queens on two floors.
$249 on 15/11/2019, which was about 218 € at the time. Waking up at dawn to the sight of the buttes lighting up is worth a small splurge (just 80 € extra in total).
The Starview is overrated...
As for the Grand Canyon and other parks, I follow a simple rule when possible:
the closer you are—even inside the park—the less "far" it feels, unless the prices are ridiculous (like in Page).
I’ve tried the Best Western and Red Feather Lodge in Tusayan: they’re fine.
And the Bright Angel Lodge, with its slightly old-fashioned cabins, but you step out of your room and—20 meters later, maybe less—you’re RIGHT on the canyon rim. The price difference is negligible.
Alain