Review of our cruise on the Renaissance - August 1-11, 2026
FR

Translated into English.

Original post
AF
Just back from our first cruise on the Renaissance, and I’d like to share a few thoughts about life on board. Our feelings are mixed—we wanted a change after several MSC cruises, but the value for money on this repositioning cruise left us torn. After taking advantage of successive promotions, we finally secured a well-located balcony cabin for 2600 € (almost 50% off the brochure rate). Given the amenities and the ship’s age, this now feels like the absolute maximum we’d pay for that period. Overall, we were happy with our vacation on board, but a few details—when added up—left us with a somewhat mixed impression.

The pros: - Ship size - Reasonable noise levels, except in the restaurants (aside from the covered pool area) - Spacious balcony cabin (20 + 5 m²) with plenty of storage and a bathtub with jets - Understated, tasteful decor - French language spoken on board - Friendly staff for the most part - 100% French-speaking clientele - Decent food with French dishes (even with an Indian chef) - Tables for two available (though the ship was full, so no changes possible) - Some high-quality shows, thanks to an excellent English-speaking troupe - Interesting lectures (especially on history and cetaceans)

The cons: - Unreliable air conditioning in common areas (you’d go from a freezing lounge to a hot one, as if the system only worked in certain spaces at certain times) - Aging ship with a few glitches (noises, AC, toilet flushes, lights) reported at reception (luckily, our only issue was the bathroom door not closing...) - Industrial, thawed-out bread and pastries (a letdown for a ship with a French image) - Limited fruit selection (often just apples and watermelon/melon) and not much variety in vegetables - Worn, sometimes stained restaurant towels

We’re not ruling out another cruise on the Renaissance—their itineraries are unique—but only at a very competitive price.
PO Poupou10 Globetrotter ·
Hello! A BIG THANK YOU for this feedback! Many people ask for info, but few come back to give a summary. Just to be sure—2,600 € isn’t the price per person, but for two, right? I think you were lucky to have a cabin with working AC, because on those dates, many didn’t and really struggled with the heatwave… Unfortunately, this company reminds me a lot of CROISIÈRE DE FRANCE—they had a similar concept. You can’t make something new out of something old, and the many technical issues on board will likely keep happening 😕 True, the only real upside is the original itinerary… They seem to have trouble filling the ship off-season, so I think it shouldn’t be too hard to snag a good deal 😉 All the best! 🙂
Isabelle, amoureuse des croisières: COSTA, MSC, ROYAL CARIBBEAN, CELEBRITY, PRINCESS, NCL, HAL, PONANT, OCEANIA, AZAMARA A VENIR CELEBRITY EQUINOX 09/11/2026 Grèce Italie Malte AZAMARA JOURNEY 14/01/2027 tour de l’Amérique du Sud
AF Afpjle Regular ·
It was indeed 2600 € for two, including service fees but no drinks. We’re aware we were lucky compared to others, even though it seemed like there were a lot of regulars on board. We were also surprised that, given the size of the ship, we weren’t docked closer to city centers. All the promotions suggest the base price is probably unrealistic.
4Y 4yne Globetrotter ·
Hi Frédéric,

Like Poupou, I really want to thank you for this review. Too few people take the time to share their experience and impressions after their cruise. It’s a real shame. You got a good deal and were lucky not to have too many issues in your cabin—this poor ship is really poorly maintained. Port spots near city centers are more expensive for cruise lines, and that’s one of the first areas where they cut costs. Even with Oceania Cruise, we had this issue in Alaska.
Catherine
AF Afpjle Regular ·
Built in 1993, it may be nearing the end of its service life. I didn’t mention the pools because I had doubts about the water quality a few days after boarding when I noticed they weren’t drained in the evenings. I tried it on the first day and found the desalinated water nice, even if I was the only one taking a shower before swimming! Another positive point I forgot: the large library/game room where you can find many books, puzzles, and board games freely available. For information, France Télévisions and Arte channels are accessible in the cabins. Regarding port access, no information is provided on board about local transportation options, which is a shame.
AL Alfre99410 Veteran ·
Hello,

Thanks for taking the time to share a little recap of your latest cruise. It’s something that’s becoming rare on this forum—lots of people sign up, come looking for info, and don’t even bother to give us a follow-up. So, once again, a big thank you to you.

In my opinion, this ship won’t last long. It’ll be like CDF: sure, the concept could’ve been good, but not with that old boat. There are too many negative reviews. You were lucky to get a cabin that was more or less okay, but I’ve read some reviews that are honestly scary.

If I understood correctly, you paid 1300 € per person. Personally, I don’t think it’s worth more (even in peak season). Apparently, the food is still decent, but the rest is a total mess.

But hey, if you’re happy, that’s what matters. Thanks again for the recap.
AF Afpjle Regular ·
Even though personal opinions are always subjective, I’ve always enjoyed reading trip reports on VF. To justify the value for money, we really appreciated having a balcony cabin that was this spacious and well-equipped—we’d never had one like it before. We’d hesitated over a slightly cheaper promenade cabin, but once onboard, we didn’t regret our choice. There was a lot of foot traffic on Deck 6 during sea days for the daily walk, and the private loungers were often windy.
JO Johncruise ·
Hello,

Thank you so much for your feedback. We’re boarding the Renaissance this Monday, and after 9 cruises with MSC—including 2 in Aurea—we wanted to try something simpler, quieter, and more authentic, plus the itinerary was a bit different.

I’ll admit, the latest reviews are making us pretty nervous, especially about the major AC breakdowns in the cabins... I have no idea how we’ll handle 30°C inside...

As for the crowd on the ship, how was it? I’ve read everything and its opposite—some say when the ship is full, it’s tough, while others say there’s always space. We have 4 days at sea.

Regarding the shows, on a 12-day cruise, do you know if the second week repeats the same shows from the first?

Are the photographers less pushy than on MSC?

One last little question: for boarding, can we get on a bit earlier than scheduled? We’re supposed to be there at 2:45 PM (on MSC, we’d already be in the jacuzzi by then 😂), but here again, I’ve read mixed things—some say it’s possible, others say no.

Thanks in advance for your feedback, and I’ll definitely leave a review when we disembark.
AF Afpjle Regular ·
Trying to answer your questions: - First, we really enjoyed how quiet the ship was. Just avoid the central pool, which gets noisy with lots of kids. Also, the mostly French-speaking crowd is generally less rowdy, which suited us better. We never felt crowded, even at the buffet, if you pick the right times. - For dining, the quality isn’t that different from MSC, with some "French-friendly" dishes but fewer options. - As for cabins, I think it’s luck of the draw... Some issues had to be sorted out at reception. - We didn’t use the poolside loungers—the towel-reservation problem is still there. Our balcony cabin was really spacious and comfy with their own loungers. - Over the ten evenings, we never saw the same show twice. - The photographers eventually recognize you if you always refuse their offers. - Called for 1 PM, we arrived at 12:15, and boarding had already started at noon. In Dunkirk, it was quick. - I hope you’re driving—because the shuttle (every 30 minutes) drops you 1 km from the ship. Marseille’s port has the strongest taxi lobby...
JO Johncruise ·
Thanks so much for the details!

We’re coming by car, so that’s all set on that end. Do you happen to remember what time the buffet closes on embarkation day? We’re boarding around 2:45 PM...

Thanks!
AF Afpjle Regular ·
For us, the buffet was open until 4:00 PM. Have a great cruise!
JO Johncruise ·
Thanks!
NA Nataly03 Globetrotter ·
Hi there I’ll still be a bit less harsh than you... Even though not everything was perfect, we had a great cruise in April on it. And the balcony cabin was really nice.
nathalie
AF Afpjle Regular ·
We were also generally satisfied with our vacation and really enjoyed our cabin on deck 9, but we were probably hoping to find the same atmosphere as our first cruises twenty years ago. I also didn’t mention other minor details that made us think they could have been more attentive to customer satisfaction. My benchmark is the quality-to-price ratio; for us, a balcony cabin with these amenities isn’t worth more than 120 € per day. Paying more for premium services is probably possible.
NA Nataly03 Globetrotter ·
Hello I didn’t understand your last sentence?
nathalie
AF Afpjle Regular ·
I wanted to say that when choosing different cruises (like Ponant, for example), the price difference has to be justified. People often talk about the standards of American cruise lines, but the language barrier doesn’t hold them back.

Our last MSC trips were so disappointing that CFC really restored our love for cruising in the end. If the opportunity (route and price) comes up again, we’ll probably give the Renaissance another try.
NA Nataly03 Globetrotter ·
Yeah, same here—I’d sail with CFC again if the itinerary is good, mainly for the route. But Ponant is way over my budget. However, I’m fine with American cruise lines in terms of value for money. I’m actually heading to Iceland with NCL in a week. The budget is higher than CFC, though.
nathalie
AF Afpjle Regular ·
Iceland was such a beautiful memory! Another possible trip for us: the Coastal Express. Only one NCL experience, but it was very satisfying. Happy cruising! 😎
TO Tonyma Regular ·
Hi, you mentioned Croisière de France—we’ve done six cruises on the Zenith and the Horizon up until 2016, and we loved those ships (capacity of 2,000 passengers, usually around 1,200 on board). We really miss them; the ship was very comfortable, well-maintained, and the service stayed consistent, unlike with CFC. The prices were also very reasonable and stable. With CFC, the prices are unpredictable and almost non-negotiable, with huge variations just weeks apart. So, for the same services, passengers can end up paying double.

At first, the service matched the high price (more expensive than MSC or Costa but cheaper than Ponant). The advantage is that the ship is small, so there’s less crowding, less noise, a beautiful library, very friendly staff (a constant on cruises), a single boarding process, mostly French passengers, and no screaming kids.

Downsides (plural): The Renaissance is becoming less and less French-speaking. Since the merger with Ambassador, many servers don’t speak French, and a lot of perks have disappeared. The free ice cream at the buffet has been gone for a few months, the coffee machines now only dispense bad coffee—before, there was good coffee, espresso, cappuccino, café moka, mocaccino. There’s no longer sparkling water at the fountains, and you have to pay for better-quality water. Herbal teas at afternoon tea or in the evening buffet are gone, as is the chocolate powder. The honey at breakfast comes from China (checked the jars). At the Vatel restaurant, the lobster and Angus beef from the early days are no longer available, and the beef Wellington has also recently disappeared. The lunch buffet is much less varied than before. It’s clear that Ambassador is cutting costs everywhere.

Also disappointing is the lack of a loyalty program... The ship is outdated, with rust everywhere, recurring issues with the AC and plumbing—sometimes balcony cabins on deck 9 get flooded (this was still happening on our last cruise in June). Ports are often canceled without real justification (e.g., Dublin).

For first-time passengers, there are plenty of reasons to be happy, but when you compare it to what it used to be, it’s frustrating.

By offering departures from Dunkirk, CFC is attracting a new clientele from the north of France and Belgium—there’s a big market there. But for cruisers like us who depart from Marseille, the value for money is less favorable due to the loss of services and the lack of a loyalty program.

We’ve just booked two MSC cruises for under 1500 € for two, with a drinks package and service fees included. After eight cruises on the Renaissance, that’s quite a comparison. For example, the 15-day cruise in September to Italy/Greece was 2990 € per person without a drinks package or service fees. If you break it down per day per person, it’s more than double what MSC charges. That’s a lot to pay just for a quieter experience—I don’t support these prices.

Too bad...

To answer Johncruise: It’s not necessary to follow the boarding time indicated by CFC—they don’t check. You can board at any time; it’s just to avoid everyone showing up at the start of embarkation. As for the photographers, they’re discreet and don’t insist.
AF Afpjle Regular ·
Thanks for this comparison I hadn’t seen. Indeed, the services have gone downhill without any price reduction! Too bad Croisière de France no longer exists... I also forgot to mention that on sea days, we didn’t even have satellite coverage to receive our texts; we opted for 24 hours of Wi-Fi at 15 €. As for the filtered water package at 13 € per person, it’s not excessive to fill your water bottle for 11 days; after that, getting glasses at the buffet can take a while... We stopped sailing with MSC because of the "amusement park" crowd drift—why go to sea for that? If we ever try again, it’ll be on the company’s smaller ships. But I’m aware we’re going against the current trend...
TO Tonyma Regular ·
Totally agree about the water—the price is reasonable (though I’ll note it’s already gone up in just two months). And it avoids the waste of included bottled water in packages.

As for the MSC fleet, we prefer the older ships from 2010–2015 with 2,500–3,000 passengers, like Splendida, Magnifica, Orchestra... Sure, there’s noise at the pool, but outside school holidays, it’s manageable. The newer ships—Meraviglia, Grandiosa, Bellissima, etc.—are a different story, with up to 6,000 passengers...
AL Alex075 Regular ·
Hello, On this cruise, the "water package" cost 11.90 € (the price was the same regardless of the cruise duration). But the water was "premium filtered water" without any explanation of what "premium" means (mineralized water?) or where the water came from (desalination?). Similarly, what’s the difference between this and the free water served at Vatel or available at the buffet (non-mineralized water?) In short, I think this package is expensive, and it’s outrageous that you can’t buy a bottle of mineral water anymore, even though it’s still listed on the bar menu (in 2025, it was Corsican mineral water Zilia). Best regards

Similar discussions

You might also like