Peut-on changer de culture?...
by Williama
This discussion is in French, the community’s main language.
Pour la petite histoire, au XVIe siècle les protestants français calvinistes se considéraient comme les "vrais catholiques".
😉, bien entendu puisque "catholique" veut dire universel et que les protestant estimaient qu'il revenaient aux sources du christianisme.
🙂 mais ? Vous n'aviez pas compris ce que je voulais dire en évitant de trop entrer dans la polémique en précisant catholiques romains ?
😉, bien entendu puisque "catholique" veut dire universel et que les protestant estimaient qu'il revenaient aux sources du christianisme.
🙂 mais ? Vous n'aviez pas compris ce que je voulais dire en évitant de trop entrer dans la polémique en précisant catholiques romains ?
Catherine
" La lucidité est la blessure la plus proche du soleil" René Char
http://www.catherinegil.com
http://www.catherinegil.com
quand un pays oblige les enfants a suivre des cours de religion, je ne vois pas où est la laïcité.
De quel pays parles-tu exactement ?
depuis le debut on parle, je crois, de la france que ca soit pour la "culture" ou bien la laïcité
De quel pays parles-tu exactement ?
depuis le debut on parle, je crois, de la france que ca soit pour la "culture" ou bien la laïcité
au contraire, si un etat est laïc, toutes les religions peuvent s'épanouirent
Dont celle de ne croire en rien.....😉
Dont celle de ne croire en rien.....😉
parce qu'une region , au passé et à la geographie particuliere a décidé de garder le rapprochement de l'eglise et de l'etat , toute l'histoire francaise est faussée ???
ca n'a aucun sens .......
alors si je te dis que les autoroutes en France sont gratuites , tu es d'accord !
non ?? ben en alsace elles le sont donc c'est valable partout ! on va aller loin comme ca ! je te propose d'alller faire un tour sur le site de droit local , et tu verras que ton raisonnement ne peux fonctionner ! prendre une exception pour la generaliser, ne marche pas !
et puis , petite precision, l'enseignement du religieux n'est pas obligatoire, mais naturel. il est possible de faire la demande de non ensegnement religieux .
ca n'a aucun sens .......
alors si je te dis que les autoroutes en France sont gratuites , tu es d'accord !
non ?? ben en alsace elles le sont donc c'est valable partout ! on va aller loin comme ca ! je te propose d'alller faire un tour sur le site de droit local , et tu verras que ton raisonnement ne peux fonctionner ! prendre une exception pour la generaliser, ne marche pas !
et puis , petite precision, l'enseignement du religieux n'est pas obligatoire, mais naturel. il est possible de faire la demande de non ensegnement religieux .
au contraire, si un etat est laïc, toutes les religions peuvent s'épanouirent
Dont celle de ne croire en rien.....😉
ca serait une religion? serait-ce interdit de ne pas croire qu'il n y a pas de dieu ou de dieux? 😉
je dirais que chacun sera libre de croire (dans la religion qu'il a choisit) ou de ne pas croire.
Dont celle de ne croire en rien.....😉
ca serait une religion? serait-ce interdit de ne pas croire qu'il n y a pas de dieu ou de dieux? 😉
je dirais que chacun sera libre de croire (dans la religion qu'il a choisit) ou de ne pas croire.
J'essaie de comprendre...
Tu affirmes que dans les écoles publiques de France, "on" oblige les enfants à suivre des cours de religion ?... Que l'enseignement religieux est obligatoire ?... dans les écoles ?... en France... ?
C'est ça ?
Tu affirmes que dans les écoles publiques de France, "on" oblige les enfants à suivre des cours de religion ?... Que l'enseignement religieux est obligatoire ?... dans les écoles ?... en France... ?
C'est ça ?
navré mais cé ton raisonnement qui ne tient pas debout.
quand un pays applique des lois diffferents sur la laïcité cela signifie simplement (simple logique elementaire) qu'il n y a pas de laïcité
alors si je te dis que les autoroutes en France sont gratuites , tu es d'accord !
non ?? ben en alsace elles le sont donc c'est valable partout !
en bretagne aussi cé gratuit. cé le cas aussi pour le pourtour de paris. 😏
mais cela signifie simplement que les autoroutes ne sont pas gratuites car il en existe des autoroutes payantes.
et puis , petite precision, l'enseignement du religieux n'est pas obligatoire, mais naturel.
naturel?
la religion serait naturel, tu m'en apprends des choses 😎
si tu demandes de ne pas suivre les cours de religion, tu dois obligatoirement suivre des cours de moral. Et evidement la morale religieuse 😏
Et evidemment le president de la republique ne nomme pas l'eveque! 😏
alors si je te dis que les autoroutes en France sont gratuites , tu es d'accord !
non ?? ben en alsace elles le sont donc c'est valable partout !
en bretagne aussi cé gratuit. cé le cas aussi pour le pourtour de paris. 😏
mais cela signifie simplement que les autoroutes ne sont pas gratuites car il en existe des autoroutes payantes.
et puis , petite precision, l'enseignement du religieux n'est pas obligatoire, mais naturel.
naturel?
la religion serait naturel, tu m'en apprends des choses 😎
si tu demandes de ne pas suivre les cours de religion, tu dois obligatoirement suivre des cours de moral. Et evidement la morale religieuse 😏
Et evidemment le president de la republique ne nomme pas l'eveque! 😏
serait-ce interdit de ne pas croire qu'il n y a pas de dieu ou de dieux?
Prends juste l'exemple d'une personne née musulmane qui affirmerait son athéisme à la Mecque. Je crains fort qu'on ne la revoit pas🤪
je dirais que chacun sera libre de croire (dans la religion qu'il a choisit) ou de ne pas croire
Dans quelques générations, j'espère.
Mais chut........ Certains vont encore dire qu'on est en plein rêve😉
Prends juste l'exemple d'une personne née musulmane qui affirmerait son athéisme à la Mecque. Je crains fort qu'on ne la revoit pas🤪
je dirais que chacun sera libre de croire (dans la religion qu'il a choisit) ou de ne pas croire
Dans quelques générations, j'espère.
Mais chut........ Certains vont encore dire qu'on est en plein rêve😉
Peut-être veut-il parler de "l'enseignement du fait religieux" ? Je ne me souviens plus si c'est en éducation civique ou en histoire-géographie que c'est abordé, mais ça existe bel et bien.
On y enseigne les fondements des trois "grandes" religions monothéistes, soit le christianisme, l'islam et le judaïsme. Pour le reste, nada.
On y enseigne les fondements des trois "grandes" religions monothéistes, soit le christianisme, l'islam et le judaïsme. Pour le reste, nada.
Qui veut chasser une migraine n'a qu'à boire toujours du bon
aller une strophe de poème pour ne pas trop devier et pour rester futile (baudelaire):
Qu'est-ce que Dieu fait donc de ce flot d'anathèmes Qui monte tous les jours vers ses chers Séraphins ? Comme un tyran gorgé de viande et de vins, Il s'endort au doux bruit de nos affreux blasphèmes.
Les sanglots des martyrs et des suppliciés Sont une symphonie enivrante sans doute, Puisque, malgré le sang que leur volupté coûte, Les cieux ne s'en sont point encore rassasiés !
....
Qu'est-ce que Dieu fait donc de ce flot d'anathèmes Qui monte tous les jours vers ses chers Séraphins ? Comme un tyran gorgé de viande et de vins, Il s'endort au doux bruit de nos affreux blasphèmes.
Les sanglots des martyrs et des suppliciés Sont une symphonie enivrante sans doute, Puisque, malgré le sang que leur volupté coûte, Les cieux ne s'en sont point encore rassasiés !
....

C'est bien sûr de cela qu'il s'agit... 🙂
J'aurais néanmoins souhaité que l'auteur de ces 2 affirmations : ... "l'enseignement de la religion est une obligation"... et... "les cours de religion sont obligatoires" apporte la précision lui-même.
Sur un forum écrit, les mots et la manière de les utiliser sont l'unique moyen de communiquer avec les autres. Si on ne les utilise pas à bon escient, il ne faut pas s'étonner des conséquences qui s'ensuivent...
Ajout : @ nemo1001... c'est toi qui a supprimé la réponse que je n'ai pas eu le temps de lire ? 😕
J'aurais néanmoins souhaité que l'auteur de ces 2 affirmations : ... "l'enseignement de la religion est une obligation"... et... "les cours de religion sont obligatoires" apporte la précision lui-même.
Sur un forum écrit, les mots et la manière de les utiliser sont l'unique moyen de communiquer avec les autres. Si on ne les utilise pas à bon escient, il ne faut pas s'étonner des conséquences qui s'ensuivent...
Ajout : @ nemo1001... c'est toi qui a supprimé la réponse que je n'ai pas eu le temps de lire ? 😕
il me semble que tu sois quasiment la seule a ne pas l'avoir compris que c'est en france et precisement en alsace moselle (concordat). Pourtant cité par un autre intervenant.
Tu aurais été bien avisé de le préciser dans tes deux messages... lesquels lus hors-contexte, jettent un doute sur la crédibilité de tes interventions.
l'enseignement est naturel de part la spécifité de la region et l'histoire ( et les cours de morale c'est de cela dont je parle, si tu etais un poil o.p tu serais que les cours de religion s'appelle cours de morale et sont donc facultatif si t'en fais la demande, je sais ca pourrait marcher dans l'autre sens, mais non) .... mais je sais meme pas pourquoi je discute....
donc le petit poitevin qui n'a jamis appris aucunes religions dans aucunes classes vit dans un etat religieux !
je vais m'arreter la ...........😕😕😕😕😕😕🏴☠️
donc le petit poitevin qui n'a jamis appris aucunes religions dans aucunes classes vit dans un etat religieux !
je vais m'arreter la ...........😕😕😕😕😕😕🏴☠️
"l'enseignement de la religion est une obligation"... et... "les cours de religion sont obligatoires"
Le droit concordataire est toujours en vigueur en Alsace Lorraine.
Un lien : http://www.europe-et-laicite.org/Documents/MEL-France4.html
Il est intéressant de noter que toutes les religions n'ont pas le même statut .....
Le droit concordataire est toujours en vigueur en Alsace Lorraine.
Un lien : http://www.europe-et-laicite.org/Documents/MEL-France4.html
Il est intéressant de noter que toutes les religions n'ont pas le même statut .....
Que la religion n'a pas le même statut en Alsace Lorraine que dans les autres régions françaises....
Et qu'un enseignement religieux y est toujours pratiqué🤪
Même si tu peux désormais choisir la morale à la place.
Attention de ne pas être Musulman Bouddhiste ou Caodaiste, ce n'est pas prévu.....
Et qu'un enseignement religieux y est toujours pratiqué🤪
Même si tu peux désormais choisir la morale à la place.
Attention de ne pas être Musulman Bouddhiste ou Caodaiste, ce n'est pas prévu.....
Merci de la précision...
La spécificité (ou l'exception) régionale est quand même importante à souligner.
Et qu'un enseignement religieux y est toujours pratiqué🤪
Pourquoi, c'est mal ???
Il ne faut pas confondre imposer les religions, et les étudier...
Dans un pays comme le nôtre, dont l'histoire est intimement liée aux religions, je ne vois pas en quoi il serait scandaleux de les étudier. Et puisque des vacances ou des congés scolaires sont ménagés en fonction des fêtes religieuses, il serait peut-être cohérent que les enfants comprennent à quoi se réfèrent ces fêtes.
Pourquoi, c'est mal ???
Il ne faut pas confondre imposer les religions, et les étudier...
Dans un pays comme le nôtre, dont l'histoire est intimement liée aux religions, je ne vois pas en quoi il serait scandaleux de les étudier. Et puisque des vacances ou des congés scolaires sont ménagés en fonction des fêtes religieuses, il serait peut-être cohérent que les enfants comprennent à quoi se réfèrent ces fêtes.
l'histoire est intimement liée aux religions, je ne vois pas en quoi il serait scandaleux de les étudier.
Il n'est pas scandaleux d'étudier les religions si cet enseignement est à charge comme à décharge....
Malheureusement dans le cas de l'Alsace Lorraine, il s'agit plus d'une sorte de "cathéchisme" que d'un enseignement des religions😕
"Le Statut Scolaire Local s'appuie sur la Loi Falloux de 1850 qui institue des enseignements obligatoires de religion dans les écoles publiques, et donne aux représentants des religions un droit de contrôle sur les programmes scolaires "
Il n'est pas scandaleux d'étudier les religions si cet enseignement est à charge comme à décharge....
Malheureusement dans le cas de l'Alsace Lorraine, il s'agit plus d'une sorte de "cathéchisme" que d'un enseignement des religions😕
"Le Statut Scolaire Local s'appuie sur la Loi Falloux de 1850 qui institue des enseignements obligatoires de religion dans les écoles publiques, et donne aux représentants des religions un droit de contrôle sur les programmes scolaires "
ce n'est pas ca tout a fait !
les cours de religion s'appelle cours de morale et y sont enseigné aussi bien les versions chretienne que hebreuse ( et certains y appliquent aussi le coran ) Et ce n'est pas un enseignement religieux, mais une approche de la morale au travers des courants religieux ( et non qu'au travers de la chretienneté ). Ce qui donne une acceptation assez notable et forte de la population turque ( acceptation que je n'ai pas vu si evidente dans d'autres regions francaise)
mais oui, la loi de 1905 n'est pas passé ici ! les alasciens ont choisis de taper aussi bien dns le droit francais que dans le droit allemand pour y constituer une identité a part entiere.
ce qui donne deux jours fériés en plus, une secu remboursé a 90 %, et tout un tas d'autres droits assez differents !
je conseille le site droit local pour avoir un bel appercu de tout ca .
les cours de religion s'appelle cours de morale et y sont enseigné aussi bien les versions chretienne que hebreuse ( et certains y appliquent aussi le coran ) Et ce n'est pas un enseignement religieux, mais une approche de la morale au travers des courants religieux ( et non qu'au travers de la chretienneté ). Ce qui donne une acceptation assez notable et forte de la population turque ( acceptation que je n'ai pas vu si evidente dans d'autres regions francaise)
mais oui, la loi de 1905 n'est pas passé ici ! les alasciens ont choisis de taper aussi bien dns le droit francais que dans le droit allemand pour y constituer une identité a part entiere.
ce qui donne deux jours fériés en plus, une secu remboursé a 90 %, et tout un tas d'autres droits assez differents !
je conseille le site droit local pour avoir un bel appercu de tout ca .
Le Statut Scolaire Local s'appuie sur la Loi Falloux de 1850 qui institue des enseignements obligatoires de religion dans les écoles publiques, et donne aux représentants des religions un droit de contrôle sur les programmes scolaires
je te laisse imaginer que ca n'a plus lieux depuis quelques temps.... 1850, ont avait a peine aboli l'esclavagisme !
je te laisse imaginer que ca n'a plus lieux depuis quelques temps.... 1850, ont avait a peine aboli l'esclavagisme !
D'après le lien que tu as cité, pourtant d'obédience laïque, je lis "histoire religieuse" ou "enseignement des religions", et non "catéchisme"...
Le même lien précise qu'en Alsace "au collège, la participation est d'environ 50%, au lycée de 10%", et qu'en Moselle "seuls 18 instituteurs et professeurs d'écoles (0,3 %) enseignent la religion". Il me semble donc assez simple de déroger à cet enseignement...
En outre, je me demande comment se répartit cet enseignement, entre catholicisme et protestantisme (luthéranisme et calvinisme), voire judaïsme.
Le même lien précise qu'en Alsace "au collège, la participation est d'environ 50%, au lycée de 10%", et qu'en Moselle "seuls 18 instituteurs et professeurs d'écoles (0,3 %) enseignent la religion". Il me semble donc assez simple de déroger à cet enseignement...
En outre, je me demande comment se répartit cet enseignement, entre catholicisme et protestantisme (luthéranisme et calvinisme), voire judaïsme.
les cours de religion s'appelle cours de morale et y sont enseigné aussi bien les versions chretienne que hebreuse ( et certains y appliquent aussi le coran ) Et ce n'est pas un enseignement religieux, mais une approche de la morale au travers des courants religieux ( et non qu'au travers de la chretienneté ). Ce qui donne une acceptation assez notable et forte de la population turque ( acceptation que je n'ai pas vu si evidente dans d'autres regions francaise)
Ah voilà, Simon, tu réponds précisément à la question que je me posais.
Ah voilà, Simon, tu réponds précisément à la question que je me posais.
Tu aurais été bien avisé de le préciser dans tes deux messages... lesquels lus hors-contexte, jettent un doute sur la crédibilité de tes interventions.
si tu avais lu les messages echangés tu aurais compris qu'on parlait du concordat qui d'aileurs a été cité. il ne suffit pas de lire un message mais aussi les autres qui s'y rapportent car entre ta 1ere question et la seconde, on avait parlé du concordat
si tu avais lu les messages echangés tu aurais compris qu'on parlait du concordat qui d'aileurs a été cité. il ne suffit pas de lire un message mais aussi les autres qui s'y rapportent car entre ta 1ere question et la seconde, on avait parlé du concordat
je te laisse imaginer que ca n'a plus lieux depuis quelques temps.... 1850, ont avait a peine aboli l'esclavagisme !
On ne te parle pas de 1850 mais de 1870.....
La région est revenue depuis dans le giron français mais du fait de cette période bleue de prusse certaines lois françaises n'y sont toujours pas en vigueur...
On ne te parle pas de 1850 mais de 1870.....
La région est revenue depuis dans le giron français mais du fait de cette période bleue de prusse certaines lois françaises n'y sont toujours pas en vigueur...
l'enseignement est naturel de part la spécifité de la region et l'histoire ( et les cours de morale c'est de cela dont je parle, si tu etais un poil o.p tu serais que les cours de religion s'appelle cours de morale et sont donc facultatif si t'en fais la demande, je sais ca pourrait marcher dans l'autre sens, mais non)
je crois que tu n'arrives toujours pas a comprendre. d'abord ca n'a rien de naturel. secondo, il faut distinguer les cours de religions et de morale a proprement parlé. Si l'eleve fait une demande dispense cé a ce moment la qu'il doit suivre les cours de morales obligatoirement. 😏
Evidemment pour toi, si l'etat paie ses religieux comme des fonctionnaires et obligent une partie de ses enfants a suivre des cours de religion, ce meme etat est un etat laïc. 😏
je crois que tu n'arrives toujours pas a comprendre. d'abord ca n'a rien de naturel. secondo, il faut distinguer les cours de religions et de morale a proprement parlé. Si l'eleve fait une demande dispense cé a ce moment la qu'il doit suivre les cours de morales obligatoirement. 😏
Evidemment pour toi, si l'etat paie ses religieux comme des fonctionnaires et obligent une partie de ses enfants a suivre des cours de religion, ce meme etat est un etat laïc. 😏
Merci pour ces précisions. Je suis naturellement d'accord avec toi sur le fait que la France est un État laïc !
ce qu'il ne faut pas lire alors que les cours de religions sont imposés ou encore que l'eveque soit nommé par sarkozy comme president de la republique francaise ou encore que ces religieux sont des fonctionnaires payés avec nos impots 😏
tu devrais envoyer ta nouvelle definition de la laïcité a l'académie francaise 😎
ce qu'il ne faut pas lire alors que les cours de religions sont imposés ou encore que l'eveque soit nommé par sarkozy comme president de la republique francaise ou encore que ces religieux sont des fonctionnaires payés avec nos impots 😏
tu devrais envoyer ta nouvelle definition de la laïcité a l'académie francaise 😎
Et ce n'est pas un enseignement religieux, mais une approche de la morale au travers des courants religieux

je conseille le site droit local pour avoir un bel appercu de tout ca
Je conseille le vécu de parents d'élèves ....
" En Alsace et en Lorraine, des cours de religion sont donnés dans les écoles publiques (et accessoirement c'est l'Etat, qui prend en charge l'entretien des églises, cathédrales, etc). Pour y échapper, il faut écrire une lettre de dispense! (alors que ce devrait être l'inverse: aller à ce cours devrait être en option, au moins). Sur 23 gamins de la classe de ma fille, seuls 4 n'y vont pas. Ce chiffre m'a vraiment étonnée..."
Ou les renseignements fournis par un sundicat enseignant.....
"A-1-2-7 Statut d’Alsace-Moselle : Statut scolaire local
Les départements du Bas Rhin, du Haut Rhin et de la Moselle relèvent dans certains domaines (droit communal, sécurité sociale, affaires religieuses et scolaires, chasse, ...) d’un droit local particulier du fait de leur annexion par l'Allemagne de 1871 à 1918. C'est la raison pour laquelle certaines lois françaises votées durant cette période ne s'y appliquent pas.
A-1-2-7-1 Des textes qui donnent lieu à des interprétations
Pour l’enseignement, le statut scolaire n’a jamais fait l’objet d’une codification, de sorte qu’il n’existe pas une liste exhaustive des lois et règlements constituant ce statut scolaire. Le Conseil d’Etat «interprète» les lois locales. L’administration se réfère à des compilations.
Ces textes proviennent de certaines lois françaises d’avant 1871 (notamment des articles de la loi Falloux), de lois allemandes, et de lois et décrets français d’après 1918 à nos jours.
Le statut scolaire d’Alsace-Moselle est un manquement aux principes de laïcité et d’égalité. Il doit être abrogé. Le congrès demande que les lois laïques s’appliquent à l’ensemble du territoire national. Il enregistre comme une étape significative le caractère optionnel enfin affirmé de l’enseignement religieux en Alsace-Moselle. (Congrès SNUipp - Seignosse 2004) A-1-2-7-2 Les obligations
En Alsace et Moselle, l’enseignement religieux (de l’une des 4 religions reconnues : catholique, les 2 confessions protestantes et la religion juive) est obligatoire dans l’enseignement public à raison d'une heure par semaine dans le cadre du service hebdomadaire d'enseignement.
Depuis le décret du 03/09/74, les enseignants ne sont plus astreints à assurer eux-mêmes cet enseignement. Dans la majeure partie des cas il est assuré par des ministres des cultes concernés.
Le SNUipp a enregistré comme une étape significative l’appréciation de la commission Stasi, reprise par l’Institut du droit social précisant le caractère optionnel de l’enseignement religieux. Reste à traduire cette avancée dans la réglementation, la volonté de participer à l’enseignement religieux devant se substituer à la demande de dispense de celui-ci. Les parents qui en font la demande peuvent faire dispenser leurs enfants des cours d’enseignement religieux (circulaire de Guy LACHAMBRE du 17/06/1933). Ils sont informés et consultés à cet effet en début d’année scolaire. Les élèves dispensés sont pris en charge par les enseignants de l'école.
Des crucifix existent encore dans certaines salles de classe. Ils relèvent du «mobilier scolaire», bon nombre ont disparu après négociations avec les municipalités. On notera que, dans quelques rares localités (hors d’Alsace et de Moselle), des crucifix ont été maintenus sur des murs d'écoles ou de classes. Ils sont amenés à disparaître lors de la réfection des locaux."

je conseille le site droit local pour avoir un bel appercu de tout ca
Je conseille le vécu de parents d'élèves ....
" En Alsace et en Lorraine, des cours de religion sont donnés dans les écoles publiques (et accessoirement c'est l'Etat, qui prend en charge l'entretien des églises, cathédrales, etc). Pour y échapper, il faut écrire une lettre de dispense! (alors que ce devrait être l'inverse: aller à ce cours devrait être en option, au moins). Sur 23 gamins de la classe de ma fille, seuls 4 n'y vont pas. Ce chiffre m'a vraiment étonnée..."
Ou les renseignements fournis par un sundicat enseignant.....
"A-1-2-7 Statut d’Alsace-Moselle : Statut scolaire local
Les départements du Bas Rhin, du Haut Rhin et de la Moselle relèvent dans certains domaines (droit communal, sécurité sociale, affaires religieuses et scolaires, chasse, ...) d’un droit local particulier du fait de leur annexion par l'Allemagne de 1871 à 1918. C'est la raison pour laquelle certaines lois françaises votées durant cette période ne s'y appliquent pas.
A-1-2-7-1 Des textes qui donnent lieu à des interprétations
Pour l’enseignement, le statut scolaire n’a jamais fait l’objet d’une codification, de sorte qu’il n’existe pas une liste exhaustive des lois et règlements constituant ce statut scolaire. Le Conseil d’Etat «interprète» les lois locales. L’administration se réfère à des compilations.
Ces textes proviennent de certaines lois françaises d’avant 1871 (notamment des articles de la loi Falloux), de lois allemandes, et de lois et décrets français d’après 1918 à nos jours.
Le statut scolaire d’Alsace-Moselle est un manquement aux principes de laïcité et d’égalité. Il doit être abrogé. Le congrès demande que les lois laïques s’appliquent à l’ensemble du territoire national. Il enregistre comme une étape significative le caractère optionnel enfin affirmé de l’enseignement religieux en Alsace-Moselle. (Congrès SNUipp - Seignosse 2004) A-1-2-7-2 Les obligations
En Alsace et Moselle, l’enseignement religieux (de l’une des 4 religions reconnues : catholique, les 2 confessions protestantes et la religion juive) est obligatoire dans l’enseignement public à raison d'une heure par semaine dans le cadre du service hebdomadaire d'enseignement.
Depuis le décret du 03/09/74, les enseignants ne sont plus astreints à assurer eux-mêmes cet enseignement. Dans la majeure partie des cas il est assuré par des ministres des cultes concernés.
Le SNUipp a enregistré comme une étape significative l’appréciation de la commission Stasi, reprise par l’Institut du droit social précisant le caractère optionnel de l’enseignement religieux. Reste à traduire cette avancée dans la réglementation, la volonté de participer à l’enseignement religieux devant se substituer à la demande de dispense de celui-ci. Les parents qui en font la demande peuvent faire dispenser leurs enfants des cours d’enseignement religieux (circulaire de Guy LACHAMBRE du 17/06/1933). Ils sont informés et consultés à cet effet en début d’année scolaire. Les élèves dispensés sont pris en charge par les enseignants de l'école.
Des crucifix existent encore dans certaines salles de classe. Ils relèvent du «mobilier scolaire», bon nombre ont disparu après négociations avec les municipalités. On notera que, dans quelques rares localités (hors d’Alsace et de Moselle), des crucifix ont été maintenus sur des murs d'écoles ou de classes. Ils sont amenés à disparaître lors de la réfection des locaux."
tu devrais envoyer ta nouvelle definition de la laïcité a l'académie francaise
Article 1er de la Constitution du 4 octobre 1958 actuellement en vigueur :
« La France est une République indivisible, laïque, démocratique et sociale. Elle assure l'égalité devant la loi de tous les citoyens sans distinction d'origine, de race ou de religion. Elle respecte toutes les croyances. Son organisation est décentralisée. La loi favorise l’égal accès des femmes et des hommes aux mandats électoraux et fonctions électives, ainsi qu’aux responsabilités professionnelles et sociales. »
Article 1er de la Constitution du 4 octobre 1958 actuellement en vigueur :
« La France est une République indivisible, laïque, démocratique et sociale. Elle assure l'égalité devant la loi de tous les citoyens sans distinction d'origine, de race ou de religion. Elle respecte toutes les croyances. Son organisation est décentralisée. La loi favorise l’égal accès des femmes et des hommes aux mandats électoraux et fonctions électives, ainsi qu’aux responsabilités professionnelles et sociales. »
Je vous laisse vous étriper joyeusement comme hier soir parce qu'il y a mon dîner qu'est en train de refroidir....
Je crois que c'est "curé" au menu ce soir 😛
Je crois que c'est "curé" au menu ce soir 😛
t'es lourd !et puis c'est desagreable ta maniere d'aborder les gens...
si l'etat forcé l'alsace a revenir la dessus, tu serais le premier a le qualifier d'autoritaire. l'etat a laissé couler, a oublié pendant longtemps de revenir dessus....
encore un fois ce n'est valable que dans une region sur 22, ca fait un peu faible ... et puis , dans l'ecole a coté de chez moi , les cours de religion se nomme cours de morale, les sociétés evoluent ..
pour completer , je vais meme rajouter que le matin les cours sont en francais et l'aprem en allemand ! ( c'est pas ecrit dans le wiki ca !)
aller retournons plutot aux juifs incapables d'adopter la culture francaise , alors alsacien !!!
si l'etat forcé l'alsace a revenir la dessus, tu serais le premier a le qualifier d'autoritaire. l'etat a laissé couler, a oublié pendant longtemps de revenir dessus....
encore un fois ce n'est valable que dans une region sur 22, ca fait un peu faible ... et puis , dans l'ecole a coté de chez moi , les cours de religion se nomme cours de morale, les sociétés evoluent ..
pour completer , je vais meme rajouter que le matin les cours sont en francais et l'aprem en allemand ! ( c'est pas ecrit dans le wiki ca !)
aller retournons plutot aux juifs incapables d'adopter la culture francaise , alors alsacien !!!
Wikipédia (article Concordat en Alsace-Moselle) donne une assez bonne synthèse de l'enseignement de la religion tel qu'il est pratiqué en Alsace-Moselle :
La religion est enseignée obligatoirement à l'école primaire et au collège, mais une dispense est acceptée sur simple demande écrite des parents en début d'année scolaire. En cas de dispense, les élèves du primaire assistent à des cours de morale, les collégiens sont simplement dispensés de cours. Dans certains établissements (en particulier les lycées professionnels) le cours se nomme faits religieux. Les professeurs de religion catholique et protestante sont formés par les deux facultés de théologie correspondantes (cf. infra).
Le concordat n'affecte en rien l'enseignement privé confessionnel, par ailleurs assez développé en Alsace. Il y a d'ailleurs des établissements primaires et secondaires des trois religions concordataires.
Dans beaucoup de collèges aujourd'hui, la religion n'est plus le pilier central de ces cours. En effet, les élèves et leur professeur débattent de plus en plus sur des sujets humanitaires, internationaux, sociaux, culturels, et religieux. Ce n'est donc pas un cours de catéchisme mais plutôt un enseignement culturel et religieux (le catéchisme au sens strict, préparation des enfants et jeunes à la Communion et à la Confirmation, est assuré dans les paroisses indépendamment des cours de religion à l'école).
Par ailleurs, le fait que des crucifix existent encore dans certaines salles de classe en Alsace-Moselle ne me semble pas constituer un crime contre l'humanité.
Enfin, pour ce qui est des églises (bâtiments), je te signale qu'elles sont la propriété des communes sur l'ensemble du territoire national, et que leur entretien incombe donc aux municipalités.
La religion est enseignée obligatoirement à l'école primaire et au collège, mais une dispense est acceptée sur simple demande écrite des parents en début d'année scolaire. En cas de dispense, les élèves du primaire assistent à des cours de morale, les collégiens sont simplement dispensés de cours. Dans certains établissements (en particulier les lycées professionnels) le cours se nomme faits religieux. Les professeurs de religion catholique et protestante sont formés par les deux facultés de théologie correspondantes (cf. infra).
Le concordat n'affecte en rien l'enseignement privé confessionnel, par ailleurs assez développé en Alsace. Il y a d'ailleurs des établissements primaires et secondaires des trois religions concordataires.
Dans beaucoup de collèges aujourd'hui, la religion n'est plus le pilier central de ces cours. En effet, les élèves et leur professeur débattent de plus en plus sur des sujets humanitaires, internationaux, sociaux, culturels, et religieux. Ce n'est donc pas un cours de catéchisme mais plutôt un enseignement culturel et religieux (le catéchisme au sens strict, préparation des enfants et jeunes à la Communion et à la Confirmation, est assuré dans les paroisses indépendamment des cours de religion à l'école).
Par ailleurs, le fait que des crucifix existent encore dans certaines salles de classe en Alsace-Moselle ne me semble pas constituer un crime contre l'humanité.
Enfin, pour ce qui est des églises (bâtiments), je te signale qu'elles sont la propriété des communes sur l'ensemble du territoire national, et que leur entretien incombe donc aux municipalités.
"Le statut scolaire d’Alsace-Moselle est un manquement aux principes de laïcité et d’égalité. Il doit être abrogé. Le congrès demande que les lois laïques s’appliquent à l’ensemble du territoire national. Il enregistre comme une étape significative le caractère optionnel enfin affirmé de l’enseignement religieux en Alsace-Moselle"
j'imagine dire ca a une alsacien ... c'est un coup de carabine assuré....
ils veulent decider de garder leurs spécifités ou non. ils ont eu beaucoup de mal a se foger.. un jour francais, un jour allemand... et refusent une domination complete de l'etat...
j'aime assez.....je trouve ca tres punk ( et les punk portaient descroix aux nez, et on les taxaient pas de catho) !!!!
j'imagine dire ca a une alsacien ... c'est un coup de carabine assuré....
ils veulent decider de garder leurs spécifités ou non. ils ont eu beaucoup de mal a se foger.. un jour francais, un jour allemand... et refusent une domination complete de l'etat...
j'aime assez.....je trouve ca tres punk ( et les punk portaient descroix aux nez, et on les taxaient pas de catho) !!!!
🙂🙂🙂, Bonjour,
Bon, maintenant qu'on est rassurés sur le statut laïque de la France 😄😄
Je reviens à ma proposition :
On ne peut pas changer de culture car on ne peut pas changer ce dont on souffre. La douleur physique est une donnée objective +/- mesurable et +/- identique pour tous. Qu'on pique des fesses blanches, noires ou jaunes la douleur sera toujours la même par contre la souffrance, elle, est subjective et culturelle :
L'islam prône le fatalisme il faut me piquer les fesses "inch Allah", pour l"hindouisme, la sagesse doit permettre de dépasser la souffrance, en psycho on dit sublimer ( en faire une force supplémentaire ), dans les cultures animistes, on souffre parce qu'on a contrarié un dieu, quant à l'humanisme , typique des cultures occidentales, il voudrait créer un monde où toutes les souffrances seraient éradiquées par la raison, mais l'humanisme, comme toutes les cultures est fondé sur la religion dominante des cultures qui l'ont promu : le christianisme. On a donc en filigrane à l'arrière de l'utopie humaniste la valeur sacrificielle de la souffrance qui est le fondement du christianisme.
Bon, maintenant qu'on est rassurés sur le statut laïque de la France 😄😄
Je reviens à ma proposition :
On ne peut pas changer de culture car on ne peut pas changer ce dont on souffre. La douleur physique est une donnée objective +/- mesurable et +/- identique pour tous. Qu'on pique des fesses blanches, noires ou jaunes la douleur sera toujours la même par contre la souffrance, elle, est subjective et culturelle :
L'islam prône le fatalisme il faut me piquer les fesses "inch Allah", pour l"hindouisme, la sagesse doit permettre de dépasser la souffrance, en psycho on dit sublimer ( en faire une force supplémentaire ), dans les cultures animistes, on souffre parce qu'on a contrarié un dieu, quant à l'humanisme , typique des cultures occidentales, il voudrait créer un monde où toutes les souffrances seraient éradiquées par la raison, mais l'humanisme, comme toutes les cultures est fondé sur la religion dominante des cultures qui l'ont promu : le christianisme. On a donc en filigrane à l'arrière de l'utopie humaniste la valeur sacrificielle de la souffrance qui est le fondement du christianisme.
Catherine
" La lucidité est la blessure la plus proche du soleil" René Char
http://www.catherinegil.com
http://www.catherinegil.com
l
es alsaciens ayant integrés le territoire francais ont tout de suite changé leur culture par la francaise.
Ils n'ont été sous domination allemande que 44 ans...
es alsaciens ayant integrés le territoire francais ont tout de suite changé leur culture par la francaise.
Ils n'ont été sous domination allemande que 44 ans...
Je pense qu'un végétalien français a une culture beaucoup plus en symbiose avec celle d'un végétalien argentin qu'avec moi ou tout autre carnivore.
Tiens je vais changer de culture, je vais devenir Végétalien !!
Tiens je vais changer de culture, je vais devenir Végétalien !!
l
es alsaciens ayant integrés le territoire francais ont tout de suite changé leur culture par la francaise.
Ils n'ont été sous domination allemande que 44 ans...
pkoi tronquer une reponse pour faire dire autre chose?
je te rappelle que l'alsace faisaient partie du saint empire romain germanique; on pourrait aussi remonter jusqu'a la, non. pkoi remonter l'histoire a seulement a 1871? ca serait le debut de l'histoire de l'homme?
es alsaciens ayant integrés le territoire francais ont tout de suite changé leur culture par la francaise.
Ils n'ont été sous domination allemande que 44 ans...
pkoi tronquer une reponse pour faire dire autre chose?
je te rappelle que l'alsace faisaient partie du saint empire romain germanique; on pourrait aussi remonter jusqu'a la, non. pkoi remonter l'histoire a seulement a 1871? ca serait le debut de l'histoire de l'homme?
On ne peut pas changer de culture car on ne peut pas changer ce dont on souffre.
Salut,
intéressant comme point de vue! ... cela revient à dire que fondamentalement les cultures ne sont pas mixables, sauf sur certains signes extérieurs? ...
😎, mon postulat n'est pas une loi, c'est juste ce que je crois et c'est par essence discutable.
Et c'est tant mieux si les cultures ne sont pas mixables, la diversité pour peu qu'elle soit accueillie avec ouverture d'esprit et intelligence est un enrichissement, pour tous, par contre la mondialisation coca-cola/séries B est un appauvrissement dramatique culturellement et humainement ce me semble.
Salut,
intéressant comme point de vue! ... cela revient à dire que fondamentalement les cultures ne sont pas mixables, sauf sur certains signes extérieurs? ...
😎, mon postulat n'est pas une loi, c'est juste ce que je crois et c'est par essence discutable.
Et c'est tant mieux si les cultures ne sont pas mixables, la diversité pour peu qu'elle soit accueillie avec ouverture d'esprit et intelligence est un enrichissement, pour tous, par contre la mondialisation coca-cola/séries B est un appauvrissement dramatique culturellement et humainement ce me semble.
Catherine
" La lucidité est la blessure la plus proche du soleil" René Char
http://www.catherinegil.com
http://www.catherinegil.com
navré de te contredire mais la france n'est pas un pays laïc
La France est pour l'instant et jusqu'à preuve du contraire un pays laïc. On pourrait savoir ce qui te fait affirmer le contraire? Un pays laïc n'exclut pas le religieux elle le sépare du politique.
La France est pour l'instant et jusqu'à preuve du contraire un pays laïc. On pourrait savoir ce qui te fait affirmer le contraire? Un pays laïc n'exclut pas le religieux elle le sépare du politique.
navré de te contredire mais la france n'est pas un pays laïc
La France est pour l'instant et jusqu'à preuve du contraire un pays laïc. On pourrait savoir ce qui te fait affirmer le contraire? Un pays laïc n'exclut pas le religieux elle le sépare du politique.
quand on oblige a etudier la religion (cathé) ou a nommer des eveques... tu trouves cela qu'il y a une separation entre le politique et le religieux?
il suffit de le lire plus haut la démo pour plus de detail 😏
La France est pour l'instant et jusqu'à preuve du contraire un pays laïc. On pourrait savoir ce qui te fait affirmer le contraire? Un pays laïc n'exclut pas le religieux elle le sépare du politique.
quand on oblige a etudier la religion (cathé) ou a nommer des eveques... tu trouves cela qu'il y a une separation entre le politique et le religieux?
il suffit de le lire plus haut la démo pour plus de detail 😏
parce qu'une region , au passé et à la geographie particuliere a décidé de garder le rapprochement de l'eglise et de l'etat , toute l'histoire francaise est faussée ???
ca n'a aucun sens .......
alors si je te dis que les autoroutes en France sont gratuites , tu es d'accord !
non ?? ben en alsace elles le sont donc c'est valable partout ! on va aller loin comme ca ! je te propose d'alller faire un tour sur le site de droit local , et tu verras que ton raisonnement ne peux fonctionner ! prendre une exception pour la generaliser, ne marche pas !
et puis , petite precision, l'enseignement du religieux n'est pas obligatoire, mais naturel. il est possible de faire la demande de non ensegnement religieux .
+1 C'est à mon avis absolument imparable mais on trouvera toujours des contradicteurs de l'impossible!!!
ca n'a aucun sens .......
alors si je te dis que les autoroutes en France sont gratuites , tu es d'accord !
non ?? ben en alsace elles le sont donc c'est valable partout ! on va aller loin comme ca ! je te propose d'alller faire un tour sur le site de droit local , et tu verras que ton raisonnement ne peux fonctionner ! prendre une exception pour la generaliser, ne marche pas !
et puis , petite precision, l'enseignement du religieux n'est pas obligatoire, mais naturel. il est possible de faire la demande de non ensegnement religieux .
+1 C'est à mon avis absolument imparable mais on trouvera toujours des contradicteurs de l'impossible!!!
quand on oblige a etudier la religion (cathé) ou a nommer des eveques... tu trouves cela qu'il y a une separation entre le politique et le religieux?
il suffit de le lire plus haut la démo pour plus de detail
Ta demo n'en est pas une! Tu racontes n'importe quoi! et tu utilises un fait anecdotique pour en faire une généralité. Ici tout le monde est d'accord ( enfin je pense) sur le fait que la France est un pays laïc et qui défend de pied ferme la laïcité.
il suffit de le lire plus haut la démo pour plus de detail
Ta demo n'en est pas une! Tu racontes n'importe quoi! et tu utilises un fait anecdotique pour en faire une généralité. Ici tout le monde est d'accord ( enfin je pense) sur le fait que la France est un pays laïc et qui défend de pied ferme la laïcité.
🙂, bon, bon, bon, nemo 1001 n'est toujours pas convaincu de la laïcité de la France et veut continuer sur cette base : la France qui a inventé le concept de laïcité républicaine n'est pas un pays laïque et l'agnosticisme ou l'athéisme sont selon lui interdits en Alsace/Lorraine.... Ben pardi ! 😉
Catherine
" La lucidité est la blessure la plus proche du soleil" René Char
http://www.catherinegil.com
http://www.catherinegil.com
Log in first, then come back to this page.
You might also like
Storm in the Canary Islands
New adventures from Perpignan to Ranchi (Jharkhand)
Breathtaking Kyrgyzstan!
Argentine and Chilean Patagonia from El Calafate to Ushuaia
Turkey 2026: Riviera, Antalya, and Cappadocia
Page by Page on the Assisi Way – 1,200 km on Foot
How to nail your trek in wet climates: which pants keep you truly dry?
Densha Otaku - Lesser-Known Regions
More discussions
Hello everyone on this forum!
I know in advance that what I'm about to say here won't please everyone, but honesty is a virtue, isn't it?
Here's the thing: for many years now, I've noticed a habit in French-speaking posts of using abbreviations left and right, as if to show that we're "in the know." Let me explain with a few examples:
- - In discussions about Peru, I see "Aguas" for "Aguas Calientes." And if it's Mexico, well, it'll be "Aguas" for "Aguascalientes"!
- - For Guatemala, "travelers" will say "Guaté." Come on, saying "Guatemalas" would maybe be the undeniable sign that you know nothing about the country???
- - Back from Indonesia, many will talk about how familiar they've become with the country's language: "bahasa." Of course, everyone will know what you're talking about, but it still gets on my nerves because the language (one of the many languages) of Indonesia is "bahasa Indonesia." "Bahasa" actually means "language," and you'll find this word of Indian origin ‘Bhāṣā’ (it's Sanskrit originally) outside Indonesia too: in Thailand, for example, any language will be "phasa" as in "phasa thai" (official Thai), "phasa isan" (what's spoken in northeastern Thailand), "phasa angkrit" = English, etc.
Am I an incorrigible nitpicker? Maybe. But I'd also find it ridiculous if a foreigner came and told me they visited "Monte" during their trip to France, when it was actually Monte Carlo.
I read a lot in English and don't think I've encountered such a habit among English speakers.
Hi everyone,
Who’d like to share their best and worst travel memories in a few lines? For me, it’s watching the TAJ MAHAL at sunrise and getting chased by dogs at the top of a mountain pass in GREECE on the way back from ISTANBUL. THANKS GUYS
Who’d like to share their best and worst travel memories in a few lines? For me, it’s watching the TAJ MAHAL at sunrise and getting chased by dogs at the top of a mountain pass in GREECE on the way back from ISTANBUL. THANKS GUYS
Good evening everyone,
This is my 15,000th post, and it's a message I would have preferred never to write.
Patrick—Yangguizi—won’t be returning from his trek in Uganda. His health betrayed him in the mountains.
Like many of you, I laughed until I couldn’t anymore at his travel stories. I met him in Shanghai, then in Istanbul... We scoured restaurants—he was an incredible expert on world cuisines. We relived Korea, China. Always brilliant, so sharp, so funny, so down-to-earth. Being even a little bit his friend was something to be proud of. I think I envied him.
Patrick is still out there, of course... He found his happiness running across the world. He’s on his path. He never doubted that "the traveler doesn’t even know if he’ll return one day."
Not sure this would’ve suited him, but his departure devastates me.
Alright, Farewell, you foreign devil. Safe travels.
Michel
This is my 15,000th post, and it's a message I would have preferred never to write.
Patrick—Yangguizi—won’t be returning from his trek in Uganda. His health betrayed him in the mountains.
Like many of you, I laughed until I couldn’t anymore at his travel stories. I met him in Shanghai, then in Istanbul... We scoured restaurants—he was an incredible expert on world cuisines. We relived Korea, China. Always brilliant, so sharp, so funny, so down-to-earth. Being even a little bit his friend was something to be proud of. I think I envied him.
Patrick is still out there, of course... He found his happiness running across the world. He’s on his path. He never doubted that "the traveler doesn’t even know if he’ll return one day."
Not sure this would’ve suited him, but his departure devastates me.
Alright, Farewell, you foreign devil. Safe travels.
Michel
hello to all travelers with their eyes wide open to the desert...
I’ve always wondered what I was "doing" on this earth. And why my father, who died a few months after I was born—a former youngest French resistance fighter—joined the First Saharan Motorized Company in Atar and spent the rest of his life repairing army engines in Algeria, Mauritania, Senegal, Mali (which didn’t exist under that name back then), Morocco, and finally Algeria, where my mother was born and raised. (Believe me, it’s not "cool" being the child of a soldier in a country occupied by France, and even less so the child of a "pied-noir.") Of course, I never got an answer: the dead don’t talk, and the army doesn’t either. But here’s the thing—I had photos... So naturally, one day I hit the road. I wanted to see, to understand. It’s thanks to VF that I was able to do a little research on crossing the Morocco-Mauritania border, and I’m grateful to its members, just as I’m grateful to all those who welcomed me on the road for 14 years. For the past few weeks, I’ve been wondering if I should talk about this or not... It turns out the Mauritanians changed my life by asking for my help... And that started as early as February 2012... (Did I owe them something? No answer to that question.) Ah, the irony—they saw me coming. But when you’re handed sick children and begged to do something, what would you have done? I’d worked in a hospital, so I knew a bit about the rules to follow. I didn’t hesitate. And well, over all these years, I met doctors, surgeons, and together we organized care, evacuations of children, training for surgeons—even trying to stop children from having to travel outside their country. It was never easy. I’d like to thank those who supported us, as well as *La Chaîne de l’Espoir*, *La Fondation Face au Monde*, and everyone who built bridges between our two countries. Unfortunately, despite the constant efforts of Mauritanian doctors and surgeons, some children couldn’t be helped in time. Today, I want to talk about four siblings—orphans of their mother—suffering from congenital glaucoma causing irreversible blindness. Their case was entrusted to me in 2020, just weeks before the big lockdown. We couldn’t do anything for them then, but when their father asked me for a gift, I rushed to my computer and wrote a story. Through a tale, the children take a great journey, explore their country, and fulfill a dream. I never thought this book would be published—it was, in 2023. This book pays tribute to Mauritania. It’s a message for those who know nothing about the hardships of life there, carrying both the harshness and beauty of an immense desert where you can travel by 4x4, bike, on foot, or by camel in complete safety. It bears witness to the kindness of Mauritanians toward travelers. As a woman traveling alone in my vehicle—a now-rusted old Mercedes that no longer runs—I had the most beautiful encounters of my life there (I’ve seen other parts of the world...). The blind children of Choum, Atar, Nouadhibou, and Nouakchott will forever be in my heart. Volunteer readers transcribed the book into a free audio version for the visually impaired. It’s available in sound libraries in France, the *Fondation Valentin Haüy*, and the Swiss Romande library. I made my last trip to Mauritania in my old 4x4 to distribute the book everywhere, especially to its heroes and the school for the visually impaired in Nouakchott. After that, I thought it was time to close the chapter because I no longer have the means or the strength to travel. My publishers chose this title for it: *The Blue Eyes of the Desert*. This publication helped a mission of Swiss volunteer ophthalmologists come to operate on glaucomas in Mauritania. I’m thrilled because they come back every year! This adventure is ending, yes—everything must come to an end—but ultimately, it was born here, on the VF site!! So yes, I had to say it: THANK YOU!!!!!
I’ve always wondered what I was "doing" on this earth. And why my father, who died a few months after I was born—a former youngest French resistance fighter—joined the First Saharan Motorized Company in Atar and spent the rest of his life repairing army engines in Algeria, Mauritania, Senegal, Mali (which didn’t exist under that name back then), Morocco, and finally Algeria, where my mother was born and raised. (Believe me, it’s not "cool" being the child of a soldier in a country occupied by France, and even less so the child of a "pied-noir.") Of course, I never got an answer: the dead don’t talk, and the army doesn’t either. But here’s the thing—I had photos... So naturally, one day I hit the road. I wanted to see, to understand. It’s thanks to VF that I was able to do a little research on crossing the Morocco-Mauritania border, and I’m grateful to its members, just as I’m grateful to all those who welcomed me on the road for 14 years. For the past few weeks, I’ve been wondering if I should talk about this or not... It turns out the Mauritanians changed my life by asking for my help... And that started as early as February 2012... (Did I owe them something? No answer to that question.) Ah, the irony—they saw me coming. But when you’re handed sick children and begged to do something, what would you have done? I’d worked in a hospital, so I knew a bit about the rules to follow. I didn’t hesitate. And well, over all these years, I met doctors, surgeons, and together we organized care, evacuations of children, training for surgeons—even trying to stop children from having to travel outside their country. It was never easy. I’d like to thank those who supported us, as well as *La Chaîne de l’Espoir*, *La Fondation Face au Monde*, and everyone who built bridges between our two countries. Unfortunately, despite the constant efforts of Mauritanian doctors and surgeons, some children couldn’t be helped in time. Today, I want to talk about four siblings—orphans of their mother—suffering from congenital glaucoma causing irreversible blindness. Their case was entrusted to me in 2020, just weeks before the big lockdown. We couldn’t do anything for them then, but when their father asked me for a gift, I rushed to my computer and wrote a story. Through a tale, the children take a great journey, explore their country, and fulfill a dream. I never thought this book would be published—it was, in 2023. This book pays tribute to Mauritania. It’s a message for those who know nothing about the hardships of life there, carrying both the harshness and beauty of an immense desert where you can travel by 4x4, bike, on foot, or by camel in complete safety. It bears witness to the kindness of Mauritanians toward travelers. As a woman traveling alone in my vehicle—a now-rusted old Mercedes that no longer runs—I had the most beautiful encounters of my life there (I’ve seen other parts of the world...). The blind children of Choum, Atar, Nouadhibou, and Nouakchott will forever be in my heart. Volunteer readers transcribed the book into a free audio version for the visually impaired. It’s available in sound libraries in France, the *Fondation Valentin Haüy*, and the Swiss Romande library. I made my last trip to Mauritania in my old 4x4 to distribute the book everywhere, especially to its heroes and the school for the visually impaired in Nouakchott. After that, I thought it was time to close the chapter because I no longer have the means or the strength to travel. My publishers chose this title for it: *The Blue Eyes of the Desert*. This publication helped a mission of Swiss volunteer ophthalmologists come to operate on glaucomas in Mauritania. I’m thrilled because they come back every year! This adventure is ending, yes—everything must come to an end—but ultimately, it was born here, on the VF site!! So yes, I had to say it: THANK YOU!!!!!
Hi everyone,
I’m Loulou, a French expat who’s been living in Southeast Asia for about fifteen years, currently in Phnom Penh, Cambodia. A passionate walker at heart, I’ve trekked in Nepal (Thorung La, Mardi Himal), India, Vietnam, and I’m still planning new hikes (Char Dham, Langtang, Annapurna).
I’ve just published my first travel journal, recounting three months of walking and encounters across India. A portion of the sales goes to an educational center I support in Kep, for children whose parents work in the salt marshes.
I’m also working on a second book about Nepal with a musician friend, focusing on the Mardi Himal trek—two independent perspectives on the same journey.
Happy to swap stories with you about the Himalayas, India, Southeast Asia, or just the urge to hit the road and walk far from home.
Safe travels,
Loulou
Hi! It was totally by chance that I stumbled upon VoyageForum (an ad online and a story lol), and I’ve been reading some really old posts from 2011 about Thai massage schools—discussions on how to get by, accommodation, prices, etc. It reminded me of my own experience: I kept things simple by staying with a local family during my entire trip. I only shared all the expenses with them, which, I’ll admit, was super cheap… and I often traveled with them, which naturally opened a lot of doors for me. To start, at the school in Salaya, my Thai friend immediately connected me with Teacher Phong (the school’s mentor and teacher of teachers, a former monk). I was supposed to join a group session with other foreigners, but for some reason I don’t know, I got two days of private lessons for free with this expert… incredible! And on top of that, he loved France! It was an amazing experience. I "discovered" massage by chance—the Thai family just told me: "Try it, you’ll see!" (I’d had a pretty intense massage in the capital before 😅… but the next day, I felt unbelievably great!))
Every morning, I’d take a taxi (chosen by the Thai family at prices that beat all the competition) to this school—I’ve forgotten the name of the little village now… right in the heart of the countryside. Then, in the evenings, I’d keep practicing massage on all the family members… and they’d teach me Thai at the same time!))
Since then, I’ve practiced a bit, with lots of positive feedback. Following Teacher Phong’s advice—he thought my pressure was deep, firm, and precise—he strongly encouraged me to take this seriously.
I love Thailand so much. It’s a whole different way of living… and it’s a real blessing, even if I couldn’t live there full-time. Anyway, that was an unforgettable memory, and sometimes the Thai family and I still say hi—from 2011, 2013… right up to today!
Take care, everyone! !
Every morning, I’d take a taxi (chosen by the Thai family at prices that beat all the competition) to this school—I’ve forgotten the name of the little village now… right in the heart of the countryside. Then, in the evenings, I’d keep practicing massage on all the family members… and they’d teach me Thai at the same time!))
Since then, I’ve practiced a bit, with lots of positive feedback. Following Teacher Phong’s advice—he thought my pressure was deep, firm, and precise—he strongly encouraged me to take this seriously.
I love Thailand so much. It’s a whole different way of living… and it’s a real blessing, even if I couldn’t live there full-time. Anyway, that was an unforgettable memory, and sometimes the Thai family and I still say hi—from 2011, 2013… right up to today!
Take care, everyone! !
"It seems to me that poverty would be less painful in the sun" wrote Aznavour...
Not sure...😕 Who can prove that people in hot countries are happier than others? What do you think?
Is it better to live in Montpellier than in Lille? Are the Pygmies happier than the Inuit? Are Canadians less happy than the people of Louisiana? Are there more French expats in hot countries?
And your travels? Do you choose your destinations based on the climate? Do you rejoice when a bit of sunshine appears?
Not sure...😕 Who can prove that people in hot countries are happier than others? What do you think?
Is it better to live in Montpellier than in Lille? Are the Pygmies happier than the Inuit? Are Canadians less happy than the people of Louisiana? Are there more French expats in hot countries?
And your travels? Do you choose your destinations based on the climate? Do you rejoice when a bit of sunshine appears?
Hi everyone, just this once I’m not posting for a travel story, but to share a thought for Venezuela.
If you didn’t know—since it’s not making headlines—the country was hit by two 7.5-magnitude earthquakes last week. Over 2,200 people have died, more than 50,000 are missing, and some coastal towns have been completely destroyed. Maybe when the scale of the humanitarian crisis becomes clear, our media will cover it a bit more... especially since earthquakes with this many casualties usually make the front page, but there’s been nothing in France.
So here’s a thought for this country, which, whatever you think of its politics, is a true jewel of South America, both for its landscapes and its people.
If you didn’t know—since it’s not making headlines—the country was hit by two 7.5-magnitude earthquakes last week. Over 2,200 people have died, more than 50,000 are missing, and some coastal towns have been completely destroyed. Maybe when the scale of the humanitarian crisis becomes clear, our media will cover it a bit more... especially since earthquakes with this many casualties usually make the front page, but there’s been nothing in France.
So here’s a thought for this country, which, whatever you think of its politics, is a true jewel of South America, both for its landscapes and its people.
hi there
I’d like to invite you to discover my coastal province in central Vietnam: Quang Ngai.
This year, my province has really improved its infrastructure—mountains, countryside, and sea are all authentic here.
No harassers or thieves, and no Russians either.
A local lunch costs around 1 €.
A *** hotel room is about 25 €, and you can find hotels right on My Khe Beach.
We have a specialty: *banh xeo*—10 crepes for just 1.5 €.
You can rent motorbikes to explore the province and maybe visit the many ethnic minorities.
I live here—I’m not selling anything, but I can help if needed (my father-in-law is a traditional Vietnamese doctor and he’s very skilled).
We're planning to spend a month in Vietnam. Is hiring a guide helpful?
Hi everyone! 😉
I’m Typhaine, 35 years old. Five years ago, I left France for a solo round-the-world trip—no planes, just a van, hitchhiking, cycling, and even a canoe in the Amazon! Today, I work as a naturalist guide in Argentine Patagonia.
Wherever I go, my compass stays the same: observing and photographing wildlife, which I deeply admire and respect.
My project: I’d love to share this experience through a sustainable, authentic, and immersive nature tourism initiative. But to build something meaningful, I need to understand how other nature enthusiasts experience their own adventures.
If you:
Are over 20 years old
Have a true passion for Nature
Have already taken at least one trip lasting more than 3 nights (in your country or abroad) in your life
Then... would you have 5 to 7 minutes to help me by filling out this questionnaire? 🙂 »» https://forms.gle/y74ckkvN9TjrougLA
Promise: I’m not selling anything, this isn’t marketing. Your answers are 100% anonymous and will only help me shape this wild project. A huge thank you to everyone for your help and kindness! Looking forward to chatting in this thread 😛
(Dear admins, this is purely a collaborative effort for my project study, with no commercial purpose. Thank you so much for your support!)
Photo: Grizzly Bear (Ursus arctos horribilis), female on the left and her cub on the right. Photo taken by me in Alaska, Denali National Park.
My project: I’d love to share this experience through a sustainable, authentic, and immersive nature tourism initiative. But to build something meaningful, I need to understand how other nature enthusiasts experience their own adventures.
If you:
Are over 20 years old
Have a true passion for Nature
Have already taken at least one trip lasting more than 3 nights (in your country or abroad) in your life
Then... would you have 5 to 7 minutes to help me by filling out this questionnaire? 🙂 »» https://forms.gle/y74ckkvN9TjrougLA
Promise: I’m not selling anything, this isn’t marketing. Your answers are 100% anonymous and will only help me shape this wild project. A huge thank you to everyone for your help and kindness! Looking forward to chatting in this thread 😛
(Dear admins, this is purely a collaborative effort for my project study, with no commercial purpose. Thank you so much for your support!)
Photo: Grizzly Bear (Ursus arctos horribilis), female on the left and her cub on the right. Photo taken by me in Alaska, Denali National Park.
Hello everyone,
It’s something we often notice in this forum—and many others—this behavioral shift.
A long-time member, or even a new one, asks a question. They get one or more answers, some brief, some detailed, and then... nothing???
Not even a simple thank you!!!
From what I’ve gathered, if the answers don’t align with what they wanted to hear, it seems natural for the asker to just disappear!! 😕 Unless—(and I fear this is the case)—basic politeness is no longer part of our society????
Please forgive my little rant.
Wishing everyone all the best. Cheers,
Puma2A

...
It’s something we often notice in this forum—and many others—this behavioral shift.
A long-time member, or even a new one, asks a question. They get one or more answers, some brief, some detailed, and then... nothing???
Not even a simple thank you!!!
From what I’ve gathered, if the answers don’t align with what they wanted to hear, it seems natural for the asker to just disappear!! 😕 Unless—(and I fear this is the case)—basic politeness is no longer part of our society????
Please forgive my little rant.
Wishing everyone all the best. Cheers,
Puma2A

...
I spent 3 weeks in Bali last summer (+ 3 nights on Gili Meno and a day trip to Kawah Ijen in Java). So I wanted to see what ChatGPT could suggest for comparison...
Here’s the prompt I gave:
"You’re a local expert guide for Bali.
- Plan a 20-day itinerary for Bali with a side trip to Gili Meno and a day trip to Kawah Ijen in Java without staying overnight.
- I’m traveling with my wife, and I love visiting historical sites, hiking, relaxing at the beach, snorkeling, and exploring rice terraces...
- For the duration of the stay, I don’t want more than 8 places to sleep, and I’d like to stay at least 2 days at each stop to avoid unpacking too often. Except for the last night, where I’m okay with just one night near the airport.
- I prefer neighborhoods that are walkable and try to avoid typical tourist traps, though I don’t want to miss the must-see spots. So suggest a mix of iconic sites and hidden gems.
- Recommend hotels or guesthouses with a budget of 50 to 100 € per night, including breakfast. Make suggestions in areas popular with travelers, specifying the vibe (I prefer quiet), and consider safety and proximity to attractions.
- For lunch and dinner, suggest two to three restaurants that are well-rated by customers.
- Give me a day-by-day program with details on travel times, visiting times for each point of interest, and recommendations for transportation (taxi, train, bike, etc.). Estimate the total cost of the trip, including accommodations, food, transportation, and activities, and suggest two tips for saving money in each category.
- Don’t make anything up—be realistic about travel times, take into account the opening dates and hours of sites, and give me the entry fees for places to visit.
- Ask me all the questions until you’re 95% sure you understand what’s being asked. Don’t generate your response until you’ve understood."
The AI asked for a few clarifications:
"Great request—I can build you a really optimized and enjoyable itinerary, but to be 95% sure I hit the mark, I need a few key clarifications (this will really influence the pace, areas, and accommodations)."
In the end, it proposed a program very close to what we actually did. I’ll skip its accommodation and restaurant suggestions...
Its proposal:
"Ubud (4 nights) => we did 5 nights Sidemen (2 nights) Amed (3 nights) => we’d planned 2 nights Gili Meno (3 nights) => we did Gili between Sidemen and Amed Munduk (3 nights) => we did 2 nights before Pemuteran Pemuteran (3 nights) with Ijen => we did 4 nights Sanur (2 nights + 1 last night) => we chose Jatiluwih instead of Sanur
It suggested "activities" (and accommodations too):
IN UBUD: - Walk around central Ubud (1–2h) - Campuhan Ridge Walk - Tegalalang Rice Terrace - Tirta Empul - Gunung Kawi - Massage / market / slow café
IN SIDEMEN: - Rice terrace hike (2–3h) - Cooking class
IN AMED: - Snorkeling - Japanese Shipwreck - Beach + relaxation - Volcano sunset
ON GILI: - Snorkeling at Gili Meno Turtle Point, Nest Underwater Statues
IN MUNDUK: - Jungle & waterfall hike - Munduk Waterfall + Melanting Waterfall - Loop: 3–4h (perfect for your level) - Ulun Danu Bratan Temple - Twin Lakes
IN PEMUTERAN - Snorkeling: Menjangan Island
For Kawah Ijen, it detailed the day well: 👍 from Pemuteran = best possible option 12 PM: leave hotel (we left at 10 PM) 1 PM: ferry 3 PM: arrival in Java + transfer 11 PM: start ascent 2 AM–6 AM: volcano Return to Bali around 11 AM–12 PM (we got back at 4 PM) 👍 still very intense, but doable with an agency 💰 ~80–120 €/person all-inclusive
IN SANUR: - Relaxation - Quiet beach - Proximity to airport (30 min)"
BUDGET: "3,000 – 3,900 € for 2 people" (We paid 3,200 €)
In conclusion, it’s not (yet) enough, but it’s (already) pretty impressive!
Here’s the prompt I gave:
"You’re a local expert guide for Bali.
- Plan a 20-day itinerary for Bali with a side trip to Gili Meno and a day trip to Kawah Ijen in Java without staying overnight.
- I’m traveling with my wife, and I love visiting historical sites, hiking, relaxing at the beach, snorkeling, and exploring rice terraces...
- For the duration of the stay, I don’t want more than 8 places to sleep, and I’d like to stay at least 2 days at each stop to avoid unpacking too often. Except for the last night, where I’m okay with just one night near the airport.
- I prefer neighborhoods that are walkable and try to avoid typical tourist traps, though I don’t want to miss the must-see spots. So suggest a mix of iconic sites and hidden gems.
- Recommend hotels or guesthouses with a budget of 50 to 100 € per night, including breakfast. Make suggestions in areas popular with travelers, specifying the vibe (I prefer quiet), and consider safety and proximity to attractions.
- For lunch and dinner, suggest two to three restaurants that are well-rated by customers.
- Give me a day-by-day program with details on travel times, visiting times for each point of interest, and recommendations for transportation (taxi, train, bike, etc.). Estimate the total cost of the trip, including accommodations, food, transportation, and activities, and suggest two tips for saving money in each category.
- Don’t make anything up—be realistic about travel times, take into account the opening dates and hours of sites, and give me the entry fees for places to visit.
- Ask me all the questions until you’re 95% sure you understand what’s being asked. Don’t generate your response until you’ve understood."
The AI asked for a few clarifications:
"Great request—I can build you a really optimized and enjoyable itinerary, but to be 95% sure I hit the mark, I need a few key clarifications (this will really influence the pace, areas, and accommodations)."
In the end, it proposed a program very close to what we actually did. I’ll skip its accommodation and restaurant suggestions...
Its proposal:
"Ubud (4 nights) => we did 5 nights Sidemen (2 nights) Amed (3 nights) => we’d planned 2 nights Gili Meno (3 nights) => we did Gili between Sidemen and Amed Munduk (3 nights) => we did 2 nights before Pemuteran Pemuteran (3 nights) with Ijen => we did 4 nights Sanur (2 nights + 1 last night) => we chose Jatiluwih instead of Sanur
It suggested "activities" (and accommodations too):
IN UBUD: - Walk around central Ubud (1–2h) - Campuhan Ridge Walk - Tegalalang Rice Terrace - Tirta Empul - Gunung Kawi - Massage / market / slow café
IN SIDEMEN: - Rice terrace hike (2–3h) - Cooking class
IN AMED: - Snorkeling - Japanese Shipwreck - Beach + relaxation - Volcano sunset
ON GILI: - Snorkeling at Gili Meno Turtle Point, Nest Underwater Statues
IN MUNDUK: - Jungle & waterfall hike - Munduk Waterfall + Melanting Waterfall - Loop: 3–4h (perfect for your level) - Ulun Danu Bratan Temple - Twin Lakes
IN PEMUTERAN - Snorkeling: Menjangan Island
For Kawah Ijen, it detailed the day well: 👍 from Pemuteran = best possible option 12 PM: leave hotel (we left at 10 PM) 1 PM: ferry 3 PM: arrival in Java + transfer 11 PM: start ascent 2 AM–6 AM: volcano Return to Bali around 11 AM–12 PM (we got back at 4 PM) 👍 still very intense, but doable with an agency 💰 ~80–120 €/person all-inclusive
IN SANUR: - Relaxation - Quiet beach - Proximity to airport (30 min)"
BUDGET: "3,000 – 3,900 € for 2 people" (We paid 3,200 €)
In conclusion, it’s not (yet) enough, but it’s (already) pretty impressive!
Hello everyone,
I’m sharing the menu posted at the entrance of a bar at the foot of the Porto Tower in Southern Corsica. . .
.
.
Greetings and have a great Sunday.
Puma2A . .

...
I’m sharing the menu posted at the entrance of a bar at the foot of the Porto Tower in Southern Corsica. . .
.
.Greetings and have a great Sunday.
Puma2A . .

...
I’ve kept the habit of blowing my nose in the sink and then washing my hands—a custom I picked up in India. Sometimes, non-travelers are shocked when they catch me in the act... 🤪
Also, when I run out of toilet paper, it doesn’t bother me—unless I’ve got company over... 🤪
Just got back from walking a friend’s dog (while they’re on vacation), wearing a djellaba and Tibetan boots... 😏😏😏 Oh, for sure, if I’d run into locals, I probably would’ve shocked them? 😏
Anyway, as long as I’m not spitting on the floor at a restaurant or squatting on the side of a highway with a water bottle in hand...
Do you bring back customs from your travels?
Also, when I run out of toilet paper, it doesn’t bother me—unless I’ve got company over... 🤪
Just got back from walking a friend’s dog (while they’re on vacation), wearing a djellaba and Tibetan boots... 😏😏😏 Oh, for sure, if I’d run into locals, I probably would’ve shocked them? 😏
Anyway, as long as I’m not spitting on the floor at a restaurant or squatting on the side of a highway with a water bottle in hand...
Do you bring back customs from your travels?
After taking a little trip around the world, I came back a few months ago with an idea in mind.
I mostly do diving, and I love observing animals in their natural habitat without disturbing them.
During the trip, I realized it was quite complicated to know where and when to see certain species.
For example:
where to dive with sharks or manta rays where you might get a chance to swim with whales
I even discovered thresher sharks during my trip… I didn’t even know this species existed before, even though they’re incredible to see.
We spent a ton of time searching for info all over the place, especially on social media, without ever getting a clear picture.
So I started putting all this together on my own, in the form of a map, to make it easier to visualize where to go depending on the seasons.
I recently put a first version online (it’s called Fauneya). There are probably mistakes, inconsistencies, or things to improve, and that’s partly why I’m posting here.
I’d really love to know how you all go about planning this kind of trip.
I mostly do diving, and I love observing animals in their natural habitat without disturbing them.
During the trip, I realized it was quite complicated to know where and when to see certain species.
For example:
where to dive with sharks or manta rays where you might get a chance to swim with whales
I even discovered thresher sharks during my trip… I didn’t even know this species existed before, even though they’re incredible to see.
We spent a ton of time searching for info all over the place, especially on social media, without ever getting a clear picture.
So I started putting all this together on my own, in the form of a map, to make it easier to visualize where to go depending on the seasons.
I recently put a first version online (it’s called Fauneya). There are probably mistakes, inconsistencies, or things to improve, and that’s partly why I’m posting here.
I’d really love to know how you all go about planning this kind of trip.
As part of my Master’s thesis, I’m currently conducting a public survey on a topic that concerns all of us when planning a trip: artificial intelligence and the role of human contact in travel planning.
These days, we’re using more and more digital tools to find ideas, compare options, and book trips... but is the role of human advisors still essential? At what moments? And for what types of trips?
The survey is anonymous and takes about 7 minutes.
It’s aimed at anyone who travels (or has traveled) for leisure, whether you plan everything yourself or go through an agency.
Survey link: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdkmBzW2QOE3_ZirhmdG8e2LQyaWLJxWUeyTR0LzpC8ytlufQ/viewform
Your response will be a huge help for my work and will contribute to a broader reflection on the future of the travel experience.
Thanks in advance to everyone who takes the time to participate!!
These days, we’re using more and more digital tools to find ideas, compare options, and book trips... but is the role of human advisors still essential? At what moments? And for what types of trips?
The survey is anonymous and takes about 7 minutes.
It’s aimed at anyone who travels (or has traveled) for leisure, whether you plan everything yourself or go through an agency.
Survey link: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdkmBzW2QOE3_ZirhmdG8e2LQyaWLJxWUeyTR0LzpC8ytlufQ/viewform
Your response will be a huge help for my work and will contribute to a broader reflection on the future of the travel experience.
Thanks in advance to everyone who takes the time to participate!!
While browsing the forum to gather info for my upcoming trip to Thailand, I often see the terms "traveler," "great traveler," and also "tourist"—so what’s the nuance for you?
I've traveled quite a bit in Vietnam over the past few years—from the southern delta to bustling cities and even some small islands—but what really sticks with me is the north, the high mountains.
Up there, there's something different—maybe slower, more raw. The morning markets with ethnic groups, women in traditional clothes, the colors...
The stilt houses, kids following you and laughing for no reason, the terraced rice fields—it almost feels unreal at times, so vast and quiet, yet so human and simple.
You often hear that Sapa has become too touristy, and that's partly true, especially in the center. But as soon as you move a little farther away, everything changes quickly. The landscapes open up, encounters feel more natural, and you rediscover something truly authentic.
I think it's that contrast that struck me—the difference between what you imagine before going and what you actually discover when you take the time.
And you—what memory do you hold onto from Vietnam? A particular place that touched you more than others?
Hello,
We’re finalizing the plans for our upcoming trip to China in May 2025. The second-to-last stop will be in Zhangjiajie, where we’ve planned to stay for 2 full days before heading to Shanghai.
We’re traveling solo using local transport and have arranged to stay in the city of Zhangjiajie.
We’ve seen that there’s a lot to see: Tianmen Mountain, the Grand Canyon and the glass bridge, Zhangjiajie National Park, and that the sites are quite far apart with fairly expensive entry fees. We’re thinking of dedicating one day to the national park and the Grand Canyon (glass bridge) and one day to Tianmen Mountain. But we’re not sure if this plan is realistic—any thoughts would be much appreciated!
Do you know if it’s possible to get around on our own, or is it better to go through a local agency or book a package like the one sold by TravelChinaGuide? https://www.travelchinaguide.com/package/zhangjiajie/2days-tour.htm
Thanks in advance for your advice! Alod
We’ve seen that there’s a lot to see: Tianmen Mountain, the Grand Canyon and the glass bridge, Zhangjiajie National Park, and that the sites are quite far apart with fairly expensive entry fees. We’re thinking of dedicating one day to the national park and the Grand Canyon (glass bridge) and one day to Tianmen Mountain. But we’re not sure if this plan is realistic—any thoughts would be much appreciated!
Do you know if it’s possible to get around on our own, or is it better to go through a local agency or book a package like the one sold by TravelChinaGuide? https://www.travelchinaguide.com/package/zhangjiajie/2days-tour.htm
Thanks in advance for your advice! Alod
Hello 🙂
I should be serving a warming drink to the participants in the discussion about gardens and parks that provide us with beautiful photos, I could mention the delicious buttery scent wafting from bakeries in the thread about returning to France, but my heart, its powerful pulse that nourishes my entire being, is elsewhere.
Dasht-e Lut, Yazd, Esfahan, Bam, Kerman, Qeshm, Hormuz—a melody, a prayer at the heart of desire.
A dream, an unattainable fantasy? No. Not anymore. A very serious Italian travel agency is organizing this trip for 6 people this winter. I’m signed up, I’m going, I’m living. Maybe.
"But you’re completely crazy!!!!"
I know... I know that every civilization, every society has a vital need to create scapegoats to define and justify itself, pathetically. And Iran is one of them, top of the list. I laugh or sigh, and it doesn’t bother me.
But that unchanging red, deep red and garnet, so beautiful in itself, in all the Western chancelleries repeats, whispers, shouts: don’t go, don’t go, don’t go, you’re putting yourself in danger and we can’t do anything for you. You’ll be turned into mere bargaining chips, into arguments for endless negotiations. Fear must be instilled, its power absolutely preserved, no concessions made to the enemy. The information (how many French hostages, real or fake, compared to the number of travelers?) is always lacking.
Traveling becomes a merciless confrontation between desire, the vital pulse, and anxiety, its ghosts.
Catherine
I should be serving a warming drink to the participants in the discussion about gardens and parks that provide us with beautiful photos, I could mention the delicious buttery scent wafting from bakeries in the thread about returning to France, but my heart, its powerful pulse that nourishes my entire being, is elsewhere.
Dasht-e Lut, Yazd, Esfahan, Bam, Kerman, Qeshm, Hormuz—a melody, a prayer at the heart of desire.
A dream, an unattainable fantasy? No. Not anymore. A very serious Italian travel agency is organizing this trip for 6 people this winter. I’m signed up, I’m going, I’m living. Maybe.
"But you’re completely crazy!!!!"
I know... I know that every civilization, every society has a vital need to create scapegoats to define and justify itself, pathetically. And Iran is one of them, top of the list. I laugh or sigh, and it doesn’t bother me.
But that unchanging red, deep red and garnet, so beautiful in itself, in all the Western chancelleries repeats, whispers, shouts: don’t go, don’t go, don’t go, you’re putting yourself in danger and we can’t do anything for you. You’ll be turned into mere bargaining chips, into arguments for endless negotiations. Fear must be instilled, its power absolutely preserved, no concessions made to the enemy. The information (how many French hostages, real or fake, compared to the number of travelers?) is always lacking.
Traveling becomes a merciless confrontation between desire, the vital pulse, and anxiety, its ghosts.
Catherine
Hi everyone, here’s our itinerary. Arriving on the evening of December 13th. Departing on January 7th.
Thanks in advance for your tips and valuable feedback.
Manila – 1 night Coron – 4 nights Coron to El Nido cruise – 2 nights El Nido – 4 nights Port Barton – 5 nights Flight from Puerto Princesa to Vigan Vigan – 2 nights Sagada – 2 nights Banaue – 2 nights Bagabag – 1 night Manila – 1 night I’ve only booked the flight to Manila and the Manila/Coron flight so far. Is it possible to book boat trips, accommodations, and the Puerto Princesa flight last-minute?
Thanks in advance. Florence
Manila – 1 night Coron – 4 nights Coron to El Nido cruise – 2 nights El Nido – 4 nights Port Barton – 5 nights Flight from Puerto Princesa to Vigan Vigan – 2 nights Sagada – 2 nights Banaue – 2 nights Bagabag – 1 night Manila – 1 night I’ve only booked the flight to Manila and the Manila/Coron flight so far. Is it possible to book boat trips, accommodations, and the Puerto Princesa flight last-minute?
Thanks in advance. Florence
Really disappointed with Costa Rica! Pura vida? The scam of the century!
(Costa Rica pure emptiness).
The country where animals are free and people are in cages. 3 weeks in December in this country and never again. Imagine the trailer of a movie that seems interesting, and when you go see it, you realize it’s a flop and the best moments were in the trailer. Well, that’s exactly how we felt with Costa Rica pure emptiness. My wife and I have traveled quite a bit and didn’t expect to be so wrong about a place. On the main routes, we visited: San José Alajuela Limón, Cahuita, Puerto Viejo, Manzanillo (Caribbean side) Jaco, Quepos, Manuel Antonio (Pacific side) And a few short stops in intermediate towns.
Our dissatisfaction grew gradually like this:
When we arrived at the hotel, the taxi dropped us off on a small street in front of a white metal gate with ground-floor windows barred. We looked at it skeptically, but the sign matched. He approached the gate, rang the bell, the buzzer sounded, and the door opened slightly. The hotel wasn’t bad for the price, a 10-minute walk from downtown, but with a "Fleury-Mérogis" vibe guaranteed.
So far, so good.
After showering and regaining our bearings, we headed downtown. What started to unsettle us on the way was seeing houses with bars on the ground-floor windows and even on the second floor. At first, we thought the hotel’s neighborhood wasn’t great.
Downtown San José: It’s a generic city, not very exotic, with a pedestrian street and a small mercado where you can eat local food without frills. Very few tourists—if any—which let you blend in with the locals. We had lunch and struggled to make ourselves understood because, aside from one or two shops, English wasn’t spoken. On the way back to the hotel, we took a different route, and while chatting and strolling, my wife pointed out a beautiful two-story white house completely barricaded like Fort Knox. From that moment, we started noticing the facades of houses and buildings, and wow, it was creepy—most looked like prisons, some even with barbed wire. Though put off, we told ourselves it was probably a big-city thing and the rest of the country couldn’t be like this.
So far, so good.
We relaxed at the hotel and had a drink at the bar. Night falls early, around 5:30 PM. By 7:30 PM, we headed back downtown for dinner. A bit unsettling for a capital—downtown was almost deserted, and aside from fast-food chains, very few restaurants were open, with hardly anyone on the streets. Bars with security guards out front. I won’t say we felt unsafe that night, but once it got dark, we realized the bars on the windows weren’t for nothing. First day in, and our impression was already mixed.
The next day, we explored the city and surroundings, and our feelings didn’t change.
So far, so good.
Off to Cahuita by bus—4 hours of travel. The landscapes are very green but quickly become monotonous. The road runs alongside the forest and passes through a few towns and villages, and even in the countryside, there were just as many prison-like houses. The bus dropped us off at Cahuita’s terminal station—only four of us got off. It’s a village, or rather, a small town. Cahuita is basically one straight road and a perpendicular one, and honestly, doubt started to creep in. A few restaurants that add 13% tax and 10% service charge—so 23% extra. We dropped our stuff at the hotel and went to explore. In 20 minutes, we’d seen it all. We had lunch and planned to check out the famous park. Entry is by donation—well, the "entry" is a joke. There’s a path along the forest by the sea, and that’s it.
Nothing’s going right anymore.
We thought it was a total scam, but since we hadn’t gone far, we decided to come back the next day to explore further. We returned to the hotel, relaxed, and around 8:00 PM, we went out for dinner. Only two restaurants were open, and the streets were deserted.
Creepy!
The next day, we explored the so-called park more thoroughly and really got it. A path along the forest by the sea—2 hours there and 2 hours back, where you see animals that feel like showing their faces. A total joke—"all that for this?"
The beach was full of wood debris and coconut husks. We wondered if the photos online were edited because the sea, very rough, wasn’t the azure blue we’d seen in pictures. But calling this a park is a joke—it’s like a new concept.
When we thought about the reviews online, we started to suspect that professionals with interests in the country were monitoring and countering any negative feedback that could harm their business. Too bad we didn’t check the negative reviews beforehand—we did while we were there, and it helped. We wondered if we’d become too demanding after all our travels, but no—when something’s bad, it’s bad.
Manuel Antonio’s park is even more ridiculous—there’s a short path along the sea for about 500 meters, and then nothing. You have to climb through mud and hack your way through the forest. We ended up barefoot because the mud was up to our calves. All that to see a raccoon and a few parrots flying overhead.
We didn’t expect Noah’s Ark, but we’ve seen more animals in Bali, Mexico, and Thailand while visiting temples or just walking around than in these so-called parks!
Puerto Viejo, not far from Cahuita and supposedly livelier—well, it couldn’t be worse! According to Lonely Planet, it had a Caribbean vibe and wild nights, but maybe that was a long time ago. The good reggae music playing everywhere isn’t enough.
In the evening, Puerto Viejo was a bit livelier than Cahuita, but that’s not saying much. Very few tourists—if any—no night market, just two or three shops open selling $20 T-shirts. Same vibe as San José.
No big deal—we enjoyed the beach and the sun, which was reliable. Our itinerary was supposed to include Tortuguero Park, but after talking to other travelers who’d just been, we changed our minds, knowing we’d be visiting Manuel Antonio Park on the Pacific side.
To get back to the Pacific side, you have to take the bus and go through San José again—5 hours this time—then switch bus terminals and another 4.5 hours to Quepos. A stopover town to get to Manuel Antonio’s beach and park! A town just like the others we’d seen—deserted as soon as the sun sets, and not exactly bustling during the day either. (Where are all the tourists?)
Still as many bars on the windows and that feeling of being in the wrong place.
7 km later: Manuel Antonio beach and park. The beach is very beautiful and quite large, but don’t expect turquoise blue water—the waves stir up the sand, giving the water a brownish color. Along the beach, shops and restaurants for about 300 meters, and then nothing. At night, after sunset, the town shuts down too.
Manuel Antonio Park is highly praised for its wildlife, so we were eager to see it. When you express dissatisfaction with Cahuita or Manzanillo parks, the response is always, "But you should’ve gone to Monteverde or Manuel Antonio!" No matter what you do or say, they’ll tell you, "You should’ve gone there or here."
Back to our famous park—entry was about $16, and contrary to what we’d heard, it wasn’t crowded! Guides at the entrance with spotting scopes offered their services for about $30. The park: a mix of boardwalk and dirt paths through the forest, sometimes running alongside beautiful coves and beaches. As soon as we entered, a crowd was taking photos of a deer eating leaves. A little further on, a guide with a group of five stopped. The guide raised his arm and set up his spotting scope! He showed them, about 100 meters away, a hummingbird perched on a branch. Some, looking through the scope, exclaimed, "Oh my God! Amazing! Incredible!" For a moment, we thought they’d discovered a unicorn or were in Jurassic Park and had just crossed paths with a T-Rex! The concept is comical—looking at a bird or another animal through a spotting scope because it’s too far away. Isn’t that what TV is for? For our part, we saw monkeys, ants, an armadillo, an iguana, and the backside of a sloth climbing a tree. Amazing, incredible!
We stayed a few days in Manuel Antonio to enjoy the beach, changing hotels often because prices varied wildly from one day to the next for shameful services. On top of that, they’d quote a price in dollars and convert it at their discretion—thieves!
Alajuela, a city near the airport, has a two-story mall and a local market downtown! No interest except its proximity to the airport.
What we liked:
The climate and, in hindsight, San José—the most authentic city we visited.
What we didn’t like, in addition to what we’ve already mentioned:
Costa Ricans aren’t very friendly or communicative. English is barely spoken, not even by doctors at Quepos Hospital, where my wife ended up with food poisoning (thanks, Google Translate). The widespread obesity among Costa Ricans, who eat like Americans. The insecurity. The eco-hipsters who leave their $150 lodges in minivans with guides to visit parks and other sites, then return to barricade themselves in their fortresses at nightfall (oh my God, amazing, incredible). The blue signs at the entrance of towns that accept this payment method: "We accept American Express." Parking lots that become paid just because a guy is watching your car. Prices displayed in dollars. The cost of living (hotels, restaurants, taxes). Landscapes that are too green and not flowery enough. Beaches—nothing exceptional. Pollution in cities where big American trucks rule. Sewage dumped directly into the sea. Aside from the jungle, there’s nothing to visit—no ruins, monuments, or anything worth seeing.
In short, my wife and I think the hype about this supposedly eco-friendly country is overrated. It’s just the trendy destination of the moment. There are much better, cheaper, and more authentic places. In hindsight, we keep the good memories and our beautiful photos, but if we had to do it over...
Before signing off, a little message to those who don’t like hearing opinions different from theirs: Well, some things aren’t up for debate. And to those who’d have us believe that in 3 weeks, we don’t have the right to criticize a country or express our feelings—how can you praise it in so little time? What a scam. Costa Rica is a money pit. Pura vida? Pure cosmic emptiness.
If you like spending your evenings barricaded in your cozy hotel after dark, this country is for you. For everyone else: run!
The country where animals are free and people are in cages. 3 weeks in December in this country and never again. Imagine the trailer of a movie that seems interesting, and when you go see it, you realize it’s a flop and the best moments were in the trailer. Well, that’s exactly how we felt with Costa Rica pure emptiness. My wife and I have traveled quite a bit and didn’t expect to be so wrong about a place. On the main routes, we visited: San José Alajuela Limón, Cahuita, Puerto Viejo, Manzanillo (Caribbean side) Jaco, Quepos, Manuel Antonio (Pacific side) And a few short stops in intermediate towns.
Our dissatisfaction grew gradually like this:
When we arrived at the hotel, the taxi dropped us off on a small street in front of a white metal gate with ground-floor windows barred. We looked at it skeptically, but the sign matched. He approached the gate, rang the bell, the buzzer sounded, and the door opened slightly. The hotel wasn’t bad for the price, a 10-minute walk from downtown, but with a "Fleury-Mérogis" vibe guaranteed.
So far, so good.
After showering and regaining our bearings, we headed downtown. What started to unsettle us on the way was seeing houses with bars on the ground-floor windows and even on the second floor. At first, we thought the hotel’s neighborhood wasn’t great.
Downtown San José: It’s a generic city, not very exotic, with a pedestrian street and a small mercado where you can eat local food without frills. Very few tourists—if any—which let you blend in with the locals. We had lunch and struggled to make ourselves understood because, aside from one or two shops, English wasn’t spoken. On the way back to the hotel, we took a different route, and while chatting and strolling, my wife pointed out a beautiful two-story white house completely barricaded like Fort Knox. From that moment, we started noticing the facades of houses and buildings, and wow, it was creepy—most looked like prisons, some even with barbed wire. Though put off, we told ourselves it was probably a big-city thing and the rest of the country couldn’t be like this.
So far, so good.
We relaxed at the hotel and had a drink at the bar. Night falls early, around 5:30 PM. By 7:30 PM, we headed back downtown for dinner. A bit unsettling for a capital—downtown was almost deserted, and aside from fast-food chains, very few restaurants were open, with hardly anyone on the streets. Bars with security guards out front. I won’t say we felt unsafe that night, but once it got dark, we realized the bars on the windows weren’t for nothing. First day in, and our impression was already mixed.
The next day, we explored the city and surroundings, and our feelings didn’t change.
So far, so good.
Off to Cahuita by bus—4 hours of travel. The landscapes are very green but quickly become monotonous. The road runs alongside the forest and passes through a few towns and villages, and even in the countryside, there were just as many prison-like houses. The bus dropped us off at Cahuita’s terminal station—only four of us got off. It’s a village, or rather, a small town. Cahuita is basically one straight road and a perpendicular one, and honestly, doubt started to creep in. A few restaurants that add 13% tax and 10% service charge—so 23% extra. We dropped our stuff at the hotel and went to explore. In 20 minutes, we’d seen it all. We had lunch and planned to check out the famous park. Entry is by donation—well, the "entry" is a joke. There’s a path along the forest by the sea, and that’s it.
Nothing’s going right anymore.
We thought it was a total scam, but since we hadn’t gone far, we decided to come back the next day to explore further. We returned to the hotel, relaxed, and around 8:00 PM, we went out for dinner. Only two restaurants were open, and the streets were deserted.
Creepy!
The next day, we explored the so-called park more thoroughly and really got it. A path along the forest by the sea—2 hours there and 2 hours back, where you see animals that feel like showing their faces. A total joke—"all that for this?"
The beach was full of wood debris and coconut husks. We wondered if the photos online were edited because the sea, very rough, wasn’t the azure blue we’d seen in pictures. But calling this a park is a joke—it’s like a new concept.
When we thought about the reviews online, we started to suspect that professionals with interests in the country were monitoring and countering any negative feedback that could harm their business. Too bad we didn’t check the negative reviews beforehand—we did while we were there, and it helped. We wondered if we’d become too demanding after all our travels, but no—when something’s bad, it’s bad.
Manuel Antonio’s park is even more ridiculous—there’s a short path along the sea for about 500 meters, and then nothing. You have to climb through mud and hack your way through the forest. We ended up barefoot because the mud was up to our calves. All that to see a raccoon and a few parrots flying overhead.
We didn’t expect Noah’s Ark, but we’ve seen more animals in Bali, Mexico, and Thailand while visiting temples or just walking around than in these so-called parks!
Puerto Viejo, not far from Cahuita and supposedly livelier—well, it couldn’t be worse! According to Lonely Planet, it had a Caribbean vibe and wild nights, but maybe that was a long time ago. The good reggae music playing everywhere isn’t enough.
In the evening, Puerto Viejo was a bit livelier than Cahuita, but that’s not saying much. Very few tourists—if any—no night market, just two or three shops open selling $20 T-shirts. Same vibe as San José.
No big deal—we enjoyed the beach and the sun, which was reliable. Our itinerary was supposed to include Tortuguero Park, but after talking to other travelers who’d just been, we changed our minds, knowing we’d be visiting Manuel Antonio Park on the Pacific side.
To get back to the Pacific side, you have to take the bus and go through San José again—5 hours this time—then switch bus terminals and another 4.5 hours to Quepos. A stopover town to get to Manuel Antonio’s beach and park! A town just like the others we’d seen—deserted as soon as the sun sets, and not exactly bustling during the day either. (Where are all the tourists?)
Still as many bars on the windows and that feeling of being in the wrong place.
7 km later: Manuel Antonio beach and park. The beach is very beautiful and quite large, but don’t expect turquoise blue water—the waves stir up the sand, giving the water a brownish color. Along the beach, shops and restaurants for about 300 meters, and then nothing. At night, after sunset, the town shuts down too.
Manuel Antonio Park is highly praised for its wildlife, so we were eager to see it. When you express dissatisfaction with Cahuita or Manzanillo parks, the response is always, "But you should’ve gone to Monteverde or Manuel Antonio!" No matter what you do or say, they’ll tell you, "You should’ve gone there or here."
Back to our famous park—entry was about $16, and contrary to what we’d heard, it wasn’t crowded! Guides at the entrance with spotting scopes offered their services for about $30. The park: a mix of boardwalk and dirt paths through the forest, sometimes running alongside beautiful coves and beaches. As soon as we entered, a crowd was taking photos of a deer eating leaves. A little further on, a guide with a group of five stopped. The guide raised his arm and set up his spotting scope! He showed them, about 100 meters away, a hummingbird perched on a branch. Some, looking through the scope, exclaimed, "Oh my God! Amazing! Incredible!" For a moment, we thought they’d discovered a unicorn or were in Jurassic Park and had just crossed paths with a T-Rex! The concept is comical—looking at a bird or another animal through a spotting scope because it’s too far away. Isn’t that what TV is for? For our part, we saw monkeys, ants, an armadillo, an iguana, and the backside of a sloth climbing a tree. Amazing, incredible!
We stayed a few days in Manuel Antonio to enjoy the beach, changing hotels often because prices varied wildly from one day to the next for shameful services. On top of that, they’d quote a price in dollars and convert it at their discretion—thieves!
Alajuela, a city near the airport, has a two-story mall and a local market downtown! No interest except its proximity to the airport.
What we liked:
The climate and, in hindsight, San José—the most authentic city we visited.
What we didn’t like, in addition to what we’ve already mentioned:
Costa Ricans aren’t very friendly or communicative. English is barely spoken, not even by doctors at Quepos Hospital, where my wife ended up with food poisoning (thanks, Google Translate). The widespread obesity among Costa Ricans, who eat like Americans. The insecurity. The eco-hipsters who leave their $150 lodges in minivans with guides to visit parks and other sites, then return to barricade themselves in their fortresses at nightfall (oh my God, amazing, incredible). The blue signs at the entrance of towns that accept this payment method: "We accept American Express." Parking lots that become paid just because a guy is watching your car. Prices displayed in dollars. The cost of living (hotels, restaurants, taxes). Landscapes that are too green and not flowery enough. Beaches—nothing exceptional. Pollution in cities where big American trucks rule. Sewage dumped directly into the sea. Aside from the jungle, there’s nothing to visit—no ruins, monuments, or anything worth seeing.
In short, my wife and I think the hype about this supposedly eco-friendly country is overrated. It’s just the trendy destination of the moment. There are much better, cheaper, and more authentic places. In hindsight, we keep the good memories and our beautiful photos, but if we had to do it over...
Before signing off, a little message to those who don’t like hearing opinions different from theirs: Well, some things aren’t up for debate. And to those who’d have us believe that in 3 weeks, we don’t have the right to criticize a country or express our feelings—how can you praise it in so little time? What a scam. Costa Rica is a money pit. Pura vida? Pure cosmic emptiness.
If you like spending your evenings barricaded in your cozy hotel after dark, this country is for you. For everyone else: run!
Hello,
Since the war between Russia and Ukraine, nothing is simple anymore for traveling to Belarus due to sanctions.
No more direct flights from the EU to Minsk.
Driving is a huge hassle, especially crossing through Poland at the only open border in Brest—you can wait 2, 3, or even 4 days just to get through by car.
The least painful driving option is to come via Lithuania and cross at the only open border, with a minimum wait time of 8 hours, sometimes up to 20 hours or more!!
Controls are very strict and annoying on both the Lithuanian and Belarusian sides. Avoid bringing alcohol, food, or cigarettes—everything will end up in the trash, especially when leaving Belarus for Vilnius, where the Lithuanians are tough, even with EU citizens.
The joy I once knew when visiting my wife in Minsk is sadly over—it’s now a real ordeal.
The fastest solution is to fly. My wife travels to France by taking a bus to Kaunas in Lithuania, where you can catch a flight (though not daily) to Paris Beauvais or Charleroi in Belgium with Ryanair, for example. For the return trip, it’s the same: a flight to Kaunas and then a direct bus from the airport to Minsk. The bus crossing is quicker than driving—the 250 km journey, including border checks, takes about 6 to 8 hours for buses leaving Lithuania around midnight, but controls are still strict at the border. The biggest challenge is finding flight schedules that align with the bus routes between the two countries, given the unpredictable border crossing times. Now, my wife travels via Charleroi in Belgium (near Brussels), and you can take a train to Paris. Alternatively, you can fly into Beauvais and take a bus to Paris (Porte Maillot). For those driving, note that EU insurance and assistance policies no longer work in Belarus or Russia. You’ll need to get local insurance, usually limited to third-party liability (I don’t think full coverage exists?), as well as mandatory medical insurance. This is available at the border. You now have to pay highway tolls—no more BELTOLL boxes. Instead, you pay a flat fee for the duration of your stay. Stop at the first gas station after crossing from Lithuania to fill up on fuel and cigarettes. From what I know, Lithuania bans carrying more than 60 € in cash, but there’s no limit for USD (though it’s capped at $10,000??). With a Visa card, you can now withdraw 1,000 rubles per week (about 270 €)—two months ago, it was only 500 rubles!! For now, you can still pay by card in shops and gas stations. However, major retailers like KORONA (which may be Russian-owned??) no longer accept foreign Visa cards. Unfortunately, the additional sanctions announced by the U.S. on August 5, 2025, against Russia—and possibly Belarus—aren’t promising for the future. After 20 years of visiting Belarus, I’m truly saddened to see the joy of living in this country with my wonderful wife turn into such a bleak situation, all because of human folly.
The fastest solution is to fly. My wife travels to France by taking a bus to Kaunas in Lithuania, where you can catch a flight (though not daily) to Paris Beauvais or Charleroi in Belgium with Ryanair, for example. For the return trip, it’s the same: a flight to Kaunas and then a direct bus from the airport to Minsk. The bus crossing is quicker than driving—the 250 km journey, including border checks, takes about 6 to 8 hours for buses leaving Lithuania around midnight, but controls are still strict at the border. The biggest challenge is finding flight schedules that align with the bus routes between the two countries, given the unpredictable border crossing times. Now, my wife travels via Charleroi in Belgium (near Brussels), and you can take a train to Paris. Alternatively, you can fly into Beauvais and take a bus to Paris (Porte Maillot). For those driving, note that EU insurance and assistance policies no longer work in Belarus or Russia. You’ll need to get local insurance, usually limited to third-party liability (I don’t think full coverage exists?), as well as mandatory medical insurance. This is available at the border. You now have to pay highway tolls—no more BELTOLL boxes. Instead, you pay a flat fee for the duration of your stay. Stop at the first gas station after crossing from Lithuania to fill up on fuel and cigarettes. From what I know, Lithuania bans carrying more than 60 € in cash, but there’s no limit for USD (though it’s capped at $10,000??). With a Visa card, you can now withdraw 1,000 rubles per week (about 270 €)—two months ago, it was only 500 rubles!! For now, you can still pay by card in shops and gas stations. However, major retailers like KORONA (which may be Russian-owned??) no longer accept foreign Visa cards. Unfortunately, the additional sanctions announced by the U.S. on August 5, 2025, against Russia—and possibly Belarus—aren’t promising for the future. After 20 years of visiting Belarus, I’m truly saddened to see the joy of living in this country with my wonderful wife turn into such a bleak situation, all because of human folly.
Hi everyone!
I’m putting together our travel itinerary for Veneto at the end of April. And the more I look and research potential sites to visit, the more I find!
We’ll only be there for a week—my family and I—including 3 days in Venice. So we have to make some choices...
I plan to rent a car when we arrive in Venice and head straight to Bergamo, which would be our first stop. We’d leave the car at the airport when we return to Venice so we can explore the city at our leisure.
What do you think: 1 night in Bergamo (a 2h15 drive from Venice airport), 1 night in Garda, 1 night in Verona, 1 in Padua, and 3 in Venice—would that be doable?
Thanks in advance for your tips and experiences! :)
What do you think: 1 night in Bergamo (a 2h15 drive from Venice airport), 1 night in Garda, 1 night in Verona, 1 in Padua, and 3 in Venice—would that be doable?
Thanks in advance for your tips and experiences! :)
Now that the curtain has fallen on the past year, it’s time to see what’s happening around here.
It seems pretty quiet, but I’ll read more in detail later.
First, I need to tell you all an anecdote.
My eldest little girl, in her third year of law school, was really scared she wouldn’t pass the year. I told her: “Trust yourself, you’ve worked so hard, and worst case, if you fail, you’ll just redo the year.” “But I don’t think I’ll make it—they changed the rules, and if I mess up even one unit, I have to start all over.” I knew her grades weren’t exactly stellar, and with what I was about to say, I wasn’t taking much of a risk. “Here’s the deal, sweetheart: if you pass, I promise I’ll take you to India, just the two of us.” I have to admit, India is a country I’ve talked about so much to all my grandchildren that in their minds, it’s become a magical, mythical place (hmm).
July had barely begun when my phone rang, her name flashing on the screen. “Mamido, I did it!” My promise came rushing back—oh no, oh no, oh no! “Congratulations, sweetheart!” A little shyly, she said: “Is the India trip still on?”
And me, replying: “Of course it is!”
And that’s that—a promise is a promise, or you risk losing that precious trust that keeps hearts warm and at peace.
We’re leaving in February. Only 8 days—yikes, the carbon footprint! But we can’t miss her tutorials, or she’ll be kicked out. Personally, that works just fine for me.
Going to India has become a challenge for me. It’s far, it’s exhausting, I sweat, I hate mosquitoes, the spices bother my mouth when I used to love them. There’s noise all the time—at night, the dogs bark nonstop, and we almost get run over. I’ll get lost in the streets because my sense of direction has vanished. I don’t like rice anymore. All that chaos and those cultural differences that once enchanted me now just overwhelm me. But I promised.
The upside—and it’s a big one—Raman, the same driver I’ve had forever, will be at the airport with a sign with our names. We’ll stop at the same little shop for chai (or tea, plain and simple) with that aroma that intoxicates me, halfway through the trip.
It’ll be a tiny trip—staying with friends, I’ll show her a few places I love: Chidambaram, Mamallapuram, and the clinic where I worked. Then we’ll head back. My little girl will go home to her parents.
As for me, I’ll leave right away for our Scottish island with Homme for our chilly winter.
How can you love a country so much you want to live there, then suddenly reject it, no longer able to appreciate what once made it special? That’s the mystery of love, I guess.
First, I need to tell you all an anecdote.
My eldest little girl, in her third year of law school, was really scared she wouldn’t pass the year. I told her: “Trust yourself, you’ve worked so hard, and worst case, if you fail, you’ll just redo the year.” “But I don’t think I’ll make it—they changed the rules, and if I mess up even one unit, I have to start all over.” I knew her grades weren’t exactly stellar, and with what I was about to say, I wasn’t taking much of a risk. “Here’s the deal, sweetheart: if you pass, I promise I’ll take you to India, just the two of us.” I have to admit, India is a country I’ve talked about so much to all my grandchildren that in their minds, it’s become a magical, mythical place (hmm).
July had barely begun when my phone rang, her name flashing on the screen. “Mamido, I did it!” My promise came rushing back—oh no, oh no, oh no! “Congratulations, sweetheart!” A little shyly, she said: “Is the India trip still on?”
And me, replying: “Of course it is!”
And that’s that—a promise is a promise, or you risk losing that precious trust that keeps hearts warm and at peace.
We’re leaving in February. Only 8 days—yikes, the carbon footprint! But we can’t miss her tutorials, or she’ll be kicked out. Personally, that works just fine for me.
Going to India has become a challenge for me. It’s far, it’s exhausting, I sweat, I hate mosquitoes, the spices bother my mouth when I used to love them. There’s noise all the time—at night, the dogs bark nonstop, and we almost get run over. I’ll get lost in the streets because my sense of direction has vanished. I don’t like rice anymore. All that chaos and those cultural differences that once enchanted me now just overwhelm me. But I promised.
The upside—and it’s a big one—Raman, the same driver I’ve had forever, will be at the airport with a sign with our names. We’ll stop at the same little shop for chai (or tea, plain and simple) with that aroma that intoxicates me, halfway through the trip.
It’ll be a tiny trip—staying with friends, I’ll show her a few places I love: Chidambaram, Mamallapuram, and the clinic where I worked. Then we’ll head back. My little girl will go home to her parents.
As for me, I’ll leave right away for our Scottish island with Homme for our chilly winter.
How can you love a country so much you want to live there, then suddenly reject it, no longer able to appreciate what once made it special? That’s the mystery of love, I guess.
I’ve visited the U.S. four times myself, including two long road trips. The last one was just this past August...
I won’t be going back. I already felt guilty last August, but recent policies have finally convinced me: the humiliation of Zelensky, authoritarian excesses, Gestapo-like methods for detaining people of foreign origin, the murder of innocent people (a mother shot dead), corruption, insane "tariffs," skyrocketing healthcare costs for Americans, the abduction of foreign figures to secure oil, the requirement to disclose social media accounts, and now... threats and blackmail to forcibly take Greenland—a region that belongs to Denmark and thus the European Union!
The reality is that simply posting this could get me denied entry to the U.S.!
In this context, I just can’t keep spending money there. I loved my trips, but there are so many other countries with stunning landscapes to explore.
So I get why you’d want to travel there. I did, and I loved it. But once a country no longer respects any of the values that made us love it, why go?
How can we even consider traveling to a country that threatens to take one of our territories by force?
I won’t be going back. I already felt guilty last August, but recent policies have finally convinced me: the humiliation of Zelensky, authoritarian excesses, Gestapo-like methods for detaining people of foreign origin, the murder of innocent people (a mother shot dead), corruption, insane "tariffs," skyrocketing healthcare costs for Americans, the abduction of foreign figures to secure oil, the requirement to disclose social media accounts, and now... threats and blackmail to forcibly take Greenland—a region that belongs to Denmark and thus the European Union!
The reality is that simply posting this could get me denied entry to the U.S.!
In this context, I just can’t keep spending money there. I loved my trips, but there are so many other countries with stunning landscapes to explore.
So I get why you’d want to travel there. I did, and I loved it. But once a country no longer respects any of the values that made us love it, why go?
How can we even consider traveling to a country that threatens to take one of our territories by force?
Hi there,
While reading some travel journals, I notice that we always reflect on the people of the countries we visit.
I’d love to hear your thoughts on which people charmed you the most during your travels?
I’m not looking for controversy, just reflections and personal feelings. Looking forward to reading your replies...
While reading some travel journals, I notice that we always reflect on the people of the countries we visit.
I’d love to hear your thoughts on which people charmed you the most during your travels?
I’m not looking for controversy, just reflections and personal feelings. Looking forward to reading your replies...
Hello everyone,
Controversial topic? Not necessarily—maybe just a reflection on a world to come.
I spent the last 15 days of August on a cruise in Greenland, from Kangerlussuaq to Tasiilaq.
I was utterly amazed by this unique world of rock and ice, the little houses in every color, a simple life that’s also complicated by isolation and climate, among other things...
I carry in my heart the kindness of the people I met, the raw and gentle majesty of the icebergs, the colors of the sky...
So, I can’t even imagine a massive presence of raw material prospectors, heavy machinery requiring roads to be built—if that’s even possible—changing their way of life... putting sled dogs out to pasture!
Do fast food and Greenland’s northern lights really mix?
I wouldn’t trade my memories for an ESTA!
All opinions are respectable, which is why this isn’t a controversy—but I’m sorry, I have a soft spot for *my* Greenland.
Best regards,
So, I can’t even imagine a massive presence of raw material prospectors, heavy machinery requiring roads to be built—if that’s even possible—changing their way of life... putting sled dogs out to pasture!
Do fast food and Greenland’s northern lights really mix?
I wouldn’t trade my memories for an ESTA!
All opinions are respectable, which is why this isn’t a controversy—but I’m sorry, I have a soft spot for *my* Greenland.
Best regards,

Hello to all East Africa lovers and nature enthusiasts in general,
While I prepare to share a recap of our latest trip/safari in Kenya soon, I’d like to wish you all a peaceful transition between 2025 and 2026.
Warm regards,
Puma2A.





...