Traveler, great traveler, or tourist: what's the difference for you?
FR

Translated into English.

RE Renosu Globetrotter ·
two little things in reply to faucon de mer

when I was young I dreamed reading Arthur Rimbaud’s travels

IndiGo, the Indian low-cost airline IndiGo, just bought 180 Airbus A320s

okay, I don’t really feel like elaborating 🤪
SE Seahawk ·
It’s normal to admire the guy who doesn’t have to grind away (at the factory, in the office) to live and can fulfill his dreams thanks to… (dad/mom/lottery?)

As rouxy said, you can live on the road without necessarily spending your life working; but you’ve got to make it happen and make compromises or let go of certain things. You can’t always have the money, the big house, the wife and kids, *and* the bohemian life at the same time 😉

Bohemian life or the daily grind—sometimes you’ve got to choose!
NA Nat7 Veteran ·
Totally agree!!! ;)
RO Rouxy Regular ·
you can't always have the money, the big house, the wife and kids, and the bohemian life all at once 😉

Having kids costs exactly one sperm and one ovary—life doesn’t give you a cheaper deal😏
NA Nat7 Veteran ·
Interesting reflection. Do you have any thoughts on this?

Here’s the average daily cost of raising a child in England up to age 21 (fresh data from UK debt statistics). I don’t think there’s a huge difference compared to France. Raising a child to the age of 21 in Britain will now set you back £23.50 daily.

Or, alternatively, do you plan to have a child with your partner and then leave her to figure it out alone?
RO Rouxy Regular ·
Interesting reflection. Do you have any thoughts on this?

Here’s the average daily cost of raising a child in England up to age 21 (fresh data from UK debt statistics). I don’t think there’s a huge difference compared to France. Raising a child to the age of 21 in Britain will now set you back £23.50 daily.

Or are you planning to have a kid with your partner and then leave her to figure it out alone?

I clearly said I’d have kids, not raise them😏
TE Teamten Globetrotter ·
I did say I have kids, not that I feed them😏

Hilarious...
ME MengWan Globetrotter ·
Or do you plan to have a baby with the lady and then leave her to raise it alone?

LOL

And that desperately reminds me of someone very close....

😎

P: To be or to have, that’s an essential question... for kids! (little or big 😉)
Si vous avez compris tout ce que je viens de vous dire, c'est que j'ai dû faire une erreur quelque part. - Alan Greenspan Science sans conscience n'est que ruine de l'âme - Rabelais
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
It’s normal to admire the guy who doesn’t have to work (in a factory, at the office) to live and can fulfill his desires thanks to… (mom/dad/lottery?)

If that’s the case for the majority, there are still people who’ve traveled without help from mom/dad or the lottery, and I can confirm that because I was one of them. I’d add (based on my own criteria): Tourism is something you buy; travel is something you earn!

When you work (like—almost—everyone 😉), of course you’re not "admirable," you’re just "ordinary," and in that case, it’s time that’s most lacking… (even with paid leave…)

Admirable or not, for those who lack motivation, there’s always a reason (time, money, health, family, etc.) not to follow their own path but someone else’s… That applies to travel just like any other activity or life choice…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
HU HuguesH ·
"The traveler sees what he sees, the tourist sees what he has come to see." G.K. Chesterton
http://hugues-hardy-photo.com
WI Williama Globetrotter ·
"Tourist" or "traveler" doesn’t matter ... no one would dare say they're first and foremost a vacationer!
PY Pyj09 Regular ·
Hey Williama, I know you love debates, so I’m gonna give you something to sink your teeth into😉. I agree that most people travel as "vacationers," but a lot of "travelers" (myself included) do it mainly out of curiosity. I just got back from a trip to Asia, and honestly, China and Japan didn’t interest me at all as "vacation destinations." I only stopped there to satisfy my curiosity—and I wasn’t even on vacation. I’d like to think I’m not the only "tourist" in this situation. The ball’s in your court now. I’m curious to see where this forum thread goes. 😉

It’s all in the mind.😎
pyj09
FI Filtoche Regular ·
Thanks! It's as simple as that... Not bad, this Chesterton!

I’d even add that the tourist comes to see, photograph, and actually immortalize what they’ve seen and heard—to reproduce it through their own eyes and ears, as if to capture that lived moment forever. A great tip!
Filtoche
HU HuguesH ·
If I may dare to say it, and I think this applies to many of us on this forum too. You can be a vacationer at home. Conversely, you can also travel for many different personal or professional reasons, outside of a vacation context.
http://hugues-hardy-photo.com
WI Williama Globetrotter ·
Hey Pyj,

Without paid leave or school holidays for students, 99.9% of the people who visit this forum wouldn’t be anything! The "travelers vs. tourists" debate is just a sterile aristocratic joust that tries to pit the noble against the common in travel, when our behavior is really dictated by our vacation time! You can already see a clear difference in how travel is viewed within the same French-speaking space—between the French, with their 5 weeks of paid leave per year, and Quebecers, who only get between 2 and 4 weeks based on seniority... And let’s not even talk about retirees who suddenly discover a passion for the planet later in life... I’d also be curious to know what these "adventure junkies" who regularly visit forums like this one do for a living?
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
I just got back from a trip to Asia, and honestly, China and Japan didn’t interest me at all as "vacation destinations."

China and Japan aren’t really alike, except that both populations are "Asian." Can you share why you went to these two countries (aside from your time off, if I understood correctly)? And if it was a work trip, how did you manage to "explore" a bit and get a sense of these places—enough to conclude they’ll never be vacation spots for you? What kind of countries *would* be your ideal vacation destination, and why?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XCOyB7WStI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2eI67iCbKY
CO Cocorico45 ·
Good evening everyone,

I’ll try to settle this for you—personally, travel is just a way to get around, whether by bike, metro, or whatever. It’s the mode of transportation.

Once you reach your destination, anywhere in the world, you and I are just human beings among other human beings. All it takes is mutual respect, and everything goes smoothly.

But since we’re only "poor humans," we can sometimes act in unacceptable ways, so we’ve got to stay extra careful.

FiFI
MA Maitairoa Globetrotter ·
" I’ll try to settle this for you—travel, to me, is just the way you get around, whether by bike, subway, or whatever. It’s the mode of transportation. "

... you had a good start, though...

... but the rest is full of nonsense and contradictions—it doesn’t hold up at all, not even close! 🤪
TR Trutre52 ·
The ball is rolling now. I'm curious to see what direction this forum will take.

True, after 5 pages, we were only waiting for you....🤪 Is that your debate? 🏴‍☠️
TR Trutre52 ·
Besides, I wasn't on vacation.

So what were you doing then?

I agree that most people travel as "vacationers," but many "travelers" (myself included) do it mainly out of curiosity

So a curious vacationer can’t exist?
FI Filtoche Regular ·
...... Thanks again, master, for your navel-gazing analyses
Filtoche
HU HuguesH ·
Hello Williama, hello everyone.

I admit I have trouble understanding how some people don’t grasp that you can actually travel without being on vacation.

- What about all kinds of humanitarian workers? Everyone knows some, right? - And language teachers, whether volunteers or paid? - And many researchers, scientists, etc.? - And those who choose—I know quite a few—to leave with the goal of digging wells in villages in Mali, building brick walls in Kenya so children have a place to study, conducting wildlife censuses, setting up irrigation for agriculture, etc. They’re truly nomadic without being vacationers, aren’t they? - What about artistic professions (musicians, theater troupes, circus companies...)? Aren’t they non-vacationing travelers too? - And all the professions tied to information, journalism, photojournalism, etc. Without them, could we read a newspaper or—if we have a TV—watch the news? - What about jobs in tourism, entertainment, or divemasters all around the planet who spend their time explaining to passing tourists how to breathe through a regulator? They have a job that’s certainly enjoyable, but they’re not on vacation during their travels. - What about those Westerners who choose to invest in a business abroad during the usual 6-7 months of high season? Aren’t there countless people who’ve become partners with locals so we can find a bed in a guesthouse or a sandwich on the street? Haven’t they had to make trips back and forth to set up and maintain their businesses? We all know people like that. - And what about the growing number of people who leave to scout out artisanal product manufacturers, buy all sorts of items from them, and then resell them at markets in our Western cities?

The list could go on forever, but I hope, with all humility, to have at least partially satisfied your curiosity, globetrotter, about "the profession of these ‘adventurers’ addicted to travel who regularly frequent a forum like this one." But I’m sure others here—whether vacationers or travel professionals who enjoy participating in forums—will be able to shed more light on this than I have.

Williama, something still bothers me just a little, though. Your profile says this: "and also the must-visit emerging countries for work." The way this is phrased suggests you yourself spend time abroad for your job, meaning something other than vacations. If that’s the case, it seems to contradict what you wrote earlier—that when we’re traveling, we’re all vacationers without daring to say so. So why do you have so many doubts about the existence of those who travel for work if that’s what you do yourself? Of course, I might have misunderstood the meaning of that sentence in your profile.

To wrap up, I’ll say I admire you—Williama, still—for having conducted a conclusive survey that, to quote you: "Without paid leave or school holidays for students, 99.9% of those who frequent this forum would be nothing!" Your precision leaves us stunned, but unfortunately, it doesn’t seem to have any basis other than your own opinion.
http://hugues-hardy-photo.com
FI Filtoche Regular ·
Oh... Great Master, I found this on VF

Already on the plane, we were impatient to return to Southeast Asia. When we set foot in Bangkok, we suddenly feel happy to be back in this city. Returning to the Khao San Road area, we feel right at home and quickly fall back into our little routines: hotels, restaurants, massages… and nights out!

So? Traveler, great traveler, or tourist? Sorry, I’ve got no words—or if I do, they’re escaping my mouth and... This morning, I heard a segment on France Inter, not the one by Caroline Fourest In Egypt, some people looted the museum where others—who you could call by any name you like—were cultivating knowledge. As a result, some of them targeted the museum shop. They walked off with plaster copies. The commentator cleverly drew a parallel with a human society obsessed with appearances—a life where you *appear* to be a... dignified person. Ding dong
Filtoche
FI Filtoche Regular ·
February 14, 2004 at 11:59 AM Citer Répondre First question: What are you looking for?

And you?
Filtoche
WI Williama Globetrotter ·
I admit I have trouble understanding how some people don’t get that you can actually travel without being on vacation.

- What about all the humanitarian workers out there? Everyone knows someone like that, right? ...

Hi Hugues,

And that’s exactly what I’m saying... all the people you mention only represent the tiny 0.xx% I was talking about earlier. Each in their own way, they’re the new globetrotting stars of globalization. In a sense, they’ve erased borders—whether by choice, humanitarianism, or their work. Vacationing travelers, on the other hand, are first and foremost beneficiaries of a state system built on paid leave. They’re still representatives of the old world, the one of compartmentalization under the protective shadow of the state. Every year, they leave their cozy nest hoping to return in good health after 3 or 4 weeks abroad, with a head full of memories. The traveler vs. tourist debate doesn’t make sense—it’s paid leave that shapes the "adventurer"...

When I go abroad for work, I’m not traveling—I’m just getting around. Let’s not mix things up.
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
And what are you looking for? You’re airing your wounded pride and dragging half the forum into it without anyone understanding what’s going on!

So let me clarify: You start a discussion, and some people don’t agree with you... http://voyageforum.com/...9;page=unread#unread

So, to settle scores... (sorry, I can’t think of another way to describe what you’re doing...) You inexplicably dig up a post from 2004 here... (your post #124) http://voyageforum.com/v.f?post=36886#36886

And since then, you’ve been tracking... http://voyageforum.com/...post=4054939#4054939 http://voyageforum.com/...post=4054917#4054917 Along with all your off-topic replies in this thread...

This isn’t very constructive... 😕

(end of the tangent and off-topic part...)
MA Maitairoa Globetrotter ·
... let's leave ... you should never disturb a disturbed mind (sorry for the bad word)! 🙂
SE SeniorCH Globetrotter ·
Good evening to you both,

Phew, I'm not the only one wondering about Filtoche's state of mind😉

Danielle
A man, a plan, a canal, Panama - palindrome, auteur inconnu
RO Rouxy Regular ·
I admit I have a hard time understanding how some people don’t get that you can actually travel without being on vacation.

They leave their cozy nest every year, hoping to return in good health after 3 or 4 weeks abroad with a head full of memories. The traveler vs. tourist debate makes no sense—it’s paid leave that shapes the "adventurer"...

Not everyone, and that’s exactly the difference those who—rightly or wrongly—consider themselves travelers rather than tourists like to highlight... 😇
FI Filtoche Regular ·
Kola

Sorry for the inconvenience, but I just don’t like the way some people talk down to others, no matter the situation. I admit I let myself get carried away, trying to "track down" the kite person (I don’t remember their exact name anymore), and I regret it.

My apologies
Filtoche
KO Kola Globetrotter ·
Your reply is odd, and almost touching in its awkwardness... you sound like a little boy caught in the act!

You wanted to track down ..."the person with the kite whose exact name you don’t remember"? 🤪 (I think it’s not a kite on the avatar... but prayer flags.)
MA Maitairoa Globetrotter ·
... you were right to explain it ... I never would've made the connection! 😮
MA Marysha ·
Hi! For me, a tourist is someone who travels with everything organized by travel agencies or with everything planned in advance. A traveler is someone who plans part of their trip and wants to experience the country's immersion (values, customs, etc.). Finally, a great traveler plans the broad strokes of their trip and lets themselves be carried away by the unexpected. Roughly speaking, that's my take!.....................thanks
WI Williama Globetrotter ·
Hi! For me, a tourist is someone who travels with everything organized by travel agencies or with everything planned in advance. A traveler is someone who plans part of their trip and wants to immerse themselves in the country (values, customs, etc.). Finally, a great traveler plans the broad strokes of their trip and lets themselves be carried away by the unexpected. Roughly, that's my opinion!.....................thanks

Hello,

Tourists and independent travelers are both obsessive planners... The only difference between them lies in how they plan. The first outsources the problem to an agency, while the second tackles the planning themselves. On this forum, we’ve lost count of posts like "what do you think of my schedule: Day 1 here... Day 2 there... Day 24 still around here, etc."... The independent traveler leaves even less room for the unexpected than the tourist, as they’re so focused on seeing as much as possible, squeezed by dates, all on a tight budget... In both cases, they’re just vacationers, I’m telling you!!!!
FA Fabd Regular ·
Absolutely, you're right about planning! And yes, the tourist vs. traveler debate is a bit outdated. Having said that, unlike you, I do make more of a distinction between vacation and travel. For me, vacations are really about rest and tranquility. A traveler is more active, gets out there, and rolls with the punches...
LA Lautre99 Regular ·
Good evening,

Tourists and independent travelers are obsessive planners... The only difference between them lies in how they plan. The first outsources the problem to an agency, while the second tackles the planning themselves. On this forum, we can’t count the number of posts like, "What do you think of my schedule: Day 1 here... Day 2 over there... Day 24 still around here, etc."... The independent traveler leaves even less room for the unexpected than the tourist, as they’re so focused on seeing as much as possible, squeezed by dates, all on a tight budget... In both cases, they’re vacationers, I’m telling you!!!!

Is an independent traveler not a tourist? Can a tourist not be an independent traveler? Haha. This forum, honestly...

See you soon, Laure.
CE Cescableue Veteran ·
Well, like many, I travel during my vacations 😉 And during each trip, I knock about, I stay busy between several quiet spots where... I rest! 😏
Quand il n'y a pas de solution, c'est qu' il n'y a pas de problème ! Woody Allen
WI Williama Globetrotter ·
Well, like many, I travel during my vacations. And during each trip, I knock about, I keep busy between several quiet stops where... I rest!

... Finally, a frank and clear answer from a vacationer who owns it😏
TO Toutayeti ·
Hello everyone!

I’m jumping into this discussion, which seems to be stirring up some strong feelings! Just like human evolution, we go through different stages depending on how long our journey lasts! We’ve all been tourists at some point, when time was limited. I get it now! When you don’t have much time, you travel differently......... We’ve met so many people like that! So, I think it’s already great to go see what’s happening elsewhere, no matter how you do it! And yes, travel makes you more tolerant! In three years, I’ve learned way more about myself than about others! Maybe that’s simply what "being a traveler" is all about—GETTING TO THE ESSENTIALS, because above all, it’s a very personal story! ;) Currently in Vietnam!

PS: It’s true—after three months, NO MORE TOURISTA! A fond memory from three years ago!
Toutalanguille ! :)
JE Jeddhai Regular ·
For me, there are very few true travelers—that is, people who travel primarily by their own means, preferably modestly and respectfully toward the Earth and the nature of this planet. I have much more respect and admiration for those who travel on foot, by bike, by sailboat, among other ways (though not the obnoxious rich yacht owners, of course ;)), "by fair means," rather than those who are "transported" by airlines for nearly all their trips, catapulted from one place to another on the planet. To me, those aren’t travelers but rather "kerosene burners," consumerist tourists who rush to invade many places in the world (often already overcrowded...), contributing to the destruction of the biosphere... Mass tourism, at the expense of quiet and still-wild places (if any remain). On this forum, I’ve often noticed that many are "proud" to show off the countries they’ve visited, like a trophy or a hunting score—it always strokes their ego. Ego-ism is the most widespread religion on Earth, along with money, consumption, and its sidekicks: greed and the rest. It’s too bad—I’m not blameless either, since I’ve also taken a few flights abroad—but at least I don’t see things the same way as others do.
«Si tu ne trouves pas d'ami sage, prêt à cheminer avec toi, résolu, constant, marche seul, comme un roi après une conquête ou un éléphant dans la forêt.» Bouddha
TA Tatra Globetrotter ·
Hi there,

On this forum, I’ve often noticed that many people are "proud" to show off the countries they’ve visited, like a trophy or a hunting scorecard. It always strokes their ego—ego-ism being the most widespread religion on Earth, alongside money, consumption, and its sidekicks: greed and the rest.

Between the ego-boosting display of how many countries you’ve visited and the smug self-righteousness of someone who sees themselves as the world’s moral savior, expecting blind admiration from others, I’m not sure I want to pick a side.

Michel
MA Maitairoa Globetrotter ·
... you beat me to it! 🙂

... but I don’t share your uncertainty: the second one seems way more suspicious than the first ones! 😇
TA Tatra Globetrotter ·
... you beat me to it!

.... I was just about to jump in..... 🙂

Michel
TH Thartampion Regular ·
hello

Tourism is the act of leaving one's home for personal reasons, for a period longer than 24 hours. This may involve staying overnight with a hotelier and possibly booking transportation tickets. Initially linked only to leisure and health, tourism now also encompasses all the economic activities a person uses during an unusual trip (transportation, hotels, restaurants, etc.). For example, it could be a business trip (referred to as "business tourism") or a religious pilgrimage ("cultural tourism"). You can also receive medical treatment in a country other than your own, which is called medical tourism. Practicing tourism also allows you to take breaks from the utilitarian schedule imposed by the need to earn a living. Tourists are generally interested in the culture or landscapes they visit. This practice was long the privilege of wealthy people who could afford to travel to see remarkable buildings, works of art, or taste other cuisines. Tourism gave rise to a real industry when the middle classes of Western countries (Europe and North America) began to travel. The general improvement in living standards allowed people to devote more time to leisure, including tourism, not to mention the considerable progress in transportation (maritime, rail, but especially air travel). According to the UNWTO (World Tourism Organization), "tourism is traveling outside one's usual place of residence for more than 24 hours but less than 4 months, for leisure, professional (business tourism), or health purposes (health tourism)."

so, according to Wikipedia, beyond 4 months, you're no longer a tourist!

but does that make us travelers?

Personally, I travel to get from point A to point B, and once I arrive, I'm a tourist. I take tours. City tours, village tours, countryside or mountain tours.

I wander and meet people—locals or other wanderers.

I wander, look, eat, and even buy souvenirs sometimes.

And, I barely dare say it, I take photos.

(and maybe I even write postcards...)

But I promise, next time I'll try to leave for more than 4 months, now that I know it'll make me a traveler.

aaaah, I can't wait!

and to answer Williama about the 99%: I always travel with my own money, saved up with difficulty. The last time I left, I didn’t claim unemployment benefits (which I was entitled to) because I didn’t want to owe anything to anyone. I’ve met a lot of people "traveling" (can we really use such a strong word?) who did the same. And I think many here travel outside of "paid leave/retirement/parents’ help." If we had to guess percentages, it’d be closer to 60%. Cheers.

ps: adapting Levi-Strauss a bit (sounds fancy, right!): "The traveler is first and foremost someone who believes in travel." It works for tourists too.
CA Carthago47 Globetrotter ·
And those who choose—I know quite a few—who leave with the goal of digging wells in villages in Mali or building brick walls in Kenya so that children have a place to study,

hello,

I’d call those people ‘Useless Travelers’ or ‘Useless Tourists.’ Because traveling to dig a well or build walls? I’m sorry, but the locals know how to do that without needing these tourists. What they *actually* need is the materials to do it—so money to buy them. If those travelers donated the cost of their flight ticket toward the materials instead, they’d be a lot more credible...
http://tiakomadagasikara.uniterre.com/ http://mananara.free.fr/ http://voyagevoyages.over-blog.fr/
HU HuguesH ·
Yes, but starting from that principle, you could argue that (for example) the locals in Thailand also know very well how to clear the ruins of their homes after a tsunami. Yet that doesn’t stop us from helping them. The key is wanting to. There are those who give their time to meaningful causes... and then there are those who just watch, criticize them on forums, and suggest they donate the cost of their flight ticket instead. Credibility? Oh, really?!
http://hugues-hardy-photo.com
CA Carthago47 Globetrotter ·
What I do, I don’t write about on the forum. Where I live, the needs are huge, and I’d never say I’m going to dig a well or build walls. But they do it because we help them with materials and give them work... You’re confusing a daily latent need with a tsunami, an exceptional event. I’ve even seen people come to help after cyclones, but they spent their time taking photos to sell later—that’s pathetic. It’s true there are different kinds of people: those who do whatever and those who act with some logic. But logic... when you want exoticism on top of that... 😏
http://tiakomadagasikara.uniterre.com/ http://mananara.free.fr/ http://voyagevoyages.over-blog.fr/
HU HuguesH ·
I agree with you—you and I have seen the same kind of people—and my point wasn’t against yours, no offense intended! I still firmly believe that the desire and the act of giving are far more important than the means by which we give. It’s the intention behind giving that should take precedence, with the method adapting to each person’s possibilities. Not everyone has exceptional financial means (myself included, for example), so I try to offer my services by giving my time, just like the people I mentioned earlier, whose selfless and logical actions I know firsthand. They balance their travels between on-the-ground help and sharing through photos, videos, etc. All of this isn’t incompatible or contradictory when you manage to find a bit of balance and common sense.
http://hugues-hardy-photo.com
HA Harptallica Regular ·
Right now, I'm traveling completely independently: 6 months by bike, maybe more, and for resources... I started at 16. I worked in a crappy supermarket butcher shop where I was taken for a fool, but I think it's more honorable to work, to endure, to save up knowing you have goals. Very few people show that kind of determination (for me, it was two years; for others, twelve).

As for mom and dad, I don’t hide the fact that in a way, I was privileged: I stayed at their place with a larger monthly allowance, but I would never have done the traveler thing with a silver spoon in my mouth and my parents breathing down my neck... Freedom is something you earn for yourself, not what your parents/family or sometimes even 100% sponsors hand you :/

Anyway, freedom is paid for with sweat ;)
Des petit tours de roues ... http://loic-eurotrip.over-blog.com/
SK Skyfarer Regular ·
I’m a tourist traveler.... I stay at a hotel but dine with locals. I visit monuments AND the trails less traveled by 'tourists.' I always try to learn a few words of the local dialect (Maltese and Chinese weren’t easy, but with enough repetition, the words eventually 'sound right' and people understand you). I respect the places I visit (no wild camping, I pick up my trash and other litter) but still enjoy my vacation. I talk to people, even if I’m shy—I try to reach out to them, hoping to make friends, but when you’re only there for a week or two, it’s not easy to build real connections.

I think humility has nothing to do with it. A tourist can be humble, and a traveler can be condescending.
J'ai voyagé avec Jules Verne et Saint-Saint-Exupéry, mais maintenant j'aimerais voyager avec moi-même.

Similar discussions

You might also like