Sumatra: Off the Beaten Path in Asia
FR

Translated into English.

Original post
MI
Here’s the thing: ever since Sumatra, I’ve become picky. I don’t want the grey-green of the North Sea anymore. I want turquoise, crystal-clear waters—so clear you can see the coral 10 meters down. You see it, right? I don’t want those "equatorial greenhouses" you visit politely in well-maintained park alleys. I want wild, humid, buzzing jungle—hostile yet captivating at the same time. I don’t want wheat that becomes flour that becomes bread that dips into soup. I want jade-green rice terraces rippling in the wind through distant valleys, where you can enjoy a nasi goreng. I want more! I want coconut trees in sight, fine sand underfoot, smiles in the streets, and the world’s largest volcanic lake with a charming little island inside. Simple, really!

Here’s the 26-day itinerary across this island:

LAKE TOBA: 4 days It’s the story of a volcanic island at the bottom of a lake at the bottom of a volcano. The lake is Toba. The island is Samosir. Time here is for pausing. Time is for savoring lobsters, swimming in calm waters, enjoying the mild climate without the tourist crowds. And when time isn’t for pausing, it’s for wandering at a leisurely pace—walking, canoeing, or scootering. You’ll discover lush jungle landscapes, Batak villages (a Christian ethnic group) with surprising architecture, small inner lakes, and breathtaking views from the summit. Tuk Tuk, the main village on Samosir, offers plenty of charming restaurants and accommodations. But you can also venture into lost villages and find a peaceful haven with locals... and never want to leave. If you want to know more and see all the photos, it’s here: Lake Toba.

BERASTAGI: 2 days We’re in the heart of Sumatra’s volcanoes. Berastagi is the starting point for climbing the smoking, sulfurous mountains nearby. The town itself isn’t interesting, but you’ll find everything you need (markets, lodging, warungs, restaurants...). For the volcanoes, the most accessible is Gunung Sibayak. No guide needed—the hike only takes a few hours (depending on where you start). All accommodations provide clear directions. The summit is only 2,095 meters high. Oh, this volcano isn’t all that impressive. But it’s really nice to feel the earth’s warmth in this lunar, ochre-yellow landscape, through the hissing fumaroles escaping the rocks. The place is stunning on a clear day, or even better if you’re lucky enough to rise above the clouds. Across from it, you’ll see the splendid view of a more turbulent neighboring volcano: Mount Sinabung and its dramas.

The jungle KETAMBE: 4 days

This is the real jungle. Not the Hollywood studio kind or the city zoo version. No: the jungle. Teeming, dense, humid, and noisy. With the help of a specialized guide, we spotted plenty of insects and birds, long-tailed macaques, "Thomas leaf monkeys," and the much-anticipated orangutan... Ketambe is less touristy than Bukit Lawang. The animals are completely wild, not "semi-tame." This part of Gunung Leuser National Park is also harder to access, but the experience remains authentic even as tourism grows. In these times of deforestation advancing like a terrestrial cancer, experiencing the jungle is a unique, moving, essential moment: it’s "For the wild beauty of the last primary forests" (Le Monde, November 13, 2013). Leech socks and a small backpack: you’re ready for a multi-day trek? Off you go for muddy slopes, liters of sweat, hot rivers, endless green... and primates! Sleeping at least one night is a memorable adventure: the sounds of the jungle in total darkness deliver their dose of sensations, chills, and lifelong memories. If you want to know more and see all the photos, it’s here: the Ketambe jungle.

PULAU WEH: 5 days It’s all here: turquoise waters, fishing villages, thrilling scuba diving, lush jungle, coconut trees, warungs, and fresh fish on abandoned beaches with seashells and crustaceans. A small island north of Sumatra (50 minutes by ferry), Pulau Weh is slowly recovering from the 2004 tsunami. For now, the place isn’t overrun by tourists. But the infrastructure is more pleasant than in the rest of Sumatra. You’ll find some charming bungalows right on the water. Rent a scooter, and you can easily find yourself alone on a paradise-like cove for a romantic sunset. For the party scene, uh... it’s pretty quiet! People come here mainly for scuba diving with its colorful corals (though some have bleached) and lively marine life. Snorkeling also reveals beautiful sights. If you’re not here to swim, there’s always lazing on the beach in a hammock, sipping while gazing at the turquoise waves. That’s great too! If you want to know more and see all the photos, it’s here: Pulau Weh.

LAKE MANINJAU: 2 days The mist yawns slowly over the waters at dawn. When it finally lifts, you discover a blue treasure at the bottom of the old volcano’s caldera. In central-west Sumatra, Lake Maninjau is home to the Minang Kabau people. Less touristy than Lake Toba, it still offers equally beautiful landscapes. By scooter, a full day is enough to circle the lake (40 km) through villages, jungle, and rice terraces: it’s very pleasant, especially the southern part where traffic is light. You’ll find bungalows by the water, mainly near the village of Maninjau (yes, same name as the lake). From the crater’s heights, you can admire the whole of Maninjau (the lake!). To get there, you can navigate the 44 hairpin turns (!) by motorized vehicle from Maninjau (the village!) or tackle the path climbing from Bayur to Puncak Lawang, where the view is... top (yes, same name as the village).

HARAU VALLEY: 3 days Magnificent rice terraces surrounded by towering cliffs and cascading waterfalls. That’s what awaits the adventurer—happy like Ulysses after a long journey to the fertile Harau Valley. It’s peaceful, off the beaten path, and rejuvenating. Few tourists here, and few accommodations. The well-known Abdi Homestay offers quiet bungalows, slightly set back from the main road, in a stunning setting. Again, renting a scooter is a great idea, but here, "happiness is in the fields"—well, the rice terraces. So, park your two wheels and venture along the paths crisscrossing the terraces, following small streams, brushing past villages lost in the valley. If you want to know more and see all the photos, it’s here: Harau Valley.

BEACHES SOUTH of PADANG: 4 days 20 km south of Padang lies Bungus Beach. But that’s not it yet... You’ll need to take a fisherman’s boat for 40 minutes south to land on a peninsula inaccessible by car. That’s the minimum to reach this little paradise, nestled between jungle and sea, far from Padang’s pollution and hustle. An Eden on an isolated beach, with nothing but small bungalows and possible excursions to the nearby islands. The only way to get around: by boat and on foot... Pure bliss, toes in the water. And on the blog "Un tour dans le sac", nothing is spared—especially not the description to make your mouth water (Indian Ocean water, that is): sublime turquoise waters, postcard-perfect coconut trees, lazing in your favorite hammock.

For the practical side, here’s some info:

Sumatra Travel: Itinerary Summary My thoughts Sumatra is a magnificent Indonesian island and still relatively untouched. Tourists mainly flock to Java and Bali. It’s especially suited for nature lovers who’ll appreciate its volcanoes, paradise islands, jungle, and rice terraces. Sumatra is huge: in 3 weeks, we only visited the northern half of the island... And even then, we barely scratched the surface of this stunning part of Sumatra. That said, this itinerary offers an exceptional variety of landscapes: beaches, volcanoes, rice terraces, jungle—the winning combo!

Overall, Sumatra is still lacking in infrastructure, and maybe that’s a good thing: it’s far from Bali’s rampant "hotel urbanization." That said, you’ll have to accept spartan comfort: Sumatra, as beautiful as it is, is only for backpackers, adventurers, and travelers who can do without cozy 3-star hotels. In short, Sumatra is earned, but the effort is well worth it, and the warm welcome from the locals will make you forget the minor travel inconveniences.

A disappointment? The food isn’t as good as Bali’s (check out our article on the subject (link)). The stop in Berastagi is nice but not essential, especially if you’ve already seen Java’s impressive volcanoes.

A favorite? There were so many! But if I had to choose, I’d pick the Ketambe jungle. It was my first experience in a natural environment I didn’t know: a primary forest and memories that’ll last!

Would I do the Sumatra trip again? I regret not going to the Mentawai Islands. This archipelago, off Sumatra’s west coast, has long remained isolated: some inhabitants still live traditionally. These "flower men" live in harmony with nature. Unfortunately, their way of life is threatened by modern influences, and their fragile, unique culture risks disappearing. I would’ve loved to spend time with this incredible ethnic group. But it takes time: a week seems necessary. I would’ve had to skip some stops in our itinerary—maybe the peninsula south of Bungus and Berastagi?

Budget: It’s really cheap, especially the food, which, let’s be honest, isn’t amazing. Backpackers who can settle for spartan comfort (small bungalows without AC or hot water) and local food in warungs can easily get by on 20 € per day for two people (food + lodging). The cost of flights from Europe to Sumatra remains high. For our part, we found great deals on Paris-Hong Kong tickets (350 € round trip). Then you just need to reach Medan by low-cost airline.

No mandatory tipping in restaurants or accommodations. However, it’s more common to tip guides or taxi drivers.

Like many places in Indonesia, everything is negotiable. If you’re new to this, it’s not easy at first... Especially when dealing with a population poorer than us, "rich Westerners." But bargaining is part of the local culture! And you’ll get used to it—it even becomes fun. Plus, you don’t want to be that tourist paying the "tourist price" they’ll likely quote first, right?

To negotiate, be firm, respect your counterpart, smile, stay polite... Clearly show it’s too expensive or that the deal is done (by shaking hands, for example). Typing the numbers on your phone helps communicate the price. Learning a few words in the local language ("It’s too expensive," "How much?") is appreciated! Okay, it’s a rough tip, but here’s a base: dividing the first price by 2 gets you close to a fair negotiation.

Currently, 15,000 Indonesian rupiahs are worth about 1 €.

Accommodation Infrastructure is underdeveloped in Sumatra. You’ll find fewer "charming lodgings" than in Bali. Still, there are some very pleasant places. If you read our Sumatra articles, we recommend Abdi Homestay in Harau Valley and Silimalumbo at Lake Toba. In Pulau Weh, the choice is wider, but we suggest trying the seafood pasta at Bixio Café!

Health We didn’t get sick in Sumatra. By following a few simple rules (avoiding tap water, not swimming in stagnant freshwater), you’ll avoid the main issues. Hygiene is improving anyway. Anti-malaria treatment is still recommended, but cases are rare.

Also, keep in mind that Sumatra has a hot, humid climate—adjust your behavior accordingly (stay hydrated, protect yourself from the sun, etc.).
https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/
RA Ragamuffin Globetrotter ·
Hi there,

Thanks for sharing your experience!

des villages Batak (ethnie chrétienne), à l'architecture surprenante



But it’s especially the Batak funerary art that’s surprising.



I put together a photo album after my two trips to Samosir Island.

https://photos.google.com/share/AF1QipMyIl6gvvbQYGT84-6CKwsQcKUX2xz5C5c_anW0KT7sq60XsHc10c8MtdaF4SsVXQ?key=ZnhIRGk5Q3p2ZE11OWwyM2hVZVZnS2I1WW45ZUFR
"Nous ne sommes plus une communauté d'être humains qui se parlent mais un conglomérat de grappes de consommateurs en niches, séparés les uns des autres par des obsessions diverses et innombrables. Nous sommes de l'ère de la désintégration." Marc Moulin (1942-2008) in Humoeurs
ON OneChai Veteran ·
Thanks for the walk :-) Huge fan of Indonesia, I haven’t made it to Sumatra yet, but seeing this and the blog posts, it just makes me really want to go :-
One Chaï, blog de voyages à contre-courant : https://onechai.fr
RJ Rjulie95 Globetrotter ·
Thanks for the walk! 🙂
"Je suis africain, non pas parce que je suis né en Afrique, mais parce que l'Afrique est née en moi." Kwame Nkrumah.

"J'ai appris que le courage n'est pas l'absence de peur, mais la capacité de la vaincre." Nelson Mandela

https://www.en-voyages.fr
MA Mardidi Veteran ·
Great job introducing us to Sumatra! I was looking for where to go on my round-the-world trip, and I’ve found it! 😊
HE Henon21 Veteran ·
Well done and thank you for this trip! I visited Bukit Lawang 10 years ago, and now I’m tempted to discover Ketembe and finish with the Mentawai people on Siberut, just like last time. Congrats on the photos—they’re really well selected—and the comments that add value to the blog. Eric l
HENON Eric
SE Servanel Regular ·
Thanks for this feedback!

I checked out your blog and I think it’s really great—what amazing work!

I just signed up for the newsletter ;)
KA Karltoffel Veteran ·
hi michael, and congratulations on this beautiful poetic travel journal and the stunning photos. A small correction: you mentioned enjoying "lobster" at Lake Toba. The restaurants offer "loabster, Batak sauce," but in the freshwater of Lake Toba, these are actually crayfish... Being an early riser, I saw fishermen pulling up their traps every morning... However, don’t hesitate to try them: they’re reserved the night before, priced by the kilo... Get about ten per person for the price of a McDonald’s meal... A little downside: avoid visiting Sumatra in September/October because the massive recurring forest fires (to replant neatly aligned oil palms) darken the sky. For example, from the viewpoint at Puncak Lawang (Lake Maninjau), you can’t see the lake below at all. You gave a crucial tip for traveling between the Medan and Padang areas—take a domestic flight, as the bus ride is endless... Best, Jean-Louis
MA Max68 Globetrotter ·
Thanks for this lovely travel journal—great balance of text and beautiful photos that really make you want to go 😎

Well done! 🙂
https://apprentisvoyageurs.com
HO HohYao Veteran ·
Hello Thank you for this amazing travel journal—it’s so tempting! As a snorkeling fan (I’ve been to Sulawesi and Raja Ampat several times), I devoured the info on the Baniak Islands and would love any additional tips you have. 🙂

Do you have any photos of the underwater scenes? I didn’t see any on your blog.
Mes vidéos de voyages et surtout de snorkeling https://www.youtube.com/user/tsarabanjina
FA Facoalfr Veteran ·
Thanks for this story and these amazing photos. Sumatra is where my heart lies... and it’s been that way for a long time. Have a great day! Fabienne
MA Max68 Globetrotter ·
Hi Fabienne,

Great photo, it really makes you want to go! 😛 Where is it? 🙂
https://apprentisvoyageurs.com
MI Michael7759 Regular ·
Hi Catherine!

I didn’t make it to the Banyak Islands, much to my regret, but I did go to Pulau Weh (which was also amazing). That’s why I don’t have any of my own photos of the Banyak Islands. The info I noted down came from chatting with other travelers and reading articles while I was there.
https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/
HO HohYao Veteran ·
Hello, Thanks. I’m gonna go dig for info 🙂
Mes vidéos de voyages et surtout de snorkeling https://www.youtube.com/user/tsarabanjina
MI Michael7759 Regular ·
Hi Jean Louis!

You're absolutely right about the lobsters/crayfish from Lake Toba... It's a "deliberate mistake" that I correct later in more detail in the article.

Regarding your comment: "a little downside—avoid going to Sumatra around September/October because the massive recurring forest fires (to replant neatly aligned oil palms...) darken the sky, and for example, from the viewpoint at Puncak Lawang (by Lake Maninjau), you can't see the lake below at all."

May I add this note to my article so it can help other travelers? I did have the information but not enough details about the exact timing.
https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/
FA Facoalfr Veteran ·
Thanks, It's Taruko Cafe in the canyon below Bukittinggi. Have a great trip!
MA Max68 Globetrotter ·
Thanks! 🙂

The region really does look gorgeous and has quite a few interesting spots. 😛
https://apprentisvoyageurs.com
MA Max68 Globetrotter ·
I just "traveled through" your blog/site—congrats, it’s really top-notch! Super professional in how you present destinations/articles, well-researched, great photos, and even the "balance" of the trip itself is spot-on... impressive. 🙂

So when I look at mine now, it just seems meh. I’m even more impressed knowing how much time it takes... 🤪
https://apprentisvoyageurs.com
MI Michael7759 Regular ·
Thanks so much! What’s your website?

Tell me, where’s the photo from your profile?
https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/
MA Max68 Globetrotter ·
It's in Marienfluss, Namibia 🙂

My site is called apprentisvoyageurs... we're mostly self-drivers.

By the way, we're heading to Kyrgyzstan this summer 😉
https://apprentisvoyageurs.com
MI Michael7759 Regular ·
Great!

Thanks for the website address! I thought I might find some info on South Africa there. Almost! ;)

Kyrgyzstan is amazing... we loved that country!
https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/
RJ Rjulie95 Globetrotter ·
I also went to check out your site—bravo, it’s really well done and beautifully written!
"Je suis africain, non pas parce que je suis né en Afrique, mais parce que l'Afrique est née en moi." Kwame Nkrumah.

"J'ai appris que le courage n'est pas l'absence de peur, mais la capacité de la vaincre." Nelson Mandela

https://www.en-voyages.fr
MI Michael7759 Regular ·
Thanks, Regis! It’s true that we really like writing... And congrats on your animal photos on your site! ;)
https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/
CH Champassak ·
I really love the writing style. So much talent, bravo!
Champassak
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
Congrats on your trip report! Bravo! It’s well-written, very clear, and packed with great practical tips.

I went to Lake Toba in the early 80s! I imagine it’s still just as beautiful... though I’ll still miss the Batak house roofs where corrugated iron has now replaced woven palm...

As for the lobster tasting—that’s new to me. More like langoustines, right? Do they really bring them all the way there? From Padang? With the transport, freshness isn’t guaranteed ;) I’m a little surprised.

I checked out your blog, especially the Georgia section, and it’s made me want to go and do a trek like yours there.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
MI Michael7759 Regular ·
Thanks so much for your comment!

About the lobster: good catch! I actually wrote "lobster" to keep things simple, but they’re really big crayfish! I’ll correct that in the Lake Toba article... ;)
https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/
FL Florence07 ·
Hello and a big thank you for this feedback! Fascinating! I’m heading to Sumatra in January, and your insights really interest me. I plan to meet the Flower Men as well.

Thanks, and happy travels ahead! Florence
Flp
MI Michael7759 Regular ·
Awesome!

I'm glad you liked the Sumatra travel journal. Have a great trip!
https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/
GA Gallinava Regular ·
Awesome!

I'm glad you liked the Sumatra report. Have a great trip!

Thanks for this great report. I’d forgotten about the Batak roofs and how beautiful it was. I spent two months there 20 years ago—almost makes me want to go back!

The Mentawai area is really nice if you love hiking in primary forest.
GA Gallinava Regular ·
Will you be traveling alone?

Sumatra as a solo woman can be really, really tough. I traveled there for 2 months and was never so on edge—constant come-ons, worse than in India, where I’d lived before that trip. Guys are often looking for a woman who can support them (that was the case with several couples I met), and it’s exhausting.

After that, I traveled with another woman, and it was better. Then with a guy, and I really enjoyed it more—I became invisible :)
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
Will you be all alone?

Well no, she’ll be with the flower men ;)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
: Sumatra, as beautiful as it is, only reveals itself to backpackers / adventurers who can do without cozy, comfortable 3-star hotels

It’s nice to try to preserve the island from mass tourism, but that’s not entirely true. 😉

If Sumatra only offered spartan comfort for adventurers, I never would’ve gone...
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
It's nice to try to preserve the island from mass tourism, but that's not entirely true. 😉

If Sumatra offered only spartan comfort for adventurers, I never would've gone...

If you stick to the classic well-marked routes like Medan-Berastagi-Bukit Lawang-Lake Toba... You can indeed find a cozy hotel at every stop, and that’s been the case since the '90s. It’s true that compared to the vast size of Sumatra, it’s not much, and it’s a bit like those who come to France and first visit Paris to see the Louvre, go up the Eiffel Tower, then spend an hour at the Palace of Versailles before visiting one or two châteaux in the Loire Valley, the Puy du Fou in Vendée, or Futuroscope in Poitiers, then take a quick trip to an Atlantic beach before catching their return flight from Bordeaux/Paris😏
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
KA Karltoffel Veteran ·
hi it's true that you can find comfortable accommodations in the spots Djalma mentioned, as well as in Bukittinggi. But what "classy" places have you found in Harau Valley or around Lake Maninjau (which are still tourist sites... here it's more like mandi toilets, mosquito nets patched up with multi-colored tape, only cold water, rusty nails for your towel and washcloth, chickens running around and pooping on your bungalow terrace...) cheers jean-louis
HK HKGmevoila Regular ·
Great travel journal—it really inspired us! I think we’re heading to Sumatra this summer (after a lot of back-and-forth).

We’d considered Sumatra + Java, but Sumatra is so diverse that there’s plenty to keep us busy while keeping a relaxed pace...
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
You could compare Bali to a highway, Sumatra to a country road—the title of the travel journal really reflects reality.

But in both cases, we're far from adventure. Unless we're trivializing the word.

Adventure is more like the conquest of the West or the first steps on the moon. The truly unreasonable.
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
What "classy" accommodations did you find in Harau Valley?

A quick search on Maps, Booking, and Airbnb turns up several places that are far from your apocalyptic description... Places where I could sleep well even as a regular tourist, not some adventurer.

Same in Maninjau.

If I ruled out the big Sumatra crossing 10 years ago, it was because of the long bus ride between the island’s two main attractions—not because of a lack of decent places to stay.
FL Florence07 ·
Honestly, I’ll be with a partner, so there’ll be two of us. Your message made me laugh! I think once you’re over 60, you’re a bit more protected! 😄 But it can happen anywhere—I’ve experienced it in Latin America. Luckily, there’ll be the flower men 🌺🌺
Flp
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
You could compare Bali to a highway, Sumatra to a country road—the title of the travel journal reflects reality.

Sumatra is almost the size of France! While there may be a country road from Medan to Sibolga, there are also vast areas that are practically unexplored, at least by adventure seekers. And if you haven’t found what you’re looking for in Sumatra, there are still the Mentawai Islands. A few daring travelers are starting to take an interest in Siberut, even though it’s been accessible for over 35 years. Now, it’s being coveted by agencies that have added it to their programs for photo safaris with the "Flower Men," but in the other three islands, I’d be surprised if you ran into many visitors.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
Just to remind you what was written:

Sumatra, as beautiful as it is, is only for backpackers / adventurers who can do without cozy and comfortable 3-star hotels

This travel journal isn’t about remote spots at all. All the places mentioned have accommodations listed on Booking, Airbnb, etc. It’s about Sumatra, an island off the beaten path but accessible to any traveler like me. You don’t need to be an adventurer, backpacker, or rough traveler to go there.
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
There’s no question of lost corners in this travel journal. All the places listed have accommodations available on Booking, Airbnb, etc. We’re talking about Sumatra—an island off the beaten path but within reach of any traveler like me. You don’t need to be an adventurer, backpacker, or globetrotter to go there.

I agree with you on that point.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
MI Michael7759 Regular ·
Hi Attila! Thanks for your messages. I think we can try to debate without being too "harsh"... It's just a simple travel journal :) with its flaws and its strengths. We can also try to debate by adding nuance and staying calm...

I agree with you, Attila: in big cities (Medan, Padang) and tourist spots (Berastagi, Pulau Weh...), it's totally possible to find hotels with Western comfort or even luxury. You can also "arrive" in these cities by "comfortable taxi" or by plane, avoiding the uncomfortable buses on chaotic roads. So Sumatra becomes accessible to people who enjoy comfort and aren't adventurers. To open the debate: are there still places only accessible to pure adventurers? Even in Papua, even in the Gobi Desert, even deep in the Colombian jungle, anyone can get there if they have the means... Maybe the Arctic and Antarctica? And yet, luxury cruises are multiplying...

On another note, and in this sense I agree with Djalma, if you're coming from Bali (or comparing to Bali), Sumatra is less accessible to average travelers. It's harder to find 5-star hotels in less touristy areas. It's also less easy than in Bali to travel long distances comfortably...

As a concluding thought, I'll add some nuance to this "controversial" phrase from my travel blog: "Sumatra, as beautiful as it is, is only for backpackers / adventurers who can do without cozy, comfortable 3-star hotels."

Maybe I can rephrase it like this, which is more accurate: Sumatra is particularly suited to backpackers / adventurers who can do without cozy, comfortable 3-star hotels, even though it's possible to find luxury accommodations in big cities or tourist spots.
https://un-tour-dans-le-sac.fr/
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
I don’t think the "particularly" adds anything here.

It’s not just adventurers/backpackers/explorers who venture off the beaten path where travel conditions are decent—it’s also people who are a little more curious than average, or those on their second, third, or umpteenth trip to the same country.

Sumatra, like other Indonesian islands, caters to these kinds of travelers.

Besides, Sumatra was once a rising tourist destination. The tsunami, repeated earthquakes, the blacklisting of local airlines, and the implementation of Sharia law in Banda Aceh have all taken a toll on tourism, making it tough to recover.
RA Ragamuffin Globetrotter ·
Hi there 😉

Uh! Are we talking about Sumatra here?

Sumatra used to be a land of future tourism

Lake Toba is a great example, with the large number of guest houses built on the Tuk Tuk peninsula (with a name like that, it must have attracted all the tourists craving Thailand), yet paradoxically, the few people you come across there. But that *might* have changed in the last 10 years—maybe on weekends with folks from the city (Medan).

The tsunami, repeated earthquakes, blacklisting of local airlines, and the implementation of sharia in Banda Aceh have taken their toll on tourism, and it’s been tough to recover

After several trips (6 in 9 years, including 2 to Sumatra) across the archipelago, I got the impression of a general lack of infrastructure management. Or when the friendly nonchalance quickly turns into unpleasant carelessness (hoping not to encounter situations caused by criminal negligence).

Example in the photo of an abandoned resort. I’ll keep its location quiet to avoid making things worse, though I hope it’s improved—though I’m probably dreaming.







"Nous ne sommes plus une communauté d'être humains qui se parlent mais un conglomérat de grappes de consommateurs en niches, séparés les uns des autres par des obsessions diverses et innombrables. Nous sommes de l'ère de la désintégration." Marc Moulin (1942-2008) in Humoeurs
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
Hey folks! 🙂

Tourism in Indonesia outside Bali and Java hasn’t managed to bounce back from the tsunami and those airline blacklists, even though the lists have gotten a lot less harsh toward the country since then.

For a long time, Indonesia disappeared from travel agencies’ catalogs—except for a few spots served by airlines that weren’t on those blacklists, like Bali. French travel guides even scrubbed their editions of anything beyond Bali, Lombok, and Java, even though earlier versions covered Sumatra, Sulawesi, and more.

Only independent travelers who weren’t scared off by the idea of a possible plane crash kept exploring all the islands—and there weren’t many of them.

Not enough to fill the hotels from the golden age, let alone build new ones...

And most of those independent, free-spirited travelers were (are?) on a tight budget. So even fewer customers for mid-range and upscale places.

Those places fell into disrepair—no money, no maintenance...

Add corruption to the mix...

Now, I think it’s the frequent earthquakes and all the international news that’s scaring off the more cautious travelers.
VI Vikingboy Regular ·
And they still haven’t had a repeat of Bali 2002... Whether we like it or not, it’s hanging over them. Most recent attacks have targeted law enforcement (Medan recently, Wiranto two months ago, etc.), but it’s only a matter of time before some lunatic goes after Westerners... And when that day comes, tourism numbers will take a nosedive...
Récits d'Indonésie : Aceh / Java / Kalimantan ( 1999 - 2017 ) https://fortgonodeux.blogspot.com/
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
I don’t know. Westerners have "gotten used to attacks since they can happen anywhere."
VI Vikingboy Regular ·
But there’s a difference between potentially being the victim of an attack at home and in a faraway country where you don’t know the language or the customs... Though I might be wrong.
Récits d'Indonésie : Aceh / Java / Kalimantan ( 1999 - 2017 ) https://fortgonodeux.blogspot.com/
AT Atila Globetrotter ·
Bali has experienced terrorism. Yet, it bounced back...
LE Lemairebis Regular ·
Hi,

Thanks for this really beautiful travel journal with great photos. I’ll think about heading there in 2025.

Lemaire Lionel

Similar discussions

You might also like