Motel or RV in the American West?
FR

Translated into English.

Original post
TH
Hey everyone, we’re heading to the American West for 21 days in August. Two options for us: renting a regular car and staying in motels, or going with an RV. We’ve traveled a lot in Southern Africa on our own with a 4x4 roof-top tent, but the US is a whole different story. I’d love to hear your thoughts—budget-wise, we’re probably looking at similar costs. Thanks for your input! Thierry
VO Voyajou Globetrotter ·
Hi Thierry,

Some friends who, like you and us, have their "spot" in Southern Africa just got back from a trip in the West. They rented a Jeep Wrangler with a rooftop tent (photo). This rental option is pretty new in the USA.

As for us, we’d really miss bivouacking, but that doesn’t stop us from mixing in motels. Here, like anywhere else, it’s still a great way to meet people. Spending the night outside in landscapes like that (Valley of the Gods, Utah) reminds us of… Africa ;)

If you go for an RV, opt for a camper van for better maneuverability.
AT Attila Globetrotter ·
Hi,

I think the RV option is more expensive (insurance, added cost of campsites, fuel, etc.) and doesn’t necessarily let you go everywhere (Death Valley is off-limits, for example).

How about a mix of car camping in the parks and motels elsewhere?
Ponts du monde : concours de photos amical de juillet 2026 Rubrique Jeux Voyages C'est le moment de poster vos meilleurs clichés !
PA PapJ59 Globetrotter ·
Hi everyone, we’re heading to the American West for 21 days in August. Two options for us: Rental car and motel or RV. We’ve traveled a lot in Southern Africa independently with a 4x4 rooftop tent, but of course, it’s nothing like the USA. I’d love your thoughts—budget-wise, we’re probably in the same ballpark. Thanks for your feedback! Thierry

Hello,

Car or RV? Only those who’ve tried it can give an "authorized" opinion...

But to help, you need to be more specific: 1) About the route (from where to where, and which parks and cities). 2) Who’s going—adults, kids, ages. 3) Any experience in other countries or regions DOESN’T apply to the USA. 4) YES, an RV is more expensive, but only by 5 to 10% overall (based on high season/3 weeks/4 people), but it’s a completely different way to travel!

You’ll find ALL the details on my USA blogs in my signature—the Grand West one is from 2009, so of course, costs need updating! Click everywhere there are files, and especially on the "annexes" tab for RVs, campgrounds, visits, and costs.

See you, Oh... Vénissieux—I worked there (and knew a Thierry!).
4 fois en Camping-car: Parcs US - NewMex - Yellowst - Louisiane. http://blogs.crespel.me/usa2009/ http://blogs.crespel.me/usa2011/ http://blogs.crespel.me/usa2012/ http://blogs.crespel.me/usa2013/ Andalousie, Bretagne, Corse, Provence, Sicile, Toscane, villes d'Italie. sur : http://blogs.crespel.me/
DE Dennis2 Regular ·
Hello,

It’s really easy to camp in the West—there are tons of spots in all the parks.

There are shared (dry) toilets and a barbecue at each site. Some also have water.

It’s paid (between $5 and $10), so it’s best to book on weekends and during peak season.

If you can’t find a vehicle with a roof-top tent, you can always use a regular tent, which would be cheaper than an RV. A night in a motel varies in price depending on the location and time—I just got back and paid between $60 and $120 per night.
US Usafan Globetrotter ·
Hello, You can go to Death Valley in an RV. However, you must absolutely park overnight in a designated campground. I only know of one near Furnace Creek (Sunset Campground). I stayed at this campground, which is pretty minimalist. Basically, there are just parking spots. $15 if I remember correctly. That said, not all roads are suitable. Also, following the recent floods, even fewer roads are open. Recently, the road to Badwater was closed, and the 20 Mule Team Drive was also closed. I don’t know the current status...
Carnets de voyage : Ouest : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/video-time-lapse-road-trip-dans-ouest-usa-novembre-2013-carnet-voyage-d6301659/ Floride : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/retour-voyage-en-floride-21-mai-9-juin-2016-d7536021/
US Usafan Globetrotter ·
Hello,

I’d really love to know who you rented the Jeep with a rooftop tent from if you have that info.
Carnets de voyage : Ouest : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/video-time-lapse-road-trip-dans-ouest-usa-novembre-2013-carnet-voyage-d6301659/ Floride : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/retour-voyage-en-floride-21-mai-9-juin-2016-d7536021/
US Usafan Globetrotter ·
Hi there,

It all depends on what you're planning to do during your trip. For me, camping is ideal, but in August, expect it to be really hot in many places. However, when I say "camping," I mean a tent. RVs, in my opinion, aren’t suitable for many trails and end up costing more than staying in small hotels.

Another option is a pickup truck with a bed tent, but that won’t work if there are more than two of you.

So, it’d help to share a bit more about yourselves and your trip.
Carnets de voyage : Ouest : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/video-time-lapse-road-trip-dans-ouest-usa-novembre-2013-carnet-voyage-d6301659/ Floride : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/retour-voyage-en-floride-21-mai-9-juin-2016-d7536021/
TH Thierry1961 ·
Hi Olive, thanks for your feedback. Well, yes—the rooftop is fine; we’ve been traveling around Africa like this for years, so we’re really comfortable with this kind of trip. But for the USA and this particular journey, due to some specific reasons, our only options are an RV or motels. There are two of us on this trip, starting in LA and ending in Yellowstone over 21 days. So for the cities, we’re covering LA/San Francisco/Las Vegas/Salt Lake City, plus Yosemite, Death Valley, Grand Canyon, Monument Valley, Grand Teton, and Yellowstone. I was thinking a car and hotels might be a bit more suitable given our timeframe, but an RV could be another adventure. That’s a quick summary of my thoughts!
US Usafan Globetrotter ·
So, an RV might be a bit of a hassle in San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Las Vegas. And in Death Valley, you’ll likely be *very* hot in August in an RV.

Otherwise, I admit that an RV is perfect for Yellowstone and Grand Teton. I camped at Colter Bay Campground for several nights—it was really nice and not too expensive compared to the price of a hotel.

Also, make sure to check the mileage, as it’s not always unlimited for RVs and minivans. Some agencies charge a lot for extra kilometers, and it can end up doubling the rental price. And it seems like you’ll be covering a lot of miles to get to Yellowstone.

You’ll really need to run the numbers for both scenarios to get a better idea.

My advice: Plan your itinerary and start estimating both options. Both have pros and cons. But I’d lean toward saying the best option is a hotel and a good car for the trip, which will be pretty long. And if you’re not afraid of driving, you could also stay a little farther away to save on the cost of hotels in Yellowstone and Grand Teton, which will be the most expensive on your route.

RVs are generally much less practical once you’re in cities. And you’ll have a harder time getting around given the number of miles you’ll be covering...

Personally, I live in my car most of the time—I rent a big car, and it works out great ;)
Carnets de voyage : Ouest : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/video-time-lapse-road-trip-dans-ouest-usa-novembre-2013-carnet-voyage-d6301659/ Floride : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/retour-voyage-en-floride-21-mai-9-juin-2016-d7536021/
AT Attila Globetrotter ·
Hi there,

The terms and conditions of the rental companies I checked included a ban on driving through Death Valley.

This was only for the summer months, not all year round.
Ponts du monde : concours de photos amical de juillet 2026 Rubrique Jeux Voyages C'est le moment de poster vos meilleurs clichés !
CH Cheesecake14 Regular ·
Hi everyone, we’re heading to the American West for 21 days in August. Two options for us: Rental car and motel, or RV. We’ve traveled a lot in Southern Africa self-sufficiently with a 4x4 rooftop tent, but of course, it’s nothing like the USA. I’d love your thoughts—budget-wise, we’re probably in the same ballpark. Thanks for your feedback! Thierry

My best memories in the US are from camping. This country is made for it ⛺️—a good 4x4 with a tent in the trunk is, in my opinion, the best way to go. Once you try it, you’ll love it. RVs are comfortable but so limiting, not to mention the cost of the trip.
VO Voyajou Globetrotter ·
Hello,

I’d really love to know where they rented the Jeep with a rooftop tent

They rented the Jeep from Escape Campervans in Denver. Indie Campers also offers this model. Regarding Thierry’s trip and after his clarifications, like you, I’d go for a car + motels.
TH Thierry1961 ·
Hey Fabrice, A Lyonnais can only be right!! Listen, I think we’re gonna go with the motel and camping option. We’ll pick up a tent and some gear at Walmart and do both, especially for Yellowstone and Death Valley. It’ll keep that African spirit we love so much alive for us!! Thanks for your help. See you soon, Thierry
MI Mitch341 Regular ·
we’re buying a tent and some gear at Walmart and we’ll mostly do both for Yellowstone and Death Valley

Hello! Don’t forget that for Yellowstone and likely Death Valley, no reservations are possible. It’s first come, first served. That said, there’s still plenty of space for a tent. 😉
Evita Bella ! https://www.flickr.com/photos/201886709@N02/albums/
US Usafan Globetrotter ·
Great choice! ... And it's coming from a local from Saint-Étienne, so you know it's got weight! 😄 If you're heading to Grand Teton, you can book ahead at Colter Bay Campground. It's 1 hour from Yellowstone, and in the end, we stayed there for 4 nights and explored both Grand Teton and Yellowstone from there... it's totally doable by leaving early in the morning and getting back late. We even made it all the way to Lamar Valley without any issues.

I know I’ll get criticized for this choice, but if I had to do it again, I wouldn’t change a thing 😏
Carnets de voyage : Ouest : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/video-time-lapse-road-trip-dans-ouest-usa-novembre-2013-carnet-voyage-d6301659/ Floride : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/retour-voyage-en-floride-21-mai-9-juin-2016-d7536021/
US Usafan Globetrotter ·
Oh yeah, for my 26 days, it cost me 3980 €. I’ll be sleeping on my mattress in the car. I got a big SUV for 1190 € for 26 days. That saves me 2790 € 😮 The Jeep Wrangler, though, isn’t very comfy in the back (I’m 1.65m). This year, I went for a Jeep Wagoneer—super comfy. You can fit a 140cm mattress in the back 😎
Carnets de voyage : Ouest : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/video-time-lapse-road-trip-dans-ouest-usa-novembre-2013-carnet-voyage-d6301659/ Floride : https://voyageforum.com/discussion/retour-voyage-en-floride-21-mai-9-juin-2016-d7536021/
TH Thierry1961 ·
😄😄 Oh wow, if it's a Stéphanois!! Perfect, I think this solution could work since we’ll be in Grand Teton, but we’ll still try to find something in Yellowstone at the two main campgrounds. Thanks again!
SI Simonic Regular ·
Hi there. We did a mix of camping, motels, and sleeping under the stars in the back of the pickup. On the heights above Gardiner, take the track toward Jardine. There’s a primitive campsite (toilets only). We used to shower in Yellowstone hotels (public showers) after our visits. One little quirk at the campsite: share the space! 😊

Similar discussions

You might also like