Taiwan: The End of the Natives
FR

Translated into English.

Original post
EL
I’d heard—and rightly so—about the incredible kindness of Taiwanese people. I had just spent a few weeks in Korea, a country of teddy bears, where the locals loved telling me about a place full of… more teddy bears. It was going in circles.

So I arrived in Taipei with stars in my eyes, ready to face all that generosity. Yet, surprisingly, the guard posted in front of the presidential palace wasn’t exactly courteous. And then, the countless military vehicles really struck me. Have you ever seen a teddy bear driving a tank?

I spent most of my evenings in a bar along a very large avenue. I’d go alone and always find company—men, women, it didn’t matter as long as I could blend into this new country, discover its people, their culture, their history.

The heat made me sweat nonstop, my beard had grown back, I was wearing a black T-shirt as worn-out as possible, and my face bore the marks of several months in Russia and Korea. In short, I looked like the perfect globetrotter—the kind I’d probably dreamed of being as a kid.

So there I was, sitting at the bar, deep in conversation with a Taiwanese friend, when a fight broke out between an Italian and an American—two drunk, stupid beasts. Shouting, shoving, we kicked them out. Well, *we* didn’t. My friend didn’t move; I was the only one who reacted, letting my temper get the better of me. He looked at me and said, without malice, that white guys had also fought two days earlier. I turned my head toward the room—I was the only foreigner. I was used to it, but tonight was different. The looks in the mirror were full of distrust. I felt like an idiot for all the others. I felt like an idiot. I said goodbye to my friend; I was convinced I’d never see him again. As I headed toward my hostel, my brain was racing. Asia had confronted me with a side of travel I didn’t know. I’d always managed to blend in, to go unnoticed, but when your features and skin color prevent that, the game changes. And this hyper-globalization, this hyper-communication, the fact that poor guys like me can enjoy travel—is it really a good thing? Does it create an expectation, a need for a mass of tourists who couldn’t care less about the country they’re visiting? No, really, I felt like an idiot. And then all those damn tanks, and what’s with those dozen tents in front of the presidential palace? It intrigued me. It was late, but there was movement. Hey! Hey! How are you? Good, just a little drunk. Ha ah aha! What are you doing here? Why are there so many military personnel around you? Ha ha ah! You can come if you want! Oh really? Yeah, yeah!

I climbed over the fence and learned. I learned that in the mountains to the east of the island, the island’s natives still live. I learned that their culture is disappearing, that they themselves are disappearing. That nothing is being done to preserve the very origin of this country. That all those tanks and military personnel were there for about thirty cheerful troublemakers who had made the trip. Because by being there, they were announcing: *Yes, we’re still here.* I spent the rest of the evening with them until early morning. They showed me how to weave my own shoes (flip-flops), plied me with endless coffee, laughed when a cop took my picture and I shouted, *Yes, I’m a French spy*, and gave me a bracelet. I left with a new look in my eyes. This trip will end as it began, but the next one will be different. I’ll be prepared; it won’t just be an escape or an adventure. Travelers destroy more than they preserve—it’s not easy to tip the scales, but I’m going to try anyway.
MA Marathon Globetrotter ·
Hello,

Ketagalan Boulevard, which leads to the Presidential Palace, is to Taipei what Tiananmen Square is to Beijing or the Champs-Élysées are to Paris: a symbolic place for demonstrations in the heart of the capital. The difference with China is that the military present don’t massacre protesters. The difference with France is that the protesters present don’t throw stones at the police.

In this world of brutes, Taiwan is a country of teddy bears.
AN Anneorange Regular ·
I really appreciated how helpful the locals were. The military presence is easily explained. Their large neighbor is lying in wait, and their army is a relic of the past. I also noticed the recognition—even if recent—of indigenous populations.
MR MrBruno10647 Regular ·
I really appreciated how helpful the locals were. The military presence is easily explained. Their giant neighbor is lying in wait, and their army is a relic of the past. I also noticed that Indigenous populations are being acknowledged, even if it’s recent.

You’ve got the Ministry of Defense right there, the Presidential Office, Parliament... it’s kind of expected in a country that isn’t part of the UN and doesn’t even have a seat at the WHO. Twenty years ago, military service lasted two years for young people—now it’s barely four months. I think there are 18 ethnic groups in Taiwan.
YE Yemen Veteran ·
WOW, your feedback is surprising and interesting! This is your third post on the forum—so practical, I love it . For those who know how to read and appreciate your way of traveling. laurence
On est la somme de nos rencontres
BH Bhara Regular ·
Good evening,

We just got back from a family trip to Taiwan (https://lepourquoipas4.wordpress.com/2018/12/05/taiwan-octobre-2018/).

To follow up on your post, yes, when you're abroad, you don’t know all the social norms... I was super stressed on public transport because my daughters might make even the tiniest bit of noise, since there’s absolute silence (in a packed plane, a packed train, etc.). I was afraid of bothering people or coming off as rude with our little family. In Spain or Italy, that kind of thing isn’t even a question. My girls are really well-behaved—they can sit and read quietly for hours... but as soon as they spoke a little too loudly, I was terrified of being seen as impolite. The QUIET was what surprised me the most in Taiwan, especially since I spent a year in China, and let’s just say silence isn’t exactly their national pastime there!!!

So what to do? Observe the locals, try to understand, gather as much info as possible before coming... and hope you don’t make any faux pas! In the end, I think we didn’t do too badly—our girls got so many gifts, and we were even invited to eat twice...

I also think it’s best not to get involved in local issues (whether it’s a fight or a protest): you don’t know the ins and outs, especially after just a few days in the country... and you have no idea how the police might react—locking us up with two drunk guys, taking us to the station, and deporting us after we showed support for the indigenous people...??? Even in France, it’s not always clear how things work (especially right now with the yellow vests!!!). So abroad... observe, gather info, but unless you’ve been living there for a long time, don’t take sides or intervene.

Of course, after a few beers, good judgment is probably optional... Lol

YiLian
MA Mariecurry Globetrotter ·
I’ve learned that in the interior, in the mountains on the east side of the island, live the native people of this land. I’ve learned that their culture is disappearing, that they themselves are disappearing. That nothing is being done to preserve the very origins of this country. That all those tanks and soldiers are there for a few dozen happy-go-lucky folks who made the trip. Because by their presence, they announce: Yes, we’re still here.

They’re fighting. It’s not easy, but they’re trying to keep their culture alive. They continue to speak their languages (because there are several). They organize festivals, concerts. They release DVDs, CDs—I even brought some back with me.

The Museum of the Aborigines in Taipei is definitely worth the trip. To discover who they are. How long they’ve been here. To understand why their culture so closely resembles that of Polynesians. www.museum.org.tw/symm_en/index.htm

As usual, the Aboriginal minority is the poorest population and the one suffering the most from unemployment.
EL Elcoyote69 ·
Thanks for the info and the link 😉
JG JG07 Globetrotter ·
I’d heard—and rightly so—about the incredible kindness of Taiwanese people. I had just spent a few weeks in Korea, a country of teddy bears, where the locals loved telling me about a place full of… more teddy bears. It was a never-ending cycle.

So I arrived in Taipei with stars in my eyes, ready to take on all that generosity. Yet, surprisingly, the guard posted in front of the presidential palace wasn’t exactly courteous. And then there was the staggering number of military vehicles—it really took me aback. Have you ever seen a teddy bear driving a tank?

I spent most of my evenings in a bar along a very busy avenue. I’d go alone and always find company—men, women, it didn’t matter, as long as I could blend into this new country, discover its people, their culture, their history.

The heat made me sweat nonstop. My beard had grown back, I was wearing a worn-out black T-shirt, and my face bore the marks of several months in Russia and Korea. In short, I looked like the perfect globetrotter—the kind I’d probably dreamed of being as a kid.

I was sitting at the bar, deep in conversation with a Taiwanese friend, when a fight broke out between an Italian and an American—two drunk, stupid beasts. There was shouting, shoving, and they got kicked out. “They” didn’t do anything—it’s not true. My friend didn’t move; I was the only one who reacted, letting my temper get the better of me. He looked at me and said, without malice, that some white guys had also fought two days earlier. I turned my head toward the room—I was the only foreigner. I’m used to it, but tonight was different. I saw distrust in their eyes. I felt stupid for all the others, I felt stupid. I said goodbye to my friend—I knew I wouldn’t see him again. As I headed back to my hostel, my mind was racing. Asia had shown me a side of travel I didn’t know. I’d always managed to blend in, to go unnoticed, but when your features and skin color prevent that, everything changes. And this hyper-globalization, this hyper-communication, the fact that guys like me can travel so easily—is it really a good thing? Does it create expectations and needs for a mass of tourists who don’t care about the country they’re visiting? I really felt stupid. And then there were all those damn tanks. What was up with the dozen tents in front of the presidential palace? It intrigued me. It was late, but there was movement. Hey! Hey! How are you? Good, just a little drunk. Ha ah aha! What are you doing here? Why are there so many military personnel around you? Ha ha ah! You can come if you want! Oh really? Yeah, yeah!

I climbed over the fence and learned. I learned that in the mountains to the east of the island, the island’s natives still live. I learned that their culture is disappearing, that they themselves are disappearing. That nothing is being done to preserve the very origins of this country. That all those tanks and soldiers were there for about thirty cheerful folks who had made the trip. Because by being there, they were saying: *Yes, we’re still here.* I spent the rest of the evening with them until early morning. They showed me how to weave my own shoes (flip-flops), plied me with endless coffee, laughed when a cop took my picture and I shouted, “Yes, I'm a French spy,” and gave me a bracelet. I left with a new look in my eyes. This trip would end as it began, but the next one would be different. I’d be prepared—it wouldn’t just be an escape or an adventure. Travelers destroy more than they preserve. It’s not easy to tip the balance, but I’m going to try anyway.

Great writing—really well done.

Still, it wasn’t exactly smart to get involved in a fight. You don’t know the country’s laws, and it could’ve cost you dearly. I don’t know how it works in Taiwan, but in Japan, you’d definitely end up in custody at best. At worst, it could mean jail time and a 5- or 10-year ban from the country…

Same goes for telling a cop, *‘I’m a French spy’*—that’s just plain stupid. It could’ve cost you too.

Anyway, you seem really young, or immature, or a bit of both…
EL Elcoyote69 ·
In short, you seem very young or immature, or a bit of both.

Haha! Thanks for the comment. To answer, neither, I think. Just an impulsive temperament is sometimes enough. A temperament that allowed me to spend time with Russian hooligans, protest against the government in South Korea, follow cocaine dealers in Vietnam, and more. So far, I’ve never had to fight or raise my voice because of a mistake on my part. As for the "French spy," the police officer was taking my picture, and he laughed—it was all in good fun. Maybe I’ll get burned one day, but I love traveling this way. Besides, I’ve always loved Hemingway. Have a good day! 🙂
MA Marathon Globetrotter ·
As for the "French spy," the police officer was taking my picture and he had a good laugh about it—it was all very good-natured.

Protests in Taipei are generally very good-natured, contrasting with the routine police gear deployed. Back in the spring of 2014, when students occupied Parliament (the "Legislative Yuan") for over a month to block the forced passage of trade deals with China, they spent half a day cleaning the place before leaving, returning it to the exact condition they found it in. Police take a lot of photos and videos during protests, and so do the demonstrators, to document any potential clashes from either side. I took some surreal photos of protesters and police filming each other from ten meters apart in complete calm, with the cherry on top being that they were using identical camera models.
ZO Zorba Veteran ·
You're a real camera with your words. Well, keep on capturing moments for our pleasure and stay with us—see "French spy." As for "French spy," it might fly in a lot of countries, but there’s one where they’re totally humorless: the USA. Let’s remember that young French guy on an American plane who stayed in the bathroom for a long time and jokingly said through the door, "My shit is a bomb." He spent that very night at Riker’s Island, the New York hostel of DSK.
MR MrBruno10647 Regular ·
The indigenous minority is, as usual, the poorest population and the one that suffers the most from unemployment.

There’s a reason for this—they drink a lot and can never finish a job... that’s how they’re perceived by the rest of the population.
MA Mariecurry Globetrotter ·
Australia, Nunavut, Taiwan, and so on. Always the same pattern, the same story. Always the same people who pay the price—literally and figuratively.
JG JG07 Globetrotter ·
In short, you seem very young or immature, or a bit of both.

Haha! Thanks for the comment. To answer, neither, I think. Just an impulsive temperament sometimes. A temperament that’s allowed me to spend time with Russian hooligans, protest against the government in South Korea, follow cocaine dealers in Vietnam, and more. So far, I’ve never had to fight or raise my voice because of a mistake on my part. As for the "French spy," the cop was taking my picture, and he laughed—it was all in good fun. Maybe I’ll get burned one day, but I love traveling this way. Plus, I’ve always loved Hemingway. Have a good day! 🙂

That’s great. Your experiences must be really interesting. But getting into a fight in a foreign country—sorry, but that’s just plain stupid. For example, in Japan, self-defense doesn’t exist. The moment you throw a punch, you become the aggressor. And good luck if the police show up. Keep burning your wings, but one day it might backfire on you.
MR MrBruno10647 Regular ·
uh, what was the topic again?😏
TI Tibet84 ·
hi there

Do you really know how Hemingway lived? To me, he’s no reference at all—just for the fact that he bragged about going to Africa to kill Big Five animals. Plus, I’ll quote two writers who knew him well: Paul Theroux in *Dark Safari* and Martha Gellhorn (his ex-wife) in *My Seasons in Hell*. I can tell you, they didn’t think much of him.

As for Taiwan, you shouldn’t just look at the protesters in front of the palace. You’ve got to go into the mountains, visit the tribes, and live with them for a while like I did with my family. My wife is Taiwanese, by the way. Even some Taiwanese people don’t want to go into the mountains because they find the roads too dangerous.

Have a good day
EL Elcoyote69 ·
Was it really necessary to reply... just to say exactly the same thing on top of that. We don’t know each other, and you’re passing judgment on me as a person. It’s sad to say, and I shouldn’t have even taken the time to justify myself. Plus, you didn’t understand the moral of this text—too bad, or as I’d put it, "that’s dumb."
EL Elcoyote69 ·
Hello, Hemingway, his prose, his characters, and all their complexities. I never knew the man himself... There’s a distinction to be made between the work and the author.

I had my mind blown reading *Journey to the End of the Night*, and yet Céline wasn’t exactly a saint, from what I know. Still, that doesn’t take away from the power of the work.

As for the native Taiwanese, I’m not positioning myself as their defender—this cause just opened my eyes, at this point in my life, to the futility of traveling just for the sake of traveling. A trip without a real purpose.

I hope I’ve answered your expectations and that I’m no longer seen as some big-game hunter in your eyes. Have a great evening
JG JG07 Globetrotter ·
Was it really necessary to reply... to say exactly the same thing on top of that. We don’t know each other, and you’re passing judgment on me. It’s sad to say, and I shouldn’t have even taken the time to justify myself. Plus, you didn’t get the moral of this text—too bad, or as I’d say, "that’s dumb."

Whether we know each other or not doesn’t change anything. You explain that you got involved in a fight that had nothing to do with you, and I’m telling you why that’s a bad idea, with reasoning to back it up. What don’t you understand?

As for the moral of your text, I don’t see one, and there’s no connection. It’s just a well-written, unusual travel story—nothing more.
CH Chacaltaya67 ·
I'm replying after 6 years—no idea if anyone’s still around to read this. On December 2, 2018, the date of Elcoyote69’s post, I had cycled up to Wuling from Hualien. I’m a cyclist, and I’d rented a bike to tackle the climb through Taroko Gorge. My stay in Taiwan was wrapping up just a few days later. I’d come to Taiwan to explore the country by joining this guided cycling tour: https://www.panagoetour.com/coastline, organized by a small Taiwanese family-run company. The father is Han, a military man who came from China with Chiang Kai-shek’s army and married an indigenous woman, so their kids all grew up with a dual culture—something that really showed in their choice of hostels. There were only five of us in the group: a New Zealand couple and an Indian couple, plus me. The Kiwi woman was learning Māori and noticed similarities with the local languages. After Tainan, like the New Zealanders, I continued on my own with one of my goals being to return to Hualien and tackle the famous Wuling climb—3,275 meters high. It’s a legendary ascent that hosts well-known races. What really struck me in Taiwan was how kind people were—their eagerness to help and go out of their way for a lost tourist like me, more than once. I’ll stop here since I’m guessing no one’s left reading this. If you *are* reading this and can make it happen—go to Taiwan. It’s truly one of a kind. François
AN Anneorange Regular ·
I went there 6 years ago. Trip was less active than yours, but I totally agree about how friendly the locals are. A bit of Japanese discipline mixed with a lot of Chinese spontaneity—such a great blend to be around!

Similar discussions

You might also like