It seems to me that poverty would be less painful in the sun
FR

Translated into English.

12 1234FP Regular ·
From a purely practical standpoint, without touching on "happiness" in a social or psychological sense, being in the sun—that is, in a hot country—certainly offers more conveniences than being in a cold one.

To take extreme cases, with every passing hour, the Inuit or the Nenets have to struggle against the cold. This means needing clothes, shelter, and making fire... whereas in hot countries, it seems easier to live (or even, unfortunately, to survive)!

Personally, I wouldn’t trade my life in Marrakech for one in Wainwright, Alaska. 😎
LA Lacalo Globetrotter ·
Personally, I wouldn’t trade my life in Marrakech for one in Wainwright (Alaska).

Me neither!!! 😎

But it’d be interesting to ask them: would they prefer living in Marrakech over Wainwright? We might be pretty surprised by their answers...
" Nous ne saurons jamais tout le bien qu'un simple sourire peut être capable de faire." Mère Teresa
TA Tafakara Globetrotter ·
Wouldn't everything be about the light?...
JE Jeanbrfr Veteran ·
" It feels like the south " Nino Ferrer 😎 😉 😎
Le ciel c'est comme la mer à l’envers,

Par dessus tout, c'est la joie qui m'en impose,

Et je vends ma sublime 500 Royal Enfield, qui se bronze à GOA !
KA Kate Globetrotter ·
Well 😮 hi! Didn’t expect to see you here 😉
Mes photos sur Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/153304262@N05/albums "Le Temps nous égare. Le Temps nous étreint. Le Temps nous est gare. Le Temps nous est train".
JE Jeanbrfr Veteran ·
Hey! I’ve been following this thread from the start—it’s a good one. After India, Montpellier’s got me loving the sun. 😎
Le ciel c'est comme la mer à l’envers,

Par dessus tout, c'est la joie qui m'en impose,

Et je vends ma sublime 500 Royal Enfield, qui se bronze à GOA !
KA Kate Globetrotter ·
I’ve been following this thread from the start, this post is good,

Meh... You’re still as classy as ever, huh? 😉 So, what do *you* think about the sun? I see on your profile that your country choices are pretty much driven by the climate, right?
Mes photos sur Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/153304262@N05/albums "Le Temps nous égare. Le Temps nous étreint. Le Temps nous est gare. Le Temps nous est train".
RA Ragamuffin Globetrotter ·
A happy country is one where it rains.

That’s me 🤪

In a similar spirit—song, boat, dreams of exoticism, and travel—and from the same era (1967 for Aznavour’s Emmenez-moi), there’s Guy Bontempelli’s 1966 song Quand je vois passer un bateau.

Dailymotion - Guy Bontempelli - When I See a Boat Pass By ...

The Tilongkabila, a Pelni ship, anchored on May 30, 2008, in the port of Lembar, Lombok (Indonesia).
"Nous ne sommes plus une communauté d'être humains qui se parlent mais un conglomérat de grappes de consommateurs en niches, séparés les uns des autres par des obsessions diverses et innombrables. Nous sommes de l'ère de la désintégration." Marc Moulin (1942-2008) in Humoeurs
JE Jeddhai Regular ·
Hey! To me, happiness—like unhappiness—isn’t really about "place," even if, as jalma says, external "conditions" are often just as necessary (for most of us, anyway) as internal "conditions" or state of mind. More than location or climate, happiness and suffering are really about "mindset" (a positive, serene attitude—or, on the contrary, a pessimistic, anxious one—toward life). Of course, those who love traveling will likely find a lot of happiness in it, but what’s key for a "happy spirit" is being and living in alignment with your dreams and desires. A guy who dreams of being a "sedentary" carpenter or a hermit will probably be at least as happy as someone who dreams of wandering—unless, of course, you take away each of their ways of life. Someone who dreams of finding the love of their life but stays alone, finds no one, or keeps getting rejected will likely be just as sad as someone who dreams of being a monk but is married with three kids. And of course, someone basking in the tropical sun who suddenly craves seeing Norway’s fjords or the Arctic ice will see their happiness melt away in the heat. Everything’s relative, as they say...
«Si tu ne trouves pas d'ami sage, prêt à cheminer avec toi, résolu, constant, marche seul, comme un roi après une conquête ou un éléphant dans la forêt.» Bouddha
KA Kate Globetrotter ·
Hey folks,

I still wonder where you get all these artistic references from?! 😏 Had to remember Guy Bontempelli 🤪 (Did you listen to Wiwi’s version on your Dailymotion page?)

But your sentence is really good: A happy country is a country where it rains. It rhymes too! 😉

I have friends from Béziers who just got back from Belgium. They had to buy sweaters there! But they loved their trip and adored Brussels, despite the bad weather...
Mes photos sur Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/153304262@N05/albums "Le Temps nous égare. Le Temps nous étreint. Le Temps nous est gare. Le Temps nous est train".
VO Voyajou Globetrotter ·
A happy country is one where it rains.

That’s from me 🤪

Oh yeah! And it’s so true these days. In this sunny region that is the Horn of Africa, if it rained more—without turning it into a horn of plenty—the hardship would be a little easier to bear.
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
More than the place or the climate, happiness—as well as suffering—is therefore a matter of "mindset" (positive, serene attitude, or conversely, pessimistic, anxious, etc., toward life)

Maybe... for those whose bellies are full enough to have the mental space for it.
PélicanBrun Veteran ·
Hello geli,

I just want to ask the question: what is happiness?

The answer to this question is both simple and difficult!

A rough answer...

For any individual living on Earth, happiness can only begin to be conceived from a foundation common to all people:

- Having enough to eat (I didn’t say caviar!) - Having decent housing (or shelter) (I didn’t say a castle!) - Staying in good health (in other words, being able to get proper medical care when you’re sick!)

Harder to achieve:

- Living in peace (that’s actually a bit more difficult, since the warrior spirit is so deeply rooted in human nature!!!)

Once these essential elements are in place—which, by the way, should be easily achievable anywhere in the world with our current scientific knowledge and a more equitable distribution of wealth—we can only then start talking about the "other factors" that contribute to happiness!

Such as: love, friendship, education, culture, leisure (travel is part of that!), beliefs, unnecessary material goods, etc., etc., etc... 😉

And honestly (to get back to the original topic of the discussion!), I don’t think sunshine has any importance in all of this!!!

When you’re cold, you bundle up, and when you’re hot, you take off layers and find some shade—end of story!!!!!!!!!!!!😉😉😉
GE Geli Veteran ·
Good evening Pelican

I just wanted to talk about the simple joy of living. One day, deep in a bush village, a young man told me: "here we have the land to grow food, the sun to keep us warm, our huts to shelter us, and our children"—that’s happiness!

And like you said: back then they had enough to eat, which isn’t always true today, enough to shelter themselves, and enough to take care of their health (hmm, that’s debatable, unless real traditional healers—not charlatans—still use local remedies) 😉
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
And honestly (to get back to the original topic of the discussion!), I don’t think the sun has any importance in all this!!! When you're cold, you bundle up, and when you're hot, you strip down and find some shade—end of story!!!!!!!!!!!!😉😉😉

And what about when it rains?????😉

It’s not the temperature that matters, but the sunlight, which affects our health (see light therapy).

I don’t know if it works, but I’d trade the current downpour for a few hours of sunshine without hesitation🤪
SO Songhai73 Globetrotter ·
let's stop complaining! ;) At work, I used to deal with people who complained about the rain one day and the next about it being too hot... Let's enjoy the present moment! 😏😏😏😏😏😏😏
le mérite d'un homme réside dans sa connaissance et dans ses actes et non point dans la couleur de sa peau ou de sa religion! Khalil Gibran
PélicanBrun Veteran ·
Hello!

And what about when it rains?????😉

Taking shelter and watching the rain fall can sometimes have a certain charm! 😏

Just like listening to the wind blow in the desert! Or hearing thunder rumble and seeing lightning streak across the sky!

Observing (when you're safely sheltered!) nature unleashing its elements can sometimes be quite enjoyable!

Of course, all in moderation—as I can already see you coming to tell me about cyclones, earthquakes, floods, and volcanic eruptions!!! 😉😉😉

Oh, I almost forgot: For you, who seems to love light... A little "hello" at the start of a message is, you see, like a first "ray of sunshine" brightening up the rest of the conversation! 😉 Are you sensitive to my luminous poetry? 😏
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
at work, I used to deal with people every day who’d moan about the rain and then the next day about the heat being too much...

I think talking about the weather is a total workplace classic. And then the weather forecast is the most-watched TV show in France
SO Songhai73 Globetrotter ·
hi 😉 I’m talking about my clients, not my work colleagues—I worked alone! And I’m not sure people are any less depressed when it’s hot... though in Africa, I never saw my friends taking antidepressants! Why are we the biggest consumers of these treatments?????? Have a good evening, Francia
le mérite d'un homme réside dans sa connaissance et dans ses actes et non point dans la couleur de sa peau ou de sa religion! Khalil Gibran
SE Sempervirent Regular ·
Let’s stop complaining!😉 At work, I used to deal with people who’d complain about the rain one day and the heat the next... Let’s enjoy the present moment! 😏😏😏😏😏😏😏

Good evening,

It’s true that we could do like Pernault’s 1 p.m. news—nothing but lighthearted, trivial stories to keep everyone happy—but I much prefer those who challenge the status quo for the most vulnerable, to avoid confusion with others who shake everything up just to end up like a roly-poly toy, changing nothing in reality—or even giving more to their own clique!
La réponse est oui. Mais quelle était la question ? Woody Allen
KA Kate Globetrotter ·
And then the weather is the most-watched TV program in France

So we’re all really preoccupied with it! It’s also a topic we often bring up when we run into someone we know. And bad weather usually gets us down... Except for Brassens 😉

"Talk to me about rain, not fine weather Fine weather disgusts me and makes me grind my teeth The beautiful blue sky infuriates me For the greatest love I was ever given on earth I owe to bad weather, I owe it to Jupiter It fell from a stormy sky"
Mes photos sur Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/153304262@N05/albums "Le Temps nous égare. Le Temps nous étreint. Le Temps nous est gare. Le Temps nous est train".
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
You really seem attached to that little word....

Hello! (or rather, good evening given the time ;))

I don’t think it’s very fitting for a forum because, to me, that word is more for speaking than writing. I think there’s an emoji with a little yellow guy holding a "hello" sign—that little drawing would make a better introduction for a forum. If VF could add it to their panel......

Taking shelter and watching the rain fall can sometimes have a certain charm! 😏

Just like listening to the wind blow in the desert! Or hearing thunder rumble and seeing lightning streak across the sky!

Observing (when you’re safely sheltered!) nature unleashing its elements can sometimes be quite enjoyable!

Even without being sheltered, all of this can be really pleasant!

But back to moderation ;), not every day 😄

Since this topic is very "song-like," I’ll take the liberty of quoting *Au P'tit Bonheur* with "I want some sun" :)
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
Another fan of the little word ;)

Hi there!

I’m not sure people are less depressed when it’s hot... though in Africa, I never saw my friends taking antidepressants!

You associate sun with heat, but the sun is also just linked to the word *light*. It seems to me that Nordic countries are hit hard by seasonal depression. It’s true that the almost endless night in winter is enough to get you down

Why are we the biggest consumers of these treatments??????

Medical school teachings? Pharma reps? The pharmaceutical lobby? Ignorance?
JE Jeddhai Regular ·
The society of the "Western model" is often a form of materialistic "false religion" that claims or makes its "flocks" or "citizens" believe that happiness is just around the corner! But that’s rarely the case. More often than not.

Poverty in so-called "developed" countries is certainly much harder to live with than in the pampas or the jungle (not the urban jungle, which is often far worse).

Because the system they’re trying to impose on the entire planet is always the same: work hard for your boss your whole life (or die trying), be a "good little worker," find a partner, have kids, and then die—that’s it. That’s what’s offered in a so-called "modern" society. That’s why so many suffer intensely in this system, why there’s despair, the "no hope" feeling so common among young people and newcomers ("We’ll all have to tighten our belts, there’s not much room left..."). How are they supposed to find their place? "So this is why I was born? I’m going to waste my life just to earn it?"

That’s the world most have chosen to "follow." And let’s not forget the "dropouts," the excluded, those lost along the way—because let’s be honest, not everyone will find a job, love, health, family, or kids. Even fewer will find "leisure, travel, consumer goods, houses, cars for all, and all the rest." Dream on.

That’s why the "depreciation"—the sense of worthlessness—is, in my opinion, much harder to live with (especially when comparing yourself to "others") for many "poor" people, or those who are alone or isolated, in so-called "civilized" countries. But these places are often the most "savage" (in a pejorative sense) when it comes to competition—school, studies, jobs, "supposedly succeeding in life," careers, social relationships, romance, finding a partner who’ll accept you (or not), etc., etc.

In short, "poverty in the sun" is, from this perspective, less painful to endure than in a modern city. At least there’s always the possibility of "sharing" with others or finding a little hut in nature to "cultivate your garden," whereas poverty in France or Paris, just to name a few, often means ending up on the streets, with nothing but a cardboard box to call home.
«Si tu ne trouves pas d'ami sage, prêt à cheminer avec toi, résolu, constant, marche seul, comme un roi après une conquête ou un éléphant dans la forêt.» Bouddha
SO Songhai73 Globetrotter ·
good evening I don’t watch the news, so the PERNO news bulletin 😉 even less! I don’t really see why you’re talking about the news, and I don’t quite understand your explanation!

"I much prefer those who question things for the most vulnerable to avoid confusion with others who turn everything upside down just to achieve a jack-in-the-box result—changing nothing in reality, or even giving more to their own clique of friends!"
le mérite d'un homme réside dans sa connaissance et dans ses actes et non point dans la couleur de sa peau ou de sa religion! Khalil Gibran
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
Hi, .

though in Africa I never saw my friends take antidepressants! why are we the biggest consumers of these treatments??????

It's because we don’t have a witch doctor or healer anymore, no priest to tell our stories to, and we wouldn’t be satisfied with their answers anymore—and psychoanalysis doesn’t work for everyone!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
Western society's "model" is often a form of materialistic "false religion" that claims or leads its "flocks" or "citizens" to believe happiness is just around the corner! But that’s rarely the case.

Shall we listen to a bit of Souchon with *Foule Sentimentale*?

In short, "poverty in the sun" is, in my opinion, less harsh to live with from that perspective than in a modern city. There’s always the chance to "share" with others or find a shack in nature to "cultivate your garden," whereas poverty in France—or Paris, to name just one—often means ending up on the streets, sleeping in cardboard boxes.

In France, poverty often boils down to not being able to consume but having to settle for the basics: food, healthcare, clothing, access to education, and culture. The right to housing isn’t guaranteed despite laws passed, but slums haven’t yet encircled major French cities.

Someone living in poverty in India would probably love to experience French-style poverty😕

That said, I’m not claiming that those left behind by France’s economic growth don’t have reasons to revolt or that their living conditions are acceptable. But life is still easier in a developed country (with some social safety nets) than in a third-world nation. Whether it’s hot or cold, raining, snowing, or windy...
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
because let's be honest, not everyone will find: work, a wife (or "love"), health, family, kids, and even fewer will find "leisure, travel, consumer goods, houses, and cars for all, and so on." No point dreaming.

When it comes to women, we should be able to make it work! So far, they’re roughly equal in number to men—unless they get caught up in polygamy... As for love, it’s not just our system that controls that—at least not entirely—so the issue lies within ourselves...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
JE Jeddhai Regular ·
For women, we should be able to manage it! So far, they are roughly equal in number to men unless they let themselves be drawn into polygamy... When it comes to Love, it's not just our system that controls it—at least not entirely—so the problem lies within ourselves...

Regarding "Love," I agree with you—its presence or absence depends only on "oneself," whether you're rich or poor, single or in a relationship, etc. But when it comes to "forming couples," we can also talk about "emotional poverty" to keep it polite, since not everyone has access to it, or at least isn’t "loved" or desired. That’s a reality too. And very often, it’s still "poverty" (financial, social, or otherwise) that plays a role. Logically, women will be more attracted to men who are "rich, good-looking, or sociable," even if "beauty" doesn’t last. Meanwhile, poor men, or those who aren’t attractive or sociable, often end up alone. But honestly, I’m not worried about women—the number of "males circling around females" means they don’t have to put in much effort to find someone they "desire" (I’m not talking about love, which is different for me). We see this "ethological" behavior in many other animal species too.

And when it comes to the "heart and mind," that’s a whole other story 😉
«Si tu ne trouves pas d'ami sage, prêt à cheminer avec toi, résolu, constant, marche seul, comme un roi après une conquête ou un éléphant dans la forêt.» Bouddha
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
That’s a reality too; and very often, it’s once again "poverty" (financial, social, or otherwise) that plays a role. Logically, women tend to be more attracted to men who are "rich, good-looking, sociable," even if "good looks" don’t last. Meanwhile, poor men, or those who aren’t attractive or sociable, often end up alone. But honestly, I’m not worried about women—given how many "males swarm around females," they barely have to lift a finger to find the one they "desire" (and I’m not talking about love, which is a different thing for me). We see this "ethological" behavior in many other animal species.

Well, that’s kinda true—maybe you’re not totally wrong. I’d never looked at it that way, me being rich... and good-looking!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
I hadn’t looked at it that way—I’m rich... and handsome!

Wow😄😄😄
JE Jeddhai Regular ·
I hadn’t looked at it that way—I’m rich... and handsome!

That’s great for you, but you must have some flaws too ;) I’m rich and handsome too, apparently. But not really sociable—you can’t have it all!
«Si tu ne trouves pas d'ami sage, prêt à cheminer avec toi, résolu, constant, marche seul, comme un roi après une conquête ou un éléphant dans la forêt.» Bouddha
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
Actually, I’m saying this because I’m looking for a travel companion! I’m so tired of being alone *sniff*
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
JE Jeddhai Regular ·
I thought you already had a partner, period, right? She wouldn’t follow you? Unless you’re looking for a second one with a "travel" option 😄 The ideal is a partner/traveler—"two for the price of one"! But hey, some people struggle so much to find a partner, period, that it’s not a sure thing. What a bummer! Might as well live it in the sun
«Si tu ne trouves pas d'ami sage, prêt à cheminer avec toi, résolu, constant, marche seul, comme un roi après une conquête ou un éléphant dans la forêt.» Bouddha
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
me, I’m rich and handsome too, or so I’m told

What a concentration of Apollos on VF! 😄😄😄

Or Pinocchios????😉

Anyway, beauty and ugliness are so relative... Like the feeling of poverty or wealth, for that matter😮
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
I'm looking for one that's a bit wild, sporty, and not too expensive—someone who'd be up for joining me on my adventures... not easy! I'll stop now. I feel like I'm gonna get censored!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
JE Jeddhai Regular ·
I spent a long time looking for the kind of girls you're after— the mountain shepherdess type, or the forest nomad. Unfortunately, I’ve stopped looking, because it’s a myth ;)
«Si tu ne trouves pas d'ami sage, prêt à cheminer avec toi, résolu, constant, marche seul, comme un roi après une conquête ou un éléphant dans la forêt.» Bouddha
PélicanBrun Veteran ·
Hi jeddhai,

In short, "poverty in the sun" is, in my opinion, less harsh to live with from that perspective than in a modern city, because there’s always the possibility of "sharing" with others or finding a shack in nature to "cultivate your garden," whereas poverty in France or Paris—just to name a few—often means ending up on the street with nothing but cardboard to sleep on.

You know, the "cardboard" in Paris or the "sheet metal" in a Rio favela—it’s all the same, isn’t it?
PélicanBrun Veteran ·
Good evening attila,

You seem very attached to that little word....

Yes, indeed, I’m very attached to it, because for me it represents so much more than just a simple, ordinary polite phrase!

On a forum like this one, I see it more as a small, delicate "friendly gesture" between people who are supposed to share a common passion! In this case, travel!

I think there’s a smiley with a little yellow guy holding a "hello" sign. That little drawing would seem like a better introduction for a forum.

That’s a great idea and would suit me just fine! You see, I’m not that difficult after all!!! 😉

See you later,
LE Lepiaf Globetrotter ·
Yes, I really care about it, because for me it means so much more than just a simple, ordinary polite phrase!

People may disagree. For my part, starting all my posts with "hello" would feel mechanical—just an extra line that’s impersonal and insincere. So no "hello" (except in PMs) unless I can insert a "Hello, " like you can with a signature (which I don’t use either).
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
You know, the "cardboard box" in Paris or the "sheet-metal shack" in a Rio hillside slum—it’s all the same, isn’t it?

I don’t really agree. I think there’s more humanity in a Rio favela or an Indian slum than on the sidewalks of Paris.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
PélicanBrun Veteran ·
(No "hello" back!) by reciprocity! 😛

For my part, starting all my posts with a hello would feel mechanical.

It’s not about writing "hello" in every post! Once a day, when first contacting one of the forum members, is more than enough! 😉

You never start an email with "hello" when you send one to a friend or acquaintance, right???

That said, we can indeed, as you say, disagree on this! And if it became a widespread custom affecting all VF members, I’d go along with it (reluctantly), just like everyone else! But for now, that’s far from being the case! So I’ll keep writing my way and might stop replying to those who don’t seem genuinely friendly!

Now, to wrap up, I must honestly tell you that the day there’s no more "Hello," "Please," or "Thank you" on the forum, 😕 I’ll quickly look elsewhere!!! 😉

Fortunately, for now, few are those (though there are still a few!) who don’t even bother replying (whether individually or collectively) when they get answers to their messages—sometimes with very specific requests! So all hope isn’t lost yet!!!

Cheers,
LE Lepiaf Globetrotter ·
You never start an email with "hello" when you send one to a friend or acquaintance???

Of course I do (I even mentioned in my previous post that I do it in PMs), but I make a clear distinction between private exchanges (PMs or emails) and public posts, which are much less personal. Honestly, whether there’s a "Hello" when a member (known or not) replies to me on VF doesn’t make any difference to me—it’s the content of the post that matters, substance over form.
PélicanBrun Veteran ·
(No hello) out of reciprocity! See message above

You know, the "cardboard" in Paris or the "sheet metal" in a shantytown on the hills of Rio, it's all the same, isn't it?

I don't really agree; I think there's more humanity in a favela in Rio or a slum in India than on the sidewalks of Paris.

Personally, I've never (just like you, I think) lived in a favela in Rio, a slum in India, a cardboard house in Buenos Aires, or squatted on the sidewalks of Paris or anywhere else, but during my travels, I've often (just like you, I suppose) come across these kinds of places without any voyeurism (I assure you!) and the poverty that goes with them.

And quite honestly, I think that no matter the place, you find a sort of microcosm of each of our societies there! With its rules (good or bad), its codes, its humanity (or not), its "good" and its "bad," its leaders and its resigned... In fact, an exact replica of our society, but in a "different world"!

Here's an example of what I mean: I recently saw a report about the unfortunate "new left-behinds" in America who became "homeless" after the last crisis. The report showed poor people who had gathered on a vacant lot on the outskirts of a city, living as best they could in old trailers, tents, or makeshift shelters. A disturbing detail struck me:

Several of these "new homeless" proudly (!) displayed the American flag on their makeshift shelters??? Unbelievable, right? These people didn't seem to have any "hatred" for the system that had so outrageously rejected them? To the point of still honoring (naively?) one of the most powerful symbols of their ex-society!

Later,
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
HELLO,

I wouldn’t want to live under a cardboard box or a Parisian highway overpass any more than in a Rio favela or a Calcutta slum, even though, for me, there are clear differences between the life of a homeless person or even a poor person in their suburban housing project in France and that of a poor person in a third-world country. The first important factor is simply the climate. While we might not particularly love the sun and heat, it’s undeniable that tropical poverty is easier to endure than poverty in so-called temperate climates. Here, when winter rears its head—even in a makeshift shack or an unheated housing project, let alone under a cardboard box wrapped in a blanket—spending the night isn’t exactly a walk in the park when temperatures hover around zero or often drop below. Next, and in my opinion just as important, are social relationships. Whether in a Brazilian favela or an Indian slum, people never live alone or in isolation like they do in Europe. I’ve never been to the heart of a favela, but (this goes way back) I spent several days in very underprivileged neighborhoods of different African cities (Douala, Abidjan, Accra), which could actually be compared to the old shantytowns I knew in Seine-Saint-Denis (La Courneuve) in the late 1960s. The people there are very poor, but they help each other out, and there’s no need for a meet-up to go share a millet meal with the neighbor. The whole family lives together, from children to grandparents (who don’t end their lives in nursing homes!), and sometimes it’s a little hard to tell whose kids are whose since they all live with each other. Here, without even going under bridges, it’s increasingly common to discover someone who lived alone, found dead in their apartment after several weeks—or even months—without any of their neighbors noticing their absence. People might tell me that in France, social aid exists, and all you have to do is knock on the doors of the Secours Catholique or the Salvation Army to find shelter for the night. Yet many homeless people refuse the room offered to them—it’s easy to understand why. Going back to the old shantytowns I knew in Seine-Saint-Denis, it seems to me that people lived better there than in the high-rises where they were relocated after their shacks were torn down. You only have to see the distress and boredom eating away at these young people and the violence that stems from it to realize how unbearable life is without work in what we euphemistically call "the neighborhoods." As for American homeless people, they’ve been so bombarded by the media after the 9/11 attacks, followed by the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, with finger-pointing at the enemies of freedom, that the star-spangled banner—symbol of liberties—has become for many a shield against what isn’t American and a refuge from material hardships...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
BA Bardak Veteran ·
This conversation is surreal... and bordering on indecency...
JE Jeddhai Regular ·
And what exactly is poverty? There’s financial poverty, moral poverty, emotional poverty, social poverty, and more. A "poor fisherman" (of fish) who tends his vegetable garden, is content with little, and appreciates the place, the peace, and the simplicity of his life, can also be happier than a millionaire who chains purchases and trips together but remains unsatisfied and always "greedy" for more 😉
«Si tu ne trouves pas d'ami sage, prêt à cheminer avec toi, résolu, constant, marche seul, comme un roi après une conquête ou un éléphant dans la forêt.» Bouddha
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
Hi Can we know who this is aimed at and why it's considered indecent?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
BA Bardak Veteran ·
Hello,

Oh, this isn’t aimed at anyone in particular. It’s the conversation as a whole that left me with a certain sense of unease.

Imagining people calmly sitting in front of a computer discussing where the poor are better off—it feels strange to me. Especially when comparing situations that are hardly comparable (for example: the homeless person in Paris, who usually wasn’t born on the streets but ended up there, often alone, versus someone who grew up in a slum with their family and has never known anything else).

So, the word might be a bit strong (unfortunately, I can’t find another one), but I do think there’s a certain indecency in the idea of this conversation.
LE Lepiaf Globetrotter ·
A "poor sinner" (of fish)

Since you specify "of fish," it’s a fisherman who’s also a sinner, like all of us 😉

Similar discussions

You might also like