Why do we always think that "ELSEWHERE" is better than our own country?
FR

Translated into English.

KA Kalchaqui Veteran ·
What Silviasenva wrote doesn’t deserve the tone and vocabulary of your reply😐
GI Gilnado ·
Totally agree. I was about to react the same way. The comment in question was certainly long and tough to get through, but it didn’t seem ill-intentioned.
AN Andrémarin ·
Thank you for finding the right words to say what I’d felt myself. Best regards. And also kudos for your photo at the Chile-Argentina border—it’s absolutely stunning!!!
Andrémarin, Payador.
GI Gildadesiles Globetrotter ·
We all have the right and THE DUTY to express ourselves freely, as long as your JUDGMENTS don’t concern us.......so why don’t you put down your backpack for a bit....it seems heavy to carry...!!! probably the weight of your Stupidity.

How to say everything and its opposite....

It’s too bad the proposition was interesting and Sylveanna’s response just as much....in the end, you weren’t looking for answers to your questions....
GR Greensnow Veteran ·
😉 Maybe the professorial tone didn’t sit well with her, and the childish advice too? (in the PS/) Re-examining the original post and the idea of "elsewhere" as a dream or desire compared to the daily struggles in France (as shown by the constant polls on French morale, which keep seesawing). She’s not the only one who feels better when traveling (elsewhere), especially since coming back is inevitable (life’s obligations).

Regarding the proposal, what’s your contribution to the topic besides rehashing and undoing things?
SY Sylviasenva Regular ·
I’m extremely shocked by your tone. I must’ve touched a nerve without even meaning to—believe me, if I’d wanted to hurt you, you’d be in a lot more pain.

Where exactly did you read any "judgments"? As for my nerves, they’ve been calm for quite a while now, so maybe look in the mirror first.

That you don’t like what I write is one thing, but that you’re being dishonest *and* rude is another. I won’t tolerate you speaking to me like this. For your information, I took the time to offer you a different perspective since you *asked* for opinions. Most adults take what they like and leave the rest.

You just answered your own discontent. What have your "elsewheres" taught you? Clearly, not much...

Try the psychiatric hospital

Good riddance, and stay far away, please :)))
Vivre pleinement, c'est rester libre de ses choix.
MA MAN18 Regular ·
As soon as I return to France, I tell myself, "it's better elsewhere." Where we went, I feel a kind of lightness in living, fewer restrictions, less pressure, less sadness, and I catch myself dreaming of somewhere else—living elsewhere, a simpler, more authentic life, with colors, color everywhere: markets, clothes, homes, and so on...!!! Meeting souls, real, gentle, kind people, and letting go completely of all this modernism, this technological excess, the indifference toward others, confinement, the racism against the elderly in France, against the poor, the weak, the beautiful, the handsome, etc... etc... fleeing the news, politics, jealousy, meanness, stupidity, greed. And in my moments of clarity, I tell myself that in the end, there are pros and cons in every country, every city, and that the best of all worlds may not be down here, and then I also tell myself that you have to know how to COME BACK in order to LEAVE better, but still...!!! IS IT REALLY BETTER ELSEWHERE?😏😏😏

Okay, there we go with the usual clichés again 😠😠. Why do we always want to generalize so much and take the worst behaviors of a few to make them a universal truth? Not all French people are like this or that! Why this masochistic attitude of always wanting to put down our beautiful France? Sure, it’s not perfect, just like every other country.

To bounce back on the debate between Aveyron and Kedor about the status of women, sure, it might still be more enviable elsewhere. But in most countries, that’s not the case. Kedor only supports his arguments by citing cases where it’s better. And he takes the example of a "business woman" greedy for money who works herself to death. That’s hardly representative of French women 😠. Tell us about Saudi Arabia, for example... About the practice of female genital mutilation, forced marriages, "honor" crimes where you’re burned alive or have acid thrown at you... So yes, women are still much better off in France than in many other countries in the world 😎
Le temps fuit sans retour.
GR Greensnow Veteran ·
😉 I get your point, but that wasn’t the original intent. You’re drawing a parallel between a conversation about "women" and the original post to ultimately say that France isn’t so bad. I agree! But! But! It depends on who you are. For many different reasons—unrelated to women, referring back to the original post—it can be really tough to live in France right now, just like in much of Europe (and of course, this depends on a lot of factors). What bothers me is that some people are struggling while others spend their time badmouthing those who are barely keeping their heads above water financially or mentally day in, day out. France is beautiful, but it can be tough in everyday life—work, environment, and so on... Right now, it’s hard to ignore the difficulties without burying your head in the sand (the vibe is pretty tense). That said, living in Paris, I realize that for some, all of this goes right over their heads, and they live, I’d say, in a "party" bubble.
MA MAN18 Regular ·
I agree with you that life is tough in France for some people. As I said, not everything is perfect in France. Here too, the distribution of wealth needs to be rethought. But we still have (for how much longer?) a social system that softens things a bit. On the other hand, people can still be happy here, and not everyone spends their days obsessing over how miserable it is to live in France. So I wanted to show that on this topic, like many others, a much more nuanced view is needed...

The debate about the role of women runs parallel but has similarities.
Le temps fuit sans retour.
GR Greensnow Veteran ·
😉The social system softens things for you or others..........For me, it doesn’t (I’m not getting into the forum debate—I don’t want to do that in writing here). So if you think this lacks nuance, the possibility for exchange is limited—the line’s already been crossed (because their opinion was pretty nuanced, and mine was too in response). I’ll quote you on the value judgment that won’t lead to dialogue: "........not everyone spends their days overanalyzing the misery of living in France..."

🏴‍☠️For women in France, I wouldn’t even try to compare with countries that have barbaric or restrictive practices—but even in France, it’s not easy for women to live freely in many places, whether it’s about daily speech or clothing (yeah, sure, it’s always worse elsewhere). Here again, I’m not going to pull out stats on the number of women reporting rapes or the many who die from domestic violence every year, or other cheerful, recurring issues in the suburbs of big cities. It’s not black and white—it’s full of nuance, really. Observe, acknowledge, and maybe help things move toward something better.
MA MAN18 Regular ·
So if you feel it lacks nuance, the possibility for discussion is limited, the threshold has already been reached (since their opinion was quite nuanced and so was mine in response). I’m quoting you on the value judgment that won’t lead to any dialogue: "........not everyone spends their days overanalyzing the misery of living in France..."

The idea of nuance wasn’t aimed at your message. 😉

I still maintain that the original post lacks nuance. On one side, everything is great elsewhere. On the other, nothing works in France . Only the final sentence adds a hint of nuance. But the bulk of the message still leans toward everything being rosy abroad and pitch-black here.

Same goes for Kedor’s reasoning—they only cite what supports their argument. I counter with other contradictory examples. QED.

In any case, nothing is ever black or white; this Manichean view is far too simplistic.

So I’ll say it again: France isn’t perfect, I’m the first to admit it, but it’s still not that bad when you look elsewhere. 😎
Le temps fuit sans retour.
NI NiniR Regular ·
Probably because in our country there’s a crisis—there are fewer jobs than in some other places.
JU Jupiteria ·
SHOCKED.....OH THE POOR THING!!!

I wasn’t wrong after all about what I sensed regarding your first ramblings... I never asked for anyone’s OPINION or advice—REREAD the original idea carefully... which, up to now, hasn’t caused any problems for anyone. On the contrary.... check the history and learn......!!!!! The "ELSEWHERE" that may not be familiar to you gives me a taste of freedom, curiosity, opens doors, and broadens the mind—we keep growing instead of just sticking to what we know and what’s certain. But that must be beyond you....!!! Grab your little backpack and explore our beautiful France.... and don’t think you have to dictate to others what they’ve already learned or done. I think you’re on the wrong FORUM—"travelers’ thoughts and philosophical reflections!!!" You’re a troublemaker looking for controversy. REREAD YOURSELF.... there’s nothing more foolish than someone who thinks they know but doesn’t.... BOOM! As for the psychiatric asylum—"very worrying that you used such a word! You must know about it...!" To conclude, calm your nerves, and if you’re shocked, too bad for your ego. I find it a shame that your attitude has polluted such a great starting idea for all travelers. I FEEL SORRY FOR YOU. A thousand apologies to everyone reading this. Jupiteria.
KA Kalchaqui Veteran ·
Dear Juliette, Isn’t something off somewhere?🤪😕😐
JU Jupiteria ·
Hello everyone,

But yes, but yes... it's back-to-school time!!! My Chilean friend, I'd love to set my suitcases down again in San Pedro, or even in the Elqui Valley—there’s so much to say... and to dream about... by the shore of a lake. Best regards, Jupiteria
SY Sylviasenva Regular ·
Your response matches your subjective "interpretations" about France and the "rainbow" world elsewhere...

Rambling? Yet another interpretation that’s yours alone.

“There are none so blind as those who will not see.” And if I had to take back anything from my first comment, it’d be the part that was aimed personally at you—suggesting you discover France differently because you’ve got to be able to see things as they are, not as you’d like them to be. Your frustrations have left you with some serious scars. Settle down somewhere for good and live with the locals’ problems—the ones you’ve clearly missed. Between dictatorships, corruption, individualism out of necessity, "human" relationships (mostly within the same family or friend group) that let them get by (or even survive) by helping each other, in societies where you can die on the side of the road for lack of money or connections.

Meanwhile, back home (?), those "idiot" French people will keep working to fund the retirement of folks who’ve found their "paradise" abroad, mostly because their purchasing power is way above the local average—not because they suddenly felt a deep connection to the people. Without generalizing too much, there *are* a few genuine expats drawn to a country, whether they’re working or not, but those people never bite the hand that feeds them. They’re too aware of the realities for that.

That said, I’ll admit I was wrong about the point of this discussion. Keep stewing in your mental ruminations—who knows, maybe one day they’ll open your mind. You can always scream, stomp your feet because I’m getting under your skin—I just find you kind of pathetic, to put it politely.

Vivre pleinement, c'est rester libre de ses choix.
GI Gilnado ·
Okay, I'm tapping out of this discussion—its subject should’ve been: *Tell me about elsewhere, give me reasons to leave, I can’t take my fellow countrymen anymore.*
JU Jupiteria ·
You’ve completely lost it...... Oh help.....!!!! Stop convincing yourself that you’re the only one who knows, who can do, who understands.... You’re "off-topic," and you’re teaching us NOTHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! that’s useful, intelligent, or helps move the conversation forward on a topic you’ve UNDERSTOOD NOTHING about! You’re stuck in moralizing judgment, stating the obvious, and a narrow-mindedness I don’t agree with, that’s all. I won’t respond to your messages anymore—"you’re not worth the time"—and also out of respect for those who actually wanted to share their thoughts on the original topic. THE END.
LO Loicfouq ·
I agree with you, it’s totally over the top. I regret coming here :/
les voyages forme la jeunesse, la preuve j'ai 20 ans (dans ma tête )
MA Mathews Globetrotter ·
As soon as I return to France, I tell myself, "it's better elsewhere." Where we went, I feel a kind of lightness in living, less restriction, less pressure, less sadness, and I catch myself dreaming of somewhere else—going to live somewhere else, a simpler life, more authentic, with colors, color everywhere, markets, clothes, homes, etc.!!! Meeting souls, real, gentle, kind people.

I’ve written this many times—it’s having a tourist’s view of things... The average tourist, and I’m part of that group, only sees a fraction of reality. I was in Romania, and it was wonderful to stay in 3-4 star hotels for just a few dozen euros, while the average person earns barely 200 € a month. So for the next country you visit, I challenge you to live like the locals—don’t do a fully organized "tourist tour." Like the average Mexican or Indian who wakes up early, takes the bus to work in a factory for 10 hours a day for a poverty-level wage, and trust me, you’ll see that elsewhere isn’t better than France.
MA Mathews Globetrotter ·
It's true, we think the grass is greener elsewhere, but I actually believe it's because we don't know our own country well enough. I thought I knew everything about France, and I dreamed of other places. I ended up with the mirage of the Vahine, white sandy beaches, coconut trees—you know, those idealized postcard images? But there's another truth behind them. It's not in a few days, or even several months or a year, that you can discover this truth.

I've been living in Tahiti for over thirty years. Paradise? Yes, for tourists, and the wealthy (at one time, for the military too), but the reality goes far beyond that.

Now I look at France through the internet, and I realize I was completely wrong. I miss my France, and I dream of it.

My blog is very revealing—I express myself as best I can. I'd love to see it again, but will I ever be able to?

Thanks for this testimony... Actually, this thread is about that recurring philosophical theme: the existential search for happiness...
CA CalamityGin Globetrotter ·
As soon as I return to France, I tell myself, "it's better elsewhere." Where we went, I feel a kind of lightness in living, fewer restrictions, less pressure, less sadness, and I catch myself dreaming of somewhere else—going to live somewhere else, a simpler life, more authentic, with colors, color everywhere, markets, clothes, homes, and so on!!! Meeting souls, real people, kind and gentle.

I’ve written it many times—it’s having a tourist’s view of things...

Or an expat’s perspective, detached from the burdens of family and/or social obligations of the place they’ve landed, enjoying a privileged status thanks to their origins, their staggering resources (compared to those of the local population), their connections with the most well-off members of the community, etc.
GI Gilnado ·
Touché!
KA Kalchaqui Veteran ·
or an expat’s perspective, detached from the burdens of family and/or social obligations of the place they’ve landed, enjoying a privileged status due to their origins, their staggering resources (compared to the local population), their connections with the most well-off members of the community, etc.

By writing this, you prove you don’t know the reality of expatriation, which very often looks more like immigration. You’re describing the reality of an extreme minority of expats.
AM Americas Veteran ·
Totally agree! Some people have a completely wrong idea of what an expat is. There are a thousand and one reasons why someone might move abroad, and the political climate in France over the past few years has led many French people to believe that money is the main reason. There are 2 million French expats, and the proportion of "rich" people is roughly the same as that of French people living in France. We should avoid lumping everyone together and treating expats in Luxembourg, Andorra, Monaco, or near the Swiss border the same as most expats who post on this forum. For the latter, the reasons for moving abroad are often sentimental (for the country or a person), they live with their families, and at the same pace as the locals. Not to mention the torture of missing camembert... 😐
On ne voyage pas pour chercher son destin mais pour fuir l’endroit d’où on est parti. (Miguel de Unamuno) L'homme est un dieu quand il rêve, et un mendiant quand il réfléchit (Friedrich Holderlin)
SY Sylviasenva Regular ·
Like a local family, but not at the same income level as the MAJORITY of other locals... In eight months, I only met one poor person (in poor countries), and he was the only one, by the way, who was happy to talk to French people without trying to squeeze money out of them in one way or another.

And quite a few of those speaking up here are certainly not the most objective, as their interests are closely tied to the arrival of tourists. Let’s give credit where credit is due...

But you’re right, let’s avoid generalizing.

Give up camembert? Not possible for me lol You’re really brave ;)
Vivre pleinement, c'est rester libre de ses choix.
CA CalamityGin Globetrotter ·
or an expat’s perspective, detached from the burdens of family and/or social obligations of the place they’ve landed, enjoying a privileged status due to their origins, their staggering resources (compared to the local population), their connections with the most well-off members of the community, etc.

By writing this, you prove you don’t know the reality of expatriation, which very often resembles immigration more than anything else. You’re describing the reality of an extreme minority of expats.

Indeed, I’m describing the minority of (very) well-off expats, detached from the everyday struggles of the locals in the country they’ve landed in, who take the liberty of badmouthing their home country under the pretext that things didn’t go their way. It’s a minority, but unfortunately, it’s a sizable one.

I’ve met them on 3 continents (Africa, America, Asia), and it’s clear that some of them post on this forum... 😉

That said, I’ve also fortunately met plenty of others who are much more pleasant. 😎
GR Greensnow Veteran ·
or an expat’s perspective, detached from the burdens of family and/or social obligations of the place they’ve landed, enjoying a privileged status due to their origins, their staggering resources (compared to those of the local population), their connections with the most well-off members of the community, etc.

By writing that, you prove you don’t know the reality of expatriation, which very often resembles immigration more than anything else. You’re describing the reality of an extreme minority of expats.

Indeed, I’m describing the minority of (very) well-off expats, detached from the everyday struggles of the locals in the country they’ve landed in, who take the liberty of badmouthing their home country under the pretext that things didn’t go their way. It’s a minority, but unfortunately, it’s a sizable one.

I’ve met them on 3 continents (Africa, America, Asia), and it’s clear that some of them post on this forum... 😉

That said, I’ve also fortunately met plenty of others who are much more pleasant. 😎

🙂 Completely agree. I’ve also come across these so-called "privileged" expats, who are insufferable to interact with and can’t stop slagging off France (and I say this knowing it’s really not easy for part of the population to feel good in France right now). The most fitting word to describe them is: arrogance (in their words and behavior).
VI Vietalier Regular ·
Hello Sylvia, What wisdom projected through this masterful philosophy lesson. Even though you were relevant in many ways, I must say you somewhat overwhelmed me because, in the end (?...), only TRAVEL (note the conditional tense, as I don’t want to be overbearing or come off as preachy) should matter—this "elsewhere" that’s better and more beautiful, etc., which each of us must craft based on what we’ve felt here or there through the SHARING we’ve done with all the unexpected encounters that have peppered our journeys. Actually, sharing along the adventure—whether geographic or human... maybe both at once—far away or just outside your door, everything should boil down to these simple notions, sprinkled, however, with a little curiosity of the eye, the ear, and... the heart. Rest assured, I appreciated some of your sharp remarks about a few forum members’ somewhat saccharine posts that I stumble upon and that often leave me grumpy, even though I’m naturally cheerful and sociable. Traveler’s regards, and see you soon, maybe? Best, VIETALIER.
Cela dépend de l'humeur du moment et va de Jean-Claude à Viet à lier.
VI Vietalier Regular ·
Dear Greensnow, There’s another small group of wealthy expats—or should I say clueless ones—who spit and vomit on the customs and people of the country they happen to be visiting. Here, I’d be more realistic than you in pointing out not just arrogance, but outright rudeness and stupidity they can’t seem to shake, like they fell into it as kids and never climbed out! The same goes for some travelers. On a flight bringing me back from Hà Nội, I overheard two people who’d just returned exchanging their impressions:

Vietnam?... It’s noisy, it’s dirty, and it stinks!

They’d spent a whole month forming these sweeping judgments and were talking loudly enough for their seat neighbors to hear. I made sure to tell them exactly what I thought of their basement-level intelligence before moving to another row of seats. Best from Vietalier
Cela dépend de l'humeur du moment et va de Jean-Claude à Viet à lier.
MA Mathews Globetrotter ·
On one hand, everything is great elsewhere. On the other hand, in France, nothing works anymore Only the final sentence adds a hint of nuance. But the main message still leans toward everything being rosy abroad and everything being bleak here.

Could someone explain to me why nothing works in France anymore?
VI Vietalier Regular ·
Open your eyes, my dear Mathews! Here, it's impossible to have an intelligent government—one that thinks FRENCH—because voters spend their time toppling the right to put the left in power, only to quickly grow tired of them, and then they do the same thing in reverse the next time around!!!!!!!!

Things will be a little brighter and a little less bleak here when the French prioritize the country over their petty careerist or other self-serving calculations, even though we all know that divide-and-conquer keeps those in power, well, in power!

Now, when it comes to travel and tourism, our country is just as wonderful as anywhere else: take a stroll around Salers in the Cantal region, go mushroom picking in Lozère at the first autumn rains, paddle down the Tarn Gorges from Sainte-Enimie in a kayak and savor a delicious Pélardon, an extraordinary local goat cheese. And for those who love the mountains, the Alps and the Pyrenees will give you plenty of reasons to see France in a rosy light...

That said, some prefer to travel without leaving home, stuck between a computer, books, a pastis, and a big purring cat—why not? There’s room for all tastes!

Alright, I’ve teased you enough and wish you a good night (it’s almost midnight!). Best regards — Vietalier.
Cela dépend de l'humeur du moment et va de Jean-Claude à Viet à lier.
CA CalamityGin Globetrotter ·
Open your eyes, my dear Mathews! Here, it’s impossible to have an intelligent government, that thinks FRENCH, because voters spend their time tearing down the right to put the left in place—only to quickly grow tired of them, and the next time they do the same thing in reverse!!!!!!!! Here, things will be a little rosier and a little less bleak when the French think of the Country first, before sharpening their little careerist or other self-serving schemes, even though we all know that divide and conquer works!

Seriously: do you really think it’s better or even different *elsewhere*? 🤪
LO Loicfouq ·
I don’t consider myself an expat, but rather a wanderer—I wanted to see elsewhere out of curiosity, to check if the sky was bluer, the grass greener, and if the birds sang better.

I *am* elsewhere now, and I still end up "eating angry cow" (it’s not just the expats who live abroad), and I watch France from afar.

Today, my kids are grown, and they dream of "elsewhere" (France, why not?), but their country is here (my elsewhere).

The truth is, the French are eternal complainers—that’s how you recognize them. Elsewhere (and it’s not just about the beret, the baguette, the *calvados*, or the bottle of wine), it’s also, and above all, their big mouths.

So today, as I look at the French here and elsewhere, I think to myself on my 71st birthday: France smells so good, even from elsewhere.
les voyages forme la jeunesse, la preuve j'ai 20 ans (dans ma tête )
LO Loicfouq ·
ps But actually, the answer to the question is quite simple: “because ‘elsewhere’ exists” no matter where you are.
les voyages forme la jeunesse, la preuve j'ai 20 ans (dans ma tête )
MA Mathews Globetrotter ·
Open your eyes, my dear Mathews! Here, it’s impossible to have an intelligent government, that thinks FRENCH, because voters spend their time tearing down the right to put the left in power—only to quickly grow tired of them, and the next time they do the same in reverse!!!!!!!!

I get that, but whether the government is right-wing or left-wing, I couldn’t care less... it’s not them who’ll give me a job or influence my career and life choices...

If I wake up in a bad mood tomorrow, it’s not Hollande’s or Ayrault’s fault, after all. When I lived in Canada and was in a bad mood, I didn’t blame Mr. Charest or Harper either...
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
Here, things will be a bit more positive and a bit less bleak when the French think of the Country first, before sharpening their little careerist or other kinds of calculations, even though we all know that dividing helps to rule!

So, according to you, this mindset in the political world is specifically French?!! In other European countries or elsewhere, it’s completely different?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
VI Vietalier Regular ·
Hello Djalma, Of course not! But with that very French touch, and when you're forced to put up with it, it becomes oppressive and turns dark gray, even black. Elsewhere, things aren’t well-coordinated between leaders and citizens either, but it’s not *my* home! There you go, dear Jean-Michel—I’ll stop here to avoid a pointless debate. Wishing you beautiful autumn days between Opède le Vieux and Roussillon in Vaucluse. Best regards — Vietalier
Cela dépend de l'humeur du moment et va de Jean-Claude à Viet à lier.
RO Rouxy Regular ·
So, in your opinion, this mindset in the political world is specifically French?!! In other European countries or elsewhere, it’s completely different?

Leaving politics aside, it’s hard to ignore that foreign tourists don’t find our grass—or at least our people—any greener than back home. Isn’t our reputation for gloominess and deep inhospitality pretty strong among foreign travelers? 😉
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
Our reputation for gloominess and deep inhospitality is still quite strong among foreign tourists, isn't it?

Oh really? For what reasons are we by far the most visited country in the world, way ahead of the US, Spain, Italy, etc.? Just for the beautiful landscapes? Thank goodness we’re so gloomy and inhospitable—otherwise, we’d be swamped with foreign tourists we couldn’t handle!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
RO Rouxy Regular ·
Our reputation for being gloomy and deeply inhospitable is still pretty strong among foreign tourists, isn't it?

Oh really? Then how come we’re way ahead of the US, Spain, Italy, etc. as one of the world’s most visited countries? Just for the pretty landscapes? Thank goodness we’re so gloomy and inhospitable—otherwise, we’d be swamped with foreign tourists we couldn’t handle!

That’s what it seemed like to me—our reputation as complainers, the slogan "France would be amazing without the French." The attraction is the variety of beautiful, moderate landscapes, the temperate climate, and the ultra-rich culture, right? I’m saying this without any aggression—if it bothered me that much, I’d have left for good by now 😉
SY Sylviasenva Regular ·
Just yesterday, I had the chance to get confirmation of my thoughts from a foreigner who visited France and not JUST PARIS. He was very well received in the countryside and very poorly received in Paris!

Like most tourists, Parisians (with a few exceptions) have the annoying habit of generalizing their own stupidity and inability to be friendly and open to others to the entire country, starting with their own fellow citizens.

The same people, arrogant enough to ignore you on vacation just because you're French (they’ve got their noses stuck in the *lovely planet* but call themselves backpackers!), are the ones who lecture you about open-mindedness. Most of them have never even left the Île-de-France region, yet they judge the whole country, the people, and tell you that elsewhere is better—without knowing the difference between "kindness" because they’re spending money and genuinely selfless kindness. The latter is much rarer and is often found in the countryside, elsewhere too, where there’s no mass tourism.

Best regards :)

Vivre pleinement, c'est rester libre de ses choix.
YU Yurok999 Regular ·
Yes, what you're saying is very true most of the time, even if there are always exceptions. Not all Parisians and other "capital-dwellers" (in the sense of "living in capital cities," but often in another sense too 😉) are like that, but a good number of them are often very arrogant, even contemptuous toward "provincials," while they’re surprised when some people give them the same treatment in return. City-dwellers treating "country folks" like "peasants" and other terms as if it were an insult—this happens in France and elsewhere often. Just a reminder that "peasants" isn’t an insult; it’s a "job—way of life" in general, and without them, most city people wouldn’t survive long. After all, they’re the ones who "traditionally" grow crops, grains, or raise animals that many will only ever see in plastic packets on their plates (it’s much easier to turn a blind eye). Meanwhile, these city folks often "get rich" with jobs in the "service sector," which are often useless or non-essential, sometimes harmful to the earth, and other urban frivolities that are far less vital than food, mountain water, and so on.

This "Parisianism" or "capital-centrism," where people think France is just the Eiffel Tower (that pile of scrap metal ruining the landscape, just like the city itself) and that the rest of the country is just fields, cows, and, of course, the beaches where they flock to roast every summer, plus the ski resorts where they go to "get their butts dragged" in winter!
Je porte plainte contre le "monde moderne", c’est lui le monstre. Il détruit notre terre, il piétine l’âme des hommes." Si tu n'as pas d'amour, embrasse la liberté
RO Rouxy Regular ·
Parisians (with a few exceptions) have the annoying habit of projecting their own stupidity and inability to be friendly and open to others onto the whole of France—starting with their own fellow citizens.

Uh, I’ve spent most of my life in Picardy...😎
SY Sylviasenva Regular ·
So? Weren’t we talking about how foreigners are perceived? I don’t see how you were targeted. That said, the person in question really appreciated the hospitality of the North.

When a French person tells me that France is this, that the French are that, I ask them what they actually know about France... Most of the time, it’s those who’ve never left their little "bubble" and keep looking elsewhere with rose-tinted glasses—or worse. :)

In the eight months I’ve been traveling, I’ve seen foreign tourists who were way worse than the French. But it’s likely that those who like them the least are also the ones who love money the most. Some nationalities couldn’t care less about the locals, and the locals return the favor. Everyone gets what they want—money... QED.

Okay, I think we’re getting a bit off-topic, but since the thread was already wrapping up, no big deal. ;)
Vivre pleinement, c'est rester libre de ses choix.
RO Rouxy Regular ·
What a lovely vibe in both of your posts... proof by example? 😇
GI Gildadesiles Globetrotter ·
Just yesterday, I had the chance to get confirmation of what I think from a foreigner who visited France and not JUST PARIS. He was very well received in the countryside and very poorly received in Paris!

And there are foreigners who are well received in PARIS and poorly in the provinces... what exactly do you want to prove?

Just like most tourists, Parisians (with a few exceptions) have the annoying habit of generalizing their own stupidity and inability to be friendly and open to others to the whole of France, starting with their own fellow citizens.

I think you’d do well to watch the plank in your own eye... generally, when I meet French people who are nice or jerks, I don’t focus on where they’re from. Your comment is stupid and tinged with real animosity toward Parisians....

The same people, by the way—arrogant, who ignore you on vacation just because you’re French (they’ve got their noses stuck in the Lovely Planet but they’re backpackers!)—are the ones who lecture you about open-mindedness. Most of them have never even left the Île-de-France region, yet they judge the whole country, the people, and explain to you that elsewhere is better without knowing the difference between "kindness" because they spend money and genuinely selfless kindness. The latter, much rarer, is often found in the countryside elsewhere too, where there’s no mass tourism.

Honestly, your rant against Parisians doesn’t make me want to talk to you either! Are you sure you’re not from Île-de-France yourself?🤪

What aggression....

As for the selfless kindness of the countryside... my farmer friends are still laughing about it!!!!😏
YU Yurok999 Regular ·
"Parisian blockheads"? Anyway, your profile pic really shows you're one of the bovines! Admitting your "redneck" (or "beefy") sides is already something 😉 (My apologies to bovines, against whom I have absolutely nothing—in fact, as a vegetarian, I wouldn’t want to compare humans to them, that’d be disrespectful to bovines )
Je porte plainte contre le "monde moderne", c’est lui le monstre. Il détruit notre terre, il piétine l’âme des hommes." Si tu n'as pas d'amour, embrasse la liberté
SY Sylviasenva Regular ·
I have some amazing Parisian friends whom I adore, and they’re the first to admit that in Paris, the mentality is generally "everyone for themselves"—to put it politely. Unfortunately, nice Parisians are pretty rare (though I’ll admit they’re not the only ones).

It’s a fact, whether you like it or not, that most tourists go to Paris and base their judgment of France on that alone.

And whether you like it or not, it seems pretty bad-faith to ignore that the jerks who keep harping on about how the French have every flaw in the book are also Parisian journalists. When you’re in the countryside and ask for directions, you’ll easily find someone to guide you. Try that in Paris, but be *very* patient...

I’m not trying to prove anything, and I don’t hold any animosity toward Parisians (only since I’ve traveled beyond our borders). If I went by the people I meet in the provinces, though, I’d definitely have some—no doubt about it. I don’t like jerks, and I don’t care if they don’t like me back. Having said that, few people from the provinces like Parisians much—they’re so arrogant, acting like they’re the center of the universe. I’m just tired of hearing nonstop that the French have every flaw imaginable and realizing that a bunch of people repeat it like parrots because they’ve been brainwashed. Yet when I share tons of anecdotes proving the opposite (like we easily do for other countries), suddenly they remember that *they* too have had positive experiences in France.

So why my fixation on Parisians? Because it’s often from the capital that these rants about the French originate.

In short, they’re describing their own world and their own behavior. It’s often the French I’ve met off the beaten path—the locals appreciate them, no matter what’s said back home. And when I look at other nationalities (the ones who don’t like us?!), who are disrespectful, drunk from morning to night, and couldn’t care less about the locals (or anyone else), it makes me chuckle that *those* people judge *us*.

I have plenty of flaws, and I own them—I don’t deny them. I grumble like a good Frenchwoman when someone tries to scam me or pull the wool over my eyes. But I keep my word and respect people wherever I go, and in return, people treat me well. It’s also a reality that it’s in the countryside where you meet far more honest people, often far removed from tourism and its corruptions.

If your farmer friends laugh about it, I’d say this: mine are rough around the edges but big-hearted. As they say, "birds of a feather flock together" :)) You keep your friends, and I’ll keep mine :)
Vivre pleinement, c'est rester libre de ses choix.
YU Yurok999 Regular ·
City calves or country calves, you can spot the former by their suit and tie or their perfectly ironed skirt and their startled bourgeois air, their iPhone and their rushed demeanor as if they were off to a meeting with the prime minister (of human stupidity ), their urban sheep-like behavior, and their "grazing" toward their bosses and other social circles, not to mention their disdain for the country calves and other field horses, who graze peacefully on tender grass, drink fresh stream water, and watch polluting, rushed Parisian cars go by; Who goes further in life? It’s relative, but one thing’s for sure—they both end up six feet under, and the meadow calves don’t destroy the earth like the former do.
Je porte plainte contre le "monde moderne", c’est lui le monstre. Il détruit notre terre, il piétine l’âme des hommes." Si tu n'as pas d'amour, embrasse la liberté

Similar discussions

You might also like