Dream Islands: Greece, French Polynesia, Mauritius...
FR

Translated into English.

Original post
HE
Hello,

Who among us hasn’t dreamed of having a ticket to Tahiti, Bora Bora, or the Marquesas in their pocket—preferably a one-way ticket to “paradise”?

Idyllic landscape of a dream island, but difficult to access: the Bay of Virgins in Fatu Hiva, Marquesas Islands

Among the values conveyed by literature, tourism, and advertising is the quest for “elsewhere,” for a change of scenery, in the truest sense of the word—that is, the need to leave one’s country. This need for otherness, for difference, is projected onto dreamlike, idealized, even mythicized places. In our imaginary world, the island is often that place.

Yet we forget that islands have also been ideal prisons. The examples are numerous: Elba and Saint Helena, Alcatraz and Poulo Condor, If and Yeu, the Devil’s Islands and Leros. The latter, located in Greece in the Dodecanese, hosted a sinister forced labor camp during the colonels’ dictatorship as well as a psychiatric hospital. Despite the beauty of its bay, tourism has remained marginal there due to its bad reputation, unlike the neighboring island of Patmos.

I’d like to share a selection of about a dozen islands from across the world’s seas and oceans. For dreaming...

°°°°°°°°°°°°°°°

SANTORINI



July 27, 1967

At dawn, the ferry from Agios Nikolaos (Crete) enters the immense caldera of Santorini. From the ship’s deck, Rainer, my travel companion, and I are left in awe by the sight of these towering, multicolored cliffs looming over us. We disembark and begin the steep climb on foot via the winding mule path up to the village of Fira, the capital perched above the cliff. Though it’s still very early, we head to the youth hostel. There wasn’t a soul in the alleys that morning—or rather, there were only cats! I have a fond memory of that encounter with Santorini: a sensory shock, a breathtaking volcanic site, a harmony of blue, ochre-red, and white. A welcoming island, as it was traditional to welcome the xénou, an island that hadn’t yet fully recovered from the terrible 1956 earthquake, a Cycladic architectural marvel where local life was still preserved.

It’s easy to see why, in antiquity, the island was named Kallisté (καλλίστη), “the most beautiful,” as it’s nearly impossible to resist gazing at this landscape shaped by tectonic forces. Indeed, a massive volcanic cataclysm—the Minoan eruption—shaped this scenery in the 17th century BCE, creating a caldera that was quickly filled by the sea. The enormous tsunamis that followed reached Crete, leading to the disappearance of the Minoan civilization.

A cliffside path along the caldera leads us to the peaceful village of Oia, at the northern tip of the island. Blue-domed churches and flower-filled villages with whitewashed houses line the way. This walk is a continuous marvel, offering splendid views of the caldera and the neighboring islands formed by the breakup of the ancient volcano (Thirissa, Nea Kameni). Oia is a large, picturesque village, like Fira perched on the cliff’s edge, which was severely damaged by the 1956 earthquake, and its scars are still visible. Its cave-like houses with vaulted roofs haven’t yet been turned into luxury hotels or shops. Absolute tranquility reigns here.

Oia in 1967—a peaceful village overlooking the caldera. But where are the pools and trendy bars?

A lush countryside covered in olive trees and vineyards welcomes us for a pleasant hike, interrupted by the kindness of a friendly islander who gives us a lift in his truck for a few kilometers. He’s off to harvest his tomatoes, which he grows at the foot of Pyrgos Hill. The delicious little cherry tomato of Santorini earned an EU Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) in 2013. We climb up to the village of Pyrgos, perched on a hill and dominated by the elegant bell tower of its church. Finally, we reach the black sand beach of Kamari on the island’s eastern coast to enjoy a swim.

{...} To be continued





°°°°°°°°°°°°°°°°°

RAIVAVAE (French Polynesia)



November 15, 2007

Éléonore from Pension Tama welcomes us with traditional flower leis, as if she’d been waiting for old friends she hadn’t seen in ages. The small airport terminal is lively, the atmosphere warm—people hugging, rejoicing in reunions, all under kilos of flowers. Then, just as quickly, the place empties until the next flight... in a few days.



In the Austral Islands, a ninety-minute flight from Tahiti, Raivavae is a world away from the frenetic pace of Papeete or the tourist crowds of the Leeward Islands. The true paradise of the South Seas can still be savored here—it’s a bit like Bora Bora half a century ago. Our first feeling upon arriving on this island is wonder, with smiles that could melt even the gloomiest among us, landscapes so stunning they take your breath away, and above all, a sense of disorientation and fulfillment. Picture a mountainous island, about ten kilometers by three and a half, encircled by a coral reef and wild motu, cradling a lagoon with shades of blue that would make Bora Bora green with envy.

The roughly one thousand inhabitants of Raivavae are spread across four villages around the island. Children are everywhere, as is typical in Polynesia, and they greet you with open, genuine smiles. Here, ancestral values have survived progress. The predominantly Protestant population is very devout, as evidenced by the several temples built across the island. Religious fervor sets the rhythm of daily life. Sundays are reserved for worship and Sunday school (catechism). Work is forbidden on that day, and tourist activities are suspended. These rules are strict and respected.

Hat contest for the worship celebration

Yet a sense of resignation is ever-present. The people of Raivavae know they are—and will remain—isolated. Despite the construction of an airstrip in 2004 and a few weekly flights to Tahiti and its nearest neighbor, Tubuai (200 km away), the island remains on the fringes of the world. One painful aspect is the separation of children from their parents when they leave for middle school in Tubuai starting in fifth grade. Television brings daily images of a world the islanders will likely never know, but one they often aspire to.

We are privileged. We have the pristine white-sand beaches of the motu and some of the most beautiful bays in Polynesia all to ourselves. The jewel in the crown, the island’s emblematic spot, is the “motu-pool,” about twenty minutes by boat. A natural, exquisite basin with crystal-clear water, gradients of blue, and white sand. And best of all, there’s almost no one there. In fact, lounging on the beach is frowned upon, especially for young women. Religion looks very unfavorably on sunbathing and lazing around. And yet, everything here leans toward that philosophy of life.



The "motu-pool"

{...} To be continued
https://www.myatlas.com/Herodote
HE Herodotos Regular ·
RODRIGUES (Mauritius)



November 25, 2012, late morning.

The Air Mauritius plane had been descending for several minutes. It made a wide turn, giving us a glimpse of the vast lagoon of Rodrigues in the distance, this small island lost in the middle of the Indian Ocean. Just before landing, the sight was magical: waters in a thousand shades of color, from jade green to turquoise blue. At the exit of Plaine Corail Airport, we were greeted by Frédéric, who drove us to our guesthouse.



Half an hour later, we arrived at Pointe Coton on the eastern tip of the island. This is where "Kafé Marron" is located, where we were warmly welcomed by Dorothy, who had prepared a delicious lunch. It’s a charming yellow house with a blue roof, beautifully decorated with African art of fine craftsmanship. The guests share a large library, a living room, and a dining room opening onto the veranda. Admittedly, the house isn’t exactly "feet in the water," and you can only see the lagoon behind a curtain of casuarina trees. However, the ocean is just a few steps away, and above all, the immense beach of Saint-François, the most beautiful on the island, is only a fifteen-minute walk away.



(...)

Who better than Le Clézio could paint a better portrait of Rodrigues, an island he roamed in every direction, following in the footsteps of his grandfather, who once searched for a chimera of a treasure: "An island born from the sea, bearing the history of the earliest eras: blocks of lava thrown, broken, flows of black sand, powder where the roots of vacoas cling like tentacles" (Voyage to Rodrigues). This old volcanic rock, far from any land in the vast ocean, is set in a lagoon dotted with coral islets, twice its size, whose splendor—contrasting with the austerity of the mountain—rivals that of the Leeward Islands. The coastline is carved into numerous points, coves, inlets, and bays. The tropical climate is tempered by the southeast trade winds. All the ingredients are here for a pleasant beach stay.

A "Boutik" in Port Mathurin

The roughly 42,000 inhabitants, mostly descendants of Malagasy or Mozambican slaves, give Rodrigues a resolutely African feel, which sets it apart from Mauritius, to which it belongs. They speak Rodriguan Creole, derived from French, since Rodrigues, like the rest of the Mascarene Islands, was a French colony before the British took it in 1809. French is also commonly spoken across the island. The mountain dwellers, descendants of maroons who took refuge there during the slave period, are mostly farmers and herders. Those on the coast, Creoles, engage in fishing on triangular-sailed pirogues and octopus hunting (locally called "ourites"), a task reserved for women. It’s early in the morning that you can see the silhouettes of the octopus hunters wading thigh-deep in the lagoon waters: an additional source of income, provided the resource doesn’t run out.

Sunday family picnic under the casuarina trees by the ocean.



{...}. To be continued

You can read the rest of this travel journal and see the many accompanying photos on MyAtlas.

Contents:

Santorini (Greece) Iona and Staffa (Scotland) Pico (Azores) São Vicente (Cape Verde) Groix (Brittany) Raivavae (French Polynesia) Naoshima (Japan) Boipeba (Brazil) Procida (Italy) Rodrigues (Mauritius) Saaremaa (Estonia)
https://www.myatlas.com/Herodote
SO Solene40 Globetrotter ·
Thanks so much, Michel, for this original themed post! I’m also a huge fan of islands, but I haven’t seen the same ones as you 😊. I dream of Procida and, on the other side of the world, Boipeba (and many others, of course). I loved Rodrigues last year, and I’d recommend—if you haven’t been yet—the islands of São Tomé, which are even more unspoiled 😍. Have a great evening
Le monde est comme un miroir, si tu lui souris, il te sourit aussi!
HE Herodotos Regular ·
Hi Christelle/Solène,

A big thank you for this lovely comment!

We’ve visited so many islands—I’ve lost count, it’s impossible! Lofoten, the Marquesas, the Canaries, Ko Yao Noi in Thailand, Chiloé in Chile, around twenty Aegean islands, Sardinia, Sicily, Corsica, Iceland, and more. This is just a sample. On the other hand, we haven’t seen the Balearics, the Sunda Islands, the Philippines, Prince Edward Island, Saint-Pierre-et-Miquelon, Wallis and Futuna, Svalbard (brrr!), or many others. Two lifetimes wouldn’t be enough!

As for São Tomé and Príncipe, I’ve already "visited" this African archipelago… uh… in one of your travel journals, I think, but I can’t remember which one. By the way, I recognized your avatar on the equator line monument on Rolas Island. 😉

Have a great Sunday! !
https://www.myatlas.com/Herodote
UN UnaMilanese Veteran ·
Islands Islands Islands we’ll never set foot on Islands we’ll never land on Islands covered in vegetation Islands crouching like jaguars Silent islands Still islands Unforgettable and nameless islands

I toss my shoes overboard because I’d love to reach you.

Blaise Cendrars

I was wondering how Santorini could make the list of "dreamy islands." 1967 explains everything.

Anyone posting a follow-up?
By this, and this only, we have existed. Which is not to be found in our obituaries. (T.S. Eliot)
HE Herodotos Regular ·
Hello and thank you for the poem.

I was wondering how Santorini could be included in the "islands to dream about" list. 1967 explains everything.

No, that doesn’t explain everything—you have to read on:

Santorini, August 1990

Returning twenty-three years later, on my fifth trip to Greece, now with family. The island is still just as beautiful, and we enjoyed walking along the cliff to Oia, admiring this incredible site. However, a new catastrophe has struck since my first visit to Thera. This time, it’s not lava flows but concrete! The relentless effort to disfigure this exceptional site made me angry, starting with that ridiculous cable car that lets thousands of cruise passengers bypass the elevation gain to reach Fira as quickly as possible, rushing through the alleys lined with bars and luxury shops before heading back to their ship anchored in the heart of the caldera. But what have they done to your beauty, Santorini? What have they done to your unique landscape? With this cable car, with all these pools—despite your aridity—with these bars and pseudo-Cycladic-style hotels, with these luxury boutiques. They’ve turned you into a tourist spectacle, a pastiche of Cycladic traditions—in two words: a commercial product! What sadness, what a waste! This island no longer makes me dream...

Jacques Lacarrière, the writer who loved Greece, spent long stays in the country over twenty years but refused to return after the 1967 coup. When the colonels fell in 1974, he hesitated to come back, fearing disappointment. Here’s what he wrote in the latest edition of Greek Summer: « Greece today, for us old lovers, is like Eurydice for Orpheus. If we return to her, we lose her forever. » Nevertheless, he did return in 1976: « It’s true. Eurydice has changed a lot. She now dresses in Western style, speaks Greek with anglicisms, uses credit cards, eats in self-service restaurants when in a hurry, takes hydrofoils to Hydra or Spetses, and prefers whisky to ouzo. »

I had the same impression during my second trip in 1976: like him, « I found a heavily made-up Eurydice! »

Are you posting a follow-up?

No, as mentioned, I’m referring you to my travel journal on MyAtlas, because copying everything here would be too tedious.
https://www.myatlas.com/Herodote
UN UnaMilanese Veteran ·
My first—and last—trip to Santorini was back in 1979. Back then, flight tickets cost significantly more than a meal at a restaurant or a winter jacket, and they were a deliberate choice, one my parents had to make at the time. We’d sleep for just a handful of drachmas under the stars on the rooftop terrace of a house, and the island remains a wonderful memory, close to the magic of your twenties. An Atlantis now.

I prefer the VF format over MyAtlas... 😐

But I enjoyed reading your account of Naoshima. Wandering through the museum at night is a desire that will be fulfilled.

Happy travels!
By this, and this only, we have existed. Which is not to be found in our obituaries. (T.S. Eliot)

Similar discussions

You might also like