Skip to content
Who really loves India?
India › South Asia (Indian subcontinent) Fastkoala

Who really loves India?

Translated into English.
Add a reply…

Sign in to reply

Your reply to “Who really loves India?” is one step away. We’ll bring you right back to it.

Create a free account

Why become a member?

74 replies

Noham· 18 years ago
I just got back from India after a short 10-day trip to the Golden Triangle (Delhi-Jaipur-Agra)


10 days—wow! I think the answer’s already clear. I don’t think anyone who truly loves India would’ve stayed only 10 days or stuck to just that "Golden Triangle."
Noham· 18 years ago
The reasons you didn’t like India are right there in your question: Time. You can’t appreciate this country with a 10-day itinerary! On my first trip, it took me about a week just to acclimate, and on top of that, I don’t think you did the best of Rajasthan—you missed Jaisalmer, Udaipur... cities that are human-scale and truly charming. As for accommodation, if you’d been willing to pay what you’d pay in France, you’d have gotten high-end service and people fussing over you😉; Anyway, like I always say, a trip to India takes preparation, study; you’ve got to love the history of civilizations, be ready for a journey that won’t always be a walk in the park. You don’t just end up here by chance, hesitating between Izmir and Majorca in a brochure😎


Oops, I hadn’t read to the end—that’s exactly what I think from A to Z. Time, preparation, and reading beyond tourist guides (I talked about this in another post). That said, if travel agencies didn’t present India like Izmir or Majorca and took the time to "talk" to travelers, to gauge them, to "psychoanalyze" them a little (as Stalingrad put it) to offer something else by understanding who they’re dealing with in that armchair across from them... but I must be dreaming—profit first, right? One more thing to add: talk, talk, talk with as many travelers as possible who’ve visited India. Of course, there’ll be the worst anecdotes and the most glowing praise. After that, you make your choice, deep down. Either you give up on it, or you dive in, or (what I chose) you go and see for yourself, knowing full well there’ll be the worst and/or the best. You experience it, feel it, and then you share your story, saying, "This is me." People criticize your bitterness, but maybe you’re still caught up in the emotions of what you feel was a failure? Maybe you’re taking it out on others a little? Maybe you’re expressing your own frustration at not having loved it, at not having felt what so many travelers feel when they visit this continent? At having chosen this destination without prior info? In a way, it seems like you’re blaming them because YOU didn’t like it. But you’re allowed to say: I didn’t like it. Emotions are deeply personal.
Duppyconquer· 18 years ago
Hey,

I recommend checking out these videos if you have time—it won’t take long. For some people, this is what can happen: http://www.dailymotion.com/...me%2Bde%2Bl%2527inde ("some tourist crazy, some tourist not crazy" like the little girl says in the video).

Look, after some people struggle with this country, it’s normal. Everything is so different—it’s not Tunisia or England. In India, you’re faced with a *real* culture clash. Some people remember mostly that (photos 1 and 2).

Others are literally transported by a kind of energy (lol), seriously—mysticism, spirituality, life everywhere. Here, all our senses are heightened. Okay, maybe I’m exaggerating a little, but that’s the effect it has on me ;) What allows me to fully live it, while managing what you’ve seen, is remembering this (photos 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8).
KliFF· 18 years ago
It's hard to stay indifferent about a country like India. Indeed, it seems unreasonable to love or reject everything outright. I traveled through much of the country for four months earlier this year, and I adored the gentleness of South India, as well as the high peaks of India, particularly in Sikkim. On the other hand, the overcrowded Ganges Valley and the ultra-touristy Rajasthan with its air-conditioned coaches, where you run into the same tourists from city to city, didn’t leave me with unforgettable memories.

It’s impossible to stay unmoved by so much life at every crossroads, by such a complex spiritual life, by that deafening concert of sounds, all those crowds, those smells. After about fifteen weeks, my digestive system and I had had enough, and we were happy to leave. But just a few days later, in Bangkok, I was already missing that crazy country (said affectionately, of course). Will I go back someday? Absolutely! ... I found it’s more a country to "experience" than to visit, and one that deserves you stay as long as possible to form a nuanced opinion, if you have the chance, of course.
Serendipita7· 18 years ago
Goethe, who doesn’t strike me as half an idiot, said something very true: "Tolerance should only be a transitional state. It must lead to respect. To tolerate is to offend."

Now, it seems to me that saying—or letting others say—about a country, under the guise of tolerance, that everything there is noise, filth, scams, and that there’s nothing good to take away from it, isn’t showing much respect. In my opinion, it’s even a form of racism.

You can say you didn’t like it without claiming there’s nothing to love in that country. Don’t you think? Isn’t that what tolerance—or rather, respect—is really about?

Besides, I’m not saying Club Med is a horrible thing—far from it—I’m just saying you shouldn’t judge all situations by the same standards. That’s all. I don’t see where the harm is.
Noham· 18 years ago
I hated it: Madurai, Tanjavur, Chennai.


Could you elaborate, please? For those of us who’ve never been and are planning to stay there? I’m planning to spend at least 8 days in Madurai myself.
Sara70· 18 years ago
I found the city of Madurai really unpleasant—extremely noisy and oppressive. The temple is magnificent, that’s for sure, even though it’s under renovation so the towers are hidden by scaffolding. The atmosphere inside is also very special and pleasant, but outside of that, I couldn’t stand the city.

It’s totally a personal opinion—I arrived in Madurai after a week of traveling and had a full-on anxiety attack there, to the point where I almost went back to France.
Michel46· 18 years ago
Hi, It's true, it's a complete change of scenery. A lot of people in France complain, but they should go visit other countries! Still, you get to see amazing sights despite everything that's said. I posted a tiny photo preview on the site: http://michel.talon.free.fr Have a great day
Marcomarco· 18 years ago
I hated: Madurai, Tanjavur, Chennai.


Could you elaborate, please? For those who’ve never been and are planning to stay there? I’m planning to spend at least 8 days in Madurai.

everyone’s got their own tastes... I love these places! 😎 That’s where you really feel like you’re in the India that *lives*.
Duppyconquer· 18 years ago
Hi Sara,

I invited you to watch some short videos about this anxiety phenomenon. If we're stressed, if we're tired, it's normal that we might only see "the bad sides." I totally understand you on that level. For example, last year, I went from India to Nepal—no problem there. After that, I headed to Thailand, and... after a week and a half, I fled to Laos even though I was in the south. What I remember most about Thailand is the prostitution, pedophilia, propaganda, and the Anglo-Saxons taking over the places. You see, everything is debatable...

For the link, either go to the first page of this post and it’s at the bottom (with photos), or go to Dailymotion and search for "India syndrome."

Hasta Luego,

David.
Show 10 more replies
Marcomarco· 18 years ago
Hi Sara,

I invited you to watch some short videos about this anxiety phenomenon. If we're stressed or tired, it's normal to focus only on "the bad sides." I totally understand where you're coming from. For example, last year, I went from India to Nepal—no problem there. Then I moved on to Thailand, and after a week and a half, I fled to Laos while I was in the south. What I remember most about Thailand is the prostitution, pedophilia, propaganda, and the Anglo-Saxons taking over the places. You see, everything’s debatable...

For the link, either go to the first page of this post (it’s at the bottom with photos) or head to Dailymotion and search for "syndrome de l'inde."

Hasta Luego,

David.


These are the docs I uploaded to "Dailymotion," here’s the address: http://www.dailymotion.com/playlist/xg8a3_froggygoestobollywood_south-india

😉
Noham· 18 years ago
There’s no accounting for taste… I just love these places! 😎 Here, you really feel like you’re in the real India.


Well, I’m actually pretty passionate about it too, which is why I chose to stay longer. When I get back, I’ll have plenty to share and stories to tell about all these places
Duppyconquer· 18 years ago
This is an excellent documentary, and I watched it again last night. Thanks for posting it on Dailymotion, Marc😉

"You want a video? Get a real video, not a virtual one. Which god do you want? Here, you have all the gods. Do you want a blue pill or a red pill?" (Excerpt from the video)

So, on that note, I always conclude by saying, "Some tourists crazy, some tourists not crazy"🙂.

Cheers,

David.
Dumnorix· 18 years ago
It's curious all these stories of anxiety and delirium! I read the book "Mad About India", it's really interesting! But we always hear stories of people who have problems—aren’t there also people for whom everything goes well? People who simply enjoy their trip without having anxiety attacks or delirious episodes?
Noham· 18 years ago
No, no, marcomarco and Stalingrad know how to get us excited—they give us tons of details and make us want to dive in. They’ve got plenty of arguments. On the other hand (no offense meant), a short sentence without details, like "I couldn’t stand the city" or "it stresses me out," doesn’t tell me much or explain anything...
Noham· 18 years ago
or else you go on Dailymotion and type "India syndrome".


I found lots of videos, but not "India syndrome"
Duppyconquer· 18 years ago
Hi,

To be honest, I'm far from being an expert. However, for example, I know that my first trip was truly an experience. I went alone during the summer holidays with my backpack (I've always been a bit of an adventurer;-). When I returned to France, it wasn’t easy... I had too much comfort, I didn’t need all that, it was useless. People in the street, nothing was happening anymore, no noise, no scents, no discovery around every corner... I finished my studies, left again the following year, and rediscovered this country I love so much.

Of course, there are plenty of people for whom everything goes well. It’s just that there’s a real culture shock in India. You can go to Africa or South America; it’ll never be comparable to what you can experience in India😉.

Don’t be apprehensive—everyone reacts differently. Just look at how opinions vary in this thread...

And you, fellow forum members, what do you think? Does this make us all "prone" to some kind of neurosis?

Cheers,

David.
Duppyconquer· 18 years ago
Hi Noham,

Check the first page of this post. There's a message I left with photos at the bottom of the page. You'll find the link to access the video in that reply to Sara ;). I think it lasts about 45 minutes, but it's a really excellent documentary if you have time tonight.

Cheers,

David.
Piecaud· 18 years ago
Same opinion! For someone who’s never been to Thailand, Vietnam, or Indonesia, I get it. For someone who’s pissed about having paid for their flight ticket and doesn’t want to admit to friends back home that the grime, poverty, and smells, etc., overshadow the pretty pictures—I get it. For the person who loves Smecta and Imodium… I get it.

In short, it can definitely appeal to a lot of people, but I don’t think there’s anything wrong with saying it still sucks… and that you can easily find better.

I spent 3 weeks in Ladakh—you’ll say it’s not *really* India—but I met people there who were taking a break after a tough stay in Rajasthan or some other scorching, filthy place. And in Leh, everyone dreads the stopover in Delhi.
Noham· 18 years ago
Okay, thanks David. I'm on vacation, the weather's crap, so it's perfect for continuing to dream about my trip—just 4 more months of patience. A little nap and I'll check it out right away

You might also like