vous pouvez voir en entier l'emission si vous avez une box avec m6 replay
ce reportage nous met bien dans l'ambiance des croisieres en plus ils montrent un peu les coulisses
Bonus nous etions sur le bateau quand ils ont tournés le reportage ( nous avons reconnus les personnages )
Mais le peut que j'ai vu, je trouve dommage que les explications sur la croisière ne soit pas plus positif et il manque la partie Yacht club du Splendida...
Bonjour
Tu n'as pas tout vu ! Si si ils ont montré le yacht club à plusieurs reprises, le majordome qui passait la cabine au crible avant l'arrivée des croisierites .puis l'accueil personnalisé, avec la visite de la piscine , de la conciergerie, de la cabine, avec "champagne".puis l'ascenseur avec acces privé avec la carte . Ils ont expliqué que c'etait un espace Vip et que ces passagers payaient quatre fois plus que les autres , pour la tranquillité.
De quoi me donner encore plus envie d'être au 14 juin en profiter,
J' ai lu sur le site msc que l'espace yacht club sera plus grand sur les deux nouveaux bateaux en commande. Cela fera plus de choix dans les itinéraires, si comme tu disais , quand on a goûté au yacht club on ne peut plus aller dans "le reste du bateau "
Bonsoir Claudine
D'abord merci pour le lien,
Ensuite je suis d'accord avec toi ça donne pas forcément une bonne image de la croisière mais ça reflète quand-même bien la realite, comme par exemple où l'on voit les enfants dans le jacuzzi...C'est la volonté des compagnies qui veulent une democratisation des croisières et je l'ai souligné dans le questionnaire en Fin de croisiere à laquelle nous avons participés, nous etions sur le bateau lorsqu'ils ont tournés le reportage.
Après chacun peut vivre sa croisiere comme il le veut a condition de faire les choses un peu en decalage avec les autres voyageurs et là c'est deja plus agreable.Sinon il y a le yacht club mais ce n'est pas encore dans mes moyens.
Bonjour,
Je viens de le regarder
Je ne le trouve pas négatif il reflète bien la réalité : le monde à la cafétéria quand le bateau arrive en début d'après midi, les excursions Msc au pas de course ... Mais quand on connaît un peu, on sait que l'on peut aller au restaurant et que l'on met organiser les excursions soit même 😉
Je pense que ce bateau n'est pas adapte aux personnes âgées car trop grand, ni aux très jeunes enfants
En effet le yatch club, ça donne envie, peut être un jour ...
Je confirme : des habitudes se prennent au YC , et un goût prononcé pour en reprendre un peu " trottine " dans nos esprits .... dès le retour .
Nous avions essayé le YC sur le Fantasia ..... pour voir , .... comme un tour de manège . ( compte rendu : " Transat Brésil au Yacht club du MSC Fantasia " sur le site )
- ... A la fin de l' année , nous aurons vécu près de 60 jours en YC ; sur 3 bateaux différents .... de chutes en rechutes .
Ce n' est pas tellement que vous ne sentiez plus bien la grandeur de vos hésitations pour recommencer , .... c 'est que vous n' avez plus envie d' aller ailleurs .
Nous essayons une cure de désintoxication en suite Auréa sur le Magnifica cet été . Il faut un traitement progressif ....
Beau voyage a tous les passagers qui découvrirons cela .
j'ai egalement eté déçue par le manque d'enthousiasme de ces croisieristes, leur capacité à raler : notamment le jeune homme qui ne fait pas vraiment d'effort pour se faire comprendre par la reception au sujet de sa chambre qui semble etre une chambre pour deux et non pour 4. Et egalement la jeune femme qui n'est pas contente que les babysitter soient en exercice de sauvetage au lieu detre au mini club. La securité est importante, on ne peut pas raler pour cela.........
Bonjour,
C'est bien representatif du français moyen 😄
Lors de ma dernière croisière lors d'une excursion des nanas ralaient car le guide parlait d'abord italien puis qu'elle n'entendaient pas alors qu'elles faisaient plus de bruit en ralant 🙁, elles se sont fait ramasser pour les autre ...
Peux-tu précisé ta pensée ou la développer de chute en rechute ?
Si tu parles de mauvaises prestations, alors j'en ai beaucoup mais chez Costa même en suite...
Alexandre
.. Non , non .... au contraire : cela nous plait tellement que nous y retournons sans hésiter a chaque fois .
Dans mon expression : - le " raisonnable " n' impose pas le Yacht Club . MSC propose des catégories et des voyages qui sont tout a fait bien hors YC .
Je voyage maintenant , et reste chez MSC .
Mais dans une théorie , ou le raisonnable devrait l' emporter sur " le super plus du YC " : ... nous choisissons le YC !!!
Nous n' arrivons pas a nous guérir de ces bonnes choses , et comme une maladie , qui n' en finit pas ... " - ... de chutes en rechutes ... " : nous y retournons .
Par contre si pas de bateau avec yacht club, on ne prend pas...
Pour nous, on a fait une dernière tentative costa (après 2 ans d'absence) pourtant en grande suite samsara, mais très déçu des prestations....🏴☠️😠
Alors, nous avons attendu notre retour Costa pour réservez la suivante, nous avons 2 croisières yacht club de réservé:
du 18 au 26 octobre 2014 sur le Précioza
du 8 au 19 avril 2015 sur le Fantasia en suite royale et c'était la dernière, donc maladie oblige de réserver pour un excellent soins...
D'habitude chez Costa nous avions toujours 1 ou 2 croisières de réservez d'avance, et maintenant chez MSC
Je voudrai qu'il mette aux Emirat un bateau avec YC...
Bonjour
Si j'ai bien compris, il y a le virus des croisieres classiques et le virus encore plus virulent du yacht club !
J'ai lu ton compte rendu sur la transatlantique Brésil -Italie. Ça me tente bien , mais pour plus tard, car il faut se libérer au moins trois semaines .
J'ai été étonnée de lire que le yacht club n'était pas complet, je pensais que pour ce genre de croisière, il fallait reserver très tôt, parce qu'il n'y en a que deux ( une à l'aller et une au retour).J'aurais pensé que ce serait vite complet.Tant mieux ça laisse plus de temps pour se décider.
Merci pour ce comte rendu détaillé.
Claudine
C'est marrant parce que en croisière classique je trouve le service chez Costa un poil au dessus de Msc au niveau service cabine et restaurant ( pas self et accueil embarquement ).
Je n'arrive pas à juger si la différence de prix du yc est justifiée ?
Bonjour, pour l'instant je ne connais le yacht club qu'en rêve, ou plutôt en projet! Nous partons , avec mon mari, le 14 juin prochain , sur le msc splendida , en yacht club . Comme ce sera notre dixième croisiere (7 avec Costa , 2 avec Msc, la dernière sur le même bateau) Je pourrais t'en dire un peu plus au retour .
Mais comme les prestations évoluent dans le sens de la dégradation avec le temps ...ce n'est pas évident de comparer .
Il faut dire que pour les prix (hors yacht club) ils ont aussi bien baissé en une dizaine d'années.
Claudine
C'est vrai que le prix yacht club a bien baissé mais depuis 2 ans, le prix reste le même.
Entre les avantages et se qui est inclus dans le prix yacht club, une fois tout payé à bord en cabine classic balcon minimum (hors promo), on arrive au prix yacht club.
Une fois que vous aurez testé le yacht club, vous serez contaminé...
Bonjour ,
En tous cas la communauté des grands malades de ces virus est très sympathique.
Merci pour vos réponses et vos indications.
Ce forum est une mine d'or pour préparer une croisière. J'ai déjà fait neuf croisières et je regrette de ne pas avoir connu ce forum avant .
Je me demande, , si il ne se "déconnecait" pas au bout de quelques minutes de lecture , il y a quelques années.
Il y a beaucoup de choses que l'on découvre tout seul , mais c'est beaucoup mieux d'être informé a l'avance.
Merci encore
Claudine
Just back from our first cruise on the Renaissance, and I’d like to share a few thoughts about life on board. Our feelings are mixed—we wanted a change after several MSC cruises, but the value for money on this repositioning cruise left us torn.
After taking advantage of successive promotions, we finally secured a well-located balcony cabin for 2600 € (almost 50% off the brochure rate). Given the amenities and the ship’s age, this now feels like the absolute maximum we’d pay for that period.
Overall, we were happy with our vacation on board, but a few details—when added up—left us with a somewhat mixed impression.
The pros:
- Ship size
- Reasonable noise levels, except in the restaurants (aside from the covered pool area)
- Spacious balcony cabin (20 + 5 m²) with plenty of storage and a bathtub with jets
- Understated, tasteful decor
- French language spoken on board
- Friendly staff for the most part
- 100% French-speaking clientele
- Decent food with French dishes (even with an Indian chef)
- Tables for two available (though the ship was full, so no changes possible)
- Some high-quality shows, thanks to an excellent English-speaking troupe
- Interesting lectures (especially on history and cetaceans)
The cons:
- Unreliable air conditioning in common areas (you’d go from a freezing lounge to a hot one, as if the system only worked in certain spaces at certain times)
- Aging ship with a few glitches (noises, AC, toilet flushes, lights) reported at reception (luckily, our only issue was the bathroom door not closing...)
- Industrial, thawed-out bread and pastries (a letdown for a ship with a French image)
- Limited fruit selection (often just apples and watermelon/melon) and not much variety in vegetables
- Worn, sometimes stained restaurant towels
We’re not ruling out another cruise on the Renaissance—their itineraries are unique—but only at a very competitive price.
Hi, I’m about to go on a cruise on the Costa Smeralda but I’ve never been on a cruise before. Could anyone share the à-la-carte drink menu? I’d like to know if the prices are excessive, since the MyDrinks drink packages, for example, cost 266 € per adult.
Have a great day! 😉
Hi everyone,
I’m going on a Mediterranean cruise in November and I’m looking for some "tips" to visit the cities of Naples, Messina, and Valletta in Malta without booking the ship’s excursions, which are really expensive.
Thanks so much for your advice and suggestions. We’re a group of 6 people.
Looking forward to hearing from you...
Best,
M
PS: We’re also stopping in Genoa and Barcelona—even though we know these two cities, we’d still love any tips for visiting them!
Thanks
Hello everyone,
We’re a senior couple signed up for a 13-day cruise in Japan on the Princess Sapphire, departing from Yokohama on April 8, 2027.
Are there any other French speakers on this forum who’ll be on this trip?
Hoping for a reply...
Hi,
The MSC Magnifica has been refurbished and a Yacht Club class has been added. Could anyone share their impressions of cabin 14001, as the view is slightly obstructed? Is it really a "disadvantage" in terms of brightness? Thanks in advance
Hi, we're heading to Venice soon. We have a hotel in Mestre and we'd like to know which bus can take us from the Mestre hotel to Marghera Port. Thanks.
Hi everyone ...
We’re planning to do the 83-day Cunard cruise ...
departing from Southampton on January 10, 2027 aboard the Queen Anne ...
has anyone done it ... or have any info ... or tips ...
for example ... deck and cabin choices ... drink packages ... excursions ... etc.
... anything good to know about this ship???
Thanks everyone ...
Hi there,
Here’s the 2027 cruise schedule.
It’s a great way to get ideas and maybe even meet up with other members!
2 essential rules:
1) Never "quote" the schedule when replying—this avoids any confusion.
2) Follow this format:
DD/MM - username / SHIP IN CAPS / number of days / cruise title / departure port
DON’T FORGET THE SPACES between the / /
REMINDER Despite my requests, few people follow the requested format. Cruises that stray too far from it won’t be listed anymore—sorry about that. IMPORTANT Please respect the templates!
PLEASE COPY AND PASTE THE FORMAT BELOW AND REPLACE WITH YOUR DETAILS IF YOU’RE HAVING TROUBLE
DD/MM - username / SHIP IN CAPS / number of days / cruise title / departure port
DON’T FORGET THE SPACES between the / /
It takes time to fix mistakes, so THANKS TO EVERYONE for your help!
YOUR TURN 😉
NUMBER OF 2027 CRUISES: 1
JANUARY
14/01 - poupou10 / AZAMARA JOURNEY / 74 days / South America Tour / Miami
FEBRUARY
MARCH
APRIL
MAY
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER
Hi there,
I’m looking for an all-inclusive Nile cruise on a comfortable boat with as few passengers as possible.
Which tour operator can you recommend?
Thanks in advance.
I’m about to book the panoramic suite, and I’m not sure whether I should go for the one at the front of the ship or the one at the back. I’d really appreciate any feedback—anyone who’s already booked this kind of suite and can share the pros and cons?
Hi,
We’ll be visiting Barcelona for the first time on our upcoming cruise.
I was wondering if it’s better to book a taxi in advance to get from the train station to the cruise terminal, since there’ll be four of us. Are there enough taxis around that we won’t have to wait too long?
For the return trip, same question—are there enough taxis, since we have a flight to catch? Though I doubt we’ll know in advance which terminal we’ll dock at.
I came across this site below—has anyone heard of it?
https://taxibarcelona.taxi/fr/
hi there
Here’s the cruise schedule for 2026.
It’s a great way to get ideas and maybe even meet up with other members.
2 essential rules:
1) never "quote" the calendar when replying—this’ll avoid any confusion
2) follow the format below
DD/MM - username / SHIP IN CAPS / number of days / cruise title / departure port
DON’T FORGET THE SPACES between the / /
REMINDER Despite my requests, few people follow the requested format. Cruises that stray too far from it won’t be listed anymore—sorry!PLEASE respect the templates!
COPY AND PASTE THE FORMAT BELOW AND REPLACE WITH YOUR DETAILS IF YOU’RE STRUGGLING
DD/MM - username / SHIP IN CAPS / number of days / cruise title / departure port
DON’T FORGET THE SPACES between the / /
It takes time to fix mistakes, so THANKS TO EVERYONE for your help!
YOUR TURN 😉
NUMBER OF CRUISES 2026:
JANUARY
FEBRUARY
MARCH
APRIL
MAY
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER
Hi everyone, we're going on a week-long cruise and I have a question: can we travel by train and on a cruise with small refrigerated injectable syringes?
Do we need to complete any formalities?
And how should we store them?
Thanks in advance for your feedback.
I'm considering a cruise on the Hurtigruten Coastal Express from Bergen to Kirkenes and back to Bergen over 11 days in mid-March 2027.
Has anyone already done this trip?
I think it’s a great way to discover the Norwegian coast with the chance to see magnificent northern lights, but isn’t the trip a bit *too* long?
There are about thirty stops, but most last only a few minutes, with just one daily stop of over 2 hours, which gives a quick glimpse of a few towns but doesn’t allow for a full excursion.
Is the supplement for an outside cabin with a porthole (800 € for 2!) really worth it?
It’s more pleasant than an inside cabin, but do you spend enough time in your cabin to make the most of it?
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this journey.
Best regards.
Hi everyone! I’m used to sailing on a sailboat with two or three people—it’s amazing. But I’d love to try the experience of a cruise. Just to clarify, I’ll be going alone. My first question: are there other solo travelers on these cruises, or is it mostly couples and families?
For a first cruise, I’d prefer a short one (maximum 8 days). Do those exist? And on the smallest boat possible. I live in Marseille, so a departure from Marseille would work, but I’m open to other ports too. If you have a cruise line to recommend and a destination you’ve enjoyed, or if you’ve had a great experience on a more intimate-sized ship, I’d love to hear about it!
We’re looking for a group of people available to share an excursion to the Trollstigen (Trolls’ Road).
We’ve contacted a local provider who’s offering us the following rates:
- 6,325 NOK for 4 people
- 6,874 NOK for 5 to 8 people
Don’t hesitate to get in touch if you’d like to discuss!
Happy planning to everyone! !
We just returned from a cruise from 08/13/26 to 08/20/26 on the MSC ORCHESTRA with stops in Tarragona, Valencia, Livorno, Civitavecchia, Genoa, and back to Marseille.
The ship was fully booked. Deck chairs were already occupied by beach towels early in the morning, and there were only 1 or 2 people in the pools... However, on the day the Italians disembarked, there were very few towels on the deck chairs.
We found the Italians less talkative.
We had a balcony cabin on deck 9, starboard side. The cabin was spacious, but the sofa was facing the desk, making it a pain to watch TV (neck strain guaranteed). So, we changed the sofa’s orientation to face the TV (we put it back in place on disembarkation day).
There were 325 French speakers on board, and a lot of staff from Mauritius, which made communication easier.
No annoying announcements about bingo, etc.—a nice change from COSTA.
For dinner, we were at the first sitting at 7:45 PM, at a table for 6. On the first night, we were two "gray-haired" couples at the table. The second night, two young women joined us but asked to change tables after seeing us...
The show for our dinner time was at 10:15 PM and ended around 11:00 PM. We found that a bit late for us. The shows were varied and of good quality.
The restaurant menus offered plenty of choices, but at the buffet at lunchtime, there were a lot of dishes with quite a few carbs. Afternoon tea from 4:30 PM to 5:30 PM included some great pastries, among other things.
We had an issue with the air conditioning and bad odors in the cabin one afternoon. I reported the problem to the reception, and staff along with our cabin steward came to check the cabin. The issue was resolved that same afternoon.
Two days later, we were surprised to find a bag with items inside: 2 MSC mugs and 2 MSC thermos flasks that keep drinks hot or cold for 10 hours. It was a gift from customer service following the bad odors in our cabin. We weren’t expecting this at all and thanked MSC’s customer service.
For excursions, MSC always offers port-to-city-center transfers for 14 € per adult in Valencia and Tarragona, and 12 € per child. In Livorno, it was 10 € per adult and 7 € per child.
In Civitavecchia, there was a shuttle to the train station for 6 €.
On the MSC for Me app, there were "promotions" on certain excursions.
We really enjoyed this cruise, but we couldn’t revisit some stops (Tarragona and Valencia) on our own because it was too hot.
Great evening: Mum49
We're leaving on August 25th for a Danube cruise from Vienna to Bucharest. The travel agency refuses to postpone this cruise despite navigation changes due to the exceptional drought, which include bus transfers that don’t interest us.
Have you had any experiences with this that you’d like to share?
Hi there!
I’m going on a cruise with MSC on the World Europa this coming October.
Stops: Genoa, Naples, Messina, Malta.
Has anyone visited Mount Etna and Pompeii?
Could you share some tips for each of these stops?
I’d like to explore on my own without booking the ship’s excursions.
Thanks for your advice!
Hello!
After a lot of hesitation between different cruise lines (Explora, Oceania, YC, HAL, NCL) and several destinations like Norway, Ireland, and Iceland,
I finally chose NCL’s Star for Iceland.
I had already looked at this itinerary when I went to Scotland in April with CFC, but it was really expensive.
You should know that CFC often offers last-minute deals 45 days before departure (the point when you can no longer cancel or modify).
So, I got a great opportunity and grabbed it.
Departure is on August 23rd.
Hi everyone,
I’m staying in a suite on the Pacifica in October and I can’t find any details about the suite benefits beyond the elite restaurant, the butler, and the espresso machine.
What about breakfast and meals served free in the cabin, and the spa?
Costa’s been cutting back on perks for Gold members, and it seems like suites are next.
Thanks for your replies!
Hello,
We’re back from this cruise.
Boarding in Dunkirk: The doors opened around 12 PM. Since we were a bit early, I asked if my husband, who uses a walker, could wait inside instead of outside. I left him with the two suitcases and our two backpacks in the small hall while I parked the car in the reserved CFC parking lot for 10 € per day.
The shuttle that was supposed to take people from the parking lot to the model pavilion was supposed to arrive in 5 minutes, but after 15 minutes, nothing. After waiting 15 minutes, I saw a man walking and asked if I could follow him. In 15 minutes, we arrived, and still no sign of the shuttle—it must have passed us. Arrived at the model pavilion.
My husband had already checked in the suitcases with the help of a CFC staff member. The remaining formalities were completed quickly. We were on board by 12:15 PM. Headed to the buffet on deck 11 and waited in a lounge to access our cabin.
At 2 PM, we discovered our balcony cabin on deck 9 at the rear: spacious with a large balcony compared to MSC/COSTA.
Since we were at the rear, cabin 9202, there was always an issue with elevator number 4: "priority."
Elevator number 2 stops at deck 10... and elevator number 3 was often out of order, leaving only number 1 for those with mobility issues to reach the buffet, especially for people who struggle with stairs. Note: only one child on board and lots of "gray hair."
DAY 2: At sea. Lots of activities offered.
Day 3: GOTHENBURG (Sweden). Sunny, 19°C at 11 AM.
Excursion booked with CFC: Gothenburg and Haga for all.
Interesting visit with a great guide. The HAGA district, in our opinion, is full of cobblestones and nothing special, not suitable for people using a cane or wheelchair. Elevator number 3 was out of order again.
Day 4: Copenhagen. 15°C in the morning, showers in the afternoon.
We didn’t book an excursion since we’d already stopped here with CFC in 2025, and based on advice from this forum, we took the hop-on/hop-off bus right in front of the ship. I still went to see the Little Mermaid again.
No TV, but the elevator was fixed.
DAY 5: At sea. Still no TV.
DAY 6: GDANSK (Poland). 15°C, rain all day.
There’s a shuttle to get to the city center.
We took the excursion: Panorama of Gdansk.
The guide left us at the entrance of the city center for 45 minutes, telling us what to visit. Meet-up for the rest of the tour at 3 PM. The bus left at 3:15 PM to cover 10 km to see St. Mary’s Cathedral. We arrived at 4:16 PM... The guide said there are often traffic jams in that direction. We had 10 minutes on site before heading to see the lighthouse and the Westerplatte monument, where we also had 10 minutes.
Many of us wondered why we didn’t do the tour in the opposite direction since they knew there would be traffic...
I went to reception to complain about the organization. The staff member read me the program: we were supposed to start with the lighthouse, then go to the cathedral and stay for 30 minutes before heading to the center of Gdansk for a short guided walk with some free time to buy souvenirs, etc.
The guide did the complete opposite of what was planned and didn’t even give us a guided tour—just dropped us off in the city...
DAY 7: Bornholm Island (Denmark). 14°C, a few sunny spells.
We saw in the excursions that there was a walking tour of RØNNE. So, like many others, we explored on our own. There was a small orchestra welcoming us at the port and two people with city maps. We took the shuttle to leave the port—it ran every 15 minutes. The tourist office was next to the "shuttle bus." A pleasant visit at our own pace.
DAY 8: KIEL (Germany). 18–23°C, nice weather.
We took the "Kiel for all" excursion. Great guide and interesting visits.
The port is in the city, and in 10 minutes, we were in the city center by following a blue line on the ground from the port. Elevator 3 was stuck again... and the TV was back.
DAY 9: At sea. Elevator 3 works.
DAY 10: At sea. Elevator 3 is out of order again...
DAY 11: Disembarkation in Dunkirk.
Cabins had to be vacated by 7:30 AM. Buffet open until 9 AM.
Elevator number 1 was "reserved," leaving only number 2, which doesn’t go up to deck 11... a problem for people with mobility issues who had to cross the entire deck 11 and try to use one of the four working elevators at the front, which were crowded.
My opinion: Interesting stops.
The onboard staff were always welcoming, smiling, and mostly French-speaking.
Evening shows were better than in March/April 2025—better singers, dancers, and presenters, and the costumes were improved.
I liked the "magician" shows less.
There were three onboard lectures by a very cultured person, but they went off-topic and were too historical for my taste. I didn’t attend the other two; my husband went to the second but not the third.
For this cruise, there was a bridge theme, but we’re not players or interested.
We didn’t take a drink package on board—water, coffee, tea, and herbal teas were available.
We had a water leak in our cabin the night before disembarkation. We reported it, and after the technical staff came (with a translator who didn’t speak English), we were asked to leave the cabin for a while for repairs. We went to a lounge, and after 1.5 hours, I checked in at reception. The repair took longer than expected... we had to change cabins... not ideal the night before disembarkation. No balcony cabins were available, so we got an ocean-view cabin, 6075, with a bathtub (impossible for both of us to use). We packed our suitcases, took a shower in our cabin, and moved to the new one. Noise from chairs until 12:30 AM because the cabin was under a lounge, and constant ventilation noise in the hallway... sleep was hard to come by.
Disembarkation: Well organized. We were helped with transporting the two suitcases and bags to the waiting room while I took the shuttle to get the car.
Guylène