Travel: A Right for All? Reflections on Global Freedoms and Inequalities
FR

Translated into English.

UN UnaMilanese Veteran ·
Good evening,

Sure, with miss Atila we’re competing in enthusiasm to contribute to the topics and, without going so far as to tie the knot, we take off together. Unfortunately, part of the squadron is missing...

The espadrille’s rope is worn out...

And then

In this post, I discuss topics like:

The inequalities between passports ("strong" vs. "weak" passports). The specific challenges faced by travelers from marginalized communities. How to take action to promote more inclusive and equitable travel. I’d love to hear your thoughts! 😊 Have you ever felt these inequalities during your travels?

And then... having a "strong passport", maybe for a little while longer, belonging to a marginalized group (females over 180 cm) that indeed faces a number of challenges but hasn’t yet formed a "community", I do have some ideas for promoting more "inclusive and equitable" travel (reducing the number of seat rows in economy class on planes, standardizing 2-meter-long beds in accommodations, etc.), but I have a feeling this isn’t the kind of participation that’s expected.

Cat
B7 B737 Globetrotter ·
Going to Rome for 2 days, Tenerife for 4, Cancun for 6 seems absurd to me.

A tax of 500 euros for a same-day round trip, 300 for the weekend, 200 for the week, and 100 for a fortnight would greatly curb global tourism and thus carbon emissions from air travel.

Okay, that would spell the end for Ryanair and other low-cost airlines, but personally, I wouldn’t shed a tear...

They’re right to say that environmentalists are primarily characterized by their tax rage! Taxing travel like you suggest mainly means only the rich will be able to travel as they please. That’s the second hallmark of environmentalism—it benefits the wealthy. The poor stay home and make way for the rich. Damn the poor! Obviously, the demise of Ryanair wouldn’t upset those who only travel business class—when there’s no first class...
UN UnaMilanese Veteran ·
I didn’t read Attila’s message as dismissive of bank accounts. More like pointing out that the low cost of air travel, which shrinks distances, reduces travel to just another consumer product: "Well, Saturday, should I buy a nice sweater or sip whisky in Glasgow?"
JO Jojoone1 Globetrotter ·
I hadn't even noticed it was an ad for the creator of this thread's blog, not until you pointed it out :)

And even then, I rarely click on links shared by other members, figuring that if they're posting here, they could just as well share the main points or their travel journals directly on VF.

The message wasn't clear enough, so I wanted to know more, but the travel agency vibe really jumped out at me.
B7 B737 Globetrotter ·
I didn’t read Attila’s message as a disdain for bank accounts. More like the fact that the low cost of air travel, which shrinks distances, reduces travel to just another consumer product: "Let’s see, Saturday—should I buy a nice sweater or sip whisky in Glasgow?"

Thanks in part to low-cost carriers, travel has risen (not fallen) to the level of an everyday consumer product—and there’s no reason to be ashamed of that. On the contrary, I think we should celebrate it.

I remember the pre-deregulation era, when flight tickets were exorbitantly priced—and I had to give up a lot to travel. Now, young people and those with modest means can fly without having to sacrifice too much elsewhere, and that’s a great thing. They should make the most of it—it might not last forever...

Herb Kelleher (Southwest), Michael O’Leary (Ryanair), Stelios Haji-Ioannou (easyJet), and József Váradi (Wizz Air) are benefactors of humanity. We should erect statues in their honor.

PS: Between a nice sweater and a trip to Glasgow, I don’t hesitate for a second—like most regulars on this forum, I imagine—but for me, it’ll be a beer over whisky.
UN UnaMilanese Veteran ·
Hi there!

Thanks in part to low-cost carriers, travel has risen (not fallen) to the rank of an everyday consumer product—and there’s no reason to be ashamed of that. On the contrary, we should celebrate it, in my opinion.

A desire immediately fulfilled only offers mediocre satisfaction, at least for those who also lived before these poor *anthropoi* were reduced to mere consumers. The ease of travel, for those who do it effortlessly, devalues these frantic little hops.

I remember the pre-deregulation era, when flight tickets were exorbitantly priced—and I had to go without so many things just to travel. Now, young people and those with modest means can fly without having to sacrifice too much else, and that’s a great thing. They should make the most of it—it might not last forever....

Same here. It made the hierarchy of my values crystal clear, always having to choose. And back then, with little money, I traveled mostly by train, to my great delight, on routes that low-cost airlines have since killed off, leaving us with the choice between flying or driving (maybe the bus... but that’s not my thing).

Catherine
AT Attila Globetrotter ·
I don’t see the connection between what I said and class struggle.

Whether you earn 1,500 € or 1,500,000 €, it doesn’t change the fact that taking a weekend flight is nonsense. Ecologically, maybe, but not just that... I don’t get the point of collecting cities like Panini stickers.

Heavily taxing round-trip flights over a short period would significantly reduce this compulsive—even bulimic—tourism, which would help ease the impacts of overtourism.

That said, I was a bit stingy with my tax amounts.

5,000,000 € for a day, 500,000 € for a weekend, 50,000 € for a week, and 50 € for two weeks would be fairer.

99.99% of the planet would then be affected, instead of just 90% of the French with my initial figures.

Instead of taking 6 two-day trips, people would travel once for 15 days. It wouldn’t cost them any more...
JO Jojoone1 Globetrotter ·
So, we have to accept giving up small pleasures that cost us some financial sacrifices after reading things like:

Gabriel Attal’s plane made a 7-minute flight between Rochefort and La Rochelle to visit... an eco-district. Source: "La Dépêche"

In just four months, the Minister of Ecological Transition, Christophe Béchu, took a private jet eleven times for domestic flights. All done very discreetly. Source: "Reporterre.net"

For their back-to-school trip to Liffré, Gabriel Attal and Élisabeth Borne chose a 38-minute flight on the presidential jet over a 1h30 TGV to Rennes. Source: "Le Soir"

A 52-minute flight, 800 kg of fuel consumed. It was aboard a Dassault Falcon 7X that Prime Minister François Bayrou traveled this Monday, December 16, to Pau to preside over the city’s municipal council, despite numerous criticisms from the opposition. Source: "BFM"

It’s true that it all comes down to perspective. And when have the sacrifices of the middle class ever served as an example for the wealthy and ultra-wealthy to follow?

At the very least, I can much better understand why Leonardo DiCaprio chooses to take a private jet for his trips instead of a long-haul flight—he knows full well that you’d take the opportunity to swoon all over him. Oh, it’s not just you—you wouldn’t be the only one! 😛
PO Poste42 Veteran ·
A little objectivity is necessary. It’s not just frenetic tourists on those low-cost flights. When I went to Vietnam in 2019 and Bulgaria in 2023, both on the way there and back, there were a lot of people from those two countries on the plane. What do we do in that case—tax them to the max or give them special treatment? There are also a lot of people on planes who take them for a day or two for work. Do we tax work too? It’s not all that simple.
DJ Djalma Globetrotter ·
A desire immediately fulfilled offers only mediocre satisfaction, at least for those who also lived before these poor *anthropoi* were reduced to mere consumers. The ease of travel, for those who do it effortlessly, devalues these frantic hops

I totally agree with you on this.

I remember the time before deregulation, when flight tickets were exorbitantly priced—and I had to go without many things to be able to travel. Now, young people and those with modest means can fly without having to sacrifice too much elsewhere, and that’s a great thing. They should make the most of it—it might not last...

Same here. It made the hierarchy of my values crystal clear, always having to choose.

Exactly. For my part, I had my best trips with very little money.

@B737 If flight tickets were expensive, the cost of living in most visited countries was very low. With one month’s minimum wage, you could live for 3 months in South or Southeast Asia! That’s far from the case today🙁
AT Attila Globetrotter ·
So we have to accept giving up a little pleasure

I never said we should give up the pleasures of a weekend away from home.

But not by plane...😛

So much closer...

Rediscovering your region?

some financial sacrifices

Hmm. I’m not convinced that three-quarters of the people on this forum are really sacrificing to travel.

Given the average age of participants, we’re more likely nearing the end of our careers or retired than in the lean years of youth.

Plus, wealth is relative. Some feel rich on 2,000 € a month, others poor on the same amount. And everyone spends differently.

As for the rest of your argument, just because a neighbor does whatever they want doesn’t morally justify doing the same...

Leonardo Di Caprio

Meh. Find a better example!
MA Mathews Globetrotter ·
I don’t see the point in collecting cities like Panini stickers.

I totally agree with that. And personally, even if I’m going off-topic, staying in 5-star hotels has never really appealed to me. For me, the point of travel is discovering different cultures, visiting local communities like the Indigenous peoples in the Amazon, and experiencing local cuisine. In short, everything that makes travel truly special.
AT Attila Globetrotter ·
When I went to Vietnam in 2019 and Bulgaria in 2023, on the plane both ways, there were a lot of people from those two countries. What do we do in this case—do we tax them a lot, or do they get special treatment?

Generally, they aren’t traveling for a day or a week.

So, the case of a round-trip ticket for a stay longer than 15 days.

There are also a lot of people on planes who take them for 1 or 2 days for work. Do we tax work too?

Yes. "Réunionite" is a very French affliction.

And maybe it would bring production and sales locations closer together... The different players in a supply chain...

There are still plenty of unnecessary business trips—just hot air, showing off...

It’s not that simple.

True.

Traveling for a funeral, for example.

And then there’s an inequality even greater than money: time.

Not everyone can take 15 days off.
PO Poste42 Veteran ·
Yes. "Réunionite" is a very French affliction.

And it might bring production and sales locations closer together... The different players in a supply chain...

There are still plenty of unnecessary business trips, though. Just hot air.

That’s changing very quickly—we need to realize it and stay objective. I’m talking more about construction site follow-ups.
PO Poste42 Veteran ·
" Meh " So-so about that charming town in Loire-Atlantique (which I know).

Similar discussions

You might also like