Masai Mara and Melting Pot Safari... So disappointed!
FR

Translated into English.

PY Pygmalion19 Veteran ·
Hi Gérard,

Unfortunately, I share your opinion because learning that this park is suffocated not by "tourists"—who are absolutely right to go there—but by the locals themselves is disheartening. From my perspective, Ruaha and Selous are also an excellent alternative. See you,
pygmalion
PY Pygmalion19 Veteran ·
Hi Tony,

Thanks for your analysis of the chaos in the Masai Mara. Indeed, it seems difficult to control under any circumstances, so the worst is unfortunately yet to come.

See you,
pygmalion
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
hi is the Masai Mara being stifled by the locals??? the Maasai have been there for centuries independent Kenya decided to turn it into a nature reserve, excluding the Maasai, but eventually part of the land was returned to them, free to manage and graze their livestock, even if it's true that some encroach on the tourists' territory... it seems to me that every national park in Africa is very different from another so Selous, Mikumi, Ruaha, yes, but there are also other national parks in Kenya
SI Sissi57 Globetrotter ·
Hi, I’d add that when you’re a seasoned traveler, you don’t forget to pack your own soap and you take care of your own underwear, like a big girl. Or you bring enough for the whole trip if water is scarce and you need to save it.
Je n'aurai pas le temps...
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
hi sylvie I don’t get this attraction people have for their expat compatriots who run camps, hotels, restaurants, and so on. the real change of scenery is actually not running into your neighbor on the other side of the world. totally agree—you can ask the guide to stick to the trails unless you’ve got a few excitement-seekers trying to snap the photo of the century. the best is definitely going solo, no doubt, even if sometimes you get side-eyed by tour operators who think they know better. and like you said, Kenya is huge. valerie
PY Pygmalion19 Veteran ·
Hi Valérie,

If the predators (poisoned) are eradicated from their habitat, then only the herbivores will remain, and they’ll eventually disappear too because they compete with the Maasai’s goats and cows—which don’t eat meat but sustain their livelihood. And there you have it! 😉

even if it’s true that some encroach on the tourists’ territory...

The tourists’ territory? The park isn’t theirs—it’s dedicated to wildlife. So it’s not abnormal for our big cats and other carnivores to take a few. As for tourists, they’re just passing through, asked to observe with their eyes and not disrupt the natural order.

See you,
pygmalion
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
hey did I misread your message to gerardelux? park suffocated by locals
PY Pygmalion19 Veteran ·
Hi Val��rie,

“Asphyxiated” might be a bit strong, but there’s definitely a sense that overgrazing is encroaching on that balance.

See you,
pygmalion
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
hey eric I still don’t get it—between your message and your reply—how we were supposed to see the predators in there. I was only saying that the Maasai are legitimate and had little to do with the disappearance of the habitat compared to tourist overconsumption. They’ve always been there; the national park has only existed since the 60s. What’s happened since then? A skyrocketing Maasai population or a skyrocketing number of tourists? valerie
RO Rotsaka Globetrotter ·
Good evening,

For my part, following the interesting exchanges with Blesl, I went back through my documents and references, and there’s no clear study showing a direct link between overgrazing and the decline of large herbivores. The strongest connections seem to be around natural resources and access to them (water in particular), the spread of animal diseases, and the fact that many of the problems aren’t caused by herders but by agricultural populations who "block" migration corridors for both wild and domestic animals.

I’d also like to point out that many reserves were created on land where people were already living. These same pastoral communities are being pushed off their land, not just by reserves (which has been going on for a while) but now also by the expansion of agriculture and general population pressure.

So blaming them as scapegoats seems a bit simplistic to me. Especially since tourists, who don’t stay long (though the camps do, and the damage caused by overtourism, etc.), could just as easily be called out. And we don’t manage our own reserves in our countries the same way (where herders can live just fine).

Then there’s the myth of prestige livestock farming, which has been debunked for quite some time. Accumulating livestock is a risk-management strategy in extremely difficult areas. Of course, there are wealthy people with large herds they don’t use, but most are small-scale herders trying to have more to survive (and they make up the vast majority).
RO Rotsaka Globetrotter ·
'they compete with the Maasai's goats and cows, who don't eat meat but live off their livestock'

The Maasai do eat meat and they live off their livestock.
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
hi bernard being a vet, do you think the photo I saw of a cheetah on the hood of a car is normal behavior? valerie
MI Michel85200 Globetrotter ·
Well, yeah Classic habituation behavior The car is nice It's useful Why not?
michel85200
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
hey michel well yeah, classic habituation behavior? don’t get it well no, it really strikes me valerie
PY Pygmalion19 Veteran ·
Hi Din,

The Maasai eat meat and live off their livestock.

Yes, they eat meat, but not bushmeat, so they aren’t direct competitors with predators. However, if predators threaten their livestock, they *will* defend it! That said, they aren’t the only ones responsible for the decline of big cats or other carnivores. I’m fully aware of that, but they and their herds are still part of the problem. Other factors—like the predators themselves—also need to be considered, making this a complex issue, of course.

Later,
pygmalion
MA Max68 Globetrotter ·
Hi there,

Just a side note: I followed the Instagram link Besl shared—bravo!!! I think your photos are gorgeous and have such an original framing 😎

I won’t comment on the Masai Mara since I haven’t been, but I totally agree with your "stars" for the other camps in Southern Africa, especially BBC Camp where we spent 3 amazing days... By the way, did you also go to Chitake? If not, book a flight ticket and go ASAP 😉

Best,

JF
https://apprentisvoyageurs.com
RJ Rjulie95 Globetrotter ·
So when are you telling us all about this, Jean François? 😛
"Je suis africain, non pas parce que je suis né en Afrique, mais parce que l'Afrique est née en moi." Kwame Nkrumah.

"J'ai appris que le courage n'est pas l'absence de peur, mais la capacité de la vaincre." Nelson Mandela

https://www.en-voyages.fr
MA Max68 Globetrotter ·
Well, it's all on my blog 😉

Have a great rest of the evening!
https://apprentisvoyageurs.com
MI Michel85200 Globetrotter ·
Hello,

Animals have lived alongside humans for a very long time.

Humans are predators to animals. Animals can be predators to humans.

Over generations, animals have grown accustomed to certain situations. These lived experiences are passed down to new generations.

Human = hunter = danger.

If an animal has never encountered a situation before, it won’t identify it as dangerous or disruptive.

Example: Humans arrived on Réunion Island. There had never been humans on this island before. The first travelers could catch birds very easily, by hand. The birds quickly learned from their own experience or their parents’ that humans = danger. Try catching a bird on Réunion Island today! It’s an example of rapid learning across a few generations about a danger. An adaptation to a way of life, a living space... (Another example: the first humans arriving in the Americas via Bering... or in Australia in ancient times... wiping out entire species with "ease").

In an animal park (a closed, long-established one), it’s the opposite. Humans in a car = a big, smelly creature that isn’t dangerous. The cheetah’s grandmother wasn’t afraid because *her* grandmother wasn’t afraid. She passed this behavior down to her daughters, sons, granddaughters, etc... So today, cars = part of life in the park. No danger, and even useful for dominating the savanna. I’m not in danger, I’m not bothered, I use it...

Example: In South Africa (which I know well), buffaloes and cars? No problem. Humans on foot and buffaloes? The buffalo charges... (with exceptions, of course...). Adaptation to this big creature that doesn’t represent danger and doesn’t even seem disruptive. I saw a female leopard use the ranger’s vehicle and its tourists to hunt. I move when the car moves, hidden behind it. I freeze when the car stops... and I sneak up on my prey. Using a "foreign" element that’s become ordinary due to habituation.

That’s why, in cases of culling (for example, too many impalas), they shoot at night from a distant vehicle so there’s no association of car = danger.

So our cheetah isn’t bothered by the car... The jackal comes to pee on the 4x4’s wheel... the leopard hunts with the car. The four cheetahs that hunted a zebra in Madikwe, very close to our car, weren’t disturbed at all.

Well... The price of an animal park where life is still quite wild... is this. Well... Now, too many cars, obviously... excess is rarely a good thing!
michel85200
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
hey michel one foreign element that’s become commonplace is what really gets me honestly, maybe we shouldn’t have let great-grandma climb onto the hood I live in a country that unfortunately ranks in the “top” and is therefore getting more and more visitors so we’re bound to see worse things valerie
PY Pygmalion19 Veteran ·
Hi Michel,

I completely agree with you. I remember a similar moment in Tanzania, in the southern parks. A trio of young lions right by the open 4x4 🦁 No problem at all, even if we were pretty nervous. That’s when I started to understand. As for the crowds of vehicles, I’d be in favor of limiting their numbers through quotas, but not banning access entirely. The parks should remain a business, but a respectful one.
pygmalion
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
hi again I thought, being a vet, your opinion might be a bit different from regular tourists. Madikwe, which you mentioned, is closed to animals but also to visitors—it costs an arm and a leg! I’ve never been there, preferring self-drive. I’d rather see African wild dogs on the main road between Nata and Kasane and two cheetahs between Panda and Robins outside the parks—this actually happened to me, since what everyone ends up writing about on this forum is what they’ve *actually* seen. Valérie
MI Michel85200 Globetrotter ·
Hello,

Unfortunately, if the grandmother hadn’t climbed onto the hood, it would be because there was no tourism. Tourism still brings a lot of money to countries—African ones in this case—that really need it... And probably, I do mean probably, that wildlife (in a world that, whether we like it or not, depends on that money) wouldn’t be protected much...

Seeing African wild dogs on the road you mentioned is amazing, but... for a traveler who’s only there for a limited time, it would be quite a stroke of luck.

Travelers who come to Africa to see animals... prefer to actually see them! In good conditions if possible! Otherwise, they won’t come back.

Madikwe is a closed space, yes, and expensive, but it’s large and recreated. A new, recent space for travelers, sure... but also for the animals that can live there... So, isn’t it still better? No?

As someone who tries to explain that we shouldn’t be fooled by "petting lions" (see my discussion), I’m very aware of the excesses of tourism... but also of its benefits for wildlife, communities, and countries (see Tembe, iSimangaliso, etc.).

As a vet, I try to balance these things.
michel85200
PY Pygmalion19 Veteran ·
Hi Valérie,

I prefer seeing African wild dogs on the main Nata-Kasane road and 2 cheetahs between Panda and Robins outside the parks—this actually happened since everyone eventually writes about what they’ve seen on this forum

... leopard and greater kudus jumping a fence over 1.7 m high on the road from Nata to Maun, impressive! 🙂.

See you,
pygmalion
CH Chiarafont Regular ·
Hello,

Just a side note: I followed the Instagram link Besl shared—bravo!!! I think your photos are stunning and have such an original framing 😎

I won’t comment on the Masai Mara since I haven’t been there, but I completely agree with your "stars" for the other camps in Southern Africa, especially BBC Camp where we spent 3 amazing days... by the way, have you been to Chitake? If not, book a flight ticket and go ASAP 😉

Best regards,

JF

Thanks! No (not yet!), we haven’t been to Chitake, even though we stayed for 9 days. We really fell in love with BBC Camp. Mana Pools is a wonder of the world...
Dream, live, share...
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
No car habituation = danger.

The fact that we don’t automatically see humans as a potential threat wouldn’t be an issue in a perfect world.

But poaching is a real scourge. And animals that get too used to humans are the first victims.

Rhinos let people get way too close. How do we teach them again that we can be real jerks?
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
I didn’t quite get what your usual way of traveling around Africa is?

Totally self-drive? Private car with a driver and logistics handled by an agency? Small-group organized tour?

Accommodation in a rooftop tent, a pitched tent, or a lodge?

Food self-catering, a dedicated cook, or the lodge restaurant?

This could be one of the reasons for your disappointment.
MI Michel85200 Globetrotter ·
Well, this is complicated! Many animals will charge at people on foot 🦁 The hunter In Gorongosa, the animals are very wary After thirty years of slaughter
michel85200
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
I didn’t say it was easy. 😉

But if we want to see rhinos outside of zoos, maybe we should teach them to hate us.

Moving them while making it clear who’s moving them and giving them a fear of helicopters? Stress to avoid ending up as, well, you know… balls, as they say.

A necessary evil.
CH Chiarafont Regular ·
I didn't quite understand what your usual way of traveling around Africa is?

Total self-drive? Private car with a driver and logistics handled by an agency? Organized small-group tour?

Accommodation in a rooftop tent, pitched tent, or lodge?

Food self-catering, a dedicated cook, or the lodge restaurant?

This could be one of the reasons for your disappointment.

I've done a bit of everything in Southern Africa, especially self-drive (Botswana, Zambia, South Africa, Zimbabwe), self-drive with a 4x4 and rooftop tent, game drives through all kinds of lodges—4-star, camping, you name it. Anyway, I'm not here to show off my "resume" of African experiences, but contrary to the venom Doppio might spew, I'm only here to share my point of view. Overall, that’s exactly what this forum is for: sharing experiences, desires, and tips about our shared passion for travel (and it’s perfect that way!). I find it a shame to take things this way because, as I mentioned in my first post in this thread, this is JUST my opinion. I simply feel that some people might be interested in hearing about my experience in the Mara. The place itself is still stunning, the safaris are still fantastic, but the park is, well, quite touristy, and this camp just seemed a bit overhyped and disappointed me in some ways. Anyway, I’m not here to harm Mr. Crocetta’s business—I just have the right to share my experience, even if it doesn’t please everyone... Should we only give our opinion if it’s positive?
Dream, live, share...
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
Some feedback can be explained by travel choices that don’t suit us.

For example, I know a multi-day guided group safari would just not be my thing, whereas others who love that way of traveling would adore it.

Plus, the Masai Mara isn’t exactly known for being quiet.

I think it’s a shame to take things this way

Meaning? I didn’t express any opinions. Just tried to find out more.

No need to get worked up.

Should we only share our opinions if they’re positive?

No. But highlighting what’s positive for us and what’s negative for us.

Criticisms with universal appeal are rare. What you don’t like might appeal to others, and vice versa.

To each their own quirks and desires.

The main issue is knowing them so we can sift through reviews and then take trips that reflect who we are—not the neighbor with totally different expectations.
CH Chiarafont Regular ·
Some feedback can be explained by travel choices that don’t suit us.

For example, I know a multi-day guided group safari would just not be my thing, whereas others who love that way of traveling would adore it.

No. But highlighting what’s positive for us and what’s negative for us.

Criticism with universal intent is rare. What you don’t like might appeal to others, and vice versa.

To each their own quirks and desires.

The main challenge is knowing them so you can sift through reviews and ultimately take trips that reflect who you are—not the neighbor with completely different expectations.

I couldn’t agree more! The whole point was to share what I liked and what I didn’t —everyone has their own way of traveling, as you said, and we generally know our tastes.

And the Masai Mara isn’t known for being low-key.

I still thought—never having been there but having done my research—that the Masai Mara wouldn’t be *that* touristy (meaning, for me, beyond animal welfare and ethics, with 50 vehicles revving around a leopard...). I figured a private safari (just 4 of us in the car—perfect!) would suit me better. I was wrong, that’s all.

In my first post on this thread, I started by saying, on the one hand, that this was just my opinion, and on the other, I also described the things I enjoyed about the trip (the stunning Mara, the comfortable tents, the view of the river from the campsite...).

Sorry for the "I think it’s a shame people are taking it this way"—in this case, I was talking to Dobbio, who’s outraged by my comments because he must have shares in Melting Pot Safari . Joking aside, it’s totally normal for Africa to stir such passion—let’s be honest, it’s just so incredible...!
Dream, live, share...
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
Hey Michel, This idyllic vision of tourism bringing money to local populations... really? Apart from possibly employing them as staff, what else? It’s because the money goes directly into their pockets that they make an effort—take Bob and Zuma, for example. Have you seen the poverty of the rangers at Hwange, Zimbabwe’s largest park? They were so eager to please us for a light bulb or a leaking tap. I just got back from a private camp in Hwange—a small family-run concession, not expensive. When you ask the staff what we can bring them next time, it’s food. Zimbabwe and Botswana are handing everything over to South Africans who want to make a quick buck with luxury lodges. Don’t you think that when private reserves are created, some locals get pushed out? What will they do in Madikwe when there are too many elephants—because it *will* happen—since natural selection isn’t allowed? They’ll let them starve, like what’s happening in Zimbabwe right now due to lack of food. Bad image for tourists. Because in the end, tourists want to see an idealized version of nature, and with a guide, you can avoid the disturbing sights. I have friends in France who have no idea about these issues—they go on cruises and... But I was lucky enough to be born in ’61 and have seen things that no longer exist. And since I’m an Africa lover and have lived here for 16 years, I’m getting a little "emotional." Valerie
MI Michel85200 Globetrotter ·
Good evening, Is this message for me?
michel85200
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
well yeah
ZE Zezettedez Regular ·
Message from October 4th
JI Jijicques ·
Totally agree with you. We visited the Masai Mara on our own, with a rented car and our camping gear, after exploring other parks like Samburu, Nakuru, Aberdare, Tsavo West, and Amboseli (we spent 3 weeks in Kenya). We saved the Masai Mara for last, and, along with Aberdare, it was the most disappointing park for all the reasons you mentioned. We also had to deal with rangers over a serious "offense": two of our wheels had left the track to see leopards eating meat... which those same rangers had just thrown to them (gotta attract tourists to that spot, right?). We got out of it by pretending not to understand a word of English and only speaking French to them. Never has such a farce cost us 100 €. In the end, there are so many less prestigious parks that are nice and give you more than the Masai Mara.
Jijicques
CH Chiarafont Regular ·
Wow! What a heartfelt and frustrating post... I'm just as sorry for you as I am for myself, and I truly hope to one day visit the other parks you mentioned under better circumstances! Thanks for sharing your experience!
Dream, live, share...
SP Spiderweb ·
Sorry you were disappointed, but we just returned from a 10-day safari in the Masai Mara with MELTINGPOT SAFARIS and we were absolutely thrilled. The welcome, organization, meals, and quality of the guide-drivers were all fantastic. When you do this kind of trip, you have to be very open-minded and tolerate a few minor inconveniences or imperfections... Tony CROCETTA wasn’t on-site, but he still called us twice before departure and a third time recently after our return. And we were truly amazed by the wildlife and birdlife we encountered, thanks to the eagle eyes of Edward, our guide-driver! For the record, we travel regularly around the world. This message doesn’t require a specific response; I just wanted to share our positive experience with MELTINGPOT...
RJ Rjulie95 Globetrotter ·
Well, Bernard, back just in time! A little travel journal in the works? 😇
"Je suis africain, non pas parce que je suis né en Afrique, mais parce que l'Afrique est née en moi." Kwame Nkrumah.

"J'ai appris que le courage n'est pas l'absence de peur, mais la capacité de la vaincre." Nelson Mandela

https://www.en-voyages.fr
SP Spiderweb ·
I have a very slow internet connection, so I won’t be posting any photos. Especially since I consider myself a "newbie" when it comes to DSLR cameras. However, you can download a summary of our journey (people, landscapes, animals, birds) here: Download the files: www.grosfichiers.com/X79GxqkJYmb
RJ Rjulie95 Globetrotter ·
Some really beautiful observations and a special mention for the African wild cat! 🙂
"Je suis africain, non pas parce que je suis né en Afrique, mais parce que l'Afrique est née en moi." Kwame Nkrumah.

"J'ai appris que le courage n'est pas l'absence de peur, mais la capacité de la vaincre." Nelson Mandela

https://www.en-voyages.fr
SP Spiderweb ·
I didn’t believe this cat at all (I thought it was a "stray domestic" one...), so I put my camera down too soon because I could’ve gotten much better shots!
BL Blesl Veteran ·
Hi Bernard (nice name, right, I’m jooooking),

Maybe you could take advantage of the lockdown to share some of your best photos? I’ll admit I don’t like downloading friends’ photos—not so much for security reasons (fake JPG files with malware, which isn’t an issue here) or storage space, but because of the risk of importing random keywords that don’t match ours. There, I said it.

Otherwise, thanks for your justified, positive feedback about Melting Pot. If there was still any doubt, it’ll help set the record straight, call a spade a spade, and dot the i’s, etc.

Have a great day, take care of yourselves, and stay safe!

BL
safari photo en Tanzanie et ailleurs https://safari-tanzanie.fr WILIPI photographie animalière
SP Spiderweb ·
Yes, some i's need to be dotted...

For photos, I have an ADSL connection with a *very* *very* *very* slow speed, so I don’t dare try! Back in the day... in 2025 (sic!) when my countryside is hooked up to fiber, I’ll get into it. Hi Hi! Another panorama on F....R: https://www.flickr.com/photos/187263250@N02/
JI Jijicques ·
With two friends, we spent three weeks in Kenya on a self-drive trip. Aberdare and the Masai Mara were the most disappointing parks. Luckily, since we were independent, we didn’t stay more than a day—same reasons as you mentioned. We were also threatened with a $100 fine because two wheels of our vehicle went off the track... and we were only saved by pretending we didn’t speak a word of English... There are cheaper, friendlier, and far more charming parks. And Kenyans are welcoming, helpful, and even selfless when they realize you’re struggling sometimes...
Jijicques
CH Chiarafont Regular ·
Hi Bernard, thanks for your feedback. This isn’t about competing perspectives—I just shared my own because I wish I’d had these insights before leaving.

That said, I’ll admit that the Masai Mara is indeed a very busy park, and I was aware of that before I went. It’s a shame for such a beautiful corner of Africa, but personally, I won’t be going back for all the reasons I mentioned. Oh well, the world still has so much to offer! ;)

Jijicques, thanks for your reply too. I’d love to hear about other incredible places if you’re happy to share! 😉
Dream, live, share...
JI Jijicques ·
Claire, what might interest you about Kenya, Tanzania, or Zanzibar, where we were in September 2019? We were there on a free drive, without going through an agency.
Jijicques
CH Chiarafont Regular ·
Oh, thanks for your feedback! I know you can also go there on a self-drive trip. I’d be really interested in Tanzania, since I’ve never been and, like many, I dream of the wildebeest migration. Kenya in general too—if you’ve had any incredible safari moments yourself, especially if you were lucky (and maybe experienced) enough to spot animals without being packed in with 50 vehicles around one poor creature...

Camps, local guides if needed, and vehicle rental agencies—everything interests me! Thanks a million in advance for sharing!
Dream, live, share...
GI Girardinpho Veteran ·
Hi there,

Back in 2018, we did a self-drive trip in Tanzania and had some amazing encounters. If you need any tips, I’d be happy to help. Otherwise, you can check out our travel journal on our site!
Nathalie

Photos et carnets de voyage : http://www.girardinphoto.net

Similar discussions

You might also like